10 Surprising Last-Minute WWE WrestleMania Card Twists
'Card subject to change' applies in these surprise opponents, impromptu matches.
Given that WrestleMania is WWE’s biggest show of the year, you would think that its card would be locked down well in advance, an ironclad contract between the company and its fans on the quality of the program it plans to deliver.
But in increasing frequency, WWE has been employing last-minute changes to its slate of entertainment to wow fans on the day of the show. These have included impromptu challenges, surprise opponents, and late additions to existing matches.
The result through the years has been mixed. Some are open secrets that deliver on the night of, while others come out of nowhere to take up a spot on the card. Some of these twists have been very well-received, while others have landed with an absolute thud and make you question what mind-altering chemicals the higher-ups were on when they booked them.
Regardless, it’s become more commonplace to expect at least a couple surprises on the night(s) of WrestleMania. But it’s fair to note that this practice goes back 30 years.
For purposes of this list, surprise entrants in battle royals don’t count (think LOD 2000 at WrestleMania 14), and the same goes for the entire WrestleMania 4 tournament, whose subsequent rounds were unknown until the night of the show. We also will disqualify Big Show challenging Drew McIntyre after the Scottish Warrior toppled Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 36, as that was a dark match that aired on Raw the day after.
Let’s get to it…
10. Crazy Old Man Vince Goes Full Shane
Shane McMahon might have been on the outs with WWE after his 2022 Royal Rumble debacle, but that didn’t stop his father from taking his place hogging the spotlight at WrestleMania 38.
Vince McMahon had been ensconced in an ongoing mentor/protégé storyline with Austin Theory, a modern-day “Chosen One” gimmick that ultimate did the current United States Champion no favours.
Theory wrestled SmackDown announcer Pat McAfee on night 2 of Mania, with the former NFL star wowing fans (once again) and defeating the brash upstart. Not content to let that slide, Vince jumped (as well as his decrepit body would allow) into the ring and challenged McAfee to an impromptu match right then and there… which McMahon (at age 76) would improbably win (with help from Theory), thus undoing the announcer’s dramatic victory and moment.
All of that would the immediately be undone by Stone Cold Steve Austin storming to the ring to Stunner everyone at ringside, thus rendering the previous 20 minutes entirely moot.
9. Braun Strowman Needs A Tag Partner
These days, Braun Strowman has found success in the SmackDown tag team division alongside smaller compatriot Ricochet. But several years ago, the Monster of all Monsters made a splash in the tag ranks with an even smaller partner.
Heading into WrestleMania 34, Strowman was embroiled in a feud with The Bar, who were the reigning Raw Tag Team Champions. Braun proved to be more than a match for both men, but he was not allowed to challenge for the tag titles alone. Incredibly, no one on the Raw roster was willing or capable of signing on prior to Mania, leaving Strowman to declare that he would reveal his tag partner the night of the match.
On the night, Braun made the announcement that his tag partner would be a fan. He then walked through the crowd before picking out 10-year-old Nicholas (who turned out to be referee John Cone’s son) to be his partner. In a completion of this “feel-good” story, Braun & Nicholas managed to topple Cesaro & Sheamus, winning the tag titles and making the kid the youngest WWE champion in history.
The next night on Raw, however, the champs surrendered the titles in part because Nicholas needed to get back to his duties in the fifth grade. It was stupid, silly, and ultimately harmless, though The Bar looked foolish for the duration of the angle.
8. Undertaker Answers Cena’s Challenge
Heading into WrestleMania 34,
there really wasn’t much doubt that this match would somehow take place, but
WWE still kept it in doubt even into the beginning of the PPV.
For several weeks before WrestleMania 34, John Cena repeatedly called out the Undertaker, challenging him to a match at Mania. (What is it with Cena and constantly not having a path to WrestleMania? You’d think the biggest star of his era would be able to get on the card with a word.)
Cena upped his criticism of Taker to try to goad him into responding. It failed, so Cena went to Mania “as a fan,” and he enjoyed the kickoff show and first couple matches from the crowd, posing for photos and even drinking a beer. But upon receiving word the Deadman was there, Cena hopped the barricade and raced to the back.
Shortly thereafter, Cena came out for his long-awaited WrestleMania match against Taker, but it was nowhere near the epic struggle we might have wanted several years prior. Instead, Taker squashed Cena in less than three minutes, bolstering his Mania record to 24-2 and giving fans a really cool entrance. Other than that, it was something that happened and isn’t really referenced these days.
7. Hogan "Defends" Bret Hart’s Honor
In 1993, the idea of adding
impromptu matches to a PPV card was pretty taboo, especially when talking about
the main event.
But that’s exactly what happened 30 years ago in one of the most infamous plot twists in WrestleMania history.
Bret “Hitman” Hart defended the WWF Championship against Yokozuna in the main event of WrestleMania IX, the first Mania main event to feature Hulk Hogan in some capacity… or so we thought. Mr. Fuji managed to blind Hart with salt, allowing Yoko to beat Bret and win the world title. In another WrestleMania first, the heel had won the main event of WrestleMania.
But hold on a minute. Hogan came out to protest the chicanery, when Fuji started running down Hogan (who had lost a tag title match by DQ earlier in the night), inexplicably challenging Hulk to a title match right on the spot.
Hart waved Hogan on, and seconds later, Hulk ducked another Fuji salt toss and toppled Yokozuna to become world champion yet again, “main-eventing” his last Mania. The move ultimately would backfire in dramatic fashion, with Hogan ultimately losing the title back to Yoko that summer and leaving WWF for nearly nine years.
6. Rock Comes Ready To Fight
The Rock made a triumphant return
to a WWE ring at the 2011 Survivor Series, followed up by main-eventing
WrestleManias 28 and 29 against John Cena. He would pass the torch to Cena in
that 2013 match, transitioning to more of a guest appearance role at Mania 30
and 31.
But at the disappointing WrestleMania 32, The Great One’s attempt to continue being a non-combative attraction ran afoul of the Wyatt Family. Rock came out to announce the totally real and not inflated at all attendance record for Dallas’ AT&T Stadium, but the Wyatts, who otherwise had nothing else to do at WrestleMania that night, interrupted.
The confrontation led the Brahma Bull to remove his outfit, revealing his wrestling gear. He challenged the trio, with Erick Rowan answering the call… and walking right into a Rock Bottom for a record 6-second loss.
The “match” really was an opportunity to squeeze Rock onto the card and set a new, more legitimate Mania record (as the old 9-second record featuring King Kong Bundy and SD Jones was actually three times as long as documented).
5. The Hardys Make A Splash
If this were an article about “biggest pops in WrestleMania history,” Chris Jericho would be clicking his pen and informing the Hardy brothers that their Mania 33 return just made the list.
Matt and Jeff had been away from WWE seven and eight years, respectively, when they made a surprise return as the fourth entrants in an announced triple threat tag team ladder match for the Raw Tag Team Championship.
The circumstances surrounding their return were nothing short of spectacular. The duo defended – and lost – the Ring of Honor Tag Team Championship to the Young Bucks at Supercard of Honor 11 the night before, meaning they were in town, but also had just competed in a gruelling match.
Then at WrestleMania 33, hosts the New Day teased that they were joining the fray as a fourth team before they gave way to Matt and Jeff. Naturally, the Attitude Era pioneers managed to win the tag titles, driving whipped-up fans into even more of a frenzy.
It truly was a “WrestleMania moment” and one hell of a surprise addition to a match.
4. Bryan Fights His Way Into Mania Main Event
This is a big of a cheat of an
entry. The WrestleMania 30 main event was going to be a triple threat for the
WWE Championship, but when the show opened, there was still the open question
of exactly who was going to join WWE Champion Randy Orton and Royal
Rumble winner Batista.
In case you forgot, 2014 was the year of the Yes! Movement, with Daniel Bryan hijacking Raw and demanding a shot at the world title. He finally got under the Authority’s skin enough that Triple H agreed to face him at Mania, with the stipulation that whomever won that bout would be added to the world title match.
Bryan would defeat Hunter in the WM 30 opening contest, setting him up for the storybook conclusion in which he tapped out Batista to win the WWE World Heavyweight Championship and close out WrestleMania as the biggest star of the night.
3. Austin Unretires To KO Owens
When “Stone Cold” Steve Austin retired after WrestleMania 19, many figured he’d take a few years off and then probably return to the ring once he healed up. After all, Shawn Michaels had just returned from a career-ending injury a few months earlier.
But Austin managed to stay out of the ring for 19 years, leaving him as one of the longest retired wrestlers to eventually change course. That came last year, when Kevin Owens called out the Rattlesnake and invited him to appear on the KO Show at WrestleMania 38 in Dallas, Texas. The segment was slated to main-event night one of the show, leaving the door wide open for what everyone hoped for, but couldn’t assume.
After some pointed back-and-forth, the two bowed up and agreed to an impromptu match, sending the stadium into a collective heart attack. They brawled into the crowd, where Austin took a suplex on the floor, and returned to the ring, where Stone Cold eventually scored the win in his first match since 2003.
As impromptu Mania matches go, this was hiding in plain sight the entire time, but that didn’t make it any less exhilarating afterward when you realized that Austin and Owens had pulled it off.
2. From Undesirable To Undeniable
When you talk about hiding a
surprise match in plain sight, WrestleMania 38 wrote the book on it. Steve
Austin/Kevin Owens wasn’t the only such rumor-turned-reality match on night
one.
As a storyline, Seth Rollins spending weeks trying to find his way into Mania was stupid from the outset. It strains – and actually shatters – credulity that a multi-time world champion would have to finagle his way into a WrestleMania match, but that’s what fans were asked to believe… right up until Mr. McMahon said what we were all thinking and wondered why Rollins didn’t just ask for a match. The catch? Seth would face a surprise opponent.
By this point, everyone knew who that opponent was going to be. But that didn’t make it any less unbelievable when former AEW executive vice president Cody Rhodes returned to a WWE ring for the first time in six years. More remarkably, this was the American Nightmare. Not Dashing Cody. Not Stardust. Not one-third of Legacy. It was AEW’s version of Rhodes, robe, theme and entrance in all.
The match kicked off a tremendous trilogy between the two men that firmly established Cody as a top babyface in today’s WWE. Even a torn pec could only delay, not deny, his ascension to the top of the card, and now Rhodes is poised to main-event Mania 39.
But go back and listen to the explosion when Rhodes made his entrance. That’s a surprise everyone knew was coming, and fans still lost their minds. That’s really impossible to pull off.
1. The Heist Of The Century
No WrestleMania surprises list
would be complete without the best mid-match surprise in the event’s
history.
At WrestleMania 31, Brock Lesnar was defending his WWE Championship against the anointed hero Roman Reigns (remember those days, when the Big Dog was shoved down fans’ throats and they gagged?). But this clash would be upended when Seth Rollins raced down to ringside carrying his Money in the Bank briefcase.
No one had cashed in their MITB title shot mid-match, and no one had cashed in at WrestleMania, so why not have Rollins do both at the same time? Fans understandably lost their minds at the WM 31 main event being thrown into disarray suddenly.
The pure chaos of the moment alone was memorable, but at the time, it also raised alarm bells that this was how they were going to either have Reigns win the title or Brock retain it: through Rollins. But the Architect would deliver a stomp to Roman to capture his first WWE World Heavyweight Championship
What do you think? Are there other WrestleMania surprise twists you think should be included?