10 Times Wrestlers Dated Celebs Vastly More Famous Than Them

For the benefit of those with flash photography.

Lana Old Spice Guy
WWE.com

It’s fairly easy to meet celebrities when you work for WWE. Whether it’s at ringside or backstage, it attracts an array of actors, musicians, athletes, reality TV stars, and even porn stars. Leading actors like Matthew McConaughey, Adam Sandler, and Stephen Amell, headline musicians such as Corey Taylor, Fred Durst and Snoop Dogg, as well as influential athletes like Shaquille O'Neal, LeBron James and Tyson Fury have all appeared ringside at various points in WWE. Some even in angles.

And with that kind of access there’s plenty of wrestlers who’ve scored dates with famous folk. Whilst wrestlers are commonly known to date someone else already in the business, given their hectic travel schedule and being around the same group of people 4/5 days of the week, some look further afield to Hollywood. Whether or not it’s a calculated move, it does create buzz and interest for them online to date someone else in the spotlight.

Alexa Bliss’ newest beau is musician Ryan Cabrera, after The Miz introduced the two. Nikki Bella met her Dancing With the Stars’ fiancé Artem Chigvintsev when she was a contestant on the show and now they’re engaged and expecting their first child together. Paige was engaged to A Day to Remember’s guitarist Kevin Skaff in early 2016 and since late 2018 has been in a relationship with Falling in Reverse lead singer Ronnie Radke. Even Dana Brooke pulled Guardians of the Galaxy’s Drax (whatever his real name is) after some social media flirtation.

But it must be weird. When you’re an over wrestler on national TV, that garners a lot of attention as well as fans. So imagine what it feels like for the wrestlers when their famous partners are far more over them nationally. This is a list of people in wrestling who know that bizarre feeling all too well.


10. Notable mentions - Rey Mysterio And Jennifer Aniston / Louie Spicolli And Madonna

Rey Mysterio Jennifer Aniston
The Enquirer

Did you know Rey Mysterio went out with Jennifer Aniston in the 90s when WCW and Friends were drawing massive ratings?

Well, not really. But it was rumoured and talked about thanks to the American tabloid the National Enquirer who published a story claiming Rey was in a relationship with Jennifer. The headline read ‘Friends star Jennifer Aniston flips for incredible hunk’ alongside pictures of Jennifer and her supposed boyfriend Rey. Of course, the story was rubbish given the greatest cruiserweight in pro wrestling history was already married with a son (Dominic).

Many thought it was a publicity stunt by WCW to push Mysterio as a bigger star. Eric Bischoff was asked to clarify the rumour on his 83 weeks podcast: "I am not sure how the story emerged. I wasn't involved in it. I can't imagine it. It had to come from somewhere. Or, maybe, they just made it all up. Who knows?"

I’m guessing they made it all up. Mind I don’t know what you’d be prouder of if it ever turned out to be true: (eventually) winning the World title or dating Rachel from Friends?

Did you know Louie Spicolli once dated Madonna?

Well, not really. Though when he performed in Mexico in the early 90s he went under the heel moniker ‘Madonna’s Boyfriend’, complete with rigorous dancing to the Madonna song ‘Vogue’ which he used as his entrance theme. Apparently Madonna had major heat in Mexico at the time I guess?


9. Missy Hyatt And Jason Hervey

Missy Hyatt Jason Hervey
WCW

There’s a long list of wrestlers that The First Lady of Wrestling has had as sexual conquests. In her time spent in WCCW, WCW and the WWF, Missy has reported to have had relationships with the likes of Sting, Eddie Gilbert, Road Warrior Hawk, and John Tatum back in the day.

In the early 90s, Missy Hyatt went further afield and got involved in a relationship with ‘The Wonder Years’ actor Jason Hervey - a hugely popular and award-winning show at the time - with him also appearing in Tim Burton’s Frankenweenie, Police Academy 2, and Back to the Future.

When Missy broke up with Jason tension built between the two. It didn’t particularly help matters that Jason Hervey was good friends with a rising executive within WCW by the name of Eric Bischoff. During a match at Starrcade ’93, Missy had an accidental wardrobe malfunction which caused one of her breasts to briefly pop out of her dress. A month or so later, while backstage a TV taping, Missy noticed a photograph of her and her exposed breast pinned to a bulletin board.

She immediately ripped the picture down and went to Eric Bischoff, demanding an explanation and to find out who was responsible. Eric promised her he’d handle it but nothing ever got done. A week later, Missy went over Eric’s head to his boss and complained about the incident and the lack of response by Bischoff. So the next day Eric fired Missy Hyatt which led to a sexual harassment lawsuit that Missy won for an undisclosed amount of money. Eric forever proving controversy creates cash.


8. Lana And The Old Spice Guy

Lana Isiah Mustafa
WWE.com

Before Dusty Rhodes put Lana and Rusev together as a double act and they fell in love for real - and before she cuckolds Bobby Lashley in storyline and accused Rusev of being a sex addict which garnered shockingly high ratings - she dated ‘The Old Spice Guy’.

If you recall the tongue-in-cheek Old Spice adverts featured a chisel-chested good-looking man on a horse speaking to female viewers, telling them that ‘anything is possible if your man smells like Old Spice, and not a lady’ and being labelled as ‘The Man Your Man Could Smell Like’. That man was Isaiah Mustafa, who Lana once dated.

We know this thanks to Total Divas when Lana ran into her ex during her bachelorette party, of all the unlikely places/events (it’s almost like that show’s partially scripted), with the two doing a little bit of reminiscing. Lana told Isaiah about how sometimes she gets scared and wants to “run away” from Rusev. Isaiah told her to run away into Rusev’s arms (probably to avoid a Machka Kick).

I wonder who smelt nicer: The Old Spice Guy or The Bulgarian Brute?


7. David Otunga And Jennifer Hudson

David Otunga Jennifer Hudson
Twitter

David Otunga has played/done various roles in his 12 years tenure with WWE. He participated in the first season of NXT, he was part of The Nexus, he was amazingly a WWE Tag Team Champion with Joh Cena, he played off his real Harvard Lawyer degree and served as the ‘Legal Advisor’ for Raw GM John Laurinaitis, he was part of the SmackDown commentary team at one point and is now a panellist on WWE’s Kickoff Shows.

Detractors of Otunga’s have long held the opinion he’s been kept on WWE’s payroll for his dating life rather than his talent. For 10 years he was engaged to actress and musician Jennifer Hudson.

Talk about a disparity in fame. Her filmography reads ‘Dreamgirls’ and his reads ‘Celebrity Ghost Stories’. It’s hard to fathom Jennifer’s Oscar and Grammys next to Otunga’s Slammy Awards and Pro Wrestling Illustrated ‘2010 Rookie of the Year’ nod.

In November 2017 Hudson and Otunga announced their split after a decade together. Jennifer essentially accused Otunga of trying to freeload off her success during their relationship - an allegation he denied. Court documents revealed that she demanded he get a job with Otunga claiming he still worked for WWE to the surprise of everyone.


6. Dolph Ziggler

Amy Schumer Dolph Ziggler
wiki

When Dolph isn’t bumping and selling in WWE, he’s on the on road doing standup comedy. And after his breakup with Nikki Bella, Dolph dated a fellow comedian, a much more famous one than him. Trainwreck star Amy Schumer revealed on The Howard Stern Show she’d once dated Dolph and talked about how he “ragdolled” her around the bedroom and how she had to break it off with him because the sex was just too much.

Dolph said after Schumer first made the comments:

“I was actually flying home, and turned on my phone off the plane to 78 voicemails or so. This is 77 more than usual. And no, it's great. She's so funny. The only thing I’ll say about Amy is we had a blast hanging out together and the rapport was unbelievable. We would just go back and forth outdoing each other with jokes and laughs. Her work ethic was and is incredible. That’s very attractive to me. Busting your ass and always working at getting better is hot and also the key to success. She deserves everything coming to her.”

I really hope he howled "Follow that!" after every time he did the deed with Amy.


5. Torrie Wilson And Alex Rodriguez

Torrie Wilson’s one of the most beloved Divas of all time. A stunning blonde bombshell, she graced the cover of FHM and Playboy (twice) and was the most popular Diva in SmackDown's early brand extension days. She captivated viewers ever since she debuted for WCW in 1999 and held their adoration until she retired in WWE in 2008.

She had plenty of onscreen relationships in wrestling, hooking up with Carlito, Dawn Marie, Billy Kidman, Billy Gunn, Shane Douglas, Tajiri, Vince McMahon, Sable and Maven. Even marrying/divorcing Kidman offscreen. But it’s her relationship with a New York Yankee that garnered the most press and attention for her.

In 2011 Torrie started dating Alex Rodriguez (also known as ‘A-Rod’) - once considered Major League Baseball’s best player in the league. They were often seen together at Los Angeles Lakers games. Prior to Torrie, Rodriguez was familiar dating celebrities that were vastly more famous than he was having had relationships and flings with Cameron Diaz, Madonna and Kate Hudson.

Torrie and Alex called it quits in 2015 after three years of dating. Since then Alex’s continued his dating streak with Jennifer Lopez and Torrie’s gotten remarried and entered the WWE Hall of Fame. It's shocking and nothing short of a travesty that Torrie’s relationship with Rodriguez drew more mainstream media attention than her relationship with Tajiri.


4. Stacy Keibler And George Clooney

Stacy Keibler kicked off her wrestling career in 1999 in WCW before being fully embraced in WWE. She was known as ‘The Legs of WWE’, with Kid Rock even writing a song about her incredible legs that she used as theme music. She called it quits in 2006 due to WWE being such a gruelling lifestyle and being on the road 4/5 days a week and finding it hard not seeing friends and family.

She started taking acting classes after she left WWE, popping up on shows like How I Met Your Mother, Psych and Chuck and appearing on Dancing with the Stars. She also started mingling at glitzy Hollywood parties where she first met one of the most recognizable actors in the world George Clooney and his effortless charm. Clooney told her he’d seen her on Dancing with the Stars with Stacy being flattered he even knew who she was. They began dating in July 2011 and ended their relationship in July 2013.

Think about the imbalance in fame there. George Clooney had a string of stunning girlfriends and was known as Hollywood's most eligible bachelor and Stacy Keibler once dated David Flair and Test.


3. David Arquette And Courtney Cox

David Arquette Courtney Cox
Universal

Well, David Arquette is technically a wrestler. He’s a lifelong fan of professional wrestling, starred in the wrestling movie Ready To Rumble, won the WCW title (even though it’s still viewed today as one of the worst decisions in pro wrestling history), decided to pursue a legitimate career in professional wrestling in 2018, has had elbow surgery following an in-ring injury and competed in a deathmatch with CZW legend Nick Gage where he took light tube shots to the head and neck and bled profusely throughout.

David Arquette was known for acting (in roles like Scream and Eight Legged Freaks) but also more so for being married to Courtney Cox. Cox and the rest of her co-stars were the biggest and most well- paid stars in television at the time with Friends. Cox and Arquette met on the set of Scream in 1996, where, according to Cox, they fell in love. They divorced in 2012 due to David’s own admission of being unpredictable in his antics – antics like competing in Triple Cage matches with DDP and Jeff Jarrett.


2. X-Pac And Jenna Jameson

Jenna Jameson
Facebook

When you think of X-Pac and dating someone vastly more famous than him you immediately think of his relationship with Chyna. However you should take note that Sean ‘X-Pac’ Waltman revealed in a shoot interview, on top of divulging he’d hooked up with divas Tori, Nidia and Ryan Shamrock, he once got together with the most well-known name in porn Jenna Jameson.

Jenna’s had a few appearances in the wrestling industry. She was at ECW Hardcore Heaven in '97 as the valet for the Dudleys and flirted with Val Venis in vignettes for the WWF.

The former 1-2-3 Kid met Jenna after a meet and greet in Pittsburgh. They later got together at a club Jenna was performing at. Jenna apparently got Waltman onstage with her and they proceeded to make out. Waltman admits he took a few tabs of ecstasy to “get in the mood” and the two then went back to her hotel and according to Waltman “had the best sex of his entire life.”


1. Ric Flair And Halle Berry

Ric Flair Halle Berry
WWE

There’s a reason hip-hop’s embraced Ric Flair. He’s the personification of their extravagant lifestyle and in promos openly bragged about how much money he spent and how many women he slept with, even claiming recently he slept with over 10,000 women in his lifetime.

And according to The Nature Boy, sometime in the late 90s, Oscar-winning actress Halle Berry was one of those 10,000, taking her for a ride on Space Mountain in his glory days. When asked on his podcast, he said he’d been with “dozens" of celebrities with Halle Berry as the first name to casually come to his mind. When asked if he was being serious or not, Ric replied “Would I have to make up a lie?”.

If true, the hook-up would have occurred when Flair was married to his second wife. A representative for Halle Berry was quick to publicly deny the hook-up ever happened, stating “There is no truth to this. Halle has literally never even heard of him let alone met him.” When asked what he thought of Berry’s denial when TMZ caught up with him, The Nature Boy coyly smiled and said that she was a “great actress and a very nice woman.”


In this post: 
Lana
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Rex Jones hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.