10 Terrible Iterations Of Legendary Gimmick Matches

Dogs, fire, electricity, and a match inside a shark cage...

Kennel From Hell
WWE.com

For the most part, I think it would be fair to say that gimmick matches have been a good thing for professional wrestling.

Ladder matches, cage matches, over-the-top rope elimination matches - all of these have been staple parts of a healthy wrestling diet over the years. And many of these match types have since been evolved into even more exciting concepts, such as your Hell in a Cell meetings, your Elimination Chambers and your Tables, Ladders and Chairs bouts.

But as is often the case, for all these classic stipulations, we’ve also seen our fair share of rubbish along the way. Even some of the most legendary, seemingly bulletproof gimmick matches have been adulterated into some pretty terrible iterations.

This article looks back at some of these most notable examples, but first let’s go over the two key qualifying factors for prospective entries on this list.

First off, it needs to be a terrible iteration, some kind of spin on a match that probably should have been best avoided. Secondly - and this is the crucial part - it has to be variant of a match that was actually considered legendary in the first place.

So all those “so-and-so on a pole” matches we’ve seen over the years aren’t up for consideration, as I’m not sure how many pole matches were even deemed “legendary gimmick matches” to begin with…

10. World War 3

WCW World War 3
WWE.com

Our first guilty party to be named and shamed is WCW’s World War 3.

A variation of a Battle Royal, this was in essence WCW’s response to the WWE’s wildly successful Royal Rumble showdown. But rather than simply mimic the Rumble, WCW wanted to up the ante.

So instead of having one ring, World War 3 would have three. And rather than featuring 30 participants, World War 3 would feature 60. Admittedly, that may sound impressive on paper, but in reality it was incredibly difficult to execute correctly.

Cameramen naturally found it difficult to capture all of the action, and with all 60 men starting the match at the same time (much like a traditional Battle Royal) there wasn’t really enough space in which the wrestlers could operate. Long story short; it was all a bit of a mess, really.

The great thing about the Rumble is that the entrants are diluted and smaller sub-plots can develop within the match. In the case of World War 3, the sheer mayhem that came as a result of staging three simultaneous Battle Royals, which would eventually merge into a single contest, just wasn’t able to replicate the magic of the Rumble.

Still, they did manage to eke out four years of the concept before finally replacing it in 1999.


9. Shark Cage Match

Now I’ll be the first to admit that, at face value, a Shark Cage match sounds pretty awesome. However, the image that those words might conjure up in your head is probably slightly different to the match that this one would turn out to be.

The contest in question involved Chief Jay Strongbow and “Bulldog” Don Kent and while there was indeed a shark cage involved, that in itself was the issue: the entire match took place inside a structure that can’t have been more than about 4 feet in diameter.

While WCW’s World War 3 may have suffered from spatial limitations, this match took things to a whole new level.

Naturally, pinfalls weren’t an option, due to the impossibility of lying down in such a small space, and so escaping the cage was the only win to win. However, the door must have been a little dodgy, as it was seemingly refusing to remain closed.

For Strongbow and Kent, that just made the difficult job of putting on an exciting match in a tiny shark cage all the more tasking still.

That being said, I’ve refrained from placing this one any higher on the list on account of the fact that it happened roughly 40 years ago. Perhaps it was a novel idea for its time. Through today’s eyes, though, it doesn’t make for pretty (or exciting) viewing.


8. Punjabi Prison

Punjabi Prison Great American Bash 2006
WWE.com

Another cage match variation here, and just as a heads-up, this won’t be the last!

The Punjabi Prison match was first introduced by the WWE around the time of the Great Khali’s initial main event push. Despite that, the match’s founder wouldn’t even participate in the inaugural contest, as elevated levels of enzymes in his liver would prevent him from being cleared to compete in the inaugural version at the 2006 Great American Bash (he was replaced with The Big Show).

As strange as Khali's liver troubles may sound, though, the Punjabi Prison match itself was even more unusual. The ring would be surrounded by two bamboo cages, the outermost one standing at 20 feet and the innermost standing at 16 feet. Each wall of the inner cage featured a small door that could be opened at a wrestler’s request, but only for 60 seconds. After that, it would be padlocked, and if all four doors would suffer that fate then the combatants would be forced to climb the structure to escape instead.

As you can probably tell, the biggest problem here was that the rules were simply too convoluted. Plus, the layers of intricate bamboo-work made it difficult to actually see what was going on in the ring, resulting in constant camera cuts to keep track of the action.

A fleeting concept, the Punjabi Prison match only ever saw two outings, which tells you just about everything you need to know about the popularity of the stipulation.


7. Reverse Battle Royal

Reverse Battle Royal Bound for Glory 2007
TNA

Our second Battle Royal variant to feature on this list, but easily the inferior iteration of the two.

In 2006, TNA looked to shake things up by putting their own twist on an age-old institution, and the outcome was a Reverse Battle Royal. Described as an “inside out Battle Royal”, in which the participants would begin by surrounding the ring, before fighting their way inside of that ring, whereupon your typical Battle Royal would ensue.

In practice, this resulted in a lot of faffing about at ringside, because really it’s not that hard to climb into the ring. In fact, every single wrestler who has ever wrestled has done this at least once every match, so it seemed fairly silly that some guys were suddenly left incapable of doing so.

Or worse still, they’d wander around the ring looking for someone to beat up as opposed to actually attempting to climb through the ropes.

And as if that hadn't been long-winded enough, the final two survivors in the Battle Royal would then enter a third stage, competing in a one-on-one singles bout to determine the ultimate winner.

Clearly TNA thought this match-up was a great idea, because they went ahead and staged a second instalment at Bound for Glory 2007. The Wrestling Observer Newsletter didn’t quite agree, though, voting it the worst worked match of 2006, a verdict that’s tough to argue with.


6. Doomsday Cage Match

Here we have another entry that may sound pretty cool on paper, but the final product wasn’t quite all it was cracked up to be.

To set the scene, Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage were looking to fend off the eight-man strong Alliance to End Hulkamania, and to do so they would have to beat them in a Doomsday Cage match. This would entail Hogan and Savage beginning the match atop a three-tier cage structure, and having to work their way through various compartments until they reached the bottom whereupon a wrestling ring - and a resultant match - would be awaiting their arrival.

But this wasn’t really a pro wrestling match. No, this was an early frontrunner to Total Wipeout, a gloried episode of Jungle Run, or something you might see on Takeshi’s Castle.

Given that the upper levels had a mesh floor, there wasn’t a great deal they could do on such unsteady ground. And so we were subjected to a lot of slow non-action, staggering around, and lumbering offense designed to eat up time. There were even long periods where guys were just standing still or laying around waiting for something to happen.

Furthermore, even from a booking perspective this one was ridiculous, it was eight versus two and somehow it was the duo of Hogan and Savage who came out on top.

I say “somehow” but, really, I’ve found an explanation there with the mention of Mr. Hogan. He wasn’t going to lose this one, was he?


5. Chamber Of Horrors

Chamber of Horrors WCW
WWE Network

Another entry, another WCW cage match variation. This time, we look at Halloween Havoc 1991 and the spookily-dubbed Chamber of Horrors match.

A star-studded affair saw El Gigante, Sting and the Steiner Brothers take on Abdullah the Butcher, the Diamond Studd (Scott Hall), Cactus Jack and Big Van Vader in what was essentially your standard cage match. Although, there was of course the minor addition of the Chair of Torture (basically a second cage housing an electric chair) which was lowered down mid-match, complete with its own eerie soundtrack.

The aim would then be to place your opponent in the chair, and activate the power switch to give the poor soul a “shocking” experience, in the words of JR.

But with the chair taking up much of the space in the ring, the majority of the action was consigned to the narrow corridor between the cage and the apron, making for a fairly disjointed and ambling affair. And while a variety of weapons were soon employed, it was tough to keep tabs on how exactly they were being used and what was really going on at all.

The contest’s conclusion arrived when Abdullah had Rick Steiner seated in the chair, only for Rick to overpower his foe and pull-off the old switcheroo. Cactus Jack then proceeded to yank down the power switch anyway, inadvertently shocking his partner. Cue flashing lights, a flurry of pyro and a spasm from Abdullah, and the end of one of the wackiest, corniest cage match iterations of all time.


4. Kennel From Hell

Kennel From Hell
WWE.com

Of course, WCW aren’t the only ones to desecrate the legacy of the cage match. In 1999, WWE actually managed to put a blemish on the records of both cage and Hell in a Cell encounters, with their ill-advised Kennel from Hell match between the Big Boss Man and Al Snow.

The match was basically a cage match, with a subsequent Hell in a Cell structure surrounding that aforementioned cage. Oh, and the reason it got its 'Kennel from Hell' moniker? There would be a pack of Rottweilers surrounding the ring, in that corridor between the cell and the cage, providing us with our canine element.

Now, this isn't necessarily a terrible idea, but the dogs didn’t actually offer anything to the match, other than the odd piddle of urine. And even when Snow did fall next to them, they were too busy barking at each other to notice, and so the entire stipulation became a little redundant.

Maybe they’d have been better off replacing the dogs with weapons of some sort, or perhaps even just a species capable of carrying out a wrestling match. Then again, maybe they should have just avoided this idea altogether.

After that woeful debut rendition in 1999 (Vince McMahon apologised to Bossman and Snow afterwards), the company wisely hasn't revisited it.

Yet.


3. Junkyard Invitational

Junkyard Invitational
WWE Network

In the late 1990s, hardcore wrestling was taking the world by storm. Having been introduced by ECW and then popularised by the WWE, clearly WCW thought it was their turn to get in on the action.

And in a similar strategy to the “bigger and better” approach they adopted with World War 3, they really went all-out on this one. Although the results remained largely the same.

The Junkyard Invitational was a multi-man hardcore match held in - you guessed it - a junkyard, in which anyone was entitled to turn up and the only way to win was by managing to escape the fenced perimeter.

The resultant scenes saw cars tipped over amidst raging fires and intermittent explosions, as well as a whole host of unidentified foreign objects incorporated into the mix. And while the helicopter camera shots were a novel touch, again this one suffered from being so disjointed that it was hard to even know what was happening in the match. Plus, it all went down in the darkness of night.

Even the commentary team suggested they just sit back and take in the action rather than attempt to actually call it.

After almost 14 minutes of sheer confusion, it was Finlay who would emerge the victor, climbing the fence after another explosion had blocked the path of his remaining opponents.

On top of all that, this match also caused a lot of legit injuries. Which is, you know, the precise opposite of the very notion upon which professional wrestling is built.


2. Electrified Cage Match

Lockdown 2007 Electrified Cage Match
TNA

We’ve seen some pretty suspect cage matches so far, but few can compare to this next entry. Borrowing from certain elements of WCW’s Chamber of Horrors, in 2007 TNA introduced the world to the first-ever electrified cage match - which does exactly what is says on the tin, really.

Brother Ray and Brother Devon of Team 3D faced off against Homicide and Hernandez of LAX, in what was formally dubbed an Electrified Six Sides of Steel match with the NWA World Tag Team Championships on the line.

Obviously, though, the cage wasn’t really electrified on account of the fact that you’re not allowed to kill people inside a wrestling ring. Or anywhere else, for that matter.

Instead, as reported by Wrestlezone, “TNA chose to run a “humming” sound of electricity over the PA system in the arena” which they later turned down because it was too much of a distraction. And while they had planned to feature pyro and sparks whenever someone was supposedly electrocuted, they instead settled for simply flashing the arena lights and telling the wrestlers to make pretend accordingly.

If this all sounds terrible, that’s because it was.

Jim Cornette recounts how Brother Ray was audibly screaming expletives in front of the camera after the match, such was his displeasure with the preceding events. Cornette himself provided his own assessment of the events, calling the match a “goddam mess” as well as a number of other things that I probably shouldn’t repeat.


1. Blindfold Cage Match

Blindfold Cage Match Lockdown 2007
TNA

Even worse than the electrified iteration of the cage match, was the Six Sides of Steel Blindfold match which actually took place on the very same pay-per-view! Man, talk about a rough night for those in attendance in Missouri.

The one positive I can say about this one is that at least the match’s name didn’t leave you in any doubt as to what to expect.

But with Blindfold matches being a tough enough sell at the best of times, did TNA really think that by adding a cage to the mix - a cage that neither participant would be able to fully utilise on account of their blindness - was going to rescue this contest?

Furthermore, this was part of the feud between former partners James Storm and Chris Harris. Surely a tag team disintegration angle is deserving of something better than a freakin' blindfold match?

Questions aside, what we do know for sure is that this match was downright absurd. It was a good two minutes before either man actually touched the other, and then once they finally got down to it their blindfolds wouldn’t stop falling off. Also, I feel like the referee took more punishment than either wrestler, given the amount of times he was mistaken for an actual competitor.

Credit to Storm, mind you, for actually having a go at climbing the cage blindfolded. Although, I’m not sure how advisable that strategy is...

Still, it can’t be more ill-advised than actually booking this match in the first place. I hate to be the guy to rip into TNA, but staging this contest was a particularly poor decision by just about anyone’s standards.

Never before and, mercifully, never again.


Contributor
Contributor

Elliott Binks hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.