10 Times Wrestlers Called Out Their Own BS

Chris Jericho thought little of Orange Cassidy...until his brilliance beat that take to a pulp.

HHH Paige
WWE

You tell on yourself when you clutch too dearly to a narrative.

If you can't let it go, despite almost definitive evidence to the contrary, you can all but be written off as a tedious bad faith actor. And some don't mind that. To them, it's all a grift designed to extract praise and money from a mutated fanbase. They will, after all, lap up anything. They are fanatical. But they risk diminishing their base and their profile, which again, fine - particularly if they've proven themselves unemployable elsewhere.

Wrestling Twitter is trapped in constant and exhausting battle in which figures are distorted, minimised, excused. In which language is parroted and mutated beyond its original meaning. It's a putrid experience, particularly since you can't reason with the unreasonable.

The very best thing you can do, to appear credible and not be a total ar*ehole, is to admit when you're wrong. It's a sign of maturity, of growth, even if it's a mere, shrewd PR move designed to add weight to that narrative. You can easily separate the bad faith actors from those willing to accept their flaws.

They just have to let sh*t go and own up...

10. Stephanie McMahon

Stephanie McMahon
WWE

Mercifully, Stephanie McMahon has all but vanished as an onscreen presence in 2020, surfacing only to b*llock people for adhering to the script as if that script didn't exist - as if they, not the writers that come up with this sh*t, were the smooth-brains.

"Pulling on a referee shirt? You think that gives you authority?" Steph asked Bayley. She phrased the question as if it was the dumbest thing a human being could possibly do. Your da came up with it, you dipsh*t!

What a tremendous way of getting stars over. Just textbook.

She has however made the media rounds, during which she exercised a quite stunning self-awareness. And by self-awareness, read "Obscures root of the issue and blames some Performance Center unknowns for failing to draw numbers in unadvertised matches with no stakes". Speaking to Forbes, McMahon laid the blame for WWE's awful spring and summer entirely on the shoulders of Brendan Vink:

"We tried bringing in our developmental talent to see if that would help in terms of some type of audience but it just wasn’t enough."

Stupid Denzel Dejournette. Doesn't know how to work.

A nonsensical and unconvincing burial, McMahon without expressly saying it did essentially admit that the Performance Center shows were grim and lifeless and revealed how little depth and craft there is to WWE without the smoke and mirrors.

This is as close as a McMahon will get.


9. The Young Bucks

Matt Jackson
Being The Elite

On the December 18, 2019 Dynamite, AEW ended the year in which the world was to change by booking a hokey supernatural-flavoured angle detrimental to its star acts.

Meet the new league. Same as the old league.

AEW recovered by the very next episode, which asked and answered and left dangling a very pressing question - Are the Elite still Elite? - in an astute and electrifying trios banger main event. Overstated in importance, yes, but also very bad: the Dark Order descended on the finish of the SCU Vs. Young Bucks main event and drew condom blood from Nick Jackson's throat. Kenny Omega arrived to save his friends, but was swiftly neutralised by some out-of-shape extras mocked up like gimps. Low-rent and counterproductive, it really didn't matter that the Dark Order made more sense in the narrative framework than virtually every critic credited the act for; the presentation was a level below utterly naff.

The Dark Order were the brainchild of the Young Bucks, who took the blame for the infamous angle - and took it well.

On the subsequent episode of Being The Elite, Matt attacked Christopher Daniels after a Christmas dinner gone awry, threw him to a sofa cushion, and intentionally missed a prolonged series of punches by about two feet.

He dwelled on every whiffed strike as if to convey that, yes, they'd f*cked it, but yes, they were going to fix it.


8. Vince Russo

Vince Russo
WWE.com

This took some doing, Jesus Christ.

Vince Russo doesn't just not own up to his multifarious, company-killing bullsh*t: he cites himself, not the actual stars, with the success of WWE's Attitude Era. He brought the ratings, bro which, incidentally, is an anagram of "boring star", which quite efficiently summarises how f*cked Russo was with Jeff Jarrett, and not Steve Austin, driving his disastrous WCW stint.

While you wouldn't expect Russo to call out his own bullsh*t - he thought so much of it that he was still swerve-turning, all the way up to 2015, by mapping a Wyatt Family explodes angle when he tried a new fantasy booking grift - he actually admits that the Kennel From Hell match sucked.

He defended Beaver Cleavage. "I wasn't given the freedom to see it through," he said on an old Truth With Consequences podcast.

Beaver Cleavage wasn't going to WrestleMania. He was principally interested in motting his mother out. This was never going to work because it was as bad an idea as making babyface Al Snow slowly climb two cages between which a pack of dogs sh*t themselves.

Least he owned up to that one.


7. Chris Jericho

Orange Cassidy Chris Jericho
AEW

Chris Jericho evolved into a superstar in the Land of the Giants and was so encased in the bubble that he once vowed never to work beyond it.

He wasn't quite Fedpilled - as an entrepreneur, he took several periods off to front Fozzy and dance with the stars - but such an epic stint in WWE was always going to condition him somewhat.

After venturing outside and cupping his ear to the buzz generated by the Elite, Jericho in 2018 was revitalised as a sadistic entertainment machine in New Japan Pro Wrestling. He was in bravura heel form, screaming "F*ckface!" at hapless reporters and unleashing a new brawling style brimming with chaotic energy. There was no going back - saying "F*ckface!" was so much more life-affirming than "Rooty Tooty Booty!" - and Jericho soon agreed to help launch the All Elite Wrestling venture.

There, he was aghast at three acts imported from an independent scene he couldn't reconcile. Marko Stunt insulted his sensibilities. He was too small even for a man once thought had a ceiling over his own head. He couldn't buy Chuck Taylor's...distinct physique. Orange Cassidy meanwhile threw off his wavelength entirely: the detached irony of his act didn't wash with Jericho, who came up in an era in which kayfabe was sacrosanct, at least internally.

Jericho in his own words "pulled his head out of his ass" and soon recognised Stunt's value as a sympathetic bumping machine, Taylor's ring generalship, and Cassidy's à la mode disposition.

Over is over, and there was money to be made.


6. Dave Meltzer

Dave Meltzer
FiteTV

In which the esteemed Wrestling Observer Newsletter editor says something nobody will ever credit him for saying: a tale as old and as excruciating as time.

He is not a wrestler, no, but it's like, here's the thing, it's like: 'Wrestlers & Wrestling Personalities' is bad SEO, and a bit, y'know, clunky. Also, UWF promoter Herb Abrams booked an enhancement talent to get his d*ck knocked in the dirt, and that man's name was 'Little Davey Meltzer'. So perhaps that counts?

Also, how marvellously petty. Vince McMahon isn't even the most spiteful wrestling promoter!

An endearing figure for his verbal idiosyncrasies and a legend of the wrestling media game, Uncle Dave can't say a damn thing without being accused of bias. A knowledgable chap, he uses data and numbers to support his arguments in a daily ritual of toxic discourse. It is exhausting. Give him a quarter, and he'll be playing an accordion and talking about the All Out pre-sales for hours.

There are as many retractions as asterisks in a typical edition of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, but people will not accept that he - at times - owns up to being wrong. Even when he does so in front of a paywall.

Meltzer didn't think one of the biggest demo draws and merch shifters of 2020 - Orange Cassidy - would work on TV. He then admitted he was wrong.

He admitted he was wrong.

He admitted he was wrong.

But he was wrong about Orange Cassidy, who can't possibly draw, and so the discourse begins anew.


5. Cody Rhodes

Cody Rhodes
AEW

It's honestly almost a shame that Cody Rhodes has somehow conspired to bring back professional wrestling to mainstream television.

Despite flirting with his heel side to get emerging babyfaces over in a situational role, the fans, when they return, won't ever boo him. He's too good in too valuable a mode - the earnest babyface is nigh-on impossible to pull off - and the intricate long-term booking and unscripted promo fire he restored is too vital for fans. He's a forever face.

But he's also an exceptional pure heel who once conspired to generate elusive, deep-felt heat in 2018 by aiming a captive bolt pistol into the temple of the sacred cow that was the original, iconic Bullet Club design. Aware of its power, Cody mischievously decided to change it.

The redesign couldn't be more Cody unless it bladed itself; an hilarious sight gag, his trademark bleached hair covered the 'Club' text, conveying the idea that he was more important than the group some fans didn't feel he belonged in. His cigar fetish replaced the guns. The red, white and blue of his insignia messed up the cool understatement that encouraged fans to wear it outdoors with pride.

But he isn't infallible: his "Daddy Eats First' t-shirt was too overbearing, too Pardew, but to his credit, he coyly acknowledged as much in the Pro Wrestling Tees documentary. It worked better in his head than on the transfer.


4. Shawn Michaels

Shawn Michaels 1997
WWE.com

Shawn Michaels was a toxic ar*ehole in 1997.

He wouldn't do business with Bret Hart and expressed as much immediately after Hart had said, to diffuse their spiralling rivalry, that he would do the honours if the occasion demanded it. He had already done the honours at WrestleMania XII, and he worked hard to get him over. It was boring as sh*t, but you can't fault the effort.

Beyond the despicable but comparatively petty pro wrestling politics - these were very rich men swarming the entire company with their personal grudge, and it wasn't life or death, it was "lots of money in a promotion you like versus even more money in a promotion you probably won't - was Shawn's awful bullsh*t at One Night Only 1997.

There, he engineered a scenario in which he undermined the promise of a home country hero who had vowed to deliver the result in honour of his dying sister. Reprehensible stuff despite the promise of a return match he was definitely going to do the job in, Michaels was more than unpleasant. That was beyond the pale, even if the electricity of the heat remains so striking in its volume and earnestness all these years later. Michaels atoned later in life, found God, and has whenever asked owned up to and regretted his BS.

He's even risked upsetting colleagues to call out theirs.


3. Seth Rollins

Seth Rollins being boring
WWE.com

Seth Rollins got himself in rather a lot of silly bother last year.

Tired of WWE's plummeting reputation among the wrestling fandom, he, as Universal Champion, felt duty-bound to protect his realm. He said WWE was the best pro wrestling on the planet. Period. He then doubled-down, dawg - his words, not your writer's, which actually explains how he couldn't tell that the scripted promos were such dog sh*t - and called Will Ospreay, who'd waded in, a "little guy". Ospreay is more hench than Rollins, and certainly Ricochet, whom Rollins had claimed was a "better version" of the NJPW standout.

This was all a PR disaster brought on himself for the "greater good" of getting WWE over. It didn't get WWE over, and in fact buried him so much that, in conjunction with his terrible pissy-pants booking, he had no choice but to go heel.

Rollins was hardly going to turn around and say "Aye lads, you're right, WWE is sh*te - a mallet is bigger than a sledgehammer lmao" - but he did have the decency to take back his bank account bragging bullsh*t. He said it wasn't in line with his own values, and that he was too stubborn for his own good.

So Rollins is deluded, but not an a*sehole.


2. Jim Ross

Jim Ross WCW
WWE

With these old guys, a non-apology sort of has to count. It's the only one you're gonna get.

Jim Ross has improved considerably at the booth following All Out, at which he shrugged at the big Falcon Arrow kick-out spot in the Hikaru Shida Vs. Thunder Rosa AEW Women's Title match. It was inserted into the match to protect the NWA Women's Champion as an appreciative nod gestured towards Billy Corgan. Ross called the spot like it was an arm drag, constitutionally unable to receive it as a moment of drama because it was the jezebel quarter hour.

Worse still was his dirty awld man behaviour concerning the very, very young Anna Jay. "Did she just suffer a wardrobe malfunction," Ross asked, "or was that just wishful thinking on my part?"

Yikes.

He was crucified on Twitter for removing the gummy Venus de Milo from Jay's a*se cheek, and he promptly apologised with, one presumes, a big gun pointed at the back of his cowboy hat.

"Weak attempt at humour," he tweeted in the aftermath. "Sorry. Now lighten up."

Ross essentially said "Sorry," and then, under his breath, "I said she had a great ass, what's the damn problem, it was a compliment".

But again: it's the only one you're gonna get.


1. Triple H

Triple H NXT
WWE

Triple H likes to play the room and be received as its Archbishop of Banterbury, its alma mater of decent patter.

It's quite amusing to note that Trips probably started those NXT TakeOver conference calls to bask in the critical acclaim, and didn't consider that the day might come when its reputation slides and he has to field questions about potential n*ncery.

He misread that room badly when speaking to the media in January of this year.

Talking up Edge and Paige's chances of returning to the ring, he said it was more important to him that they live long, healthy lives. "Edge has kids. Paige - maybe - she probably has some she doesn't know of".

This was doubly brutal: a cruel dose of slut-shaming made all the worse because Paige is unable to have children. Paige revealed her disappointment at his attempt to be one of the lads. "Even my boss jokes about me...no wonder you guys do too," she tweeted.

Paige has suffered significant mental distress as a result of her premature retirement and abusive public relationship. This was at best tactless on Triple H's part, but he did the right thing in the end. He apologised to Paige, admitted that the joke was "terrible," and all's well that ends well.

Except WWE tried to take Paige's additional income away when she can't earn much of a primary one.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!