10 Things Nobody Has Told You About WWE WrestleMania

Shawn Michaels is Mr. WrestleMania. Who isn't...?

Triple H Roman Reigns
WWE

According to the marketing, WWE WrestleMania is better than deep throat road head in a Lamborghini.

It's the Greatest Wrestling Event of All Time! It's What The World Has Come To! It's Bigger! Better! Badder! It's What The World Is Watching! It's (where) the Mega Powers Explode! It's the Ultimate Challenge - describing not the main event, but rather Hulk Hogan's struggle to put somebody over without covering himself in glory!

(Difficulty level: impossible).

It's the World's Largest Toga Party! It's, in the case of WrestleMania XI, so flat that it doesn't warrant a tagline! It's Heat! It's the Greatest PPV Attraction of All-Time! It's the Ragin' Climax! It's a McMahon In Every Corner, meaning more WrestleMania main events were built around Linda McMahon than CM Punk! It's Big Time, if that hadn't been adequately established over two decades ago, God, what a bad tagline!

It's All Grown Up, which just sounds creepy! It's the 25th Anniversary of WrestleMania, except it isn't, because Vince McMahon is an imbecile and everybody is at this point too scared to tell him he's wrong!

It's the Ultimate Thrill Ride: the Show of Shows that's always great, always the biggest of the year, and always where the top wrestlers in the world want to be!

But how true is all that...?

10. At WrestleMania 39, An 18-Year Cycle Gets Broken

Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes, with an impressive diplomacy, stated earlier this year that the Rock's presence isn't needed at WrestleMania 39.

And you know what?

He's right.

For years and years, WWE relied on part-time stars from the Attitude Era and the time of 'Ruthless Aggression' to mask the very bleak fact that the promotion was incapable of building new acts that connected with the public on that level. The Undertaker was exhumed once a year for several years. Before every muscle in his body exploded, WWE even managed to get the Rock to work two consecutive years. Brock Lesnar and Triple H worked annual matches. Batista made two separate comebacks.

By WrestleMania 36, a cycle that began in 2011 threatened to repeat itself nine years later; it was now John Cena's turn to go away, become an even bigger star, and then work 'Mania. All the while, many of the acts you were expected to invest in across the other 364 days of the year didn't get a sniff. Dolph Ziggler, for example, has worked just one singles match at WrestleMania.

Things are different now, and while Triple H's week-to-week episodic booking is sometimes dry, it is also effective. The Bloodline saga, a collaborative effort which should provide the blueprint for WWE's creative in future, is so hot and compelling in a layered way that it feels like, for the first time in years, the promotion has actually earned the hype. Really, even though the part-timer era began at WrestleMania XXVII, this year's 'Road' is the most compelling and forward-thinking build since WrestleMania 21.

And not before time...


9. There Are Shockingly Few Great Openers

Eddie Guerrero Rey Mysterio
WWE

In WrestleMania "lore", the list of middling opening matches far outstrips the list of red-hot openers.

While Tito Santana and Ricky Steamboat did a fine job of ungluing the crowd in the early years of the event, it was only at VII that the first really strong opener - Rockers Vs. Haku and Barbarian, a cracking brains versus brawn match - was promoted on the Grandest Stage. It took WWE a full decade to book a truly excellent opener, but it was worth the wait; Bret's slow realisation that he had to fight his brat of a brother at X was a superb beat that intensified a flawless technical affair.

WWE's form in the '90s was otherwise shocking.

In fact, the opening slot started to feel like a curse; by WrestleMania 21, two decades and only two very good opening matches in, Rey Mysterio struggled with his mask as much as he did his opponent Eddie Guerrero. That match was a clunky disappointment, the odd electrifying moment aside.

The 2000s was saved only by two excellent Money In The Bank matches and a blackly comedic Belfast Brawl. The 2010s hardly started off hot; furthering the "curse" theory, the Shield had their one average match in a sea of rippers at WrestleMania 29. From XXX onwards, the hex was reversed, but even 'Mania 38 feel victim to it as a result of a very unfortunate injury suffered by Rick Boogs.

Nonetheless, the seminal Daniel Bryan Vs. Triple H and a handful of hot matches aside, the opener of WrestleMania was only ever good a quarter of the time at best.


8. WrestleMania IX Is NOT The Worst One

Randy Savage Hulk Hogan WrestleMania IV
WWE.com

IX is the consensus worst WrestleMania, and it's certainly a bit poor, but how true is that?

There isn't a single good match at WrestleMania IV, though it delivered the correct, happy ending. The perception of IX as the all-time worst is informed by its own ending, but while it was a disgrace, pure desperation, the fans enjoyed it and Bret Hart did eventually become an established World champion. It was the principle of the thing, not the thing itself, and the thing didn't end up mattering too much.

Given the WWF's financial woes and downturn in popularity, IX's outdoor aesthetic was actually a spectacle as fun as it was resourceful. Even when Bob Backlund was somehow conspiring to remind fans of a time older than Ancient Rome, in an awful styles clash with Razor Ramon, the event still had a chintzy splendour to it.

Yes, even the good stuff was few, far between and too long - Shawn Michaels Vs. Tatanka, Steiners Vs. Headshrinkers - but Bret Hart was outstanding in the main event with Yokozuna, who never looked more like a dynamic, terrifying monster.

II was a low-rent experimental disaster, though the three cards did yield three cracking matches by the standard of the time. 32 was a two-match show with the most forced 'Moment' ever.

IV is the absolute worst for atmosphere and match quality. Unquestionably.


7. It's OK Not To Have Watched WrestleMania I

Wrestlemania 1
WWE.com

The other contender for the worst ever WrestleMania show is of course the very first edition.

It's slightly better than you might expect from a mid-1980s WWF card. Ricky Steamboat Vs. Matt Borne was a dynamic and unfussy sprint by the standards of the time, though it's hardly worth watching back in 2023. That applies very much to Tito Santana's opening win over the Executioner.

Andre the Giant's Bodyslam challenge win over Big John Studd was improbably effective; WWF fans of the day hadn't yet been insulted into not taking retirement stipulations seriously. The main event was a loud spectacle that was never about the in-ring quality; as much a mission statement of Vince McMahon's World Wrestling Federation as anything else. Elsewhere, it is a dimly-lit chore to get through. Much of the action borders on appalling. Enduring the first WrestleMania feels like a rite of passage, something one has to do as a fan. Some feel guilty for never getting 'round to it.

The show was fundamental to Vince McMahon's success as a promoter. He really did leverage everything on it; were it to have failed, the expansion would not have happened. The WWF may not have happened.

It's more important to Vince than it will ever be to anybody else.


6. Great Wrestling Doesn't Always Get Over On The Grandest Stage

AJ Styles Edge
WWE.com

Almost every year, a strange, recurring phenomenon unfolds at WrestleMania, particularly in this ongoing stadium-sized era: great wrestling matches on paper fail to get over.

That, or a match with ****1/2 potential very quietly creeps, just about, over the *** line. These matches, examples of which follow, aren't necessarily duds - but for whatever reason, the WrestleMania workrate special fails more often than not.

Chris Jericho Vs. Edge from WrestleMania XXVI was very good without approaching great. Two years later, Jericho had another weirdly flat match with CM Punk, which was also very well-worked but failed to generate a monstrous reaction. AJ Styles Vs. Edge and AJ Styles Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura were worse, considerably so. Not every intricate, technical match loses the crowd, whose reaction evaporates with no roof to contain what little sound is generated. Daniel Bryan Vs. Kofi Kingston at 'Mania 35 was a special match with a furnace of an atmosphere. But the list is too long relative to the talent involved.

So what's the problem?

Why does this happen every other year?

Is it a case of failing to work a match in line with the expectations of the audience? Is it as simple as WWE's agents making the more dynamic wrestlers slow it down for the benefit of a casual audience?

Watching a half-speed version of a counter-driven scientific match doesn't work; as ever in wrestling, only high-octane excitement or deep emotional stakes get over.

The strange halfway point between the two has failed WWE too often.


5. The Streak Ended As It Should Have

Streak 21-1 Wrestlemania 30 Brock
WWE

At WrestleMania XXX, Brock Lesnar defeated the Undertaker and ended his incredible 'Streak' in the process.

Bad match, incredible production: WWE effectively orchestrated a grieving process amongst the live crowd. The denial in the Superdome was, from the perspective of somebody who attended the show live, a powerful feeling. The magnitude of the result was such that it simply could not have happened. That's how brilliantly WWE had marketed the Streak. And to have Lesnar, of all people, be the one to end it?

It was a transgression.

The thing is, if you consider the alternatives, Brock was the correct choice.

Winning a major match is no guarantee of getting over, for starters.

Lesnar was a special attraction and big draw that WWE had nearly killed off by having Triple H go over him in one of the most boring major matches in recorded history. Lesnar ultimately existed to put Roman Reigns over. WWE had a long-term goal in mind. It didn't work, but there was a methodology at play. This wasn't some mean-spirited whim on the part of Vince McMahon. In Lesnar, he created a Big Bad for a purpose. Beating the guy who beat the Undertaker, in theory, would have lessened the risk of fans resenting Roman. Roman was planned to be the top guy for a decade.

Think of the names mooted to end the Streak in the 2000s. While this doesn't excuse WWE's pathetic inability to create new stars, you can probably forgive them for worrying that whomever ended such a significant record could have feasibly been the next Mr. Kennedy. "WWE should have had an emerging young star end the Streak" is probably more naive a take than many are willing to admit. Imagine if they'd actually given it to Bray Wyatt. A fat load of good that would've done.

The broken creative mechanisms simply didn't allow for Bray or Rusev or Cesaro or anyone to benefit from ending it over the long-term. In an ideal world, yes, a red-hot act should have ended the Streak - but it was never a guaranteed vehicle to stardom in that era of WWE.

Whomever ended it would have been scripted to remind fans in promos for the rest of their careers, like the Miz reading his Championships and Accomplishments section of Wikipedia every Monday night.

Sounds quite boring.


4. CM Punk Doesn't Regret Not Headlining It (And He's Not Alone)

CM Punk
AEW

CM Punk was adamant, per the Best In The World three-disc DVD set, that he should have headlined WrestleMania XXVII.

To him, WrestleMania's top attraction is a simple process: it should be the best good guy going against the best bad guy. John Cena was always the top babyface draw, and in 2010, ahead of 'Mania XXVII, Punk's exceptional work in the Straight Edge Society cast him as the premier heel in the promotion.

Vince McMahon disagreed.

Punk lobbied to get eliminated in a pitched Triple Threat match with the Rock and John Cena at WrestleMania 29. He sensed it was dry as a rematch (it was) and believed he was good enough to warrant the 'Mania main event (he was).

Vince McMahon disagreed.

Vince McMahon tried to tell him that, as his consolation match with the Undertaker was by some distance the best and hottest thing on the show, Punk was in the main event.

CM Punk disagreed.

The WrestleMania main event, the last match, was Punk's validation that he was perceived as a top star internally. This gnawed at him, and if it wasn't the sole reason why he walked, it was a not inconsiderable factor. He realised years later that going on last was something he no longer wished to get hung up on. And he isn't the only one.

Jon Moxley would rather blade and tell his own stories than have a writer plot his course to the 'Mania main event. Kenny Omega's bargaining power was such, in 2018, that he could have demanded the WrestleMania main event in the contract WWE was desperate for him to sign. He didn't. Eddie Kingston doesn't want to work for WWE. Bryan Danielson headlined the show in 2021 and felt nothing.

WrestleMania is massive - but it isn't the be all and end all it was 10 years ago.


3. AJ Styles Is The Anti-Mr. WrestleMania

AJ Styles Shinsuke Nakamura WrestleMania 34
WWE.com

AJ Styles is at this point a pro wrestling legend with an endlessly impressive body of work.

He was at his best in New Japan Pro Wrestling, in which he was finally able to become a major player at a consistent level and best showcase his brilliant ability to make a super-exciting match flow with a main event elegance. Even in WWE, past his physical prime, he has contested many thrillers. His match with Daniel Bryan at TLC 2019 might be the most underrated match in modern wrestling history. Few talk about it, because their more memorable Royal Rumble match was such an unfathomable bore, but it was so great. Intricate, breathless drama of the highest order. His WrestleMania record is closer to that Rumble match, though.

Has any great wrestler worked quite as many duds as AJ on the grandest stage?

At WrestleMania 32, he wrestled Chris Jericho in a good if clunky effort that went too long. His 'Mania 33 opener with Shane McMahon, the outlier, was a demonstration of AJ's greatness more than a great, credible match. At 34, he and Shinsuke Nakamura worked a half-speed version of a basic WWE main event. At 35, Styles and Randy Orton went on a methodical journey, the destination to which was three generous stars. At 36, he played a decent jackass in the Boneyard.

At 37, he worked a long-forgotten face in peril spot as a heel, and, at 38, he worked a match with Edge so slow and drab that even Triple H would have told them to get out of first gear.


2. It Is No Longer The Most Important Event Of The Year

Vince McMahon Saudi Arabia
WWE

In many respects, WWE WrestleMania is the biggest wrestling show of the year.

Of course it is.

It draws the most fans. It almost invariably promotes the biggest attractions. It's such a memorable and visually stunning spectacle that a good match becomes instantly better through its backdrop alone. It is the night on which wrestling superstars evolve into legends; without his Streak, the Undertaker is a naff, methodical bum who was only good for two years between the New Generation and Attitude Eras.

It is the show that the vast majority of wrestlers dreaming of headlining growing up. It is the show that the most wrestling fans watch. It is the show that lapsed fans watch because there's no stigma surrounding it. It is socially justifiable to watch WrestleMania under the pretext of nostalgia. You can't not watch WrestleMania. It's WrestleMania!

The grim truth however is, if you told Vince McMahon that he had to give up either WrestleMania or an event emanating from Saudi Arabia, he'd tell WrestleMania - the highest-grossing edition of which has only brought in a third of the money "generated" by any propaganda show - that it is fired.

"It's my fiduciary duty to shareholders, pal!"


1. 50/50

Triple H Roman Reigns
WWE

What follows is a subjective, qualitative assessment of every WrestleMania main event.

Your mileage may vary, but an attempt has been made to articulate the consensus. It would be asinine bad faith so suggest that something like the conclusion to 'Mania XXX was anything less than euphoric, just to craft an argument.

How many headline attractions did the business, commercially and or artistically?

Across 38 WrestleMania shows, incorporating the three-night 'Mania II and the recent trend of two-night events, WWE has promoted 43 main events. Of that number, 23 were worthy in some way, whereas a staggering 20 were not.

WrestleMania I - woeful match, business triumph. II - three not great main events, business failure. III, IV, V and VI all justified the retroactively imposed Golden Era tag (IV was hardly great, but delivered the happy ending). VII was a good bit of artistic business, but the event bombed spectacularly. VIII was botched beyond belief. IX is widely considered a disaster, even if the official semi-main is wildly underrated. X restored order to decent effect. XI bombed, but the main event itself over-delivered. XII bombed, and the match itself under-delivered. 13 was rotten. XIV was a monster of a success. The glory days continued at XV, but 2000, while savvy - Backlash 2000 was the most successful B PPV ever - was bang average in and of itself. X-Seven killed the business, but what a piss-up at the wake Austin Vs. Rock II was.

X8 bombed. XIX ended disastrously and was far from the best Angle/Lesnar pairing. XX - at the time - was a triumph. 21 did the business, if little else, to a record-setting degree. That gets a generous tick in the good versus dud column. 22, 23 and 24 were all great and very successful. 25 was as masturbatory as Triple H ever got. XXVI was seminal; if there's an opposite to that word, XXVII embodied it. XXVIII was as successful as 29 was an uninspiring diminished return. XXX and 31 both yielded awesome main events. 32 was a punishment. 33 was just sad. 34 was just desperate. 35 was heatless and botched. 36 was an uneven combination of resourceful "cinematic" and Paul Heyman Special cliché. 37 yielded two incredible triumphs. At 38, WWE both promoted one of the most magical returns in company history and yet another snoozer of a Heyman Brock formula match.

At WrestleMania, Vince McMahon promoted a main event dud 46.51% of the time, almost, in effect, going 50/50.

A fitting legacy for his career as a promoter.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!