10 Things WWE Wants You To Forget About WCW
DX's false "invasion" of Nitro, ratings misery, the Invasion, and other WCW moments.
True competition in American professional wrestling ended on 26 March 2001, when Vince McMahon purchased Ted Turner's ailing World Championship Wrestling and absorbed the Atlanta-based promotion into his sports entertainment empire.
Turner Broadcasting exeuctive Jamie Kellner hammered the coffin's last nail. Decreeing WCW's programming no longer fit for the broadcaster's image, he swung the axe by cancelling all shows, leaving the brand and its libraries, properties, and contracts open to the McMahon buyout. A paltry $4.2 million was all Vince paid to end a war that began in the territories 19 years prior.
Outlasting and outperforming his toughest competition gave Vince immediate power to control the WCW narrative. His skewed take on the Monday Night Wars has poisoned the well to the extent that some would have you believe WCW was a day-one dumpster fire, bringing no good to the wrestling world, though the truth is quite the opposite.
Vince Russo, the Fingerpoke of Doom, and New Blood Rising all happened. Indeed, there's a reason "late period WCW" is frequently used as a damning comparison point. The company brought plenty of dumb, destructive content to the table, and is partly responsible for its own damaged reputation.
But don't let WWE shoot holes in your memory...
10. The Most Overhyped Segment In WWE/WCW History
A perennial fixture on any piece of WWE-produced content referencing the Monday Night Wars is this segment from Raw's 27 April 1998 episode, in which D-Generation X "invaded" WCW Nitro in their "tank."
Hyped as a big, ballsy move that threatened to send the competition into complete disarray, it is the most overhyped segment in WWE (and maybe American wrestling) history. Triple H's clown troupe accomplished nothing. While convincing fans outside of Nitro to chant "DX!" may have sparked a tinge of WCW embarrassment, this was literally the extent of their rebellion. Arena staff literally pulled down the shutters, stopped DX from getting in, and that was that. Invasion over.
The segment is as pathetic as the company narrative on it. Four grown men turned up in a sh*tty little Jeep (not a tank), made some noise, and got turned away. No more rebellious than a gang of drunk students getting refused entry from a nightclub on fancy dress night, it is nonetheless celebrated as a rogue act of wrestling rebellion.
Triple H has since claimed that WCW were so spooked, they called the local police, claiming they were under attack from a militia group. Vince Russo described the segment as an "all-out assault."
Really, the "all-out assault" would have gone down had DX gotten inside the building and ran into Meng.
9. Decades Of Stolen Ideas
Wrestling promotions "borrowing" ideas from one another isn't anything new, and certainly not unique to WWE during the Monday Night Wars.
Indeed, Vince McMahon's group fell victim to creative theft multiple times while battling with WCW. Ted Turner's group saw Chyna's success and tried to recreate it with Asya, aped the Royal Rumble with World War 3 (adding two extra rings in the process), and installed its own hardcore division while the scene was servicing WWE's underserved midcard well. Pilfering was ubiquitous, is the point. Everybody was doing it.
But with Vince McMahon so often put over as a genius for genuinely revolutionising professional wrestling in the '80s and '90s, you can bet your house on the WWE Chairman wanting you to conveniently forget that his company routinely raided WCW's ideas bank.
WrestleMania changed the game, but Starrcade innovated the supercard concept over a year before McMahon's first blockbuster event. Demolition were WWE's attempt at recreating the Road Warriors' success for the opposition. The shift towards grimier, edgier content that sparked WWE's Attitude Era success happened on Nitro first, primarily through the New World Order, which heavily influenced Vince's own rogue stable, D-Generation X.
The list goes on.
8. Vince Stole Talent First
Wrestlers jumping ship between WCW and WWE was a Monday Night Wars hallmark and part of what made the era so exciting. From the moment Lex Luger stepped out on Nitro's inaugural episode mere days after his WWE contract had expired, the floodgates were opened, with the likes of Scott Hall and Kevin Nash switching allegiances having demonstrably transformative impacts on both companies' fortunes.
Particularly in their skewed Monday Night War documentary series, WWE talking heads are quick to paint themselves as victims of WCW talent raids here and indeed, Hall, Nash, and Hulk Hogan were game-changers. Regardless, Vince McMahon has no grounds to complain about another promotion "stealing" his wrestlers away.
This has been the WWE Chairman's modus operandi for decades.
WWE's biggest golden era star, Hulk Hogan, was making a name in the AWA before going supernova in Stamford, and much of the company's success in its other boom period, the Attitude Era, was built on the back of an ex-WCW star in Steve Austin. In the '80s, poaching wrestlers from other territories by first putting them on his television, then signing them up, was a big part of McMahon's expansion strategy. In the 2010s, he was so rattled by ITV's World of Sport revival that he created NXT UK and signed every British indie wrestler of note, proving that even in his 70s, this side of Vince may never fade.
7. Eric Bischoff Was Mr. McMahon Before Vince McMahon
The emergence of Mr. McMahon in the Montreal Screwjob's aftermath and the character's growth through his hugely important Steve Austin feud was pivotal to WWE turning the corner in the Monday Night Wars and ultimately emerging victorious. It's a classic wrestling character, comfortably the most effective authority figure persona in wrestling history, and its significance can't be overstated.
So successful was Mr. McMahon that it doomed generations of wrestling fans into thinking that evil boss figures were an essential norm. Only through Constable Corbin's near-universal rejection 20 years later did the trope start unravelling for WWE's less-discerning viewers.
But the thing about Mr. McMahon is that WWE didn't do the heel authority figure first. Indeed, Eric Bischoff's run as a dastardly, power-mad preceded Vince's character's emergence by over a year, with Easy E revealed as the nWo's hidden hand in late 1996. It wasn't until the aftermath of Survivor Series 1997 that Vince began finding his footing in a similar role.
They were different characters, Vince and Eric, and McMahon became the more iconic of the two, though his reinvention was no innovation.
6. The Struggles Of 1997
1997 was the height of WWE's ratings misery, with Raw failing to outdo WCW Nitro once throughout the calendar year, not turning the corner until the aftermath of the Mike Tyson-assisted WrestleMania XIV the following year.
Creatively, it was a transitionary year for WWE, effectively serving as a bridge between the ailing New Generation period and the transformative Attitude Era. Behind the scenes, however, Vince McMahon's business was failing.
WWE's financial hole was so deep that extreme cost-cutting measures were introduced at Titan Towers, with employees banned from making long-distance phone calls and the building's water coolers taken away. Pay-per-view income was ailing, with In Your House specials priced at less than half the usual value, and while the issues had started clearing up by the year's end, the company was still operating in a deficit when Vince McMahon entered negotiations with Bret Hart over the Hitman's expiring contract.
Increasing the In Your House price paid dividends and by 1998, Steve Austin was the hottest thing on the planet and supported by emerging stars in Mick Foley and The Rock, though there's no question that WWE's business was badly hampered by WCW the year prior.
5. 84 Weeks
WCW Nitro bested WWE Raw for 84 straight weeks of ratings supremacy between 17 June 1996 and 6 April 1998, putting Vince McMahon's promotion on the ropes several times throughout that period, having largely traded Monday Night Wars wins back and forth up to that point.
Masterstrokes like Hulk Hogan's heel turn, the New World Order, and shifting towards a grittier style of programming while McMahon was still stuck in Cartoonland on the other channel led to this, though it was over by 1998. Nitro never outdid Raw again after scoring one final victory on 26 October, boosted, as it was, by the promise of DDP and Goldberg's full WCW Title match from Halloween Havoc after shambolic timing issues saw most of it cut from the PPV.
This is something too big for WWE to ever ignore. A pivotal Monday Night Wars period, ommitting it from discourse would be taking the p*ss, even for Vince McMahon's revisionist history museum, but history tells us that this isn't a guy who likes showing his bloodied nose to the world. Even though he ultimately emerged victorious, those 84 weeks stand as a monument of late-90s failure.
4. Homegrown Talent
Kevin Nash, Scott Hall, Hulk Hogan, and other WWE crossovers were fundamentally important to WCW's success (84 weeks wouldn't have happened if not for this trio) but attributing Ted Turner and Eric Bischoff's success to stars made by Vince McMahon is unfair, and doesn't tell the whole story. Sadly, this is something that WWE often does when performing mental gymnastics to explain WCW's more successful periods.
Conveniently ignoring WCW's homegrown stars is ridiculous. In fact, WCW's highest-grossing pay-per-view ever, Starrcade '97, was built on the appeal of one of the company's own players, Sting, dethroning Hulk Hogan as WCW Champion. 700,000 people paid to see that happen, though the match's botched finish taking the gloss off it is one of the most aggressively WCW things ever.
Bill Goldberg was built from scratch in WCW and stood as proof of concept for the company's star-making machine as he rose through the ranks. Diamond Dallas Page was another WCW original, eventually becoming World Champion, and while Ric Flair shot to prominence in places like Jim Crockett Promotions and Mid-Atlantic, WCW's lineage can be traced back to those classic territories.
Booker T? Scott Steiner? Those guys exist too.
3. The Buyout Alienated Millions
One of the great hopes of Vince McMahon's purchase of WCW was that WWE's audience would be bolstered by millions of fans crossing over from the other channel, putting untold volumes of new eyes on Raw. Theoretically, WWE would almost double its popularity - because where else could WCW fans go to have their wrestling itch scratched?
Instead, the buyout turned out to be history's single most destructive night in terms of driving viewers away from professional wrestling for good.
Raw and Nitro scored a combined television rating of 7.7 when they last went head to head on 26 March 2001. Raw's numbers stayed in the 5.1 to 5.7 region for the next few weeks before dropping down into the 4's. Averaging 3.7 by December 2001 and 3.4 the following year, the removal of competition from the American wrestling market precipitated a near-immediate decline in popularity the sport has never recovered from.
The data tells us that millions of WCW loyalists, many of whom had been watching wrestling for decades, tuned out forever when Vince announced his purchase. McMahon's vision of pro wrestling didn't match their own. The common assumption that they'd buy into it was false, and thus began the decades-long rot.
2. The Invasion Wrestlers WERE Enough
The Invasion storyline failed - but not for the reasons WWE tries to sell you on in documentaries.
Vince McMahon and co. are always quick to absolve themselves of all blame for the situation, referencing the likes of Hulk Hogan, Ric Flair, and The Outsiders sitting at home, living off their old contracts rather than giving them up to work for less money in WWE. How can it be WWE's fault when they couldn't secure WCW's biggest names?! The invading force didn't have enough star power! It was doomed to fail!
False.
With 775,000 buys, Invasion remains the most successful non-WrestleMania pay-per-view in WWE history. This tells us that the existing WCW troup, with Booker T the biggest name, was enough. At least at this point, WWE didn't need their Flairs, Goldbergs, and Hogans because the threat of these interlopers invading WWE programming, popping, getting over, and creating a tangible sense of chaos was a draw itself. The pay-per-view's phenomenal business success shows us this.
This should have given WWE more than enough juice to effectively run the Invasion storyline beyond the pay-per-view, until those expiring contracts started coming up. Indeed, the company progressively debuting WCW's biggest names gradually across the ensuing months could conceivably have kept it going for years, keeping the money rolling in and perhaps inspiring more old WCW fans to keep tuning in.
WWE could have done this. It was in their hands, and the booking was working heading into Invasion.
Ultimately, they chose not to.
1. Its True Spirit Lies Elsewhere
For a promotion that prides itself on its depth of history and regularly uses nostalgia to generate short-term interest in its product, WWE generally do a shoddy job of referencing WCW.
Once Ted Turner's banner event, Starrcade is now no more than a glorified house show. The Great American Bash and Halloween Havoc are throwaway NXT specials completely disconnected from what those brands were originally supposed to mean. WarGames lives on, sure, but in a heavily bastardised form, swapping heat and hatred for high spots and gifs.
On TNT, WWE's new rivals do an infinitely better job of harking back to the glory days.
It's not just that WCW is in Cody Rhodes' blood, given that his father, Dusty, once booked the promotion, or that Tony Khan's fandom for it is well known. It's not even in events like 2019's Bash at the Beach revival or AEW bringing wrestling back to TNT after an 18-year absence. It's in the faithful, respectful use of WCW figures like Arn Anderson, Sting, and Tully Blanchard, the similar booking techniques, and the look, feel and presentation of many ideas that leave Khan's creative room.
Indeed, the spirit of WCW - of good WCW, when the company ruled the wrestling world - lives in on AEW, despite that company's own flaws.