10 Times TNA Went Way Too Far

Who writes this stuff, and how can we get them to stop?

For the most part, the story of professional wrestling in the United States in the last twenty years is the story of the abandonment of almost every single scintilla of traditional pro wrestling storytelling logic in favour of empty spectacle, ridiculous gimmicks, controversial antics, and €˜crash TV€™ theatrics. When it worked, it saw the formation of the NWO and rang in the Attitude Era; witnessed the second summer of Punk and the formation of the €˜YES€™ movement. When it didn€™t€ well, there was pretty much everything else, the stuff that€™s made WCW, the WWF/E and more recently TNA a laughing stock amongst wrestling fans. Wrestling legend Larry Zybysko once said of TNA president Dixie Carter that she €œknows nothing about the wrestling psychology part and at the same time she doesn€™t know who to trust. She doesn€™t know if Jeff Jarrett knows what he€™s doing, she doesn€™t know if Russo knows what he€™s doing, she doesn€™t know if Dusty knows what he€™s doing. So these people are just kind of taking guesses and whoever gives them the best line of bullsh*t gets a chance at running the thing for a while.€ That€™s an hilarious way to run a company€ but, just as the hapless bookers behind WCW and WWE have discovered over the years, there€™s a price to pay for employing self-promoting chancers like Eric Bischoff or Vince Russo to constantly chase the edgiest, most engaging stories without any clear idea of what on earth you€™re doing. In only thirteen years of operation, TNA have committed more crimes against television than companies with three times that kind of history. Crimes likes these€


10. Abyss Straight Up Murders Rob Van Dam

While the odd foreign object has long been a staple of the wrestling finish, they€™re supposed to be used sparingly and creatively. That, at least, is the old school approach, that values the psychology of setting aside blood and mayhem for when it will make the most impact. We€™ll call that viewpoint the €˜Cornette€™, versus the €˜Zandig€™: the belief that a minute that goes by without hardway blood or a weapons shot is a minute wasted. TNA mainstay Abyss, a kind of ersatz Mankind/Kane hybrid, has his own ridiculously dangerous personalised weapon to match Mick Foley€™s €˜Barbie€™ €“ in this case, a massive board covered in nails called Janice. He also wielded his own branding iron, which he€™d nicknamed Bob. TNA€™s incessant plagiarism aside for the moment, €˜Janice€™ was clearly a ridiculous idea. What audience could buy the idea that a horrifying weapon like that would be used in a wrestling ring? Barbed wire and thumbtacks are one thing, but Janice could break a boy€™s heart. On August 12th 2010, that€™s pretty much what happened: after a brawl to close that special episode of Impact Wrestling, Abyss would drag professional Tigger impersonator Rob Van Dam backstage with him€ and when the camera cut to them moments later, Van Dam was lying prone with the monster heel standing over him cradling Janice in his meaty paws. With more than a little fake claret liberally splashed all over him, Van Dam looked like he€™d lost an argument with a lawnmower.

An obvious excuse to remove Van Dam from TNA programming for a little while, the angle was still fairly grotesque€ the implication that Abyss had finally snapped and actually maimed someone with a weapon torn from the closing minutes of a slasher flick was all kinds of wrong. Shouldn€™t he be, you know€ arrested? Shouldn€™t Janice and her hulking boytoy be on trial for attempted murder? Incidentally, €˜Bob€™ and €˜Janice€™ are the names of Dixie Carter's parents, who run Panda Energy International and are the real owners of TNA, which takes €˜all kinds of wrong€™ and adds a healthy side order of €˜completely inappropriate€™, to go.


9. Fun With Dick And Rod

In the first weeks of TNA€™s operation, the NWA-affiliated promotion was just finding its feet, and about to begin operating under the weekly pay-per-view model of business. Perhaps that€™s why Mike and Todd Shane, two independent wrestlers that happened to be the NWA tag team champions when TNA promoted its first ever event, were massive penises in their debut for the company. No, that€™s not a metaphor or a description of some bad attitude backstage. Renamed Richard and Roderick Johnson (€˜Dick€™ and €˜Rod€™), the poor fellas were dressed in weirdly bulging pink latex to make them look like anthropomorphic male genitalia. Did we mention that these were the NWA tag team champions? The poor Shane boys probably believed that appearing on even pay-per-view television would lead to national exposure, but this can€™t have been what they had in mind. No one knows what Jeff and Jerry Jarrett had in mind. No one€™s entirely sure how they managed to get a second pay-per-view set up after this. The twins left TNA about a week after their debut against lucha libre legend Psicosis and a young, rubbish James Storm, and left the tag team titles behind too €“ TNA had exclusive rights to the NWA championship array. The Shane boys would later find a few months€™ work in the WWE as the Gymini, tag team enforcers for Simon €˜Nova€™ Dean€™s midcard fitness guru gimmick. Terrible gimmick, but at least they weren€™t made to look like a pair of pr*cks.


8. The Worst Gimmick Matches In The World

Terrible, terrible gimmicked matches aren€™t endemic to TNA, but they€™re the reigning, defending champions of badly thought out, dull gimmick matches. Feast Or Fired and its women€™s equivalent of the Locked Box Challenge are just overbooked versions of Money In The Bank. Feast Or Fired gives four men winning briefcases, but one of them contains a pink slip and results in the €˜winner€™ being fired. Why a promotion would book a match where one of its supposedly valued performers would be sacked for winning is beyond anyone. The one-off Locked Box Challenge was actually worse: adding a weird elimination aspect to the action, one of the boxes contained the Knockouts title itself, while another contained a title shot, a third contained Knockouts champion Tara€™s pet spider Poison, which had been stolen from her€ and the fourth had a contractual obligation to strip in the middle of the ring. Tara opened the box and got her spider back, but suddenly realised that this meant that, despite winning the match, she€™d lost her title without being pinned. Meanwhile the idea that a legally binding contract would be used to force a female talent €“ who€™d just won a match - to take her clothes off on television is just creepy as all hell€ and why would anyone else get excited about winning someone else€™s tarantula? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mi9KP6aQmW4 The Reverse Battle Royal, where wrestlers wage pointless war on one another to get into the ring, is actually stupider than it sounds. Cuffed In The Cage involved several tag teams competing in a steel cage elimination match where the losing team is cuffed to the inside of the cage. The S&M (Sadistic Madness) affair from way back when proves that it€™s not just modern TNA that sucks this badly €“ it€™s a four-on-four where no pinfall or submission will count until all eight men are bleeding. And then there€™s the daddy of them all: the King Of The Mountain match. Five men compete for the world title, and a pinfall or submission makes the pinning man eligible to win, while the pinned man gets to spend two minutes in a time out cage until he can rejoin the action (whereby you get to fight or collude with any other pinned man who might also be languishing in there). Once you€™re eligible to win, you run to a roving referee and grab the belt from them, using the ladders to try and hang the belt above the ring. When the belt is in play, any eligible wrestler may try to hang it. If you drop the belt, and no one else eligible immediately grabs it, the belt is returned to the roving referee and you carry on. If that actually makes sense to you, then you probably need a blood test to confirm whether you€™re actually a Jarrett.


7. The Chair Shot Heard Around The World

In 2010, giant Welsh fishcake Rob Terry was being groomed for epic things, and being booked as an unstoppable force was the next step in that process. To get him over properly as such, Terry was booked to take a massive, completely unprotected chair shot to the head, causing significant hardway bleeding. So far, so brutal €“ but not unknown in pro wrestling €“ except that this was shortly after the WWE had banned unprotected shots to the head over fears that repeated concussions were far more detrimental to the health of wrestlers than previously considered. It was also aired two days after Chris Kanyon committed suicide, and all the talk at the time was that Kanyon had been suffering the ill-effects of a half-dozen untreated concussions throughout his career, which may have led to his taking his own life.

The guys at the Wrestling Observer Newsletter podcast called for the agent in charge to be fired, and wrestling veteran Lance Storm threw up his hands in disgust and quit watching TNA, writing an editorial on the subject on his website. Others called for a boycott until TNA apologised. As brutal as the chair shot was, the callous indifference to timing and context was worse.


6. From Injury To Insult

Veteran wrestler Chris Candido jerked the curtain in a tag match in the very first annual Lockdown pay-per-view, in which all the matches were contested in a steel cage. Quite why the powers-that-be at TNA thought this was a good idea, heaven only knows €“ it originally stemmed from a sarcastic remark made by Dusty Rhodes during a booking meeting, suggesting to a gimmick-happy Dixie Carter that perhaps then every match on the card should be a cage match. It seems Carter had no idea that a), the Dream was joking or that b), it was a terrible, heat-sapping idea that would kill the main event of her show. Candido€™s match, with Lance Hoyt against Apolo and Sonny Siaki, Candido landed poorly after a dropkick from Siaki, and broke his leg in two places, dislocating his ankle. After surgery a few days later, he developed a blood clot and passed away. He was only thirty-three years old. TNA would honour Candido via a memorial on the episode of Impact, as well as a salute and tribute on the next pay-per-view, Hard Justice. More than that, they initiated the first ever annual Chris Candido Memorial Tag Team Tournament, where a rookie would be paired with a veteran in brand new teams to determine the final participants in the Four Way Elimination tag match at Unbreakable the following month. The trouble was, it was a cynical cash-in. TNA had already point blank refused to pay Candido€™s partner Tammy Sytch (aka WWE€™s Sunny) one red cent in respect of the money owed to his estate. Even though the pair were childhood sweethearts who€™d been together for half their lives, the fact that they weren€™t married gave the company a loophole to avoid shelling out. Eventually, they sent her a ham as a consolation gift. The Candido Cup didn€™t make it to become an annual event: once the publicity from Candido€™s tragic death dried up, there was no reason for TNA to continue to trade on his name, reputation and fanbase.


5. Whistling Dixie

The first rule of narrative is maintaining the suspension of disbelief. That€™s true for movies, novels, the little white lies you tell your parents, and especially for professional wrestling, which relies on the widespread acceptance of some pretty dumbass things in order to be appreciated as an artform. So when TNA insist on abusing what little remains of kayfabe like a drunken stepfather, it€™s not surprising that wrestling fans choose to comprehensively crap on the promotion. Two key examples immediately spring to mind: during the Genesis pay-per-view in 2010, the powers that be became so irritated with the live crowd€™s loud and insistent burial of the rubbish they were being confronted with that they sent their senior director of production, Steve Small, out to the ring to address the fans in attendance. In a weird, rambling lecture, Small made it clear that TNA expected its fans to collude and cooperate with the nonsense they were watching, calling everyone in attendance €˜cast members€™ and informing them that they had a duty to help TNA get the stories they were telling over with the audience at home by acting as though they understood and accepted said nonsense and were into it. Predictably, because wrestling fans are the dictionary definition of €˜butthurt€™, the TNA audience decided that Steve Small was a douchecanoe and that TNA was even further gone down the plughole than they realised. Many chose that moment to simply stop being fans of the promotion and the product€ they never went to a live event again, and never watched the show again. The previous year, company president Dixie Carter pulled the roster together for a managerial talk in which she informed them that if any of them disagreed with the direction that she was taking the company in (the hiring of Hulk Hogan and other WCW flotsam and jetsam to turn TNA€™s fortunes around), they should leave: it was her way, or the highway. Not the greatest of teambuilding exercises, but there you go€ the trouble was that the meeting was professionally filmed, edited and then broadcast to the public before an episode of Impact. Despite this being a legitimate message to her employees, and not a work in the slightest, she put it on telly for the fans to see. It was widely mocked and criticised by everyone who saw it.


4. New Beard, New Danger

In the most blatant storyline appropriation since WCW attempted to resurrect the Montreal Screwjob at Starrcade 1997, TNA took perennial comedy act Eric Young and transformed him into a heroic, gutsy and heavily bearded underdog€ right around the time that Daniel Bryan finally scored the big win at Wrestlemania XXX. Young, a fine performer in every sense of the word but never main event material before now, captured the TNA world title out of nowhere, days after Bryan€™s Yes Movement finally propelled him to the WWE world heavyweight championship. His fanbase were thrilled that he was finally being taken seriously€ every other wrestling fan in the world snorted incredulously and threw heavy things at their TV. A ridiculously obvious attempt to cash-in on the Daniel Bryan story and buzz, it made no sense whatsoever, especially given that there were no storylines that had led up to it: Young became number one contender after winning a battle royal on Impact Wrestling, and won the title in the main event that same night. TNA already had a reputation for being content to push ex-WWE talent and to steal WWE ideas €“ this was just stupid.


3. The Voodoo Kin Mafia

In a similar vein, after Shawn Michaels and Triple H reformed a comedy version of D-Generation X in WWE, ex-New Age Outlaws The James Gang (B.G. James, previously the Road Dogg and Kip James, aka Billy Gunn) changed their names to the Voodoo Kin Mafia (the same initials as Vincent Kennedy McMahon) and began working an ersatz D-Generation X gimmick, running skits mocking D-X and the WWE in general. The skits were almost entirely terrible, cringeworthy and desperately crying out for attention from any of the far more popular and famous wrestlers they were taking the mickey out of. At one point, VKM challenged D-X to a match for a million bucks€ unsurprisingly, the WWE team didn€™t acknowledge the challenge, let alone turn up. Embarrassingly however, the James boys didn€™t show up either. It€™s almost as if this was a crappy angle that existed purely to keep the pair of them on television. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hiI1qmFlSSQ Even more embarrassingly, Dixie Carter took the whole thing completely seriously and set the million dollars aside in case WWE took them up on the offer. Good grief, Dixie. Even Jim Herd wouldn€™t have been that much of a numpty.


2. Claire Lynch And Crack Baby Styles

Astonishingly, in 2012 TNA attempted their own version of the infamous World WWE Storyline Of All Time: the Katie Vick fiasco from 2002, a laughing stock in pro wrestling circles for the past TEN YEARS. TNA hired an actress to play the part of Claire Lynch, a junkie ex of babyface AJ Styles, who claimed to be carrying his baby. Styles, a deeply religious and happily married family man in real life, and never the world€™s most expressive or articulate wrestler, stumbled his way through the stodgy, barely digestible lines given to him like a blind man being asked to play hopscotch. Worse, as Styles claimed no recollection of Lynch, she provided photos of herself posing near his sleeping body, indicating that any sex that had taken place had been while he was passed out under the influence. The angle led to a series of matches with the scandal€™s instigator, Christopher Daniels€ weirdly, the culmination of the feud saw Styles challenge Daniels with a stipulation regarding the paternity of the unborn child. If Styles won, he€™d get a DNA test to determine whether he was the father once and for all€ if Daniels won, Styles would just admit to it. This, of course, made absolutely no sense. The storyline fizzled out when the actress playing Lynch, having received real life threats and abuse over the angle, refused to come back to record any more promos. Scuttlebutt (like gossip with an illegitimate bun in the oven) says that the idea was all Eric Bischoff€™s€ and that he received a raise for coming up with it, because TNA officials have sawdust and sorrow where their brains should be.


1. James Storm €˜Kills€™ Mickie James

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_r8fKdwyuKA Earlier this year on TNA€™s Impact Wrestling, James Storm €“ who€™d been working under a sinister cult leader gimmick €“ attempted to co-opt TNA veteran Mickie James into his weird-ass faction The Revolution. He€™d already brainwashed Sanada and Manik, and Abyss and others would follow: luring James to Nashville under false pretences, he tried and failed to talk her around. Following this, he took her to the train station for her journey home, and after distracting her, shoved her onto the tracks, crouching down to gloat about how far down it was. The implication was that he€™d attempted to murder her€ the scene was a clear pull from an almost identical moment in the premiere episode of season two of the acclaimed House Of Cards TV series, shown on Netflix the previous year. As you can see from the clip above, video of the incident shown on television was later posted to YouTube, under a wryly mocking title, with nothing to clarify matters in the video€™s description. Part of the problem was that the scene didn't play out backstage or in the ring, but in public on supposedly CCTV footage. The uproar was so huge that police actually visited Storm's home to query what had actually occurred. You just don't show a guy throwing a female friend in front of a train and pretend that it's a real life event. To give you a little context, the same incident occurred a few days earlier in New York, but for real. This news report was posted to YouTube the same day as TNA's own clip. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QKjmzxxODdE A day, and some significant social media hoohaa later, TNA finally clarified that James wasn€™t actually supposed to be dead in the storyline... she€™d just hit her head, been tested for a concussion and found to be healthy but €˜emotionally disturbed€™. She€™d return to TNA a few weeks later, confront Storm on TV and€ challenge him to an intergender tag match with Storm and Revolution cohort Serena: because attempted murder is best answered by pinning the responsible party€™s friend. Of course, the idea originally had been that the incident would write Mickie James off TNA programming €“ she€™d finished out her dates with the promotion. TNA had no intention of having Storm have his comeuppance or of backtracking until the entire internet collectively gave them a slapping over trivialising violence to women. What€™s the moment in TNA that you think was taking things just too far? There are plenty to choose from €“ let us know in the comments€


Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.