10 Things Pro Wrestling Is Still Terrible At

Reinvention needed.

The Dark Order
AEW

It's kinda' remarkable that wrestling has been enjoyable at all in 2020.

The ongoing global pandemic certainly hasn't helped WWE or AEW, but both major companies have endeavoured to keep on kicking despite the lack of natural ambience or any sense of pre-March 2020 normality. They deserve a lot of credit for that.

There, the nice bit is out of the way. Now to crucify both products and serve up a sobering sense of reality! OK, not quite. Still, there are so many things that pro wrestling generally (not just WWE and AEW) is absolutely bloody terrible at - those promotions just happen to be in the firing line first because of their status as influential leading lights.

They're not new phenomenons either. This list is crammed full of mistakes that wrestling was making before the entire world was shaken by a health scare. Most worryingly, none of them seem to be things that companies are in any real rush to fix. That's a pity, because they really need fixing.

Good sides to both groups would be enhanced if they actually sorted these out. Don't hold your breath...


10. Pre-Shows That Build Anticipation

WWE Hell In A Cell 2020 Kickoff
WWE

Yawning.

That's what you'll be doing a lot of if you tune into any pay-per-view pre-show these days. It says everything for how bland these things are that Todd freakin' Pettengill playing a borderline children's TV host on those old 'Free For All' programs in the '90s was superior to what fans see now.

Both WWE's Kickoff portions and AEW's Buy In pre-games are the most skippable pieces of content in pro wrestling. Tune in and you'll get a match, sure, but you'll also be asked to sit through endless video packages (that will probably air again on the main show) and sports-style analyst roundtables.

Somebody needs to sit down and figure out a way to make these things more entertaining. They totally fail to build anticipation for the pay-per-view that's upcoming, which is damning when that's their only purpose. The hour-long length is also a tad ambitious.


9. Moving On From Tired Ideas

Dolph Ziggler Robert Roode
WWE.com

WWE fans know what they're going to get when calendars turn to November. Suddenly, everyone gets all brand proud, and some even enjoy sporting show-specific baseball caps (Dolph Ziggler) to publicly push their so-called loyalty. It's boring, it's formulaic and it's time the company moved on.

Raw vs. SmackDown, it may surprise them to learn, isn't a good replacement for title feuds or one-on-one rivalries. There's nothing at stake - this hackneyed idea has been Survivor Series' on/off main theme since 2005, and that sucks. 15 years of quite stunning mediocrity later, it's still going on.

AEW should pay attention here. They haven't been around long enough for this to become a major problem, but it will be one if they're not careful. Wrestling in general has a real problem with moving on from concepts that are past their sell-by-date.

Survivors is proof.


8. Battle Royals

Casino Battle Royale build
AEW

Seriously, when was the last must-see Battle Royal?

Click back to the previous entry to see the word "formulaic". That sums these multi-person matches up perfectly; in fairness to workers, it must be hard to come up with anything fresh when there are between 19-49 other wrestlers filling up the ring. So, everyone relies on the same old spots or just sorta' stumbles around until they're scheduled for elimination.

This writer would go as far to suggest that everyone scraps Battle Royals completely. The only exception here would be WWE's established Royal Rumble, because that's been a winner since they tweaked the early 20-entrant format to 30, and it's an event fans look forward to every single year.

AEW's Casino variant doesn't get a pass here either. It's a time-waster on pay-per-views, and the kick and punch style of the things don't suit All Elite's roster anyway. For example, why was Rey Fenix in one at All Out? Who thought that fit his style?


7. Booking Without Authority Figures

Adam Pearce Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

There was a brief period there when WWE booked without authority figures, but that was never going to last long. Adam Pearce, previously only seen when "officials" needed to break up a brawl that had spiralled out of control, has been slotted right into a soft role as match-maker on Raw and SmackDown.

Nobody has explained how that happened.

Again, this is less of an issue in AEW. There, owner Tony Khan rarely shows face, and he's not one to come out on stage to announce main events or cut down heels. Long may that continue, 'cause it'd be unnecessary at best and eye-rolling stuff at worst. Pearce's WWE dominion is baffling.

Wrestling has relied on authority figures since Vince McMahon vs. Steve Austin hit big in the late-'90s. The problem is that nobody has been able to top that (most don't even come close), and the trope is one of grappling's laziest.


6. Fleshing Out A Women's Division

Hikaru Shida Rache Chanel
AEW

Note the words "fleshing out".

Women's wrestling has come a long way since gals were flopping around in gravy or raising heart rates by stripping one another down to their smalls. WWE and AEW proudly present serious matches that rightly promote equality, but things aren't perfect yet.

WWE tend to focus on big title feuds, which leaves the other women largely directionless. There are exceptions, of course - Mandy Rose and Sonya Deville had something going on over the summer, but they're few and far between. Over in AEW, things are even less impressive.

Other than the recent NWA integration, their women's division is woeful. Riho was a poor first champion, and characters like Hikaru Shida haven't been developed properly. It's a mess of dull personalities who rarely get enough screen time to make feuds mean anything.


5. Comedy

Otis The Miz
WWE.com

Ask Jim Ross what he thinks of comedy in wrestling and the AEW announcer will probably suggest it has no place near the top of the card. Via his 'Grilling JR' podcast, Ross once criticised wrestling's need to play 'ha ha' as much as possible. He has a point there. WWE, in particular, can't resist.

It's rare that such hijinks are genuinely funny.

Santino Marella was an exception, not a rule. His behaviour was endearing, and it was obvious that he penned much of his material himself. The Miz and John Morrison... not so much. It's hard to pinpoint exactly who would find Otis stripping Miz to his tighty-whities hilarious - it really is. Kids, maybe? Even then, maybe not.

The Rock, Kurt Angle and Chris Jericho are all examples of guys who managed to marry comedy with serious feuds and make it work. They were elite-level performers though. Miz and Morrison are hardly bad, but they're not miracle workers and can't make WWE's sophomoric slapstick land.


4. Most Heel Factions

Mustafa Ali RETRIBUTION
WWE

It's understandable why wrestling companies would pin their hopes on a bad guy collective tearing up programming; the original D-Generation X, nWo and Four Horsemen factions were all blueprints, and later examples like The Shield produced gold too. Thus, the heel faction has become a go-to template.

The success rate is lower than you might think though, especially when those groups aren't booked with any real, sustained menace. WWE's Retribution sticks out in 2020, as does AEW's Dark Order. Some Elite fans will cry foul at that, but it's true - the Order are there to be slapped around more than dominate.

Also, the less said about Brandi Rhodes' 'Nightmare Collective' experiment, the better.

Having a number of lesser members who only exist so babyfaces have someone to bump about the place is counterproductive. These associates dilute the threat of the faction they're tied to, and they only make leaders look like chumps when they cut grandiose promos promising destruction.


3. Engaging Backstage Promos

Kris Statlander Alex Marvez
AEW

Eric Bischoff recently took a pop at WWE's promo style. He called it "completely artificial", and said the company really need to find a new format that doesn't take place in front of "static environments" or feel like 2001. The Bisch refused to pull any punches. Much like JR earlier, his views hold merit.

WWE's scripted question and answer sessions are a disgrace to the lively promos once conducted by Gene Okerlund and others. Wrestlers rarely speak like real people, and finding something provocative or important in these backstage scenes is difficult. They're rinse-and-repeat sessions, and they lack punch.

AEW's are the same. Alex Marvez sounds like he's impersonating The Hurricane as 'Roving Reporter' Gregory Helms. If fans are to believe that All Elite don't overproduce talent like WWE do, then that's even worse. It means that Marvez has less excuses than Charly Caruso for being tedious.

Some energy, or some actual plot points Marvez could explore, would be nice.


2. Resisting Senseless Head-To-Heads

AEW NXT
AEW/WWE

Yours truly got caught up in the hype and hullabaloo when it was revealed that AEW Dynamite and WWE's NXT would be going head-to-head on Wednesday nights. Finally, everyone said, the same spirit evoked by ye olde 'Monday Night Wars' would ride again. The truth is a little less constructive.

In fact, this head-on clash is detrimental to both products.

Look at it this way: AEW are beating NXT weekly, but detractors will always point to this as a hollow win because they're only topping WWE's third string brand. The WWE side isn't much better. They're harming NXT's potential by constantly trying to one-up AEW rather than continuing to produce the solid, logical and counter-culture program they once did.

As a result, both companies suffer slightly. Though it may seem stuffy, someone should toy with the thought of switching nights and ceasing this old-fashioned ratings battle. Being honest, it's probably WWE who have to jump first. This head-to-head is doing nothing for them or NXT, and there's a better chance that AEW's audience will eventually rise.


1. Being Grown Up

Cody Thronebreaker
AEW (Ricky Havlik)

Unfortunately, pro wrestling just can't grow up.

The threat of AEW's rise as legit competition prompted Triple H to declare them a "pissant company" at WWE's Hall Of Fame ceremony. Firing back, Cody decided to decimate a distinctly 'King Of Kings'-like throne during AEW's first Double Or Nothing pay-per-view. Both of these scenarios made everyone involved look like children.

The petty squabbles and constant digs haven't stopped since, and it's all so... avoidable. It's like two kids watched the WWF and WCW trade barbs in the '90s and thought, 'I'm gonna' do that when I grow up'. What they should've said was, 'I'm gonna' do that unless I grow up". Wrestling shows no signs of doing exactly that.

Even Vince McMahon got involved when he dismissed AEW as "blood and guts". Really? After everything WWE has presented over the years? Cody also took another shot back on Dynamite last year when he cheekily remarked, "They're botching it on two channels now" shortly after SmackDown debuted on FOX.

Some will see this as early, harmless fun. That's fine. Does it really need to keep happening though?

What else, if anything, do you think wrestling is still terrible at? For more, check out 10 WWE Greats Who Made TERRIBLE First Impressions and 10 Gimmick Matches WWE Should NEVER Book Again!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.