10 Things We Learned From Dark Side Of The Ring: Billy Jack Haynes

The puzzling, conspiracy-filled downfall of a former WWE superstar turned murderer on trial.

Dark Side Of The Ring Billy Jack Haynes
VICE

Former WWE star Billy Jack Haynes is currently imprisoned and awaiting trial for charges of second degree murder. 8 February 2024 changed his life forever, but it ended the life of his wife Janette Becraft. She'd been suffering from dementia when police say Billy Jack shot her in the head. His trial has been pushed back, but will commence in December 2025.

Truthfully, Haynes had lived a puzzling life full of violent outbursts, conspiracy theories, possible mental illness and more long before February 2024. He was a big star in the 1980s WWF boom period, albeit briefly, and VICE's producers managed to get to the real story behind his dramatic exit from the company in 1988 just as things seemed to be going well for him. It turns out that missing some bookings after a WrestleMania high and fudging a tag-team push alongside Ken Patera was just the tip of the iceberg. 

This week's 'Dark Side Of The Ring' episode included stories about his bid to become the next Vince McMahon, his wild and often controversial claims about the entire McMahon family, Billy Jack's decision to involve himself in a double murder case from 30 years before, and even a "mercy killing" claim so incredible that nobody's quite sure what to make of it.

Admittedly, there wasn't actually that much behind the scenes wrestling chat on the show. No, VICE's documentary crew had far too much to discuss when it came to Billy's private life. Remarkably, Haynes was willing to sit down and talk freely (or as freely as lawyers would let him) about his life and career.

Here's everything gleaned from another hair-raising hour of pulsating human drama.

10. Stu Hart “Threw Him Out Of Canada”

Dark Side Of The Ring Billy Jack Haynes
VICE

Many Billy Jack bios say he was trained by Stu Hart in Canada. Whilst true, that doesn't begin to tell the full story, at least according to Larry Oliver. Larry, who is the son of ex-pro Rip Oliver, told VICE that Stu actually dismissed Haynes from his territory "because he was too rough and beat all of his boys up". That's where 'Dark Side' interviewers needed to feed Larry another question.

It's unclear whether or not Oliver meant that Billy Jack was rough with Hart brothers like Bret, Bruce etc, or if he meant "boys" in a looser wrestling locker room sort of way. Haynes did spend some time in Stampede Wrestling before really making a name for himself in Portland then jumping to the WWF's fascinating boom in the 1980s, but details remain rather sketchy on why the Harts cast him out.

Using follow up stories to come to your own conclusions is always risky, because there are some talking head accounts from fellow pros who say Haynes was actually kinda quiet and reserved behind the scenes. However, he was known to have a vicious, violent temper, and he was roundly regarded as someone who enjoyed being a bully (or at least seemed that way on the road to his peers) with those smaller than him.

Therefore, it's possible that Haynes did get too full on with a few of Stu's sons during his time in Canada. That isn't something the Hart patriarch could've tolerated; Stu was known to be a tough customer himself, but no self-respecting father was going to sit idly by and watch anybody treat his family poorly.

It wasn't long until Billy Jack moved on to pastures new anyway.


9. Ken Patera Thought Their Tag Gimmick Was “Nuts”

Dark Side Of The Ring Billy Jack Haynes Ken Patera
VICE

In 1987, the WWF put a returning Ken Patera and Billy Jack together in a tag-team. They were affectionately known as ‘The Oregon Lumberjacks’, but several behind the scenes wanted things to be a little more on the nose than that. So, according to Patera, Pat Patterson walked into the locker room and handed them actual chainsaws to use during their entrances. Ken thought that was crazy, and says he wouldn’t do it.

Back then, he also viewed Haynes as a soft-spoken type who was a real nice guy behind the scenes. However, as Ken found out, “the gloss wears off after a while”. Billy Jack's true personality started to come through, which made it problematic for the team to gain any traction on the roster. Arguably, they were damaged goods politically in the office after spurning the chainsaw gimmick anyway.

Patera might've been more at ease with the idea had the WWF given them fake saws to use. He was rather worried about accidentally cutting somebody's arm off (or something like that) on his way to the ring, and he expressed those reservations to Patterson. By all accounts, Pat didn't really agree that the duo had anything to worry about.

This wasn't explored on 'Dark Side', but Patterson was surely feeding Haynes and Patera an edict from Vince McMahon himself. Going against that was career suicide, especially when Vince had designs on pushing the pair opposite rival teams like Demolition in featured spots.

Regardless, Ken just thought the chainsaw gimmick was "nuts" and couldn't make peace with it. VICE kinda missed an opportunity by never asking Haynes about this period. Being fair, they had a lot of other pressing matters to quiz him about!


8. He Slapped Paul Bearer Over A Finish

Dark Side Of The Ring Billy Jack Haynes
VICE

Len Denton was better known as 'The Grappler' during his time in the AWA, Mid-South and other NWA territories. He worked opposite Haynes many times during Billy Jack's formative years in the biz, but Denton found out firsthand that he could never actually trust the hot young newcomer during their matches - Billy Jack had a short fuse and could snap at any moment.

At one point during the episode, Denton recalled seeing Haynes come through the curtain and make moves towards manager Percy Pringle (best remembered as The Undertaker's ghoulish Paul Bearer). Billy Jack was mad that Pringle had messed up the finish to one of his matches vs. Rick Rude, so he slapped him hard and told him why he was doing it.

It doesn't sound like that kind of over-reaction and show of violence was an isolated incident either. Longtime wrestling ref Bill Alfonso called Haynes a "Jekyll and Hyde" character, 'cause nobody knew for sure which one they were going to get on any given day. This made it more difficult for guys like Denton to respect Billy Jack.

He started to view Haynes as nothing more than a bully who’d target people he knew he could beat up. For example, Percy. Physically attacking somebody because they made a mistake and screwed up the finish to your match is unacceptable. It says everything that even those in the wild west territorial days of the 1980s also thought Billy Jack was going too far here.

Pringle didn't deserve to take a beating for making a routine error.


7. Billy Jack Contacted Dark Side’s Producers

Dark Side Of The Ring Billy Jack Haynes
VICE

This week's 'Dark Side' came to a surprise screeching halt with one pop-up message.

A mere six months after being arrested for second degree murder of his wife, Billy Jack Haynes reached out to VICE’s production team and offered to sit down with them for an interview. No-one watching the episode could've predicted that, because those familiar with VICE's series have grown accustomed to subjects either being unavailable due to death or for legal reasons.

It's certainly something that a guy currently awaiting trial for murder was willing to give his side of the story. Haynes opened by saying there’s a lot about his life that people don’t know, but also offered: “Believe half of what you hear and nothing of what you see”. That was more than a bit cryptic, but Billy Jack often talks like he’s cutting a wrestling promo. That's why he became such a lightning rod on the infamous shoot interview scene for decades.

There were several interesting exchanges between Haynes and his attorney during the episode. Fans could hear VICE's interviewers asking Billy Jack a question, then clips of Haynes turning to his lawyer to outright ask if he was 'allowed to talk about that' were aired. You don't get to see this sort of gritty, up to the minute reality too often, even on 'Dark Side Of The Ring'.

Haynes agreeing to sit down and chat elevated the documentary. It was one thing to hear from talking heads like Jim Cornette, Ken Patera or Dave Meltzer. It's another entirely to hear direct from Billy Jack himself.


6. Why The WWF Really Let Him Go

Dark Side Of The Ring Billy Jack Haynes
VICE

One of those legal 'yes or no' moments happened when VICE asked Billy Jack to talk about why he was let go by the WWF in 1988. Haynes wasn't 100% sure whether or not he should freely discuss the true story, but his lawyer summed it up by saying: "Well, it happened". Billy Jack didn't need too much convincing after that. He was happy to recap the real drama.

There'd often been a shadowy, mysterious air to BJ's departure throughout the 90s and into the new millennium. Most reasoned that Haynes was released from his contract because he'd grown far too comfortable with missing scheduled dates, and tag partner Ken Patera does say on this very episode that Billy Jack turned up at the venue after a show was finished one time.

That undoubtedly went against the pair; Vince McMahon wasn't going to push the team when he couldn't rely on them, which irked Patera. However, that's not the main reason why Billy Jack was cut loose. No, he'd overdosed on pills during a flight and almost died. Medics had to revive the stricken wrestler twice. They'd nearly lost him, and it wasn't a great look for the shiny, family friendly WWF.

McMahon didn't want to deal with the negative publicity something like that would bring about, so he made the call to get rid of Haynes for good. That was a bitter, sudden end to Billy Jack's popular run with the market leading promotion. He's gone from working featured bouts vs. Hercules at WrestleMania III to finding himself rushed through the exit doors.

That overdose was cited as the main reason why on 'Dark Side'.


5. His Own Bid To Become McMahon Flopped

Dark Side Of The Ring Billy Jack Haynes OWF
VICE

Haynes started the Oregon Wrestling Federation when he left the WWF in 1988, but that didn't sit well with some of his peers. A lot of people warned him that the move was completely disloyal to promoter Don Owen (who ran shows in Portland and had shown a lot of faith in Billy Jack right near the start of his wrestling career), but Haynes wouldn’t listen. He pressed ahead with plans to turn the OWF into a big deal locally, and he eventually planned to branch out to become 'the next Vince McMahon'.

Yes, seriously.

Billy Jack admitted to VICE that his head was all over the place back then. He was too heavily into drugs to properly focus on business, and that (along with ignoring past relationships with Don) led to some resentment. Worse, Haynes became known as somebody who'd potentially bounce payoffs and screw a lot of workers around. He had zero credibility as a promoter, so the OWF folded in 1989.

Dave Meltzer called the collapse of the Oregon Wrestling Federation “pretty spectacular”. The company didn’t draw big crowds from the off anyway, but it was a total mess behind the curtain. Later in 'Dark Side', it's alleged that Haynes was borrowing money from some pretty shady investors to get things off the ground. The mafia were mentioned, for example.

Any hopes Billy Jack had of turning his career around to become the next big time promoter like McMahon were dashed by his addictions and general lack of true business sense. Not many thought he was trustworthy or capable.


4. He Tied Himself To A Shocking Double Murder

Dark Side Of The Ring Billy Jack Haynes
VICE

In 1987, news spread that 16 year old Don Henry and 17 year old Kevin Ives had been killed by a freight train in Arkansas. The incident was shocking, but the trail went cold on exactly what happened to the teenagers. Then, out of the blue in 2017, Haynes linked himself to the story by claiming the boys had been killed before the train hit them, and that he’d helped put them on the tracks in the first place.

People were left stunned when Billy Jack laid out a scenario that seemed OTT. He said the two teenagers had stumbled across a big drug deal, and that he’d been enlisted to film the deal wearing a wrestling mask (?!). Jim Cornette recapping this is pretty must see stuff. The plot thickened when Haynes said he went down to oversee the drug deal after wrestling King Kong Bundy on a WWF card.

Here's some more context on that claim.

Henry and Ives were found on 23 August 1987. Billy Jack worked Bundy on a 21 August house show in Detroit, which is a 12 hour drive from Arkansas. Is it possible that Billy Jack got his dates mixed up and/or did drive from Michigan to the scene of the crime? Maybe, but exactly zero of the talking heads on VICE were willing to believe that.

Things became even more puzzling when journalist Phil Stanford revealed later in the episode that Haynes fabricated his involvement in another murder case after talking to him and hearing all about it. That's...alarming behaviour to say the least.


3. A Grieving Mother and PI Believed Him

Dark Side Of The Ring Billy Jack Haynes
VICE

But wait, there's more.

The mother of one of the victims, Linda Ives, told the media that Billy Jack must be telling the truth, because nobody would willingly link themselves to a murder case. Meanwhile, the family’s own private investigator also said Haynes was putting his liberty at risk, so he must be right. After all, who'd make something like this up for attention...right?

That's when a message flashed up on the show saying: “Billy Jack has claimed the videotape he made that night was stolen or destroyed”. Both Linda and the PI have since passed away. Legally, police didn’t take Billy Jack’s statements seriously, because they noticed that some details were getting more and more over the top, and the case remains open to this day.

VICE included news report footage of Haynes sitting with Linda on camera and claiming he just wanted justice for her. It's all very, very confusing, and it isn't clear exactly what Billy Jack was hoping to get out of this in the first place. The fact investigators and police couldn't fathom what role he did or didn't play in the deaths of two teenagers really says it all.

Incredibly, as journo Phil Stanford revealed later, this wasn't even an isolated incident. Haynes had a strange habit of placing himself at the site of some shocking murders or moments in history, and one of his close personal friends said he'd often carry around a binder full of newspaper clippings or other documents.

Perhaps no-one will ever know the real story of what happened to Don Henry and Kevin Ives.


2. He Says Vince McMahon Sr “Could He His Father”

Vince Mcmahon Sr
WWE

Then, there's this wild claim.

Talking heads like Jim Cornette, Bill Alfonso and various other old pros poured cold water all over some of Billy Jack’s increasingly-out there claims on the shoot interview circuit between 2006-2023. One of the wildest? Haynes alleged that he could actually be the son of Vince McMahon Sr, and thus Vince McMahon Jr's brother.

Dark Side’s producers asked Haynes about the Vince Sr stuff during their interview with him, and he still maintains that McMahon Sr could’ve “had sex with [his] mother”. Meltzer called it “ridiculous that somebody could even try to pass that off”, and most seem to believe this was a publicity stunt ploy from Haynes to stir up some attention for himself, remain relevant and squeeze more money out of shoot interviewers seeking dirt.

That's entirely possible, but there's a sad slant on everything too. Maybe Billy Jack is suffering from mental illness and delusions. A vague, palmed-off statement like, 'Vince Sr could've had sex with my mother' is hard to get a good grasp on. Something like that would be possible, but it just doesn't sound plausible whatsoever. It's so easy to fling comments like that out into the ether without logic or a care for consequences.

Neither Meltzer nor Cornette could quite believe what they were hearing. When pressed in jail today, Haynes still maintains that there's a slight chance he's a McMahon. This reads like a broken down old wrestler telling himself a story so many times that he starts to believe it could be fact.

Quite sad, really.


1. Billy Jack Calls His Wife’s Murder “A Mercy Killing”

Dark Side Of The Ring Billy Jack Haynes
VICE

When detained by police, Billy Jack said his 85 year old wife Janette Becraft had terrible dementia and that he found it unbearable. He called her murder “a mercy killing” after being arrested for shooting her in the head. VICE then caught comments from one of his friends, who says Jan “was his world”.

Man, nobody seems sure what to believe about the guy or anything he says/does. It's insane.

Hayes has since pleaded not guilty to second degree murder and unlawful use of a weapon. Becraft’s family, who didn’t approve of the relationship in the first place, refused to comment when asked by VICE. Now, Billy Jack’s trial is set for December 2025, so he'll find out then whether or not he'll spend the rest of his life behind bars.

At time of writing, Haynes is 71 years old. So, assuming he's found guilty of the crime, he'd realistically never be a free man again. The whole recap of Becraft's death ended this week's 'Dark Side' episode on a real low note, but that might sound a tad strange considering some of the other stuff Billy Jack got up to during his life and career.

He claimed to sell an endless quantity of drugs during his prime in the 1980s, was potentially attacked by gangs for stealing money from them, involved himself in a cold case about two teenagers dying on train tracks, said he might be Vince McMahon Sr's son, and is currently on trial for charges of second degree murder.

Nobody has a story quite like Billy Jack Haynes. Nobody wants a story quite like him.

What else did you learn from VICE's latest 'Dark Side Of The Ring' episode on Billy Jack Haynes? For more like this, check out 15 Things We Learned From Dark Side Of The Ring: Tony Atlas and 15 Things We Learned From Dark Side Of The Ring: Vader!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.