10 Things We Learned From Attending NXT TakeOver: New York Live
A love letter to the best NXT TakeOver ever.
At a time when so many aspects of WWE's product feel rote, stale, or overdone, and so many acts and concepts have lost their aura through oversaturation, NXT TakeOver retains its mystique.
It is the most reliable pay-per-view brand in wrestling. Time and time again, TakeOver delivers to astronomical levels, and even when the card doesn't look all that enticing beforehand, developmental's uber-talented roster never fail to craft a stunning night of cutting-edge action punctuated by big, powerful story beats. Betting against it is foolish, and we'll all look back on this as a golden era when it eventually comes to an end.
But what about the live experience? If TakeOver is that good when watched on a TV, tablet, or phone, surely it must be a borderline religious experience when surrounded by thousands upon thousands of screaming, passionate, smart wrestling fans?
Your writer is happy to report that, after attending last night's 10/10 TakeOver: New York show (his first NXT show outside of a live event in Aberdeen, Scotland a few years ago), it exceeded every single expectation - including some he didn't know he had. It was a mindblowing night, and one that put a totally new perspective to WWE's most acclaimed braind...
10. King Of Chops
WALTER is a simple wrestler. An imposing monster movie villain of a man, 'Der Ringgeneral' commands the squared circle like the heels of eras bygone, striking fear with his mammoth frame and granite perma-scowl. There's nothing flashy about his offensive arsenal, either. WALTER uses only a handful of actual moves, but executes each one with perfect, crisp brutality, and knows how to build a match around them to ensure that they serve the story, guaranteeing pops and gasps whenever he executes something as straightforward as a Butterfly Suplex.
His chops are a huge part of this. They're the hardest in the game, and it's a rare occasion when an opponent doesn't leave a WALTER match with their chest turned to ground beef thanks to the back of the burly Austrian's hand.
On television, those chops hit with a slap: from the back of the Barclays Center, they sounded more like mortar blasts. They hit with a dull, crushing thud, as if the goal was to cave the opponent's chest in, not break the skin, and that makes them all the more brutal.
Your writer has experienced WALTER's chops in many a small building, but never in a basketball stadium's nosebleed section. The barbarism translates.
9. Pete Dunne: Over As Hell
As a Brit, it's easy to overstate Pete Dunne.
'The Bruiserweight' is one of us. WWE isn't exactly awash with top-level British performers, so we feel a sense of ownership when the guy we'd torture with drawn-out "PEEEETERRRRR!" in half-empty Mancunian social clubs five years ago steps out on the big stage. Wrestling is subjective, of course, and Dunne has his detractors (a shame for them, really), but your writer often wonders if he has gone too far in praising the now-former WWE United Kingdom Champion whenever his name comes up on a list like this.
Fortunately, it looks like Dunne's appeal stretches stateside as well. Last night's pre-show video package shone a light on every single performer in action at TakeOver, and nobody got a bigger pop than Pete when his face appeared. Not Johnny Gargano, not Adam Cole, not Aleister Black, not Ricochet: nobody.
'The Bruiserweight's' entrance pop hit a similar decibel, and Brooklyn was 100% into him throughout his bout with WALTER. This is heartening. It shows that Dunne isn't just a curio that the British fans overstate, but a genuine WWE star ready for a bigger role in the company.
8. Aleister Black's Entrance, Ruined
If you want to ruin Aleister Black's awesome, imposing ring entrance for yourself, attending a WWE live event and sit on the side of the stage from which he arises. It'll absolutely destroy any in-building aura the dark Dutchman has.
We'll refrain from sharing a picture here, as we don't wish to spoil the experience for anyone else. Still, this was a glimpse behind the curtain your writer and his WhatCulture colleagues could've done without.
It went down during Ricochet's entrance. As 'The One And Only' hit the ring, a gang of stagehands and technicians hurried to the side of the stage, carting all the bits and pieces required for Black's arrival then setting them up. Slabs of wood and fake candles were quickly thrown together as if the crew were assembling flat pack furniture. Then, Black darted out from the side, hopped onto the riser, and lay waiting for his cue, unable to hide as he does on television, with smoke, fancy lighting, and camerawork preserving the entrance.
A shame, because the NXT Tag Team Championship match was f*cking brilliant.
7. "Mamma Mia!"
The full extent of NXT play-by-play announcer Mauro Ranallo's popularity can't be truly understood until you've experienced the man walking down to the ring at a TakeOver event.
That sounds daft, and if you'd told your writer this prior to the event, he'd have cast you a sideways glance. Regardless, the pop that greeted Ranallo as he, Percy Watson, and Nigel McGuinness walked down to the ring before NXT went on the air was immense. The Barclays Center was still filling up, but almost everybody in the building rose to their feet as his name was read out, and chants of "MAMMA MIA!" quickly filled the arena, belted out with the kind of passion usually reserved for top-level main eventers.
Mauro is the perfect announcer for this group of fans. His energy, enthusiasm, and constant stream of pop culture references mean he hits every note they're looking for a commentator on WWE's most revered brand. Good for him. He's more over than a big, big chunk of the roster at the stage, and it speaks volumes that the Mamma Mias returned for many a big spot on the main card.
6. Charisma For Days
Velveteen Dream is a special performer. Special.
That's he's this good this early in his career is incredible, and while his ring work still has a few rough edges to be ironed out before he's sent to the main roster, he excels in so many departments. He moves around the squared circle with the fluidity of water. A flashy in-ring arsenal carried by strong fundamentals means he's never lacking in the workrate department. There isn't a more intoxicating character in the company, and the way he projects it is exemplary.
At the top of this list of standout traits is Dream's charisma, which comes off well on television, but you don't grasp its full extent until you've shared a building with him. His magnetism reached all the way to the back row of the Barclay Center's highest section. Such things are often lost beyond the front few rows, but not with Dream. He's utterly unique in this company.
Most of Dream's best attributes are ones that can't be taught, even in a state of the art Performance Center. This bodes incredibly well for his long-term prospects.
5. Varying Energy Levels
The Brooklyn crowd were, for the most part, incredible. They peaked at the right moments, raised the roof for their favourite performers, and rarely went into business for themselves, focusing, instead, on the wrestlers. They had character, too: a mid-show Papa John's advert drew one of the loudest negative reactions of the whole night.
Despite this, energy levels definitely wavered at various points throughout the evening. It was first notable during the early stages of Velveteen Dream vs. Matt Riddle, particularly prevalent in WALTER vs. Pete Dunne and the women's four-way, and there were quiet moments in Adam Cole and Johnny Gargano's first fall too.
This isn't necessarily a problem or a complaint; more an observation. The performers are so skilled that they were able to swing the crowd back around every single time, too, so it's not something that WWE need to look into, but it definitely happens.
Main roster shows yield crowd fatigue for their grueling lengths. Here, the problem might be pace, as the audience are fed so much great action from the very first bell that crowd lulls are inevitable. Rest periods are essential, and fortunately, the wrestlers are effective at managing this.
4. Adam Cole Has Huge Babyface Potential
Traditional face/heel alignments are almost useless in NXT. This crowd is going to cheer for the men and women they like the most, regardless of whether or not they're supposed to be good or bad, and Adam Cole is the foremost example of this.
That man is over as f*ck with everyone. That sleazy, charismatic bastard gets incredible responses for his signature spots, and that first "BAY-BAY!" was absolutely thunderous. It continued throughout the match, with Cole's responses rarely matching up to his supposed heel alignment.
'The Panama City Playboy' is going to make an incredible babyface someday. He's playing a great heel character right now, but, through no fault of his own, he isn't getting booed. What that isn't necessarily an issue in this environment, it may become one on the main roster, and yeah, he's cocky, but people already love the bloke now, when he's intended to be an alpha-villain. Imagine the reactions he's going to get when we're supposed to cheer for him.
What this would mean for the rest of the Undisputed Era is unclear, but at least their leader would be fine.
3. Capitalism Moves Fast
The WWE merchandising machine is incredible. It's as excellent and effective as the rest of their marketing strategy, with the promotion shifting vast quantities of shirts, hoodies, and other tat at every event. It doesn't even matter that a lot of the designs are straight-up ugly and the shirts lose their softness after a couple of washes: they do numbers, and WWE are killing it.
So sharp are WWE's merchandising team that they were already selling Johnny Gargano's brand new "Johnny Champion" t-shirts within seconds of the former DIY man becoming NXT Champion. Your writer and his WhatCulture cohorts were shuffling through the Barclays Center concourse after the main event, cruising down the elevator, when, to our left, we spotted the merch sellers unpacking a dozen boxes of bright yellow t-shirts emblazoned with the champ's new nickname. Capitalism, baby: it moves fast.
This swiftness suggests that WWE had Gargano's victory planned a long time ago, and that makes sense. It was absolutely the right moment at the right time, regardless of whether he was going to face Adam Cole or Tommaso Ciampa, and we applaud the marketers.
2. TakeOver Without Mauro
This will not be a popular entry.
Your writer appreciates that he is in the minority when it comes to Mauro Ranallo's NXT commentary. The 49-year-old is a great professional, a student of the game, and, by all accounts, is an outstanding human being. Regardless - and this is a highly subjective take - the guy, at his worst, is absolutely excruciating.
This opinion comes from a couple of different things:-
1. The endless stream of cringe-worthy pop culture references and daft metaphors.
2. His insistence on operation at 100mph all of the time, rather than building up to his big explosions of enthusiasm. He is Metallica's "Kill 'Em All" album: all go, all of the time, with little variety. For him, "Ride The Lightning" should be the goal. Ranallo needs to slow things down so that his peaks stand out, rather than losing his mind every time someone hits a snapmare.
Having read that, you can probably understand how refreshing this scribe found it to enjoy a TakeOver event without listening to his immersion-shattering commentary. Mauro is beloved, and his appeal is well understood, but his flavour isn't to this critic's tastes.
1. A Cure For Ennui
Allow me to get personal and drop the "your writer" b*llocks for a second.
I watch a sh*tload of professional wrestling. Every minute of Raw, SmackDown, and NXT gets consumed every week. If there was something worth catching on 205 Live or NXT UK, I'll go out of my way for those as well. Then there's every major NJPW show, CMLL, buzz-worthy indie matches and moments, Dragon Gate, DDT, the other Japanese indies, and, of course, our own Defiant Wrestling.
It's great, but it's a grind, and it wears your fandom down. There is such thing as too much of a good thing. Jadedness creeps in, and there are times when I personally feel like I'm not getting fully invested in something that I know is absolutely great purely because I have overindulged myself.
NXT is often one of the biggest victims of this, but attending shows like last night's is the perfect cure for any bout of ennui. TakeOver: New York revived, re-energized, and reinvigorated me as a wrestling fan, and now, I'm already back in the mindset of wanting to consume every great bit of action that goes down in New York City this weekend... and we haven't even reached the G1 Supercard yet.
Wrestling is f*cking great, right?