10 Things WWE Wants You To Forget About Hell In A Cell

Those times WWE's ultimate stipulation backfired in their faces.

Hell in a Cell is WWE's ultimate feud-ender, and one of its most punishing match types. It's also been the site of some truly iconic moments, including Kane's debut, Mankind's legendary plummet, and the 'End of an Era' match at WrestleMania 28. Unfortunately, nothing in life is perfect - not even the Hell in a Cell stipulation. There have been 30 Hell in a Cell matches throughout WWE history (if you include a multi-man post-Raw dark match in 2011), and a fair few have been utterly terrible. The stipulation's worst moments don't just revolve around shoddy in-ring action; the Cell match has also featured its fair share of terrible booking decisions and ill-advised finishes.

10. Mick Foley Didn't Retire After Losing His Retirement Match At No Way Out 2000

Everybody knows that wrestling retirements seem to last as long as the average Hardcore Title reign. One day, Ric Flair's bidding an emotional goodbye at WrestleMania 24; the next, he's popping up to deliver nonsensical heel promos in TNA. It's cynical and money-grabbing, but it's the way of the wrestling world. Retirements are as much a work as the rest of the business. But Mick, we thought you were different. Back in early 2000, Foley was engaged in an emotional, torch-passing feud with Triple H. After losing a brutal Street Fight at the Royal Rumble, Mick challenged the Game to one last match at No Way Out. Win, and he'd become the new WWF Champion; lose, and he'd retire forever. Forever. He didn't though. Their match was an emotional epic (which saves it from a higher entry on this list) but the consequences were dire. Despite losing a barbaric contest to Triple H, Foley's retirement lasted just a month. He was shoehorned into the WrestleMania 2000 main event - part of the extremely ill-advised 'McMahon In Every Corner' angle - and given a far less dramatic send-off than originally intended.

9. Early Overkill

The modern-day Hell in a Cell PPV has certainly diluted the appeal of its titular stipulation. Fans like to remember the Cell concept as a far less predictable concept, cropping up only when a storyline needed a particularly explosive exclamation point. Nowadays, with Hell in a Cell matches rigidly guaranteed at the same time every year, their spectacular aura has been somewhat lost. However, if we take the rose-tinted spectacles off for a second, things weren't always so perfect. The first Cell match came at Badd Blood 1997, and saw the iconic debut of Kane - so far, so good. However, just one year later, fans were subjected to three such matches in around two months. One was the now-legendary clash between Undertaker and Mankind, but the other two occurred on Raw, clocking it at just over 10 and 7 minutes respectively. Less than a year into its lifespan, and the Cell match was in serious danger of over-saturation. Luckily, WWE got their heads straight and began limiting such matches - but, had they continued in the same vein, the stipulation might now be a barely-remembered relic of the past.

8. CM Punk vs Ryback

CM Punk and Ryback have never had the best in-ring chemistry, a fact that was blatantly obvious even before Punk publicly trashed him. Hell in a Cell 2012 was a prime example of this, as the pair squared off for Punk's WWE Championship in the main event. It was a plodding, crowd-sapping affair, one which could easily have taken place without the Cell stipulation. The match itself may have been poor, but the finish was even worse. In the midst of a mid-reign heel turn (despite being the most popular babyface champ in years), Punk had begun winning matches in unscrupulous fashion. This one took the cake, as the referee - a then-unknown Brad Maddox - low-blowed Ryback and administered the fastest of fast counts. It was an unimaginative hand-wave of an ending, one which greatly offended the intelligence of the fans. In a weak attempt to send the live audience home happy, Ryback sloppily beat Punk and Maddox around the Cell to an uncomfortable "this is what we paid for?" silence. At least they didn't do it again...

7. CM Punk vs Ryback And Paul Heyman

Actually, they did do it again, the very next year. By this point, the pair had switched alignments. Punk was now a babyface again, having been betrayed by the dastardly Paul Heyman, while Ryback was essentially playing Biff Tannen from 'Back To The Future' - a knucklehead bully gimmick with very little substance. The match centred around the stipulation that, if Punk won, he'd get his hands on Heyman. Paul spent the entirety of the match on top of the cage, a ploy to keep himself safe from Punk, and surely one of the stupidest decisions in the history of wrestling. The match itself was similar to their encounter the year before; the face/heel roles were reversed, and we were treated to slightly more kendo stick involvement, but the general feel was depressingly samey. Eventually, Punk got the better of a momentum-sapping finishing sequence and nailed the G2S for the win. He then climbed up to the top of the cage and hit Heyman with several kendo stick shots, before dishing out another GTS and posing in triumph. End scene. It was an anti-climactic ending by all accounts, but the stipulation was never going to live up to expectations from the moment it was introduced. We might have dreamed of Punk launching Heyman, Foley-esque, off the side of the cage to the announce table before - but it was never realistically going to happen. The whole thing smacked of rushed booking with an inevitably disappointing payoff.

6. Triple H vs Kevin Nash

Triple H vs Kevin Nash is a matchup with notorious connotations. The 'Summer of Punk' angle seemed almost impossible to screw up, yet somehow WWE managed to get from CM Punk taking on John Cena (and, by extension, the status quo of the entire company) to Triple H vs Kevin Nash at TLC 2011. Four years later, it remains shorthand for an exciting angle bombed out by terrible booking. Not only did Triple H vs Kevin Nash leave its stain on the most promising angle of the decade - it left its stain on the Hell in a Cell stipulation as well, almost a decade earlier. Nash was carrying a pair of blown knees, and the Game was at his most immobile, having packed on unnecessary amounts of muscle since returning from injury in 2002. Eddie Guerrero vs Rey Mysterio it was not. This match came across as nothing more than two big, strong dudes attempting to prove how big and strong they are - which I strongly suspect is all it was. Foley made a welcome cameo as the special guest referee, but even he couldn't save the show, eating huge chairshot from Triple H before making the pinfall for him anyway.

5. Shawn Michaels And Triple H Go 47 Minutes

Another 'classic' from the "Triple H is better than everybody, even his old kliq friends" era. 47 minutes is a hell of a long time for a match, particularly in WWE - but, if planned to a reasonable degree, executed smartly, and sprinkled with clever incidents to keep the crowd hot, it can be successful. Shawn Michaels and Triple H didn't exactly nail this formula at Bad Blood 2004. Instead, they put on a bloody war of attrition, one which sadly becomes a chore to watch. Noel Gallagher once described jazz music as "four blokes on stage having more fun than the people in the crowd" - and whether you agree with that sentiment or not, it can certainly be applied here. It's easy to imagine HBK and Triple H planning out this match, squeezing in every epic trope they could think of. It ended with them collapsing on top of one another in a heap, for goodness' sake. Triple H won, but you could have guessed that.

4. Undertaker Throws His Weight Around. CM Punk Suffers.

This entry is included more for the details surrounding the match, rather than the in-ring action itself. In the dying days of the brand split, CM Punk was enjoying a breakthrough run as World Heavyweight Champion, having won the belt in an electrifying feud with Jeff Hardy. Reportedly, Punk then got on the wrong side of the wrong people backstage. Undertaker claimed that he should dress more like a champion, Punk pointed out that John Cena dressed however he liked, and Taker mysteriously won the belt at Hell in a Cell 2009 (despite Punk riding a wave of momentum at the time). Punk was then shifted away from the main event scene, forming the Straight Edge Society and losing feuds with Rey Mysterio and Big Show. He'd have to wait until 2011 to truly regain his popularity again. Remarkably, this was the first time a championship had changed hands inside the Cell structure - the 17th match in its entire history.

3. Kane And Undertaker's Horrible Feud

It's a sad truth that Undertaker and Kane have never had a great match together. Despite being inextricably bound to one another throughout their careers (or since Kane's 1997 debut, at least), the 'brothers' have never forged a chemistry in the ring. Their Hell in a Cell match at the 2010 PPV of the same name was a particular low point. The match was a predictably slow affair, and built to an even more disappointing finish. Bearer, back in Undertaker's service at the time, turned heel on the Deadman, slinked into the Cell towards the end of the match. Then, as Undertaker set up for a climactic Tombstone, the lights in the arena dimmed for no reason other than to set up the next spot. Bearer removed the lid of Taker's urn and a light emitted from inside, blinding the Phenom and allowing Kane to steal an undeserved win. As hokey as that sounds, it comes across even worse visually, all three men straining their facial expressions to sell the weirdness of the situation.

2. Bray Wyatt's Hologram

From one ludicrous supernatural finish to another, Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose's Cell match in 2014 was hamstrung by one of the worst match endings in the recent memory. The pair put on a dramatic, hard-hitting encounter, which managed to fulfil the brutal demands of the stipulation without straying outside of PG restrictions. Then Bray Wyatt ran in and ruined everything. In fairness, the match was too good for any sort of cheap finish, but the manner of Wyatt's interference really takes the cake. With a babyface Ambrose on the verge of victory, the lights cut out and Bray's lantern appeared in the middle of the ring. It was emitting a hologram. A legitimately impressive Hell in a Cell match had immediately become farce. As Dean mirrored the reaction of legions of WWE fans around the world, and stood dumbstruck by the events unfolding before him, Wyatt rushed through the illusion and attacked - allowing Rollins to steal the win, and utterly ruining the credibility of the match.

1. Undertaker And Big Boss Man Put On The Worst Cell Match Ever

WWE superstars can talk about killing one another all they like, and nobody bats an eyelid. But when one wrestler then actually attempts to commit a murder in storyline, fans usually react negatively; it's one extreme too far, and a step our suspension of disbelief can't usually withstand. It explains why angles such as Undertaker's cement-burial of Paul Bearer and Jesus' stabbing of John Cena are remembered in a tainted fashion. WrestleMania 15 saw one of the most infamous match finishes in WWE history, as Undertaker celebrated his win over the Big Boss Man by hanging him from the ceiling of the Cell. The whole thing was rendered even more ridiculous as the segment ended, and (despite witnessing an attempted murder) JR simply brushed off the incident and began to hype the ensuing main event. On the broadcast, Boss Man was cut down during the airing of a video package; those watching at home were simply left to presume that he'd been killed off, and forget about it in time for Austin vs Rock. As poorly thought out as the match finish was, it often hides the fact that the bout itself was equally terrible. Commonly regarded as the worst Hell in a Cell match ever, it is the wrestling equivalent of two icebergs slowly colliding over hundreds of years. In other words, not very exciting. It'll always be remembered for the shocking nature of its conclusion, but coupled with the terrible action beforehand, it becomes worst Hell in a Cell moment in the history of the stipulation.

Content Producer
Content Producer

Highly overrated 23 year old from the North East of England. Hanging off of your gangster car.