10 Things WWE Wants You To Forget About Sin Cara

Hard as nails, mental as anything.

Sin Cara
WWE.com

We should be grateful for Sin Cara while he's still around - and he probably won't be for very long, if current form is any indication.

He was once protected by his marketable mask, and the merchandise sales that came with it, but there's about three other masked men on the roster these days. He has lost his status as special attraction - and, if we are to believe the recent rumours, he's lost his marbles.

On WWE's recent European tour, Cara, known backstage agitator, thought it would be funny to make some (unspecified) odd noises. Locker room leader Jericho echoed the muted sentiments of his peers by telling him to "Shut...the hell...up!" He probably didn't wheel out his Attitude Era catchphrase, but this story has already been embellished. Cara's response? "F*ck off." How pleasant. A scuffle ensued, the details of which are sketchy, but noted psychologist Jericho at least had the nous to work over a suspect body part by biting Cara on the finger.

As Jim Cornette has it, in the post-kayfabe era, wrestling has been pasteurised and sanitised for your protection. Wrestlers in 2016 don't stab each other with scissors in hotel rooms or inject themselves with monkey hormones. They play video games backstage and take selfies.

Cara is the glorious, quick-tempered exception - and it's little wonder there's much about him WWE wants you to forget.

10. He Was Triple H's Guy

Triple H Pensive
WWE

Triple H revels in his role as adulated NXT head honcho, and with good reason. From a star creation, episodic television and match quality perspective, the supposed developmental league p*sses on its main roster equivalent from a great height. Trips famously loves the spotlight - but at least he's only taking pictures with new NXT champions, and not booking himself into high profile series opposite them.

His role as developmental godfather, however, started as inauspiciously as his WWF career - only, instead of being thrown face-first into pig sh*t by Henry O. Godwinn, Triple H covered it with egg by allowing pet project Cara to sidestep the developmental system altogether.

Unlike Alberto Del Rio, who learned how to wrestle opponents on the unfamiliar left side in Florida Championship Wrestling, the original Sin Cara - Luis Urive, former Mexican sensation as Mistico - debuted directly on main roster programming.

It's often easy to view Triple H with cynicism - did he really torpedo the 2011 Summer of Punk because the Straight Edge Superstar poked fun at The Chaperone? - and if one does take this view, they might jump to the conclusion that Cara was trotted out before he was ready in order to cover Triple H's scouting nous in glory.


9. THAT Debut

Sin Cara Debut
WWE.com

This has been discussed recently - but it bears repeating. Cara was doomed from the very start, when he made his bow on the April 4, 2011 RAW to rescue Daniel Bryan from Sheamus' post-match assault.

Michael Cole on commentary went into hyperbolic overdrive as Cara emerged through the curtain. "There he is!" he bellowed. "We have been waiting for this man for a long time," he continued. That much was true. The Mistico signing was much heralded across the wrestling world. "Sin Cara - the international sensation - the Mexican high-flier!" he continued.

Cara did not live up to this lofty billing. He was due to leap majestically over the top rope by way of trampoline, which WWE had to quickly cut away from as he bounded down the aisle. The illusion of Cara as a man of otherworldly aerial ability had been by shattered within seconds - and Cara himself compounded the agony by failing to clear the top rope, falling gracelessly to the mat below.

Cole couldn't disguise the botch with a euphemism; "Oh man!" he winced, for once echoing the sentiments of the fans. The botch was catching; Cole, infected, then referred to Cara as "Cera" in a disastrous debut.


8. His Botchtastic Stigma

Sin Cara Chavo Guerrero
WWE.com

Cara's debut was not an aberration - it became apparent, in record time, that the poor bloke's confidence had been left in tatters following his terrible introduction. His 2011 matches were utterly plagued by botches. He became a laughing stock throughout year, beset by errors which included but were not limited to:

Forgetting the correct side with which to grapple Christian, resulting in him flailing on his shoulders like a kid being carried by his dad; missing Alex Riley by a clear foot with a match-ending moonsault; almost breaking his neck by landing on his head when performing a backflip taunt in a match against Michael McGillicutty; resuming hostilities with his nemesis, the top rope, by failing to clear it during a suicide senton at Survivor Series 2011, incurring a patellar tendon rupture in the process; botching La Mistica on Chavo Guerrero so badly that he almost broke both their necks...

Cara throughout 2011 couldn't time a move in a WWE ring to save his life, earning the nickname 'Botch Cara'.


7. The Sin Cara Vs. Sin Cara Feud

sin cara azul negro
WWE.com

Urive as Cara violated the Wellness Policy in what must be record time. He debuted in April 2011 - and was suspended for 30 days on July 18. He cried ignorance, citing an injection to treat a knee injury.

It was an almost merciful interjection. It represented an opportunity for WWE to write him out of the storylines, demote him to then-developmental territory Florida Championship Wrestling, and start anew. Sheamus did powerbomb Cara through a ladder and off the main roster stage, at Money In The Bank, but WWE, compelled to drive forward with the momentum he had gathered (!), debuted Jorge Arias under the mask as a placeholder. This (obvious, more muscled impostor of) Sin Cara then turned heel by laying waste to Daniel Bryan.

To underscore Cara's turn to the dark side, the ever-subtle WWE dressed him in black attire - and, if that wasn't enough, referred to him as 'Sin Cara N egro. The original Cara - now referred to as Sin Cara Azul - had returned in the meantime to seek his vengeance.

Their feud culminated at Hell In A Cell. It was hoped that Arias would, like Chavo Guerrero before and Rey Mysterio after him, help Cara's transition as a fellow Spanish speaker. It didn't wok; the HIAC bout was another dire entry into the Cara canon. Heat-free, botched and worked as if it were anything but a grudge match, the the New Orleans crowd were definitely not in their usual party mode.


6. Whonico?

Hunico Sin Cara
WWE.com

Once the Sin Cara Vs. Sin Cara feud fizzled out, Arias was repackaged, veering across the Mexican stereotype spectrum from masked luchador to bandana and wife-beater clad gang-banger. WWE were worried that the character was a little too understated - so they literally wheeled him out to the ring in a lowrider bicycle. Thankfully, the idea of replacing that with a lawnmower was considered too racist. No, wait, that wasn't it - WWE had already done it with the short-lived Mexicools stable.

Unfortunately for his WWE prospects, he resumed his feud with Sin Cara as 'Hunico'. He could not escape the Sin Cara character - and when he finally did, he wrestled exclusively on Superstars. Ordinarily, that would be considered a demotion, but Arias breathed a sigh of relief. He was no longer stigmatised by Botch Cara. His career would continue outside of that shadow.

Except, it wouldn't - when Urive was marginalised by WWE in October of 2013 ahead of his eventual release, Arias reassumed the role of Sin Cara on a full-time basis. It wasn't all bad - Arias' version was less spectacular but exponentially more solid. The man under the mask previously had damaged the act so much that Cara was never destined for main events. All Arias had to do to secure his long-term financial future through merchandise royalties was to keep his head down and get on with it...


5. He Battered Sheamus

Sin Cara
WWE.com

...that would have been a sound plan - but Arias was as fond as brawling as Urive was of botching.

In May 2014, it emerged that Sin Cara had entered into an altercation with Sheamus. You might have fancied Sheamus' chances, given his size advantage and storyline portrayal as a vicious brawler, but his record was dubious. Wrestling apocrypha has it that, when living together during their FCW days, Sheamus' a*se was handed to him by one Yoshi Tatsu over a monetary dispute.

Sheamus went 0-2 when he made a snide remark at Cara's expense. Apparently, the original target of Cara's ire was the former Drew McIntyre, who would purportedly only pay attention to his locker room peers if they were high enough up in the pecking order for it to reflect well on him. When Sheamus alluded to Cara's complaint, his legs were swept from under him and his face was pummelled.

Unfortunately for WWE, who like to depict the Great White as a legitimate hardcase, the Sin Cara Vs. Sheamus scrap story is unearthed whenever the former gets himself in the news - which at this rate will soon become a weekly occurrence.


4. ...And Simon Gotch

Simon Gotch
WWE.com

Sin Cara went full Bart Gunn in July 2016 when he floored Simon Gotch of the Vaudevillains prior to this year's inaugural edition of SmackDown! live.

Details of the story remain sketchy, but the two men had previous, by all accounts, dating back to their days in NXT. It's a wonder the situation didn't combust earlier than it did. Gotch has an alleged penchant for running his mouth, and Cara demonstrably has a penchant for shutting mouths up. It was, as the great Gorilla Monsoon would have it, a meeting of the immovable object and the irresistible force - only one that wouldn't sell any Pay Per Views.

Reports vary as to how Gotch's mouth was actually shut. Cara either floored him with an unopened can of pop (that is soda to our American cousins and somehow 'juice' to those in Scotland) or punched him in the kisser.

In any event, Cara got the better of the exchange - so much so that Gotch was removed from the imminent round of house show events.


3. That Time His Finger Went Ouchy

Sin Cara Finger
WWE

Wrestlers are notoriously hard.

Triple H withstood the agony of a torn quadricep - even exacerbating it in Chris Jericho's Walls Of Jericho finisher - in order to complete a match in 2001. The back injury Shawn Michaels incurred at Royal Rumble 1998 set his career back four painful years - yet he dropped the WWF Heavyweight Title to Steve Austin in an inconceivably gutsy performance at WrestleMania XIV. Steve Austin recovered from temporary paralysis to achieve his SummerSlam 1997 Intercontinental Title victory over Owen Hart.

Urive as Cara once, in 2013, was in so much pain from an, erm, dislocated finger, that he was unable to complete his short RAW match opposite Alberto Del Rio as scheduled. After he naturally botched a suicide dive attempt, he frantically motioned to the referee to alert him of the injury. An incensed Del Rio had to be dragged away from Cara, so intent was he on punishing him for his weakness. It matters little to WWE that this was Urive and Arias - they are one and the same in the canon, irrespective of how often it is ignored.

Where's Bill DeMott when you need him?


2. The Lucha Dragons

Lucha Dragon dive Elimination Chamber
WWE.com

The Lucha Dragons in their NXT run became a firm favourite of the Full Sail faithful - then again, Bull Dempsey was over in Orlando, so it's unclear if they were just in love with the sound of their own voices (see also: The Ascension).

The Lucha Dragons were nowhere near as bad as those abysmal Road Warriors impersonators - but they were hardly a team worth celebrating. Their crowd interaction tactic fizzled out after about a fortnight, and their championship prospects followed shortly thereafter.

Sin Cara and partner Kalisto played a major part in the disaster that was the Tag Team Title match at Elimination Chamber 2015. It was, to WWE's credit, an ambitious undertaking - but with the exception of Cesaro and El Torito (!), the remaining five men weren't up to the task. Astonishingly, it was the more talented Kalisto who damaged the Dragons' reputation on the night. Instead of contributing to the match, he spent the vast majority of it hiding on the upper walls of the mesh.

Cara and Kalisto were separated during the 2016 brand split. That WWE elected to draft in the Headbangers, rather than reunite them, should tell you how the Lucha Dragons were regarded by management.


1. Sin Cara

ryback sin cara
WWE.com

WWE, it would seem, is in the process of erasing Sin Cara himself from existence.

Following the altercation with Chris Jericho outlined in the intro, Cara was dispatched to anger management classes like Daniel Bryan and Kane before him - the key difference being is that there's no danger of Sin Cara proclaiming himself as the tag team champions in the near future. He's flying so far under the radar at present that he wouldn't have caught a Hardcore Title reign in the famed 24/7 period.

What's odd about this punishment is that, at least as it pertains to the Jericho incident, Cara doesn't so much have a rage issue as he does an irrepressible compulsion to be an annoying pr*ck.

Cara at one point was due to be removed from the European tour altogether, but the decision was made to instead temporarily transfer him to the SmackDown bus, where no rumours of annoying noises were reported. Where does Cara go from here? Backstage irritant and average talent in a sea of exciting cruiserweight stars, the man is likely on his ninth life. It'll be interesting to see who he punches on his way out of the door. I hope it's Stephanie.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!