10 Times Wrestlers Were Confronted By THEMSELVES!

Sting, Hulk Hogan, Undertaker and more join Randy Orton in being confronted by their own image!

Sting Fake nWo Sting WCW
WWE.com

As of this writing, extremely fresh in the memory is the sight of Randy Orton being confronted by a twisted, Bray Wyatt-influenced version of Randy Orton on a TV screen.

Ordinarily, this would seem a bit odd, would come across as tacky and would have wrestling fans slapping their head in that WTF manner that we're all so accustomed to. But that's the thing; the ongoing rivalry between 'The Fiend' Bray Wyatt and Orton has made us extremely accustomed to some forehead-slapping moments of TV.

The Viper isn't the first wrestler to be presented with the visage of their supposed self, mind, and he likely will not be the last. Over the decades, some of the biggest names in the history of the business have found themselves being confronted with what appears to be their doppelganger.

Some of these confrontations have been, like Orton's, cringe-inducing, yet others have been pulled off surprisingly well. That is, as well as such an idea can be pulled off, of course.

Here, then, are ten examples of wrestlers who at one point in time had to share screen time with what was depicted as 'themselves'.

10. The Undertaker

Summerslam 1994
WWE

After the bonkers antics of the 1994 Royal Rumble PPV - see: locked in a coffin by Yokozuna and a bunch of lower card heels, then his spirit ascending to somewhere - the Undertaker's seven-month absence from the then-WWF came to an end by that year's SummerSlam.

While the real-life Mark Calaway had taken that time off to heal a back injury, his time away from Vince McMahon's promotion saw Ted DiBiase lay claim to having the Deadman under his management. This angle would commence once WrestleMania X was in the rear-view mirror, with DiBiase's words shot down by the returning Paul Bearer.

From there, this mystery would finally be answered at SummerSlam '94, with DiBiase and Bearer bringing their Undertakers together in a bout to prove who the real Phenom was.

The whole story was clearly hokey, the SummerSlam bout was nothing to write home about, and Bearer's 'Taker won out because, well, because one look at him made you realise that he was clearly the Undertaker who'd been seen by WWF audiences for four years by that point.

As for Ted DiBiase's Underfaker, he was portrayed by Calaway's cousin Brian Lee, aka Chainz of the Disciples of Apocalypse faction that would turn up in WWF in 1997.


9. Kane

Kane vs. Kane WWE Vengeance 2006
WWE.com

At one point in time, wrestling fans saw the Undertaker be revealed to be behind the Kane mask as part of an elaborate ruse, but 2006 saw the Big Red Machine confronted with a fully-fledged Kane doppelganger that spent several weeks tormenting him.

To look at, this faux Devil's Favourite Demon was very much Kane-lite. His physique was notably smaller, his mannerisms weren't quite right, he was slightly shorter than the real Kane even when having his height boosted by a fluffed-up wig, and the hair... oh man, the '80s metal hair.

When the pair finally had a match a month into this story, Imposter Kane actually picked up the W in a seven-minute bout at the Vengeance PPV. In typical WWE fashion, a quick change of heart was at play, with the fake Kane attacked and kicked off of WWE TV by the real Kane on the very next night's Raw.

That Imposter Kane would be Drew Hankinson, who would resurface on WWE programming a year later as Festus. These days, of course, Festus is far better known as Luke Gallows.


8. Sin Cara

sin cara azul negro
WWE.com

It may sound a little hyperbolic these days, but Sin Cara was one of the most hyped signings WWE has made in recent memory.

When Luis Ignacio Urive Alvirde signed with WWE in February 2011, it was a major coup for the promotion. As in, certain amongst WWE brass felt that they had the nailed-on, money-drawing, sympathy-garnering masked babyface who was the second coming of Rey Mysterio Jr.

Giving the former Místico the new moniker of Sin Cara, this signee was introduced to WWE fans with his very own press conference. Unfortunately for this one-time IWGP Junior Heavyweight Champion, his WWE career just never got going. Injuries and reported attitude problems meant that he was quietly let go by WWE in March 2014 - with even the aforementioned Mysterio publicly questioning Alvirde's attitude in the years since.

What the original Sin Cara is best remembered for, though, is facing off against his own doppelganger. The former Hunico took on the Sin Cara gimmick during his predecessor's 30-day suspension, with this leading to a rivalry and Mask vs. Mask match upon the Alvirde's return to action.

The original Sin Cara would win out in that battle... but Hunico, aka Jose Rodriguez, would take on the entire gimmick permanently upon the original Cara being terminated by WWE.


7. Edge And Christian

Los Conquistadores Edge Christian
WWE.com

Edge and Christian weren't the first people to take on the Los Conquistadores mantle, with José Estrada Sr. and José Luis Rivera first using that gimmick in the World Wrestling Federation in 1987. E&C did popularise the swanky gold body suits for a new generation, though, when they started donning that shtick 13 years later.

Rendered unable to challenge for the Tag Team Championships held by the Hardy Boyz, this Canadian duo had the idea of performing as Los Conquistadores in the hope that nobody would realise who was under the masks.

This rejuvenated Los Conquistadores managed to topple the Hardyz for the belts, and they were then seen congratulated backstage by Edge and Christian - before then soon losing the straps to E&C!

To the watching audience and to the gullible babyfaces of the day, it was unfathomable for Los Conquistadors and Edge and Christian to be seen together, for both tandems were meant to be one and the same.

In actuality, the talent working as Los Conquistadors when seen opposite Edge and Christian were Christopher Daniels and Aaron Aguilera. That was until Matt and Jeff Hardy pulled a similar play to their rivals, putting on the gold duds to win the Tag Team Titles back from Edge and Christian.


6. Mick Foley

Mankind Cactus Jack Dude Love Three Faces Of Foley
WWE.com
"Are you thinking what I think you're thinking."
"I think I am thinking what you think I think you're thinking."

If seeing two of Mick Foley's personas sharing screen time together wasn't enough, the ramblings of Dude Love and Mankind on a September 1997 Monday night gave WWF audiences their introduction to a brutal third string to the Foley bow: Cactus Jack.

For a moment, wrestling fans got to see three versions of Mrs. Foley's Baby Boy stood next to each other in a moment that is still fondly remembered to this day.

The caveat here, of course, is that this was only possible due to the manipulation offered up by a pre-produced video segment. But still, Foley is one of only a select few wrestlers to say that they have legitimately appeared on-screen alongside their actual self.

For those who aren't familiar with this most grin-inducing of early Attitude Era moments, Dude Love and Mankind are left pondering a Street Fight battle with Triple H. With these two iterations of Foley putting their heads together, that's where the WWF debut of Cactus Jack came to the table.


5. Jeff Hardy

Jeff Hardy Willow
IMPACT Wrestling

For Jeff Hardy, he'd not only be confronted by one of 'himself', he'd effectively get a buy one, get two free deal when he came face-to-face with his Willow creation back in 2016.

Willow had been a persona of Hardy's dating back to his teenage years, when he, Matt Hardy and Thomas Simpson founded their own OMEGA promotion. The Charismatic Enigma had briefly taken up the Willow the Wisp moniker for a cup of coffee in Ring of Honor in 2003, but the gimmick was fully brought to the fore in 2014 as Jeff opted to give his TNA stint a shot in the arm.

That run lasted for a solid five months before Jeff Hardy reverted back to, well, Jeff Hardy, but two years later Willow resurfaced. And as alluded to, it wasn't just one Willow but three.

It would be revealed that Matt Hardy was one of said Willows, and he'd orchestrated this whole charade as a way to torment his brother.

Quicker than you could say "wooooonderful" in an awful British accent, Matt had a white streak in his hair, began referring to Jeff as Brother Nero, and the nuts world of 'Broken' Matt Hardy was soon established.


4. Sting

Sting Fake nWo Sting WCW
WWE.com

The usual practice for when a wrestler is confronted by a purported version of themselves, is for that imposter or alternate to quietly vanish after a month or two. In the case of Jeff Farmer, though, he managed to take another person's gimmick and make an entire career for himself.

Farmer had been in the business since 1991, often as part of the Thunder and Lightning tag team alongside Clark Hainess. While this tandem had toured with All Japan and served as enhancement talent in WCW's tag team division, it was 1996 where Farmer took his stock to a whole other level - which is when he turned up on WCW Nitro under the guise of then-absent Sting.

Initially as 'Surfer' Sting, then as 'Crow' Sting, Farmer went on to become a part of the initial New World Order, nWo Japan, and nWo Hollywood. In fact, this faux Sting actually became more popular than the real thing in Japan - which is why Jeff Farmer ended up spending considerable time wrestling in front of Japanese audiences.

What happened whenever the legitimate Sting would come face-to-face with his doppelganger, then? Why, the real deal would always leave his double lying.

For Jeff Farmer, he would continue to use the nWo Sting name up until his retirement in 2005.


3. Doink The Clown

Doink The Clown WrestleMania 9
WWE.com

The very notion of having a wrestler be greeted by his own image is one that's a tad out-there, even by pro wrestling standards. Yet with the character of Doink the Clown, if all felt very par for the course when another Doink (played by Steve Keirn) turned up on the scene at WrestleMania IX.

Like, at the time it was obviously a nuts moment to see two Doinks gleefully staring back at each other for those of us who lived this event in real time. When reflecting back, though, it seems absolutely perfect.

There wouldn't just be two Doinks, mind, for there'd be smaller Dinks, Bushwackers as Doink, and a whole array of other wrestlers pulling on this gimmick for one-off appearances in the years since Matt Borne first wowed under the paint back in 1993.

Borne would unfortunately be fired at the end of '93 after being caught smoking weed in his hotel, and the Doink moniker would then be taken on by Ray Apollo. Away from WWE, Matt Borne would at times dabble with the Doink gimmick - even turning up as the character in a battle royal at the Raw 15th Anniversary in 2007 - before he sadly passed away in 2013.


2. Randy Orton

Randy Orton WWE Raw
WWE.com

The most recent inclusion on this list sees Randy Orton faced with Randy Orton.

From setting the Fiend on fire, to RKO'ing Alexa Bliss, to throwing up black goo, it's been an eventful couple of months for Randal Keith. And the next stage on the 'eventful' front saw the Viper tormented by his own visage.

Continuing the oft-painful Orton/Fiend/Alexa story, this past week's Raw had a possessed Randy turn up on a backstage screen to spew some chilling words towards the real deal. Like so many times where a wrestler has been confronted by themselves - or at least their supposed selves - it came off as cheesy and a bit naff. But then again, that could be said for so much of what we've seen between Orton and Bray Wyatt for the last four months.

While many wrestling fans were hoping that this rivalry would wrap up at this year's Royal Rumble PPV, WWE has different plans, with Wyatt having been kept off TV since being set ablaze at December's TLC show.

Instead, it appears that the next (and hopefully final!) stage of this feud will take place at WrestleMania 37. In the meantime, it could well be that we get more Orton vs. Orton confrontations. Yay...


1. 'Hollywood' Hulk Hogan

Hollywood Hogan Head WCW Nitro
WWE.com

Ever happy for any excuse to yuck it up to the crowd - whether as babyface or heel - 'Hollywood' Hulk Hogan was handed a grand opportunity to oversell on the go-home WCW Nitro ahead of his Starrcade '97 encounter with Sting.

That episode of Nitro was billed as a Hogan celebration night, and that is exactly what is was for the most part. Eric Bischoff lavished praise, plaudits and gifts up Hollywood, yet there was one final gift waiting to be unwrapped during the closing moments of that Monday night offering.

Amidst some uncertainty as to who had sent this gift to Hollywood, Hulk opening the present saw the reveal that he'd been gifted his his own decapitated head, brother.

While the nWo star wasn't confronted by a full-on imposter of himself, per se, it would likely be even more traumatic to be presented with merely your own severed head. Well, if it wasn't for how cheesily over-the-top Hogan made the whole ordeal.

The person responsible for his heads-up would be Sting, who swiftly ziplined down from above the entrance ramp - ahead of a hugely anticipated match that ended up being an absolute farce.


In this post: 
Sting
 
Posted On: 
Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.