10 Things AEW Needs To Stop Doing IMMEDIATELY
For all AEW's greatness, there are still certain issues that need to immediately be stomped out.
On a weekly basis, many would claim that All Elite Wrestling delivers the best professional wrestling action in the industry right now.
For Tony Khan's promotion, it's doing so much right these days. Like any upstart company in any sector of business, there were always going to be plentiful teething problems for AEW. And while so many of those issues have been tidied up by this point in the organisation's lifespan, there are still some unfortunate niggles that continue to plague the land of #AllElite.
Some of these niggles may be long-standing ones that date back to the formation of AEW, while others may be issues that have more recently surfaced, but all of them are things that Khan's company would be best to squash as soon as possible. Despite there being so much to enjoy about the AEW product and presentation, there are still those creases that continue to need to be ironed out.
With that in mind, then - and admittedly with the awareness that, yes, some of the following content will make your writer sound like a complete curmudgeon - here are ten things that AEW needs to stop doing ASAP.
10. Exasperated Excalibur
Make no mistake about it, Excalibur is fantastic in his role at the AEW commentary booth. For the audience AEW usually attracts, the Pro Wrestling Guerrilla co-founder is pitch-perfect with his delivery, his knowledge, and his overall enthusiasm for the All Elite product.
While it was initially somewhat cute to see Excalibur having to speed through a ridiculous amount of information in a short space of time, it's nowadays become incredibly off-putting to hear Ex genuinely run out of breath as he's tasked with hyping the action for upcoming AEW shows.
Yes, this has become a running joke amongst AEW fans, but that joke is now old and not funny.
Whether this is part of a wider problem with timing amongst AEW programming is up for debate, but regardless, it's jarring to hear Excalibur have 20 seconds to run through matches for, say, next Friday's Rampage, the following Wednesday's Dynamite, possibly Battle of the Belts or a PPV, and maybe even make the odd mention of something that's coming up on Dark or Dark: Elevation.
AEW should be commended for how much it announces and promotes matches and segments ahead of time, but the way in which the company does so needs to be improved.
9. Title Eliminator Matches
WWE rightfully gets lambasted whenever it opts to use Championship Contender's contests, and AEW likewise deserves the same response to the company's Title Eliminator efforts.
In these AEW matches, someone has to defeat a champion in order to earn a shot at the title held by said champ.
This isn't a hard concept to understand, but it's a concept that's flawed on so many levels. If a talent wins a Title Eliminator and then goes on to win that championship, it means the now-former-champ has been beaten twice. If that talent wins a Title Eliminator but then comes up short in their title match, that means that the champion loses some shine due to having been beaten in a non-title contest.
Of course, the other side of this is that certain Title Eliminator competitors are never going to realistically be the one to dethrone the champion in question, which then brings a sense of predictability to proceedings. For example, did anyone really think that the Bunny would defeat Jamie Hayter in a Title Eliminator and earn herself a shot at the AEW Women's Champion? No, no they didn't.
8. Those DREADFUL Tag Team Names
JungleHook, FTWaRdlow, ThunderStorm, Swerve in Our Glory, TayJay, WarJoe, HookHausen... okay, HookHausen isn't actually that bad, but those others are all painful examples of names given to tag teams that have featured in AEW so far.
With all of those acts, it's not like they joined the promotion with those names already in place. Nope, instead someone came up with those names and genuinely thought they sounded like a great idea. And in most cases, one would have to presume that the person coming up with the name, or at least giving the seal of approval to such a moniker, would be Tony Khan.
By taking one element of Wrestler A's name and adding it to one elements of Wrestler Z's name, all that does is make the act in question sound like it was created by a 12-year-old who was naming tandems and factions for the Universe Mode on WWE 2K22.
In all honesty, not every single tag pairing needs to have an official name given to it, particularly when a good chunk of those teams listed above were only ever designed to be short-term team-ups. Could we not have just referred to Wardlow and Samoa Joe's alliance as, well, Wardlow and Samoa Joe for the month they had each other's back on TV? Did the three-week buddy act of Jungle Boy and Hook really warrant putting the utterly awful JungleHook moniker out into the world?
7. Ownership Of Contracts
It was groan-inducing when AEW first did a Wrestler A Now Owns Wrestler B story, and it's only become more and more nauseating with each subsequent time All Elite Wrestling has opted to revisit this particular plot point.
Back at the tail end of 2008, it was plain stupid to see Shawn Michaels become the property of JBL. Skipping ahead 15 years, it's just as stupid to see such a storyline mirrored multiple times in AEW's relatively short history.
Right now, Stokely Hathaway owns Matt Hardy and Private Party. Prior to that, Isiah Kassidy and Marq Quen's contracts were owned by Andrade and La Faction Ingobernable. Before that, it was Hardy himself who claimed ownership of Kassidy and Quen. And across all of this time, each and every step of this journey has been utter garbage.
In this instance, everyone mentioned there are talents with strong upsides, but it's not the talent that's the problem here. Instead, it's the childish booking decision to have a wrestler or manager assume control of a grappler's contract. Simply put, it's just all a bit daft - and not in a 'haha' funny way.
Elsewhere, we also saw MJF claiming ownership of Wardlow for a spell. At least in that scenario, it was long established that Wardlow was an employee of the Salt of the Earth's, rather than being a contracted AEW talent. Plus, the uber-prick heel antics of Max had audiences clamouring for the War Dog to finally be free of Friedman's clutches and to be able to lay hands on his old boss.
For the likes of Private Party and Matt Hardy, not only has it always been presented that they work for AEW directly, but the HFO and AFO guff left a stench on any and all stars it touched... much like the ongoing antics of the Firm are currently doing.
6. Battle Of The Belts In Its Current Form
To date, there have been five Battle of the Belts specials - with a sixth scheduled for this April - yet these events just aren't clicking in their current format.
Of course, AEW is tied to delivering quarterly specials for TNT, but surely there has to be something better than this that the promotion can do with those quarterly slots? Currently, Battle of the Belts events are just there, serving no purpose, providing no drama, and being completely and utterly skippable if you're looking to see something newsworthy take place.
Yes, Battle of the Belts has housed some very decent wrestling bouts across those five outings so far, but nothing of significant note has happened on these shows, and the most prestigious belt of all - as in, the AEW World Championship - has yet to feature on these offerings designed to showcase AEW's grandest prizes.
To show how little suspense there is for Battle of the Belts specials, there has so far been a total of 15 matches to take place under the BOB banner, and in all 15 instances, the respective champions have retained their gold. Not just that, but the contests themselves rarely drum up even the slightest uncertainty when it comes to who will emerge victorious in these bouts.
Not to knock on the talents involved, but did anyone really think that Dustin Rhodes was going to beat Sammy Guevarra to become TNT Champion at the first Battle of the Belts? How about Nyla Rose beating Thunder Rosa for the AEW Women's Title at Battle of the Belts II? Or Jay Lethal taking the TNT Title from Wardlow at Battle of the Belts III? Maybe the Gates of Agony besting FTR to become AEW Tag Team Champions at Battle of the Belts IV? Heck, what about Sky Blue being the one to bring an end to Jade Cargill's record-setting reign as the TBS Champ at Battle of the Belts V?
While some of those named matches featured pretty solid wrestling, nobody in their right mind genuinely thought a title would be changing hands.
5. Promo Interruptions
One of the most annoying elements of pro wrestling (or sports entertainment, if you will), is realising that the only reason a wrestler is stood in the ring cutting a promo is so that somebody else can come out and interrupt that promo.
This is something that is often prevalent in WWE, and it's a problem that AEW likewise has had since the company's inception.
In the case of WWE, there's at least a small chance that a talent will get to finish their words without interruption. Unfortunately, in AEW you can have entire episodes of Dynamite or Rampage that go by without a single star being able to unload their entire diatribe.
For the AEW haters, this has been one facet of the promotion's programming that has been a piece of low-hanging fruit to poke fun at AEW with. And while promo interruptions obviously have a role to play in any and all wrestling shows, the sheer number of these interruptions throughout a regular Dynamite is almost comical.
Whether it's in the ring or backstage, so few AEW promo segments play out without another wrestler entering from stage left or stage right. Seriously, if you ever feel like getting drunk while watching AEW Dynamite, take a shot every time a promo is interrupted. Your writer here guarantees you'll be sozzled by the top of the first hour.
4. Presuming Everyone Watches Dark And Dark: Elevation
Tony Khan himself has previously discussed how he views AEW Dark and AEW Dark: Elevation as developmental shows designed for younger or more inexperienced talents to hone their craft ahead of breaking out on main Dynamite and Rampage programming.
For non-televised shows that feature a lot of lesser-known names and squash match showcases, that is absolutely the perfect way to utilise these YouTube offerings. What's not ideal, though, is delivering main TV output that is reliant on your audience having watched Dark and/or Elevation.
To take an example, so much of the ongoing, nauseating tale of the Stokely Hathaway and the Firm owning Matt Hardy's contract has played out within the confines of YouTube. While this story has been featured on Dynamite as well, one has to have watched AEW Dark to be aware of the full ins and outs of the arc.
It's great that Excalibur or Taz are on-hand to recap any Dark developments, but this shouldn't need to be the case, and likewise a quick line or two from one of the Dynamite commentary team doesn't give the full picture as to what may have transpired on YouTube.
There is the argument that having storyline elements at play on Dark or Elevation can be viewed as a tool to drive TV viewers to your YouTube programming, but the reality is that those watching Dark next week will likely be the same people who always watch Dark regardless.
Likewise, when, say, Powerhouse Hobbs randomly turns up on Rampage with a literal Book of Hobbs in his hand during his entrance, those who haven't seen Big Willy bringing that book to the ring with him on Dark and Elevation in the prior weeks may be left a little confused as to why the fella is now doing so.
Even worse, sometimes you have to watch Dark or Elevation to even realise that certain major names are still active, such as poor Hikaru Shida spending several months of last year only competing on YouTube where it pertains to her AEW bouts.
3. Such Frequent Use Of Blood
When used correctly, blood in professional wrestling is an exceptional tool to have at your disposal.
WWE may have a strict no-blood policy in place these days, but many a wrestling fan would claim that the red stuff has a key role to play in the business. As part of an all-out war between two bitter rivals, in a big match on a major PPV, and delivered at a point that feels logical and sensical in that match, blood can take a great fight to an entirely different level. Heck, why do you think the term 'blood feud' has historically had such an emotion-jarring, serious ring to it?
On the opposite end of the spectrum, if you're seeing bleeding bodies on free TV on a weekly basis, oftentimes in several matches on the same night, often in matches with zero stakes on the line or in cold bouts between two random opponents, why is it particularly unique, attention-grabbing or noteworthy when the next wrestler is busted open?
Like so much in professional wrestling, less is more. If you see the same thing on, say, Dynamite for the first ten weeks of the year, what makes it so special when that same thing happens on Week 11? Nothing, that's what.
2. Running The Gauntlet
Making a heel use his sway to force a babyface to fight an uphill battle and overcome the odds in order to earn a shot at said villain? That can be a great tool when used effectively and sparingly.
In AEW, this is a tactic that already feels overused when it pertains to making somebody run the proverbial gauntlet.
Even as of this writing, AEW has two instances of a gauntlet challenge in place on its weekly television product. There's Bryan Danielson having had to defeat five stars in order to get a crack at MJF and the AEW World Title at the upcoming Revolution PPV, whilst simultaneously Ricky Starks was tasked with running the Garcia-Guevara Gauntlet to land a match with Chris Jericho at the same PPV... despite Starks having already faced and beaten Jericho earlier this year.
Retreading familiar beats with any storyline is always a dangerous move, but to have the same narrative - as in, beat a bunch of other wrestlers to earn a shot at a certain superstar - playing out with two separate sets of talent, on the exact same TV show each week, is absolutely baffling.
It may seem like an extreme example, but imagine that while the storyline of Steve Austin trying to discover who ran him over at Survivor Series '99 was playing out, at that same time we had, say, Mick Foley involved in a similar story where the Hardcore Legend was likewise trying to find out who had run him down at the Survivor Series.
In that situation, the two similar stories dilute each other and make both feel less important - which is exactly what's happened with Danielson and Starks' respective gauntlets.
1. Referees Are Idiots
Like any new wrestling promotion looking to make a substantial mark on the industry, AEW had plentiful teething issues in its first few months and beyond. And while many of those problems have been resolved, one glaring issue the promotion continues to have is that its referees look like complete and utter idiots.
One of the elements that helps to make professional wrestling great, is that the sport has rules in place. By having clear markers in the sand of what can and cannot be done in any match, that creates anticipation, angst and most importantly can be a base to draw emotion from.
In AEW, one of the biggest criticisms of the product is that rules are rarely adhered to - to the point it would be better to just scrap certain rules rather than continue to sh*t all over them.
If wrestlers are only allowed to be outside of the ring for no longer than nine seconds lest they lose a match by countout, how limp and useless does a referee look when talents regularly brawl outside for anywhere between 30 seconds and two minutes? There are only so many times one of the commentary team can note how Official A is being lenient with their count before it just becomes lazy from all involved.
Likewise, the traditional five-second allowance for double-team manoeuvres when a wrestler has tagged into a bout is another rule forever flaunted. It's unfortunately commonplace that a tag will lead to 20 seconds of double-team offense, with the referee simply standing there and admiring the action.
And not to sound like the ultimate 'angry old man shouts at clouds', but AEW similarly has a worrying habit of any illegal interference taking place directly in front of a referee, only for that official to bafflingly have not seen that action nor chastised the person responsible for it.