10 WWE Stars Who DESPERATELY Need Something New
WWE stars on Raw and SmackDown are crying out for something totally fresh!
Every wrestler needs change at some point.
Freshening up one's act is risky business, but it's essential. Roman Reigns had to turn heel in 2020 and become the 'Tribal Chief', Becky Lynch couldn't be 'The Man' forever (but returned to that guise successfully following a break), and even Seth Rollins 2023 is a million miles removed from the babyface from 2019.
There are loads of workers across both Raw and SmackDown that could do with a repackage job. Rumours abound that Triple H and his creative team plan to make those changes imminently, and they better get it right; some of the folks featured here can't afford another misfire on this roster.
In some cases, simply changing their outfit or character alignment would be enough. In others, complete change is needed. Current guises for the latter undoubtedly suck and are going nowhere fast, so something totally new would greatly help revive flagging fan interest.
It'd also recover some suspected lost motivation from the wrestlers living this staleness themselves. Even these men and women must know they need to try something fresh sooner rather than later.
Where's that box of gimmicks?
10. Hit Row
Right, so is everyone in agreement that Hit Row ranks as the least-successful return of the Triple H era? Top Dolla, Ashante Adonis and B-FAB play before near-total silence on TV, and they haven't clicked whether heel or babyface. Things do not look good for an act WWE hoped would work second time around.
It's time to ditch the name and presentation.
All three members of the faction might work if they're tied to more experienced campaigners separately. Adonis, for example, does show flashes of potential, but his chance of growth has been wrecked by association to a failing gimmick. B-FAB would be worth persevering with too.
How about Dolla? The guy has personality, but he hasn't shown anything of worth in-ring. Marry that lack of fundamental improvement with fan apathy, and you've got a recipe for disaster. If Triple H plans to keep this trio around long-term, then he'll need to come up with something else for them.
9. Shotzi
The artist formerly known as Shotzi Blackheart can't take heart from much in WWE these days. She's as peripheral a character as the women's division has, and was recently sacrificed in a MITB qualifier than lasted less than three minutes. That, don't forget, came after she was Raquel Rodriguez' plan B tag partner following Liv Morgan's injury.
Shotzi is there to plug gaps and little else.
Her energy-filled rock chick persona has been a flop since day one on the main roster. In fairness, that's not really Shotzi's fault - WWE's writers have done nothing to develop her character, and actually made her look like a total numpty last year. "Shotzi locked herself in the dressing room accidentally lol" is not going to make people care one way or the other.
Being brutally honest, it might be time for Shotzi to try something different and move away from the metalhead horror queen vibes. They'd be sweet if WWE was interested in doing anything with them, but they're clearly not.
Repackage time.
8. Xia Li
Booking Xia Li as the female locker room's "great protector" wasn't a bad idea when WWE tried it on in 2021. Sadly, they lost interest quickly, and Xia has been stuck in creative hell ever since. Recently, she's been popping up on 'C' level programming like Main Event, which few watch.
That "protector" gimmick is in WWE's rear view mirror, so it's time for something new. Xia is simply too talented to be rotting away on the sidelines losing five-minute matches to Candice LeRae on weeklies hardly anybody pays attention to, put it that way.
She deserves another opportunity to offset creative disinterest and make a stab at main roster life. To get there, Li herself is blatantly gonna have to drum up a fresh idea herself and force it down WWE's throats for a while. Basically, she has to think of something that'll grab attention.
Anything would be better than what she's doing now.
7. Rick Boogs
Rick Boogs and LA Knight proved to be a temporary alliance, and that's a good thing if you're LA. It's a...bad thing if you're Boogs though, because he doesn't have much of a purpose on the SmackDown roster without a hotter act to tie himself to (like he did with Shinsuke Nakamura pre-injury).
Where does the high-pitched rockstar go from here? That's the million dollar question. He isn't even really a rocker anymore! Boogs conjures up images of those traditional strongman from Family Guy, and that's currently his most marketable trait. Someone fetch the guy a big boulder to carry with him to the ring.
Or not.
Nah, he craves a fresh approach. Rick has been an Old Spice salesman, a Van Halen-esque rocker and now an old-timey strongman to date. You'd have to be brave to try and use that scattergun list to work out what's coming down the line for him next.
6. IYO SKY
Damage CTRL started with a bang at SummerSlam 2022, but the group has been more of a device to get others over than nourish Bayley, Dakota Kai or IYO SKY (scream it!). That's even been true when CTRL has been winning Women's Tag-Team Titles - they're a heel platform for other folks WWE wants to push.
Time to move on? Yeah, it's time.
The relationship between IYO and Bayley (in particular) has been showing cracks for a while now. SKY rarely seems interested in guffawing along with the stable leader, and it's surely only a matter of time before she rebels and turns babyface. Trips better have something cool waiting on the other side though.
IYO can get by as a hot in-ring act, but only for a while. She'll need some sort of character, and possibly a manager/follow-up ally who can cut promos on her behalf. This is a risk worth taking, 'cause CTRL has run its course less than one year in.
5. Aliyah
Aliyah is on WWE's "free agents" list post-Draft, which means she could pop up on any brand she likes. NXT might be the best shout there, if only so the one-time SmackDown hopeful can ditch the ditzy gimmick she'd been playing on Fridays. That was a hangover from Maria Kanellis circa 2006 that no-one needed.
The character was far too one-dimensional anyway. It might've worked as an endearing introduction to main roster life for Aliyah, but she sorely needed to develop from there and become someone fans could get behind. Or, y'know, she could just do sod all then randomly hold the Women's Tag Titles for a few weeks.
Aliyah did that with Raquel Rodriguez (yet another revolving door partner for Raquel) last year, but hasn't been seen much since. Being off TV for so long could be a blessing in disguise for her - at least WWE can repackage Aliyah into something else without it feeling weird or sudden.
4. New Day
Admit it, you were not expecting to see these lads.
Big E's pro wrestling future remains a real doubt, and that's depressing. The former WWE Champ's career hangs in the balance due to serious neck issues, but he'll hopefully be back someday. Whether he's present for it or not, New Day pals like Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods require a shakeup.
New Day remains popular enough, but they've been on the slide as a core group for years now. Nobody's saying they need to turn on one another and feud (that ship has probably sailed), but they do need a fresh wrinkle when bouncing back into view on TV.
Christ knows what that is, but the trombone, pancakes and sexual innuendos can likely take a back seat for a while. It'd actually be cool to see Woods and Kingston become a much more serious team who are done p*ssing about and know they've only got a finite amount of time to reclaim tag gold.
The duo/trio would work with a less comedic edge.
3. Johnny Gargano
This guy recently had quite the conversation with his friend's young son. The enthusiastic 10-year old explained who his favourite WWE stars were, then said he liked "those who have the best matches". That prompted yours truly to suggest that Johnny Gargano might be one of his favourites.
"Why would you think that?", he asked. This kid then went on to criticise WWE's handling of Gargano by pointing out that he'd rarely seen 'Johnny Wrestling' work great matches on Raw or pay-per-view. That's when it hit home: Michael (the little boy in question) hadn't seen any of Gargano's sterling work on NXT, or before than on the independent scene.
He's spot on. There's been nothing to get excited about since Johnny returned to the company! By this point, it's fairly clear that having Triple H's support isn't enough to make Gargano a key member of the main roster crew. He's another who will have to get creative and perhaps find something "sports entertainy" before he gets any house room.
So there.
2. The Street Profits
Most likely believed WWE would split The Street Profits and give Montez Ford a singles push by now. That certainly appeared to be the way things were headed a while back, but it didn't happen. The Profits remain together, and they're on SmackDown now doing the same stuff they did over on Raw.
Diminishing returns would sum it up best.
Fans still cheer the duo, but arguably not with the same fervour they once did. That might be due to the fact that Ford and Angelo Dawkins "haven't gone away to learn a new hold" (one of JR's iconic backstage quotes when analysing wrestlers who have gone stale). They really need to do just that.
A simple heel turn would re-energise the tandem if WWE doesn't want to go with that previously-expected split. They've stretched the party cup and "WE WANT THE SMOKE" material so thin it's practically see-through now. Change is definitely needed for this pair.
1. Bianca Belair
The 'EST' is at a crossroads after dropping the Raw Women's Title (now the WWE Women's Championship) to Asuka. Bianca Belair was even hearing some scattered boos ring out during her matches shortly before losing the belt, which is typically a sure sign that someone's babyface run is coming to an end.
She's another who could use a heel turn to spark things back into life.
It looks like that's what WWE has planned, too. Bianca lamented online about Charlotte Flair strolling back onto SmackDown and receiving a title match with Asuka ahead of her, and it'd make sense if she used that as fuel for a turn to the dark side soon.
Belair got years out of that babyface run after jumping up from NXT, but it's time for her to try on something else. Going heel would instantly transform Bianca's fortunes, and let her experiment a little more on the mic during promos.
Which other WWE stars badly need to be repackaged? For more wrestling, check out 10 AMAZING WWE Matches (You Should Never EVER Watch) and 5 Things AEW Must Steal From WCW (And 5 It Shouldn’t!)!