10 Times NXT Was As Dumb As WWE's Main Roster

Inheriting Raw and SmackDown's bad WWE habits means more booking blunders for NXT...

Shotzi Blackheart
WWE

For the longest time, NXT was the wrestling purist's choice for WWE fans, giving them the chance to peak into the future of the main roster and to experience a wrestling show that seemed more focused on the wrestling side of sports entertainment. In more recent years, it's become the preferred choice for WWE fans away from RAW and SmackDown owing to the state of the booking of the main roster brands.

With TakeOver cards consistently knocking out Match of the Year contenders, fans of NXT relish in the fact that a lot of the main roster silliness remains absent from what goes down on Wednesday nights. At least, that's what they want to believe.

Even before the topsy-turvy booking of the Wednesday Night Wars and COVID-stricken 2020, NXT is still a part of tWWE and as such, has always had the faintest whiff of a Vince McMahon idea brewing in the background. While some of it has a certain charm - the revival of the In Your House event as an example - a lot of these ideas should've stayed buried away in the pantheon of ideas labelled "what was Vince thinking?!"...

10. Shotzi Blackheart's Tank Is More Over Than Her

Shotzi Blackheart
WWE

The high-energy Blackheart introduced her tank to NXT on a January 2020 episode of NXT. It proved to be one helluva crowd and Twitter popper and had it just stayed as an entrance gimmick, it may have indeed remained "cool" enough to escape this list, but what happened afterwards taints the spectacle of the punk rocker driving a miniature war machine.

In May last year, NXT released "special look at Shotzi Blackheart", a video purposed to give background to the superstar but ran dry in its "AREN'T TANKS GREAT? Also my dad was cool... But TANKS THOUGH?!" presentation. In her program with Aaliyah and Robert "Definitely Not Tony Khan" Stone, Blackheart would repeatedly and comically run over Stone, and then in her subsequent feud with Candice LeRae, LeRae destroyed Blackheart's beloved tank, who responded with more emotion than Big Show when Big Boss Man stole his dead dad.

Shotzi would get a new tank for TakeOver: WarGames, almost building it up to be the fifth member of her War Games team, the added "charm" this time is that it can shoot "rockets", scaring the kiwi out of Dakota Kai and more recently, turning Austin Theory into a Ken doll.


9. Enzo Amore Produces 3 Storylines About Hair

Enzo Amore NXT
WWE

In mid-2013, Enzo Amore and Colin Cassady formed what would become one of the most entertaining and over tag teams in NXT's history. An early conflict for the brash Jersey Shore-inspired tandem was the tag team of Frenchmen Marcus Louis and Sylvester Lefort, who at one point attacked Enzo and Cassidy and shaved the beard of Enzo.

This resulted in a hair vs. hair match at NXT TakeOver: Fatal 4-Way between Amore and Lefort, which the former won. Before Lefort could get a fresh trim, the Nice-born superstar bailed, leaving partner Louis to get knocked silly, his head shaved, and his eyebrows Nair'd.

It all felt very sports entertainment, particularly in the aftermath when the already-heel Louis tried hiding his baldness á la Kurt Angle circa 2002, before turning an even heeler shade of heel by turning on partner Lefort.

Meanwhile, Enzo and Cassidy are met by a lady called Carmella, a former hairdresser and someone they had got fired due to their hijinks a couple of weeks prior at her salon and was now demanding they bring her to NXT.

A hair vs. hair match, a hairdresser-turned professional wrestler, and an angry, eyebrow-less bald man, all dominoed from one storyline.


8. Solomon Crowe Is A Hackerman

Solomon Crowe
WWE

WWE have a weird history with trying to reinvent previously hardcore/deathmatch-proficient superstars into the damnedest characters. CZW Hall of Famer Drake Younger became docile NXT ref Drake Wuertz, Jon Moxley infamously became Dean Ambrose, and former ECW Champion Taz came in to reconcile his feelings with the announcer's table to name but a few.

Another experiment was Sami Callihan, a veteran of the indies, making appearances for HWA, Evolve, ROH, and CZW, where he was a multi-time champion and won the 2012 Best of the Best XI tournament.

Callihan made his TV debut with NXT in February 2015 under the name Solomon Crowe, a hacker who controlled arena electronics using a tablet. A kind of hokey character with an "interesting" look, fans still had high hopes for Crowe but NXT proved to not the place for him to prosper, going on to have a lengthy losing streak with no long-term goals in sight, leading to Callihan asking for his release in the November - less than a year after his TV debut.

An indie star with all the promise in the world, let down by a failed gimmick and lacklustre booking. Doesn't that sound familiar, T-Bar?


7. Roderick Strong's Awkward Heel Turn

Roderick Strong
WWE.com

When Roddy Strong came to NXT in 2016, he pushed hard as a working class, underdog babyface who vied for the NXT Championship, complete with a multi-part video package that highlighted his new family and his struggles to make it in the industry.

After failing to win the strap, Strong started getting advances from The Undisputed Era, a collection of his old pals from his indie days. Initially Strong rejected their propositions, to the point where he teamed with the Authors of Pain in a WarGames match against UE at TakeOver: WarGames.

The feud would reignite six months later at TakeOver: New Orleans where Strong would team with Pete Dunne to face UE and AOP in the finals of the 2018 Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic in a triple threat tag team match. It was in this match, after months of torment from Undisputed Era, over a year of being the plucky, underdog babyface, and teaming with Dunne for the duration of the tournament as a last-minute entry where Strong would turn heel and align himself with UE, to the surprise of everyone, including Kyle O'Reilly and Adam Cole who seemingly had no clue the allegiance was coming.

A failed babyface push, flat character progression, and a poorly-timed/achieved heel turn, it's the WWE hattrick.


6. Finn Bálor: Chainsaw Ripper Demon Man

Finn Balor TakeOver London
WWE

Finn Bálor likes to bring out the 'Demon' side of him for many of his big matches, with it making appearances against the likes of Neville, Kevin Owens, Tyler Breeze and Samoa Joe, whom he faced at NXT TakeOver: London, following Joe's betrayal of his Dusty Classic partner in December 2015.

Rooted in his pre-WWE days, the 'Demon' body paint signifies Bálor tapping into deep reserves of energy and aggression, with designs seemingly adapted from his Venom-based design that he began using at an ICW show in 2014.

However, in a very WWE act, the 'Demon' really went in on his look for London. Basing his design on London's own "demon" Jack the Ripper, Bálor headed to the ring with a cloak, top hat, and... a chainsaw.

WWE have a bad habit of going über-patriotic any time they exit the States, brandishing flags of their hosting country everywhere they can fit them, just in case people forget where they are. Although a special night for The Prince, the stacking of the 'Demon' and Jack the Ripper and a wacky chainsaw felt a bit 'too many cooks'-y.

Imagine how over-bearing Bray Wyatt would be if he turned up at SummerSlam 2019 as the 'Fiend' character, sporting a Toronto Maple Leafs jersey.


5. Andrade Is A Luchador Hipster Waiter

andrade cien almas
WWE Network

Back in late 2015, WWE announced the signing of CMLL star La Sombra, a revered luchador and multi-time champion, who would report to the Performance Centre in preparation for his debut in NXT.

There were early and high levels of excitement for the star. Not only was he a third-generation athlete, but NXT was on a pretty good run of bringing in talent, with Asuka, Apollo Crews, Kevin Owens, Rich Swann and Finn Bálor all making their NXT debuts within the previous 12 months.

Unfortunately, early appearances of the soon-to-be Andrade weren't quite of the expected standard in NXT. Opting to forego his traditional mask, NXT had essentially a blank canvas of a superstar to create, and what they made was a feather-hat, braces-wearing kinda generic babyface with not much of a direction. Eeking a short but still mildly exciting match against Tye Dillinger, Andrade would turn debutant fodder for Bobby Roode just two months later, before meandering aimlessly throughout the bottom of the card with Cedric Alexander, No Way Jose and Cezar Bononi.

It wasn't until the introduction of Zelina Vega, who could act as his mouthpiece whilst he developed his English skills, where Andrade would start turning into the unfathomably good talent we have now.


4. Paul Ellering Goes Full WCW At TakeOver: Toronto

Paul Ellering The Authors Of Pain
WWE.com

In 2016, NXT ran the second iteration of the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic, following a warmly-received first venture won by Finn Bálor and Samoa Joe. The final of the 2016 tournament came down to two relative newcomer teams: The Authors of Pain (Akam and Rezar) and TM-61 (Nick Miller and Shane Thorne).

A strange stipulation added to the 2016 final was that AOP's manager, Paul Ellering, was to be suspended above the ring in a cage. This was put into place by NXT General Manager William Regal to prevent Ellering from interfering in the match, something he had done throughout the rest of the tournament.

You can probably guess how well that went.

Towards the end of what was already a fairly ho-hum match, Ellering - still chilling out like an electoon from Rayman above the ring - dropped down a chain to Rezar who promptly wrapped it around his fist and swung for Shane Thorne. Though he missed (with the chain flying into the front row), AOP still retook the advantage and defeated TM-61 to win the tournament.

Whilst Ellering's presence was much more subdued than usual, it's kinda hard to imagine the match going any differently, were he back in his usual spot ringside.


3. Leon Ruff Is Small LOL

Leon Ruff
WWE.com

Leon Ruff is not very big. Did you know that?

Standing 5'7ft and weighing 157lb, Ruff is pretty slight, even in comparison to the 205 Live roster. Most people do not care though, with modern wrestling fans being more accustomed to seeing professional wrestlers coming in all shapes and sizes, using their particular builds to alter the course of their matches.

Someone at NXT did not get the memo.

Ruff was brought in under the guise of Johnny Gargano's North American Championship roulette open challenge, with Gargano rigging the wheel to avoid contentious competitors such as Kushida, Bronson Reid and Damien Priest among others. Ruff though would actually upset Gargano and pick up the win and the NA Championship following a crucifix driver.

In the post-match, the previously-ringside Priest would celebrate with Ruff and go to put the title around his waist. As he did this, the championship slipped down to his ankles because Ruff is small guys, do you get it? It has since been reported by the Wrestling Observer that Ruff winning the strap was down to "somebody in creative thought it was funny".

Ruff being made the punchline because of his size is no different to Otis' entire SmackDown run.


2. Charlotte Flair's Toxic Second NXT Run

Charlotte Flair NXT Champion
WWE.com

When Vince McMahon got his grubby mitts on NXT following the launch of AEW Dynamite of Wednesday nights, part of his mid-week dabblings came in the form using Charlotte's Royal Rumble victory (which in itself proved contentious) to challenge for Rhea Ripley's NXT Women's Championship.

Isolated, that sounds like a really good idea. Charlotte returns to her old stomping ground, big for her britches, while Ripley explains that this is a different NXT to the one she left years ago. Meanwhile Bianca Belair is getting in the face of both women, also wanting to challenge for the title whilst also defending NXT. The blow-off everyone was expecting was for Rhea to go over Charlotte at WrestleMania, sending her to the moon, whilst Charlotte had a few modern-day dream matches along the way.

In actuality, that didn't quite happen. Charlotte, who already was popping up on damn-near every RAW and SmackDown, had a total of six matches under the NXT banner, including winning the NXT Women's Title at Mania. In the other matches, Charlotte always walked away looking strongest, picking up wins against Belair, Ripley (again), Mia Yim, Io Shirai, only losing via disqualification, and not even getting pinned in the triple threat where she would eventually lose the title at TakeOver: In Your House.


1. Compromising Storytelling For Ratings

WWE AEW
WWE/AEW

Ever since inheriting his father's company in 1982, Vince McMahon's modus operandi has always seemed to be to become the sole source of professional wrestling.

After running pretty much unopposed since 2001, WWE finally had weekly competition again from late 2019, moving NXT from the Network to USA in order to compete with AEW Dynamite.

Up until this point, NXT's biggest pull was just how much it wasn't like the 'main roster'. Characters could have nuance, matches were allowed to breathe, there seemed to be fewer punishments for mistakes, and stories progressed fluidly and - for the most part - made sense. The Triple H-helmed brand was a safe haven from Saudi shambles and Wildcard nonsense, but when NXT began getting direct competition, Vince couldn't stay away and got more involved with the week-to-week runnings of Wednesday night content.

Booking for a good show with storytelling got dropped in favour of ratings pops (e.g. Keith Lee's double title win), the poorly-booked injection of Charlotte Flair, a lacklustre tag team division, and over-shadowing a women's division match with bodily fluids (Robert Stone vomiting during Xia Li vs. Aaliyah - during a pandemic no less). NXT was a shadow of its former self in 2020, while AEW prospered.


Watch Next


In this post: 
WWE NXT
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Wish.com Jules Gill. Pretty fond of heavy music, Arsenal, video games and wrestling.