10 Things That MUST Happen During CM Punk’s WWE Return
WWE and CM Punk can make this second run better than the first. Here's how they do it!
Hell has apparently frozen over.
CM Punk has mended fences with Triple H after almost a decade of tension, and the 'Pipebomb Prince' is back in WWE. Punk's re-arrival at Survivor Series: WarGames naturally made headlines, but it also has some wondering just how long the honeymoon vibes will last before Punk starts pissing everyone off behind the scenes.
WWE will be bending over backwards to make sure that doesn't happen. Besides, this is business, and everyone has boatloads of money to make heading into the traditionally-lucrative Royal Rumble to WrestleMania season sprint. That'll be Hunter and Punk's top priority, especially until the final fireworks sound in April.
There's a lot to catch up on here anyway. Punk has titles to win, old alliances to rekindle, personal bucket list items to tick off, and dream matches to work. The latter is definitely something wrestling fans had given up on, but it's entirely possible now 'Pepsi Phil' is back in the E.
So, how do WWE (and Punk himself) make sure this second attempt matches/betters his 2005-2014 stint? Here's everything that simply has to happen in December 2023 and beyond.
10. WWE Ignores Easy AEW/Tony Khan Digs
Some folks hit social media to tear CM Punk's comeback promo on Monday's Raw to shreds. Seriously, go search his name and you'll see endless streams of comments lambasting the man for failing to reference AEW, Tony Khan, Jack Perry, Hangman Page, The Young Bucks, Kenny Omega and more.
That was never going to happen.
It shouldn't anyway - Triple H and his creative team must sidestep any temptation to senselessly guffaw at All Elite Wrestling just for the sake of it. What would that even achieve? It'd only give the other company more impressions on X, and get people talking about AEW in the same breath as WWE.
Let's make one thing crystal clear: Punk would be landing in legal hot water if he started mouthing off about Khan and the worst moments from his fiery All Elite run. That'd be stupid. Some fans can clamour for on-air dirt all they want here, but it's not happening.
9. Triple H Keeps Him On A Short Leash
Of course, that's not to say that Punk is a changed man who suddenly mellowed when he put pen-to-paper on that second WWE contract. The guy's AEW run kicked off with similar wholesome vibes and positivity, but things went to shit once backstage in-fighting became more interesting to fans than anything CM was doing on-screen.
Triple H will know he can't let that happen under his watch.
Punk will surely have been warned he'll end up headfirst in a wheelie bin courtesy of Roman Reigns if he starts getting too big for his boots. WWE is a different environment; it's a stricter one, and the kind of nonsense Punk was pulling elsewhere just won't fly anymore.
He'll have to be kept on a short leash, and perhaps regularly reminded of his responsibilities to the machine-like grind of WWE business. Do that, and CM Punk will make oodles of cash to pad both his and the company's bank accounts further.
8. Punk Is Raw Exclusive (For Now)
One can see WWE trying to capitalise on Punk's comeback by booking ratings-boosting segments on Raw, SmackDown and NXT. In short, ol' CM might go on a tour of every brand the promotion has to offer, then eventually settle into a groove on the flagship heading into 'Mania season.
Thanks, but no thanks.
It's important that Punk is booked exclusively as an attraction for Raw. SmackDown has Roman Reigns anyway, and that's enough (along with United States Champ and genuine celeb Logan Paul) to keep things locked down on the blue side. Solely dangling CM Punk in front of the Monday night crowd is a real must.
WWE does a frankly crap job of making their Draft mean a thing every single time they do one. Keep Punk exclusive to Raw, then make a lot of noise about his eventual jump to SmackDown in 12-18 months and...maybe fans will start to care about this brand stuff again.
Maybe.
7. He Wins The Royal Rumble
Granted, some people out there aren't going to like this.
LA Knight, GUNTHER and even Cody Rhodes have all been suggested as possible men's Royal Rumble match winners. Cody would be repeating his trick from 2023 just to set up a rematch vs. Roman Reigns, so he might be considered the least likely of the trio. WWE could get there rather easily sans Rumble triumph.
There'd be howls about unfairness in some quarters if Punk returned to the company mix and scooped someone else's 30-man glory too, but such is life. Keep in mind that the Rumble is supposed to ready wrestlers for guaranteed World Title matches at WrestleMania. Is that really going to happen for Knight in 2024?
LA vs. Roman isn't as big as Cody vs. Reigns II. Similarly, Knight vs. Seth Rollins doesn't sing with the same vibrance as Punk vs. Rollins. Yep, it seems 'Mr. Pipebomb' might've just put himself in the frame to win out come January.
He'll be a lot happier than he was back in 2014, that's for sure.
6. CM Punk = WrestleMania Main Eventer
One of Punk's biggest bitches about WWE life before was that Vince McMahon never let him headline WrestleMania. The 'Voice Of The Voiceless' cried foul that part-timers like The Rock were drafted in for money-spinning efforts vs. John Cena, and he generally hated the fact that he wasn't in the convo for 'Mania main events.
2024 will change that.
WWE's annual juggernaut has morphed into an altogether wider beast in the modern era. WrestleMania takes place over multiple nights now, and that means there's more scope for workers to bag the top spot on cards than ever before. Case in point: An Undisputed Tag Title match headlining the first night in 2023.
Punk has never had a better chance to go on last at 'Mania. His coming showdown with Seth Rollins has heat, and it seems likely WWE will have the World Heavyweight Title headline one of the nights. Stick Punk vs. Seth down as a safe enough bet for night one.
5. Beats Seth Rollins To Win The World Title
Seth Rollins is the first and only WWE World Heavyweight Champ under the revived belt's current lineage. He won it back at Night Of Champions in May 2023, and has held the thing with distinction as a battling workhorse ever since. Unfortunately for he-with-the-dazzling-outfits, all good things must come to an end.
Absolutely no-one would've predicted that CM Punk would supplant Rollins back when Seth beat Finn Bálor though. Therein lies the beauty of pro wrestling - it's ever-evolving, and constantly throws up surprises to keep things at boiling point. Punk is almost a dead cert to beat Rollins and become the second champion.
There's money in it.
This could even facilitate a return to the heel side for Seth, or maybe he'd show begrudging respect for someone he definitely hasn't been fond of up to this point and they'd co-exist. Stranger things have happened, but Punk is winning that strap regardless of how Rollins feels about it.
4. He Becomes A Paul Heyman Guy Again
Stop the press!
Yes, CM Punk and Paul Heyman ended up hating on one another following their critically-acclaimed partnership a decade or so ago. WWE used their split to help push Punk's latest babyface turn at the time, but that's all water under the bridge in 2023/2024 isn't it?
Would anyone be totally taken aback if Heyman and Punk came back together as one and the latter turned into a "Paul Heyman Guy" all over again? That might be too tempting for creative to resist, especially once they've burned through a few other scenarios for Punk and need something to keep things interesting.
It's only a matter of time before the Roman Reigns-led Bloodline story comes to a close anyway, so Paul E will require a fresh feeling role himself. If Triple H doesn't want to go the Curtis Axel route and try turn Heyman into an undercard miracle worker, then he may fancy getting the old band back together with Punk.
3. There’s A “Pipebomb” Moment
Again, a lot of fans apparently thought CM Punk was going to cut through his AEW run, chastise Tony Khan and then wave at FTR (or something) during his comeback promo on Raw. That's not the kind of "pipebomb" being pitched here. No, Punk shouldn't talk about his All Elite days.
He should, however, start getting more provocative again on the mic.
That's when CM is at his best. He's excellent at being a smart-arse who delights in calling things as he sees them with enough rebellious spirit to bring a tear to Steve Austin's eyes. At some stage, WWE will have to reach into Punk's bag of tricks and see if he has any cutting magic left on the stick.
Perhaps he can bite back at WWE of old, or maybe he'd be best-served keeping his best digs for Seth Rollins between January-April. Things are all nicey-nicey now, but that won't be the case forever. This is CM Punk we're talking about!
2. WWE Books Some Dream Matches
A few years ago, you'd have been laughed out of the room for suggesting that CM Punk vs. Steve Austin was a realistic proposition. After all, 'Stone Cold' had made it clear on numerous occasions that he wouldn't be wrestling again, and Punk had landed on AEW TV anyway.
That match has arguably never been more likely.
Austin returned to the ring at 'Mania 38 to brawl with Kevin Owens, and there's every chance he'd be creatively excited about the thought of matching up against Punk in 2024. Someone should whisper that in Steve's ear, then watch him hit the weights hard in preparation for a mega-match.
It's one Punk would want too. He's made no secret of his admiration for the 'Stone Cold' character in the past, and there's no way CM would scoff at the thought of finally scratching this itch. Over to you, Triple H. SummerSlam meet up, lads? Never say never.
1. He Becomes A WWE Hall Of Famer
What's the ideal length for Punk's second WWE stab? Three years? A few out there might even prefer something shorter - they'll just want to see their hero get everything he craves in an 18 month span, then ride off into the sunset with his head held high without causing drama behind the curtain.
Beyond that, the Hall Of Fame awaits.
Why not? Punk was a big deal during his first WWE run between 2005-2014, is still fondly remembered as one of the best indy standouts throughout a peak era for ROH, and he's been a lightning rod on the microphone since forever. There's more than enough meat on the bone for a HOF speech.
The man's biggest critics might disagree, but nobody can objectively dismiss everything CM Punk has contributed to pro wrestling over the past 20 years or so. Being sick of backstage histrionics is one thing. Dismissing his impact on-screen and in-ring is another.
What else do you think must happen during CM Punk's WWE comeback run? For more wrestling, check out 3 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Rampage (Nov 25 - Results & Review) and 10 New Directions For WWE After Survivor Series: WarGames 2023!