10 Times Triple H Won WWE Matches He Should Have Lost

Nobody played The Game as well as Triple H, but this list only goes to 10. Who did we miss?!

Triple H
WWE.com

Booker T.

The answer is Booker T. At WrestleMania XIX. You know the one.

No, the title of the article didn't pose the question in the first place, but the answer's still Booker T.

It gets spoken about a lot, if only because it's perhaps the best shorthand example of a tenure that chased away legions of fans that had dared to stick around after the turn-of-the-century boom. It didn't seem possible that, by 2003, WWE could do the things they chose to do in the run-up to and execution of a major WrestleMania match, and yet they did. All of them.

That World Heavyweight Championship feud was amongst the ugliest in company history, but could have reclaimed a minuscule shred of kudos had Triple H laid down on 'The Grandest Stage'. "Racist dude is racist then is validated for his racist opinions in predetermined contest" was a ridiculous Reign Of Terror pitch too far during the worst excesses of his most insecure years, but it happened and must never be forgotten.

There, Triple H won a match he absolutely should have lost. And he did a lot of that...

10. Vs Sting (WrestleMania 31)

Triple H, Sting, WrestleMania 31
WWE.com

Legendary brother brother bullsh*t this, if it wasn't such a self-own.

For those that still watched WWE week-to-week during the build up to WrestleMania 31's Sting/Triple H showdown, this made absolutely no sense whatsoever. Not that 'The Game' would have cared once the whole thing was over. He got his win and his pay-per-view time after all.

How did any of this bullsh*t make air?

For months, Hunter was a vindictive villain in need of a beating. Until showtime, when he became virtuous bastion of WWE fighting one last Monday Night War against the only WCW holdout. An absurd sales pitch on television, it was one that wasn't picked up on by the live crowd until run-ins from D-Generation X and the New World Order highlighted what this thing actually was (a nostalgic p*ss about) rather than what it wasn't (the expected payoff to a serious feud with actual ramifications).

It was Triple H's night in every sense - the match went 18:36, (not including outlandish entrances and exits), then he was back out there for a lengthy angle with The Rock and Ronda Rousey.


9. Vs Rob Van Dam (Unforgiven 2002)

Rob Van Dam Triple H Unforgiven 2002
WWE.com

There's a misconception about Triple H's mid-200s reign of terror that he should have put absolutely everybody he faced over.

This isn't the case - champions don't stay hot by losing all the time - but 'The Game' was so infuriatingly strategic in the hows, whens and to-whos that the prevailing feeling that he never lost simply wouldn't subside.

Such was the case when he wrestled Rob Van Dam at Unforgiven 2002.

As per numerous reports at the time, the summer's prepping of 'Mr Monday Night' had very much been just that. Van Dam was being readied for a top spot by consolidating all the midcard titles into a single secondary strap that could eventually serve as Raw's top prize. All until the plans change, pal and Triple H was simply awarded a brand new World Heavyweight Championship instead.

With that established, the rationale became about doing the same for the inaugural champion. RVD was flattened, Hunter kept his spot, and Raw trudged further into - rather than away from - some overfamiliar sludge.


8. Vs Jeff Hardy (Various Pay-Per-Views, 2008)

Triple H Jeff Hardy
WWE.com

If one were cynical enough to throw these types of stones, one might suggest Triple H knew exactly how massive Jeff Hardy already was before it came time to do a f*cking job for him once in a while.

Hunter retained the WWE Championship in the last seconds of an Unforgiven Scramble Match, robbing poor Jeff in the process. He pinned him clean at No Mercy and Cyber Sunday immediately following that. And he transitioned the title to a returning Edge when called to drop it at the following month's Survivor Series.

And he was just as bad when he was called to lose.

At Armageddon 2007, 'The Game' reacted with barely more than a shrug when Hardy reversed his Pedigree into a jackknife cover for the win. This flippancy towards bonafide wrestling holds would become an infuriating norm in years to come, but it was even sillier coming from a character that had once orchestrated a year-long hit-and-run plot just to make sure he secured that very same strap.

One year later, he was back in the mix with the 'Charismatic Enigma', and yet again failed to be the one to honest-to-god actually make him. Having surrendered the strap to Edge in November, he had the 'Rated-R Superstar' beat before Hardy flew in from nowhere with a Swanton Bomb to pin the Canadian himself.

The moment was still magic - Jeff Hardy's popularity is legitimately life-affirming - but Hunter had almost nothing to do with the spell being cast.


7. Vs Shawn Michaels (Armageddon 2002)

Shawn Michaels Triple H Armageddon 2002 Steel Cage
WWE.com

Outside of their genuinely gripping and evocative SummerSlam 2002 show-stealer, Triple H and Shawn Michaels' matches over the years had the distinct and musty air of two nearly-men being given far too much time to enjoy the smell of their own farts.

The pair never met a clock they didn't want to defy, but so rarely told stories worthy of the lengthy journey you'd be strapped into the back seat for. Such was the case at 2002's Armageddon, where a Three Stages Of Hell encounter restored order on Monday Night Raw after Michaels' 28-day stint with the strap.

Unlike others on this list, there were no petty politics at play. 'HBK's Survivor Series title win was a moment for the moment's sake inside Madison Square Garden. In 2002, he was back for a good time rather than a long one. Shame, then, that this match was the latter rather than the former.

Bloated and boring, the one saving grace would have come from Michaels putting somebody else over in losing the title. Instead, he did the honours for the guy who needed it the least.


6. Vs The Hurricane (WWE Raw, March 31st 2003)

Hurricane Triple H
WWE.com

In which the self-styled "diamond" of the industry dulls the sparkle of a wrestler shined up real nice by an actual star.

Though far from a finished product or made man in 2003, The Hurricane's spring fling with a heel-turned Rock had ensured he was far more than just comedic foil for the headliners to squash. All until a headliner squashed him, anyway.

The caped cruiserweight had pinned 'The Great One' and looked his intellectual superior in p*ss funny backstage vignettes on the road to WrestleMania, but with 'Show Of Shows' business taken care of, the World Heavyweight Champion took the first opportunity to start putting everybody back in their places.

It was as if 'The Game' had waited until the coast was clear, too. 24 hours before this bout, The Rock had theoretically concluded his WWE business before returning to Hollywood with a victory over Stone Cold Steve Austin. Goldberg's arrival kept him around for one more month, but the heel honeymoon was just about over.

As was Hurricane, until he ate the canvas in frustratingly straightforward fashion here.


5. Vs Eugene (SummerSlam 2004)

Triple H Eugene
WWE Network

WWE is cruel.

It always has been, it always will be, and if it doesn't particularly scan as such, then maybe the promotion is doing a better job of reflecting society than it even realises.

In 2004, a man that called himself a "Cerebral Assassin" hatched a plan as stupidly convoluted as the character it sought to mock. Yes, Triple H using and abusing Eugene was the behaviour of a heel, but look beyond the fiction and the facts speak for themselves. The act was over - maybe main event over - when 'The Game' latched on.

Much to the confusion of his jock-adjacent Evolution buddies, Triple H endorsed the superfan whims of Eric Bischoff's nephew, undiagnosed-but-broad learning difficulty and all. This was, in kayfabe, because he was part of a supposed master plan. A scheme requiring a guy you've acknowledged is a little slow on the uptake to follow instructions. wHaT cOuLd PoSsIbLy Go WrOnGuhhhh?! The company were having their cake and farting on it too, and when things inevityl went awry Triple H pounded him into mush, crushing the character the audience's hopes and dreams for it.

An off-camera power play masquerading as a pretend one on screen? Must be Monday!


4. Vs Dean Ambrose (Roadblock 2016)

dean ambrose triple h
WWE.com

There was, in defence of Triple H, a plan in place.

'The Game' had won the WWE Championship one last time at the 2016 Royal Rumble for one expressed purpose - losing it to Roman Reigns at WrestleMania 32. To write off this win as entirely justified as result of that would be going far too easy on the 'Cerebral Assassin' though.

He's been the beneficiary of the dreaded changing plans more than once in his illustrious career, and the very end of January's traditional Battle Royal should have clued WWE in on where to go for the 'Show Of Shows' instead. There, Dean Ambrose was such an overwhelming favourite with the crowd that he became an easy choice for an opponent on this filler pay-per-view. Unfortunately, the company weren't prepared to commit beyond it.

How close they came is revealed in the body of the match - Ambrose gets a near-clean three that's scrubbed due to his foot being under the ropes. It's somehow both cheap and clean, but he stood no chance after that.

Hunter retaining ensured the planned Reigns headliner went ahead. In that same match, bored Dallas fans chanted for Shinsuke Nakamura, NXT and, briefly, (and tellingly), Dean Ambrose.


3. Vs Randy Orton (Unforgiven 2004)

triple h randy orton
WWE.com

This entry could theoretically absolutely extend to New Year's Revolution and Royal Rumble 2005, but Orton felt so beaten like a drum by then that the defeats scarcely mattered - Batista had effortlessly become The Guy in his place by then anyway.

History might report this as the failing of Orton himself, but he was only ever going to be as good as the man that was tasked with getting him over. WWE had worked around attitude problems bigger than Randy's before, but 'The Game' was neither the wrestler nor the leader to keep this particular train on the track.

As was often the case with Triple H matches around this time, it wasn't just the results but the nature of them. The contests were boring as sin, which wouldn't have been ideal had Hunter not been terminating a meagre 28-day maiden reign for a supposed 'Legend Killer'.

Not content with failing to help him ascend to the top level, he eventually got around to getting in the way of keeping him there too...


2. Vs Randy Orton (No Mercy 2007)

No Mercy 2007
WWE

Vanity, vanity, vanity, the whole flippin' way.

Some rare organic chaos was permitted to reign in October 2007 after John Cena got injured just days before a scheduled WWE Championship match with Randy Orton. WWE only had the pay-per-view left to resolve the situation, which was a cooler hook than the original match itself.

Enter Triple H.

The show started with Vince McMahon awarding planned number one contender Orton with the gold, before the cool, funny, tough and handsome Hunter convinced them all to put the belt on the line there and then. And he only went and won it! What a useless tosser that 'Viper' is eh?! 'The King Of Kings' was scheduled to fight Umaga that night, and kept his booking with a hard-fought win before eventually putting Orton over in an impromptu main event that drew on how absolutely knackered he was. It was Last Man Standing to protect him taking a fall, too.

A*seholes like your writer might suggest that it wasn't a complete coincidence that Kurt Angle had worked three diverse and different matches on a TNA pay-per-view just weeks earlier and 'The Game' fancied a little bit of that acclaim.


1. Vs CM Punk (Night Of Champions 2011)

CM Punk Triple H NOC
WWE.com

It's no wonder CM Punk's mental health was in tatters.

His return to wrestling in 2021 was the sort of the unique experience few other industries could ever realistically create. There aren't too many jobs that are so oblique that a near-identical version of the thing that's killing you is required to be the cure. But "near" is doing some heavy lifting there isn't it?

AEW, for all its unchecked faults, couldn't be further away from whatever WWE is in 2021. And it doesn't particularly resemble what the product was in 2011 either. There, Punk was fed to a machine he naively believed he could change, and it happened even quicker than most cynics could have projected.

Punk sat cross-legged in Las Vegas in June, and was rightfully WWE Champion by July. He'd lost it by August, before falling to Triple H in September. There's no obscuring such an obvious deconstruction of a hot character, not least considering the fact that Punk was forced to buddy up with 'The King Of Kings' within weeks of this damaging defeat.


In this post: 
Triple H
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.