10 "Then Versus Now" WWE Dream Matches

The bouts we'll never see, but always imagine.

Seth Rollins Randy Savage.jpg
WWE

There's a lot to criticize when it comes to today's WWE, but the roster is beyond reproach. The company has spent the past five-plus years scouring the globe for the best independent and international talent in the biz, and the result is a workers' haven where any given show can offer fans a dream match in terms of names and quality.

Still, there are plenty of legends of yesteryear who, theoretically, could have stood toe to toe with the current generation of outstanding superstars. Even when the company was weaker in terms of overall talent, men like Randy Savage, Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels, and more delivered classics that have stood the test of time.

It's tantalising to imagine the great workers of the '80s, '90s, and 2000s mixing it up with WWE and NXT's assortment of gifted grapplers. Not only would the matches be classics, but the idea of such lasting and powerful personalities simply coming face to face is enough to get any fan's imagination racing. 

How would talents like Seth Rollins, AJ Styles, Kevin Owens, Finn Balor, and Sasha Banks handle their predecessors?

Here is a collection of 10 "then versus now" WWE dream matches. Unfortunately, we won't be seeing any of the bouts anytime soon, but just considering them is still worth it.

10. AJ Styles Vs. Eddie Guerrero

AJ Styles Eddie Guerrero.jpg
WWE

Early this year, news broke that four of New Japan Pro Wrestling's top stars - AJ Styles, Shinsuke Nakamura, Doc Gallows, and Karl Anderson - were leaving their home promotion to try their luck in WWE.

For longtime fans, the announcement was reminiscent of one from 16 years earlier - in 2000, WCW talents Eddie Guerrero, Chris Benoit, Dean Malenko, and Perry Saturn did the same thing, finding varying levels of success in WWE.

Out of the four Radicalz, it was Guerrero who carved the greatest legacy. Though substance abuse issues hampered his career, he was able to conquer his demons and achieve greatness before his tragic death in 2005.

Already recognised as one of the best workers in the world, Guerrero became a genuine superstar in WWE.

AJ Styles, who in three short months has become one of the company's top players, is a high-flying super-worker in a way that's not altogether different from Guerrero. Both made names for themselves with superior in-ring work, then spent years reaching the upper echelon of the wrestling industry.

A match between the two would be an incredibly exciting, superbly athletic encounter. Styles would have the edge when it came to pure high-flying, but Latino Heat's ring savvy and match leadership was second to none. This would be a mile-a-minute classic, no doubt about it.


9. The New Day Vs. The Hardy Boyz

The New Day Hardy Boys.jpg
WWE

The New Day aren't just the best act in WWE today - they're the best tag team the company has seen since the division's 2000-2001 glory days. They're legitimate stars and incredible workers, giving the belts an actual air of importance and selling merchandise like few other wrestlers in the company.

It's hard not to think about how The New Day would have fared during that era of tag team competition. Their TLC bout against The Lucha Dragons and The Usos was proof positive that they could go toe-to-toe with any of the favourites of the early 2000s, but the ultimate dream match for the trio would be against Matt and Jeff, The Hardy Boyz.

In terms of personality, The Hardy Boyz are the opposite of The New Day - their subdued attitudes played second fiddle to their ring work, which would allow The New Day to get under their skin leading up to the encounter.

Once the bout - preferably a TLC match - began, though, there'd be no holding back on either side.

None of the men on either team have any qualms about putting their bodies on the line, and this would be the time to make a statement. Expect sheer craziness and excitement.


8. Shinsuke Nakamura Vs. Shawn Michaels

Nakamura Shawn Michaels.jpg
WWE

Most fans thought Shawn Michaels was done when he left active competition in 1998, but four years later, he did the unthinkable - he came back better than ever before. The athleticism and charisma were still there, but HBK had earned a genuine likability that made his matches even easier to get invested in emotionally.

That Michaels - the artist who made the ring his canvas between 2002 and 2010 - would make the perfect foil for new NXT star Shinsuke Nakamura. Though both men would be babyfaces, the interplay between them would be stunning.

It's hard to imagine two wrestlers who can better command a crowd from inside the squared circle, and putting them together would create a rabid audience.

Nakamura's strong style-influenced offense would look devastating when sold by HBK, giving fans a heightened level of concern for the three-time WWE Champion. Likewise, his comebacks would be even more impressive after taking such a beating.

And what would happen when Michaels fired off a Sweet Chin Music just as Nakamura charged in with a Boma Ye...?


7. The Undertaker Vs. Bruno Sammartino

Undertaker Bruno Sammartino.jpg
WWE

Admittedly, this one's a little out of left field, but the idea of WWE's greatest hero versus its most intimidating presence is too tantalising to ignore.

Sammartino, who was a superstar in WWE's home of New York during the days when many babyfaces were geared to appeal to specific ethnic and immigrant populations, reigned as champion from 1963 to 1971, and again from 1973 to 1977.

He sold out Madison Square Garden myriad times, and the fans were enamoured with the babyface strongman.

Just imagine The Undertaker, in full regalia, entering MSG in the '70s to take on the Living Legend. The fans would be terrified, maybe even in tears. They'd only be more afraid when The Phenom sat up after Bruno's power-based offense and came back with a chokeslam or the "old school" ropewalk.

Even if the bout were to take place today, Bruno's strength and charisma would undoubtedly win fans over - and a challenged Undertaker would continue to defy time to claim yet another victim.


6. Sasha Banks Vs. Trish Stratus

Trish Stratus Sasha Banks.jpg
WWE

Today, WWE's Women's division is the strongest it's ever been. Not only have recent NXT call-ups Sasha Banks, Charlotte, and Becky Lynch finally found their niches, but divas like Natalya, Paige, and Emma are more than capable of challenging them in classic contests.

The best worker in the division is former NXT Women's Champion Sasha Banks, who has won over millions of fans with captivating performances and is only, at most, a matter of months removed from claiming gold in WWE.

There aren't too many performers in wrestling, male or female, with the skill and charisma of Banks, and the fact that she's only 24 makes her talent all the more impressive.

Banks would be a great opponent for Trish Stratus, who lead the Women's division revival of the early 2000s. Even though Stratus was a model who was hired to be a manager, she worked tirelessly to improve, eventually becoming the centerpiece of the division.

Her matches with Jazz, Victoria, Lita, Molly Holly, and Gail Kim are still fondly remembered, even if they weren't technically as good as Banks's bouts with the likes of Charlotte, Becky, and Bayley.

A battle of the generations between Banks and Stratus would let legions of women's wrestling fans finally decide who's truly tougher... and maybe it's still possible for a future WrestleMania.


5. John Cena Vs. Vader

John Cena Vader.jpg
WWE

John Cena's been on top of WWE for over a decade and during that time, he's had dozens upon dozens of classic matches with all sorts of opponents.

Still, there's always been an allure in seeing the ultimate babyface take on heels who could physically dominate him with their size and strength - from Umaga to Brock Lesnar to Kevin Owens, Cena does some of his best work when he's overmatched.

There's no better monster heel in wrestling history than Vader, who reigned as a terrifying king in WCW, New Japan, All Japan, UWFi, and Europe's CWA. His athleticism, ferocity, power, and attitude made him a star everywhere he went, and he delivered incredible matches well into his mid-40s - a rarity for a big man.

Together, Cena and Vader could do incredible things. Vader would assault the 15-time world champion, but Cena would weather the storm, and every time he even attempted to lift Vader up for the AA, the fans would go wild.

Vader, in fact, was so skilled at playing an unstoppable force of nature that the unthinkable might happen - fans might actually get behind Cena.

Sure, Cena would probably have to win at the end - that's just good storytelling. The journey would be the exciting part, though, and it's something we can all regret we'll never see.


4. Kevin Owens Vs. Bret Hart

Kevin Owens Bret Hart
WWE.com

Bret Hart isn't just a former WWE Champion - he's wrestling royalty. A worldwide sensation, Hart represented WWE as its top star around the globe in the mid-1990s, and a certain generation of wrestling fans still holds him in higher regard than just about any other grappler.

Many of us consider him the single greatest wrestler of all time.

None of that would matter to Kevin Owens, WWE's resident iconoclast. Owens debuted on the main roster with an attack on John Cena, and in his short time with the company, he's made a name for himself attacking legends and friends.

Sure, Hart is a fellow Canadian and a quintessential scientific wrestler, but Owens would attack him without remorse.

What "The Prizefighter" wouldn't count on, though, is that Hart would be willing to get just as vicious and violent as him. Despite Owens's size advantage, "The Hitman" would be more than happy to trade punches with him in a brawl that could easily turn bloody.

Owens's aerial abilities might throw Hart for a loop, but the former five-time WWE Champion would use his wrestling prowess to stay in the game, just as he always did.

The result would be a five-star contest, for sure.


3. Finn Balor Vs. Daniel Bryan

Daniel Bryan Finn Balor.jpg
WWE

Sadly, the legendary career of Daniel Bryan came to a close earlier this year when the former WWE World Heavyweight Champion was forced to retire due to concussion-related illnesses.

Though wrestling fans would forever be grateful for his sacrifices and contributions, they - and he - were devastated that he'd never be wrestling again.

The new influx of WWE and NXT talent that's arrived over the past couple of years represents a ton of potential Bryan matches that would have made us salivate. Rematches with Samoa Joe and Hideo Itami would have been great, as would a meeting with Nakamura, but a bout with Finn Balor could have taken the cake.

Both men took similar paths in their careers. Born only two months apart, they started wrestling in their late teens and accumulating as much experience and knowledge as possible. Both trained in European styles of wrestling and became international superstars before signing with WWE.

The personalities of the two super-talented technicians would make their match even more exciting. Bryan was the ultimate likeable underdog, a completely honest babyface who made no secret of how much he loved what he did.

Balor may be a face at the moment, but as leader of New Japan's Bullet Club, he emerged as a sneaky heel who was willing to build an army to get to the top.

The match would be good versus evil, bully versus underdog. The fact that it would feature two of the best wrestlers in the world would be an added bonus.


2. Samoa Joe Vs. The Rock

Samoa Joe The Rock.jpg
WWE

The Rock is many things - wrestler, actor, producer, role model, guru, and superstar. He's also a total badass. Even though he was more famous during his wrestling career for clever put-downs and the theatrical People's Elbow, his character was defined for his refusal to back down from a fight and the ease with which he dispatched his opponents.

That "never back down" attitude gave The Rock good chemistry with monster heels (just think back to the Brock Lesnar match at SummerSlam 2002), and it would serve him well in a battle with the company's freshest badass, NXT Champion Samoa Joe.

Though a Joe-Rock program would likely consist of hilarious promos at Joe's expense, once the bell rang, there'd be no joking around.

Both men would start hot from the opening bell, with Joe's viciousness and propensity to bend the rules giving him an early berth. Ultimately, though, The Rock would make a comeback, and the flying jabs and slaps between both men would create an amazing visual that would eventually lead to an incredible finishing sequence.

Like Sasha Banks versus Trish Stratus, this match is actually possible. Let's hope that we get to see it someday.


1. Seth Rollins Vs. Randy Savage

Seth Rollins Randy Savage.jpg
WWE

There can only be one number one man in WWE, and even though the company seems committed to insuring that Roman Reigns gets the top spot, there's no one with as bright a future as Seth Rollins.

Despite being one of the worst-booked WWE Champions of all-time, the heel Rollins spent 2015 winning over fans with incredible ring work, surprising charisma, and a star presence that only grew until he suffered a freak injury in November.

In the late 1980s, Randy Savage had Rollins's spot - he was the complete package, delivering amazing matches and showing a larger-than-life persona that ended up making him one of the sport's all-time most recognisable stars. Though he wasn't the largest man in the company, his talent spoke for itself.

A match between Rollins and Savage would have an atmosphere like no other. Savage would be the intense aggressor while Rollins would be the cowardly heel, and they'd play perfectly off one another.

The resulting bout would feel like the most athletic fight in history, with Savage attacking Rollins with punches and using his body as a weapon, and Rollins picking his spots before delivering swift kicks or surprising dives.

There's no telling who would win, but hopefully after the match they'd put their differences aside and join forces in the greatest heel union in WWE history.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott Fried is a Slammy Award-winning* writer living and working in New York City. He has been following/writing about professional wrestling for many years and is a graduate of Lance Storm's Storm Wrestling Academy. Follow him on Twitter at https://twitter.com/scottfried. *Best Crowd of the Year, 2013