10 Things We Learned From Dark Side Of The Ring: Doink The Clown

Matt Borne's life beyond WWE's iconic Doink character was anything but funny.

Dark Side Of The Ring Doink The Clown Matt Borne
WWE/VICE

"I just want people to know that's not who he was".

Matt Osborne (typically shorted to Borne) was a flawed human being for sure, and none of the talking heads quizzed for VICE's latest 'Dark Side Of The Ring' episode try to hide that. However, his ex-wife Michelle's passionate plea for people to remember that he had a good side too stood out when watching.

Best remembered as Doink The Clown, Borne's substance abuse issues would be his undoing. The final hours of his life remain mysterious, and credit must go to VICE for presenting both sides of the story. Put it this way: Tegan (Matt's daughter) thinks his then-girlfriend Connie Cook killed her father in 2013, but police reports say otherwise.

This is a story of wrestling dreams wrecked by personal demons, kids who just wanted to love their father, and various lovers who stood by Matt despite his unpredictable, often-aggressive nature away from the ring. Borne's WWF/WWE run was shorter than it should've been, and the end of it ultimately put him on a path of self-destruction he'd never recover from.

Here's everything we learned from VICE's latest look at the seedier side of the biz.

10. Matt Borne's Horrible Childhood Memory

Dark Side Of The Ring Matt Borne Doink The Clown
VICE

There wasn't a ton of detail about Matt's childhood life on 'Dark Side'. He grew up the son of a local wrestler called 'Tough' Tony Borne, and there's a particularly nice moment midway through when old footage of Tony reveals that he was always immensely proud of his boy.

His mother, apparently, wasn't.

Matt's ex-wife Michelle (who came across very well throughout the doc) revealed that Borne once told her what had happened when his parents split. The boy was just 10 years old, and would end up going to live with his father. Why? Well, his mother said: "You go with your dad, because I don't want that little bastard".

Man, that's awful. Michelle says those words stayed with Matt for the rest of his life, and he'd never understand why she'd be so cruel. That's literally the only mention of Borne's mother on VICE's show too, so it doesn't paint her in a positive light.


9. Mick Foley Wanted To Be Him

Evil Doink the clown
WWE.com

Onto something nicer and wrestling-related.

Mick Foley was friends with Borne behind the scenes, but always admired his in-ring work too. Specifically, Foley liked how Matt was able to bring his on-screen characters to life and convince fans that he really was Big Josh or Doink The Clown. Summing it up, Mick added: 'I saw in him what I hoped to one day be".

That's something VICE did well to put across here. Yes, Borne was a flawed human being with terrible habits and behaviours away from the ring, but he was super-talented within a pro wrestling context. It's cool to see someone as respected as Mick put that over, and reveal that Borne influenced him.

Footage was shown of Foley (as Mankind) raining down punches on a grounded opponent. VICE tag-teamed that with footage of Matt doing the same, then backed it up with Mick saying he admired Borne's ability to live a character.

Borne/Doink influenced Mick as Mankind and beyond.


8. The Insane Brian Blair Bar Fight

Dark Side Of The Ring Matt Borne Doink The Clown Brian Blair
VICE

This is just downright scary.

Pre-WWF days, Matt approached ex-Killer Bee Brian Blair in a bar and asked, "Why you messing with my girl?". Blair told VICE he had no clue what Borne was talking about and tried to defuse the situation. When he turned away, Matt hit him from behind, suplexed him (?!), then tried to bite his nose.

Brian ended up chomping into Borne's bottom lip and spat part of it across the room. If he thought that was the end of it, he was wrong. Later, Matt came back for more and took another beating because of it. That still wasn't the end! Borne attacked again, and tried to go for Blair's eyes; Ivan Koloff jumped in to stop that by yelling, "No eyes".

Blair thinks Borne was trying to establish himself as a tough guy, but it backfired on him. "I guess...if you have the right drugs in you, they can make you superhuman". The ex-WWF star couldn't believe how fired up Matt was about absolutely nothing.


7. Michelle Doesn’t Think He “Ever Wrestled Sober”

Dark Side Of The Ring Matt Borne Doink The Clown
VICE

Michelle James told the producers that Matt was pretty much always snorting cocaine, and he started every single day by smoking some weed. If some pain pills were handy, then he'd pop those too. It was a nightmare blend of drugs that'd wreck his adult life, but he was an addict and couldn't stop.

He didn't even stop for wrestling.

Michelle said she doesn't think her ex-husband ever worked a match without something in his system, which is a terrifying thought. Some may say it was fairly typical of the time, but it's still ghastly to think about now. It's also remarkable that Borne never had a reputation for being sloppy or dangerous in-ring.

He was coked up during the territory days in Mid-South and elsewhere, during his peak run as Doink in the WWF, in ECW as 'Borne Again' and more. Matt barely went anywhere without some kind of alcohol or drug, basically.


6. Why Matt Hated WrestleMania IX

Doink The Clown Doppelgänger WrestleMania IX
WWE

Remember that iconic double Doink shot from WrestleMania IX? Matt hated it, because he thought Vince McMahon was trying to "set him up for failure". His substance abuse issues were spiralling further out of control in early-1993, and Borne believed the boss was prepping somebody to replace him.

That'd eventually happen.

Steve Keirn, who played the second Doink at 'Mania, assumed the role once Matt got fired. Michelle revealed to VICE that Borne was always uncomfortable with the double Doink gimmick, so he must've continued harping on that for years after the fact. That random paranoia wasn't uncommon, especially after hearing the bar fight story over nothing from Brian Blair.

It's sad to think that Borne hated one of Doink's most famous moments. If pressed, many fans of the time would point to that mirror image finish as one of the character's best, but Matt didn't agree. He could see himself being pushed out the WWF exit doors.


5. He Had A Golden Doink Bathtub

Dark Side Of The Ring Matt Borne Doink The Clown
VICE

Borne was, however, enjoying the money flowing in from his WWF success.

He and Maria Straley (his first wife between 1991-1993) were in the process of building a "million dollar home" when Matt was scrapped by the WWF for drug problems in '93. Apparently, Borne had kitted the house out with lavish items, including a bathtub engraved with 18-carat gold letters spelling out Doink.

That, ladies and gents, is wild. It's also not the kind of thing you'd expect from somebody who only played a gimmick for a year or so. Doink made that big of an impression on Borne's life, but his marriage to Maria was spinning away from him. It got physical, and that pushed Straley away.

She says the breaking point came when Matt started pinging some lit cigarettes at her in their living room. Then, he threw her to the ground whilst she was still holding her daughter. Terrified, Maria left Borne after that. There was no going back.


4. Losing Doink Tipped Him Over The Edge

Dark Side Of The Ring Matt Borne Doink The Clown
VICE

Michelle, who was married to Borne between 1993-2004, says Matt told her he went on an eight-day cocaine binge with next-to-no-sleep after being fired by the WWF. He was distraught over losing his gig with the company, and knew deep down he'd signed over rights to the Doink character upon signing with Vince McMahon.

That didn't stop Matt from trying to use Doink elsewhere, but the threat of legal action stopped that. Besides, Michelle giving birth to his kids Tegan and Matthew straightened Borne up for a while, because he viewed them as his second chance. He was an addict though, and his addictions got the best of him yet again.

Matt put Michelle in hospital after accusing her of cheating on him one day. He broke her nose, then later apologised and had no recollection of the incident. Remarkably, and to the surprise of friends/family, Michelle forgave Borne.

She'd eventually leave after more problems, and even thought Matt might kill her for doing so. Wow.


3. “I Think Your Dad’s Dead”

Dark Side Of The Ring Matt Borne Doink The Clown
VICE

If you think everything detailed thus far is depressing, then you ain't seen nothing yet.

Michelle sent a text saying, "I think you're dad's dead" to Tegan in late-June 2013. She'd spotted a story about Matt's death on TMZ, but they wanted to confirm. Borne had been living with a new girlfriend, a woman called Connie Cook (who had worked in wrestling herself) by that point.

Here's where things get really shocking. Officially, Matt passed away due to an accidental drug overdose, but Tegan thinks there was "foul play" involved, and definitively states: "I know Connie killed my dad". Varying reports from police and Connie herself clash during the final hours of Borne's life.

More of that in the next entry. Seeing stills of Tegan, Matthew and Michelle standing over Matt's coffin at the funeral is really grim, and Michelle's account of never being able to "take away their pain" is heartbreaking to witness.


2. Matt’s Mysterious Final Hours

Dark Side Of The Ring Matt Borne Doink The Clown
VICE

So, Tegan thinks Connie killed her father, and Michelle believes Connie watched Matt overdose “and did nothing”. Connie’s side of the story is that she’d gone to bed after finding out Borne might’ve taken some of her mother’s medicine, then was woken up by someone pounding on the door. She just thought Borne was drunk and would be arrested, so she brought him back into the house and went back to bed.

Police reports say she saw him foaming from the mouth at 6.30am, but called her friend and went back to bed before finally phoning 911 at 9am after getting up again. Connie says that’s wrong, and that she phoned 911 hours earlier. She “didn’t go back to bed” and says, “I did everything to help him”.

Neither Tegan nor Michelle believe that's true.

Tegan, in particular, reckons Connie slipped something into one of her father's drinks and then left him to die. That's obviously quite the allegation, but it has never been proven by police investigations. Meanwhile, Connie is horrified that anyone would think she'd do such a thing.


1. The Friction Is Painful To Witness

Dark Side Of The Ring Matt Borne Doink The Clown
VICE

This back-and-forth is quite alarming to watch, being honest. Tegan and Michelle don't trust Connie's side of the story, but Cook says she loved Matt and wishes he was still here. 'Why would I kill him"?, she asks through tears. It's painful to watch people pouring their hearts out on camera like this, but that's what viewers have come to expect from 'Dark Side'.

Narrator Chris Jericho reveals that police found no evidence of Connie putting anything in one of Borne's drinks that evening/morning, and they couldn't prove negligence on her behalf for his overdose. Again, Tegan reinforces that this is wrong and that Connie had something to do with her dad's death.

It's such a sad, sad situation for everyone involved.

One thing becomes clear throughout the doc: Matt Borne needed somebody to look after him, because he wasn't capable of doing so himself. His drug and alcohol issues reached the point of no return, and the mysterious circumstances surrounding his passing in 2013 left even more heartache behind.

What else did you learn from VICE's documentary on Matt Borne/Doink The Clown? For more wrestling, check out 10 Wrestlers Who Don't Give A F*** About YOU! and 10 WWE Stars Who DESPERATELY Need Something New!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.