10 Things We Learned About Chris Benoit Tragedy From Kevin Sullivan On Jim Cornette's Podcast
The 'Taskmaster' gives his side of the story...
If you haven't checked out VICE's excellent two-part 'Dark Side Of The Ring' documentary on Chris Benoit, then you're missing out.
The stunning doc explores Benoit's in-ring career, psyche, relationship with wife Nancy, the fallout of his crimes and more. Through it all, only one thing was missing: Kevin Sullivan's side of the story. VICE ran a caption that claimed Sullivan was approached and didn't have any comments to give. That's not strictly true.
Sullivan joined Jim Cornette for a follow-up podcast interview designed to let the ex-WCW booker (and kayfabe satanist) clear up some misinformation he feels was given by VICE. There was talk on his real relationship with Nancy before Benoit even came on the scene, news on why he booked the storylines he did and what he thought of 'Dark Side Of The Ring'.
Think of this as a vital companion piece to the VICE film. It sheds some new light on several things discussed by Nancy's sister Sandra Toffolini, and it's not the bitter hatchet job some might be expecting. Sullivan is keen to move on with his life, and doesn't think it's fair others have to relive their own personal hell.
Here's everything we learned...
10. Why He Wasn't On VICE's Documentary
So, why wasn't Sullivan involved in that documentary?
He told Cornette that he wanted to get approval from Nancy's parents before agreeing to talk about their daughter's tragic death. Unfortunately, he couldn't get hold of Maureen or Paul, and decided that it'd be best not to insult them by going ahead without their express permission.
That's really all there was to it. Kevin didn't knock back the chance to speak with VICE after all; he was willing to, but only if Nancy's mother and father were there to give him the go ahead. There was a bit of a breakdown in communication between both parties, which is perhaps why 'Dark Side Of The Ring' ran their caption.
It was all a case of poor timing. Things might've been different had Maureen and Paul been available when Sullivan contacted them. They weren't though, and he wasn't about to dive into subjects that might drag up their depression.
9. Chris Benoit's Initial Concerns About Nancy
According to Sullivan, Chris Benoit was seriously worried when WCW bookers told him he'd be aligned with Nancy on TV. Did the Canadian believe he didn't need a valet? Was he doubtful that Woman could add anything to his act? It was none of those things.
Benoit was concerned about how his then-wife would react.
Martina (said ex-wife) might not have been delighted at the thought of Benoit working with another woman, and Kevin said she was all pregnant with Chris' first child. Things were all a bit up-in-the-air at home, meaning Benoit didn't want the extra pressure or to explain himself.
The amazing thing here is that Chris would end up developing feelings for Nancy and eventually leave Martina for her. Even so, Kevin claims there was a bit of frostiness towards his idea when it was broached with Benoit backstage.
8. The Real Story Behind His WCW Booking
Years later, Kevin Sullivan was booking WCW and decided to make Benoit World Champion. That, he admits, was a bit of a peace offering designed to calm fears he'd bury Chris because of what happened with Nancy in 1996-1997. What's more, Sullivan had plans beyond Benoit.
He wanted to make Dean Malenko and Perry Saturn WCW Tag-Team Champs, and crown Eddie Guerrero the new United States titleholder. Sullivan told Cornette he wanted to do this so WCW's backstage atmosphere would change. He didn't want the stigma of smaller guys (he's one himself) sticking, and fancied showing he could put business before anything personal.
It didn't work.
Benoit, Malenko, Saturn and Guerrero would all leave WCW for the WWF in early-2000. Sullivan's plan to refashion how WCW viewed smaller, more athletic workers as headliners also ruffled feathers amongst some behind the scenes.
7. There Was No Bash At The Beach Shoot
In VICE's doc, it was said that Sullivan and Benoit fired some 'live rounds' during their brawl at WCW's Bash At The Beach 1997 pay-per-view. At one point, it was even intimated that Sullivan suffered a ruptured ear drum due to some of the stiff punches thrown. That wasn't the case.
Kevin says he went deep-sea diving the week after the pay-per-view, which wouldn't have been possible had he suffered a burst ear drum. Furthermore, he revealed that Benoit and himself agreed to be stiff so the match would be heated. It was an angle, one that was meant to mimic the drama in Mike Tyson's fight with Evander Holyfield on 28 June.
That was big news in the summer of '97, and both wrestlers fancied capitalising a few weeks later at the Bash show.
The timeline adds up here. WCW's pay-per-view took place on 13 July, and Sullivan felt his match would be better if it appeared realistic. That's why he and Benoit threw some potatoes - they wanted to make the fight look genuine.
6. He Refutes Claims He Gave Nancy A Black Eye
Nancy's sister Sandra told VICE during 'Dark Side of The Ring' that Sullivan gave his then-wife a black eye in the mid-90s. She also claimed that domestic issues were common between the couple, and became even more so towards the end of their relationship.
Sullivan outright told Cornette that shiner never happened.
He pointed to Sandra's timeline of events as a fatal flaw in her argument. When Sandra claims she was called to rush to her sister's aid, Kevin was nowhere to be found. He and Nancy hadn't seen one another for around four months, he claims. That would've made it impossible for him to give her a black eye.
This kind of insight and debate is probably what VICE wanted in their documentary. Without comments from Sullivan though, they had to take Sandra's word. That made things a little lop-sided, and didn't let Kevin give his side of the story.
5. Why He Thinks He And Nancy Drifted Apart
When Sullivan and Nancy met in the early-80s, he was 32 and she was 21. The age difference didn't stop them from falling in love and eventually marrying in 1992, but it did creep up on them a little later when things got difficult.
Sullivan says he and Nancy were having problems at home for "around six months" before Benoit even arrived in WCW. In other words, things were on a slippery slope before Nancy and Chris even met, and Sullivan thinks the age thing had started to become an issue.
By 1996, he was spending more and more time in the Florida Keys, and Nancy was back home at the house in Daytona. They weren't exactly getting along, and he found it hard to see how they'd come out of their funk as a couple. They'd started to drift apart.
Sullivan isn't totally sure why, but cited the age difference as a possible reason.
4. Sullivan Genuinely Didn't See Nancy And Benoit Coming
Despite all the troubles at home with Nancy, Kevin honestly didn't think that she'd fall in love with Chris Benoit when he booked it in storyline. He said on the pod that his intention was to blur the lines between fantasy and reality with angles like Brian Pillman's, "I respect you, booker man" line. The Benoit and Woman story was an extension of that.
The only problem was that it cost him his marriage.
Sullivan didn't see that one coming. Even now, he looks back and says there weren't as many signs as people might think that Nancy and Chris were slowly becoming an item. He viewed Benoit as a quiet, loyal dude who liked to work hard and be around a small circle of friends.
It came as a bit of shock to Kevin when Nancy and Chris got together, but he's not willing to hold it against them now. He also didn't say whether or not he regrets booking the angle in the first place, or if there's anything he could've done differently.
3. He Doesn't Think VICE's Doc Was Malicious
Sullivan doesn't think VICE's doc was particularly malicious either.
His outlook on the Benoit tragedy is rather refreshing here; Kevin believes people have a hard time processing the double murder and suicide, and thinks personal timelines are warped by grief and a whirlwind of activity nobody could've predicted. That's why he's not keen to sling sh*t at VICE for covering it.
They tried their best to tell a tale of depression, tragedy and survival (for Benoit's son David and Nancy's sister Sandra) across just a few hours of storytelling. That was a tough task, but it's one Sullivan thinks they handled better than most. His only worry through all of this is for Nancy's parents.
Kevin is mindful that they lost their daughter under horrible, grisly circumstances, and he doesn't think it's fair they have to relive that hell time and time again. That's why he wanted to clear any appearance on the doc with them first.
2. Nancy Stabbed Sullivan
Remember those allegations of domestic abuse touched on earlier? Well, Sullivan admits there was some violence, but said the biggest example came from Nancy towards him. He also said he might not have brought that up to VICE on a film exploring her death (out of respect to her parents).
Nancy reportedly stabbed Kevin and spent three days in jail afterwards.
Presumably, he dropped the charges. Though Sullivan doesn't talk about that, there's surely no way Nancy would've been released from prison without his help - not when she'd attacked someone with a knife. That either wasn't known by VICE before the documentary or they chose not to include it.
It sounds like something Kevin kept close to his chest (no jokes). The stabbing proved to be the final straw for him, and he became distant from Nancy after it. Their relationship totally broke down, and there was no coming back.
1. He Heard Rumours Of Another Benoit Affair
It's important before digging into this one to say that these are just rumours Sullivan heard years after he'd left the pro wrestling biz. He was working on setting up a gym in Florida at the time, and someone told him that Benoit was having an affair behind Nancy's back.
Kevin wasn't in contact with either party, had no axe to grind anymore and didn't even know if the gossip was true. It didn't take long for the story to leave his mind, but it's something he brought back up on Jim Cornette's pod as a possible add-on to the fragmenting relationship between Chris and Nancy before their grim demise.
Did it happen? Who knows.
It's possible. Benoit was hardly thinking straight around the time of the tragedy, and VICE's documentary did explore how difficult things were between the couple by 2007. Sullivan doesn't know either way. He did hear the rumours at the time however.
What else did you learn from Kevin Sullivan on Jim Cornette's podcast? For more like this, check out 10 Things We Learned From VICE's Dark Side Of The Ring: Chris Benoit and 10 WWE PPVs Fans Thought Would Totally Suck (But Didn’t)!