10 Things WWE Wants You To Forget About Toni Storm
Alternative title: 'Why WWE Should Be Worried That Toni Storm Is Gone'.
Someone on WWE's creative team should release a book soon called, 'How To Ruin A Hot Young Star's Potential In 5 Months'. Slap a picture of Toni Storm with pie all over her face on the cover and voilà - an accurate retelling of the 26 year old's time on the main roster.
There's no getting away from how p*ss poor that July-December stretch was. It was so rubbish, in fact, that Toni herself decided she'd be better off the hell away from WWE's scriptwriters. Wrestlers taking their chances somewhere else is becoming an increasingly recurring theme these days, and no wonder when the booking is as rotten as it was for Storm.
Somewhere, Triple H is probs shaking with anger like he did when Randy Orton RKO'd his wife.
There's a lot that WWE would want fans to forget about Toni's time with the company, and most of it happened in such a short span that it's genuinely amazing they were able to screw things up so badly. Were the writers in a hurry, or something?
Indeed, Storm's whirlwind SmackDown run is a reminder of everything currently wrong with Vince McMahon's system.
10. They Didn’t Make Her A Star
It's not the entire story though.
Truthfully, Toni Storm was well on her way to becoming a major force without WWE. Vinnie Mac may take that as a slap across the chops, but it's fact. She was on the rise before signing with the company, and was turning heads wherever she went on the variety-rich pro wrestling map.
Ask Progress Wrestling fans what they thought of Storm's work, or maybe consider revisiting her embarrassment of riches as part of the Stardom roster. Oh yes, Toni was making waves in those promotions, and also in others like Germany's wXw too.
WWE will not want people to think about that. They'd much rather folks believed that Storm needed them to endear herself towards wrestling fans. OK, so it's also true that WWE's platform is bigger than anyone else's, but that doesn't mean Toni wouldn't have thrived without inking a deal on McMahon-printed paper.
9. WWE Outright Failed To Capitalise
In retrospect, Storm's WWE career was littered with missed opportunities. One of the biggest came after she'd won the Mae Young Classic at the one-off Evolution pay-per-view in 2018. That tournament triumph should've been a springboard to bigger and better things, but there was just one problem.
The E didn't know how to capitalise.
Was Toni's run in NXT fun? Sure, but that was meant to be an appetiser for more to come on Raw or SmackDown. The fact she was so heavily-endorsed by both Triple H and Stephanie McMahon (who had been cast as star-squashing members of The Authority in recent years) had to mean more than it did.
Storm looked every bit the future of WWE's women when she offed Io Shirai to win the trophy. The gorgeous bouquet of flowers she was presented with, along with the beaming smile on the youngster's face, would soon wilt and fade.
8. The One-Note Presentation
One of the biggest issues with call-ups from NXT to the main roster is that WWE routinely fail to flesh characters out. Their writers rely on one-note personality traits and cling onto them like they're some licence to print money. That's presumably why Toni's rock chick looks became her main reason for existing.
Hearing Michael Cole talk about how Storm's mother was into “80s rock n’ roll” was embarrassingly paper-thin. The dude sounded like a Geography teacher trying to appear hip when he spoke about her “being a wild child of the 80s” too, and this was especially egregious considering Toni was born in 1995.
She doesn't even remember the 80s!
That doesn't mean she can't enjoy the era, obviously, but that's not how WWE presented her. They pretended she lived in a nostalgia bubble and couldn't comprehend the 90s or beyond. It was all so terribly flimsy, but that's what happens when creative don't know what they have on their hands.
7. She Was Absent For Months
Storm debuted on the 23 July SmackDown with a win over future royal Zelina Vega. This occurred during an exciting period for WWE - fans had been welcomed back to arenas regularly for the first time since March 2020, and the promotion seemed keen to have some fresh names waiting for them.
So, of course, Toni didn’t wrestle on TV again until the 17 September show.
This near-two month gap was a real momentum killer. Fans had forgotten the win over Zelina by the time Storm showed back up, and she was thus forced to start all over again. Surely WWE should know by now that building up familiarity with the audience is key to establishing that connection with people and, y'know, getting over.
Worse, when Toni did rock back onto screens, she was placed in some random-ass tag-team matches alongside Liv Morgan. That did nothing for either babyface, and it actually kinda stifled their individual hopes of rising up the card.
6. The 'Gushing Groupie' Tease
This wasn't a missed opportunity as much as a dodged bullet.
After making her return to TV, Storm started appearing in sporadic backstage promos with the likes of Dolph Ziggler. Though these segments didn't outright say it, "lady killer" Dolph was trying to charm Toni and woo her. Unfortunately for him, the "80s wild child" much preferred Rick Boogs.
When asked for her thoughts on the Boogs/Shinsuke Nakamura duo, Storm gushed over Ricky baby like some little fangirl who just couldn't believe she was lucky enough to share a locker room with him. This was unbelievably sh*te, and it was clear that WWE didn't give a hoot how Toni was coming across.
Her 'Gushing Groupie' recasting turned out to be short-lived. Thank God for that, because Storm's main roster run could've burned out even quicker had she been asked to tickle Boogs' moustache or play air guitar alongside he, Naka and Pat McAfee every Friday.
5. The Quick Queen’s Crown Job
WWE had something else in mind for Toni anyway.
She entered the brackets for the first ever Queen's Crown tourney. Some fans on Twitter were pleased about this, 'cause most thought Storm could replicate her Mae Young Classic success from a few years prior. Or...not. The SmackDown newcomer jobbed to eventual winner Zelina Vega in just over two minutes.
This 8 October loss should've come as a big warning sign that WWE didn't really know what to do with Toni. She was the first woman eliminated from a tournament that went a grand total of 19 minutes and 35 seconds bell-to-bell. Yes, less than 20 whole minutes of ring time.
Toni got exactly two minutes and 10 seconds of those in early-October. WWE transitioning out of that embarrassment into a SmackDown Women's Title push is maybe an overall commentary on the way they do business and ready wrestlers for featured feuds too.
On that note...
4. “2 Pies Toni”
...who needs "Becky 2 Belts' when they can have "2 Pies Toni"?!
Becky Lynch's short-lived nickname reminded everyone that she held the Raw and SmackDown Women's Titles at the same time. Meanwhile, poor Storm's recent pet name reminded folks that she'd been pelted in the face with multiple cream pies over Thanksgiving. Yay?
WWE actually made Toni refer to herself as "2 Pies Toni" and thought it'd raise a titter from fans or make Storm a bigger babyface because she was owning the embarrassment. Yeah, that didn't happen. People rolled their eyes at the goofy self-assessment, then wondered why Toni wasn't out for proper revenge against Charlotte Flair.
As if that wasn't humiliating enough, Storm also buddied up with regular backstabber Sasha Banks for some backstage promos that again made the former look like the latter's teenage number one fan. Nobody stopped to explain how this was supposed to made Toni into a bigger star.
3. Charlotte Flair Gobbled Her Up
Throughout the feud with Charlotte, one other thing became crystal: Toni Storm wasn't anywhere close to Flair's level, and she probably wasn't going to be the one to take that SmackDown Women's Title from her. It's like WWE has forgotten how to use someone’s star power to get a rising face over.
That's especially true if the emerging threat is a babyface; they tend to go goofy with things all the time (hence the pie sh*t between both women), and it never really works out. All that happened to Toni is that she looked plucky one minute and like a stupid little rookie who was in over her head the next.
Last week, Storm dropped to defeat opposite Charlotte and left with a distinct 'second best' aura. Nobody could've known then that she'd ask to get out of her WWE contract, but it didn't exactly look like she was on the up and up either.
That loss would prove to be Toni's last TV appearance for the company.
2. She Asked For Her Release
Storm was unhappy with WWE’s recent direction, and rightfully so. Even so, the company won’t want to admit that a 26 year old hot prospect would rather wrestle somewhere else during the prime years of her career, and it's doubtful they actually wanted to lose her in the first place.
This was very-much Toni's decision.
Bruce Prichard has claimed on his podcast before that Vince McMahon's outlook on wrestlers requesting releases is, "Go be happy". That hasn't always been true - if it was, then he wouldn't have kept Luke Harper/Brodie Lee on the bench for so long, or tried to stop The Revival/FTR from heading to AEW for a year or two.
Again, a 26 year old has willingly decided to take herself out of WWE's nest so she can fly away for pastures new. Should McMahon be worried about this? Definitely, but not only 'cause he's just lost a prime piece of talent.
1. Her Release Is A Worrying Sign
There could be a knock-on effect here.
WWE used to be the company to work for. In fact, at one point, it was the only means for pro wrestlers to make some decent income. In 2021, those days are over, and Toni Storm's departure proves it. This fabulous worker in her mid-20s has chosen not to walk under Vince's umbrella.
A celebrated talent with all the potential in the world craves better, and Storm will absolutely get it regardless of where she ends up. Other wrestlers in WWE will see that happen. She'll go on to smash it in AEW - she'd be a great addition to any company's roster, to be honest, but Tony Khan's group seems the most likely.
Here's something else WWE won't want to admit: Vince McMahon’s insular kingdom has repelled another dead cert star. They did so with criminal booking, woeful presentation and by sticking to a system that tears a worker's credibility to shreds rather than bolstering it.
What else do you think WWE would want fans to forget about Toni Storm? For more like this, check out 10 Wrestling Matches Too Horrible For WWE To Air and WWE Day 1 2022: 10 Things That Must Happen!