10 Times Wrestling Referees Really F**ked Up!
Officials majorly screwing up in WWE, WCW and AEW.
It’s often a thankless job being a referee in pro wrestling.
Just look at Mike Chioda, after 31 years of loyal service, being let go from WWE with no explanation. Or Tim White suffering a career-ending shoulder injury officiating Triple H vs. Chris Jericho in Hell in a Cell after being knocked into the cell. Or Earl Hebner being jeered and heckled for years by crowds for being part of screwing Bret Hart in Montreal, even though he was only following direct orders on short notice from Vince McMahon and feared losing his job if he didn’t.
It certainly can be a strenuous job, with referees having to quickly relay instructions to wrestlers on the fly when a match goes awry.
Especially in WWE, where they have strict ever-changing rules and regulations dictated by its Chairman on how to conduct a match. Even going so far as to ban commentators from referring to referees by name, in case they take too much attention away from the wrestlers in the ring.
With all that stress, mistakes and botches are inevitably bound to happen from time to time. But these mistakes were regrettable, even sometimes catastrophic, in altering finishes and title changes and resulting in fines and firings...
10. Danilo Anfibio Gets Fined Thousands
In March 2018 a dark six-man tag match after SmackDown resulted in hefty fines for all involved, including the referee.
Rusev, Aiden English and Baron Corbin took on AJ Styles and The Usos, with all six of them having fun and goofing around after the TV cameras stopped rolling. They were inspired by wrestlers years past, like Steve Austin and The Rock joking around and improvising after shows that would often pop crowds big.
The Usos started throwing superkicks in the match as if they were trying to put The Young Bucks to shame, with AJ Styles getting involved in the superkick fun too. The fun escalated to the point where the wrestlers convinced the referee Danilo Anfibio to get involved in the action, with Anfibio nailing Aiden English with a perfect kick to the face. From that point on AJ convinced Anfibio to take his referee shirt off and swap places with him, with AJ refereeing and Anfibio hitting more superkicks for the win.
The crowd loved it but WWE higher-ups certainly did not, believing the wrestlers had buried the business. They fined all the wrestlers and Danilo Anfibio in the thousands for going off-script.
9. Teddy Long Screws Up And Doesn’t Care
Before he was hollering and making tag matches weekly on SmackDown as the GM, Teddy Long was officiating matches for WWE. One match he refereed, in particular, has proven popular online for Teddy not giving a damn about screwing up the finish.
At the Royal Rumble (1999) Gangrel squared up against X-Pac for the European Championship, which X-Pac was booked to win. Following a crossbody by X-Pac, Gangrel rolled him up for the pin. Teddy Long started counting too soon and didn’t give X-Pac enough chance to break out of the pin, covering 1-2-3. After an awkward few moments X-Pac, Gangrel and Teddy Long continued on with the match as if nothing had happened. The commentators tried to cover it up as boos from the crowd set in, knowing they had witnessed a live botch.
Afterwards, when others would be fearing a fine or a firing, Teddy Long hilariously kept taking out his earpiece, likely sick and tired of the abuse coming his way through the headset from Vince McMahon and others for the botched pin.
Teddy eventually counted the correct 3 count when X -Pac hit the X-Factor for the decisive win to retain his title.
8. Raw Women’s Championship Match Ends Prematurely
‘The Empress of Tomorrow’ Asuka defended her Raw Women’s Championship against underutilized legend Mickie James in September 2020 in a match that did the rounds in wrestling news outlets for its abrupt ending. Asuka was always supposed to go over, just not in the way it went down.
The match had Asuka hooking Mickie in the Asuka Lock, with Mickie trying to fight her way out of it, when all of a sudden referee Darrick Moore suddenly called for the bell. This legitimately surprised Mickie, who didn’t tap whatsoever, and was wide-eyed and in disbelief when she heard the ring bell. To cover up the live TV botch Mickie quickly pretended to pass out.
It was revealed afterwards the mistake stemmed from Moore being concerned James had suffered a legitimate shoulder injury in the Lock. Mickie was fine though, and whilst Moore had her wellbeing in mind when he stopped the match, it’s a damn shame the contest ended like that as the match was shaping up to be special.
To cover up the confusion WWE released a kayfabe statement later claiming the ‘The Raw Women's Champion locked on the Asuka Lock, and despite James' best efforts to fight out, the referee ruled her unable to continue and awarded the match to Asuka.’
Mickie James talked to talkSPORT regarding the botch:
“I honestly don’t know. I rolled back to count – one, two – there was no count. So she obviously went to go and lock back in the Asuka Lock and I think in those moments, here’s the thing: it is a dangerous sport. We have to be very careful. The refs do their job and kind of their job is to protect us and make sure it never goes too far or no one ever gets hurt. So he made his decision based on what he thought was a reality, that I was hurt or I couldn’t continue and that’s unfortunate for me.”
7. Earl Hebner Botches The No Way Out Main Event
The No Way Out clash between The Rock and Kurt Angle was months in the making and pivotal in making Rock reclaim the WWF Championship before his legendary encounter at WrestleMania X-Seven with Steve Austin. Rock was due to go over after hitting his finisher but things didn’t go exactly to plan, with the ending spoiling a thrilling bout.
The ending had Rock throwing Angle into the turnbuckle and hitting a Rock Bottom. This was supposed to lead to the winning pinfall but when Rock covered Angle referee Earl Hebner stopped counting at 2, despite Angle not moving and his shoulders being firmly planted on the mat. This ticked off ‘The Great One’, who had to right there and then call an audible to Angle on the mat to get up and take one more Rock Bottom for the 1-2-3. Rock was crowned new WWF Champion but was irked and refused to let Hebner raise his hand with the title after the match.
Kurt Angle recently went over what exactly happened on his podcast:
“I distinctly remember that Earl probably thought that was the first Rock Bottom. I believe we hit a Rock Bottom earlier in the match and Earl forgot. So, the finish was supposed to be the second Rock Bottom and Earl thought the second one was the first. So, that’s why he hesitated on the count. Dwayne, The Rock, was pissed. He picked me up, Rock Bottomed me, and looked Earl in the eye and said, ‘Count the mother f**king finish.’ He was pissed. Earl’s was going to get it when we got back to gorilla. But, Dwayne was mad at the time, but when he got backstage, he cooled off and he didn’t really yell at Earl or anything. We all make mistakes. Things like this happen. You just have to move forward and continue on with the match. That’s what Rock did. He took the initiative to Rock Bottom me again and get the win. That’s an experienced wrestler.”
6. The Biggest Botch In WCW History
The huge Starrcade 1997 main event between Sting and Hollywood Hogan over the WCW World title was monumentally screwed up thanks to referee Nick Patrick.
The ending was supposed to go down like this: Hogan would land the Led Drop of Doom on Sting and the crooked referee in the match Nick Patrick would make a fast count before Sting had a chance to kick out. Then Bret Hart would hit the ring, punch Patrick’s lights out, restart the match and Sting would hook the Scorpion Deathlock on Hogan and make him tap out to all-around cheers from the crowd.
A version of this happened, but with a severely altered narrative. After Hogan hit the big leg on Sting, Nick Patrick counted at a regular pace, making it look like Hogan clearly and cleanly won the match. So when Bret hit the ring and took out Patrick and demanded the match be restarted and Sting won, it looked to anyone watching like Hogan was decidedly screwed out of the title.
The lack of a fast count came from Patrick being unsure what to do. Prior to the match Sting told him to make the fast count and Hogan told him to count normally. Patrick feared he would be fired after the PPV went off the air from the slip-up, with Eric Bischoff coming up to him and asking “Nick, what the f**k?”.
Patrick has since spoken on the finish:
“What happened was two people, Sting and Hulk, they were the two franchise guys and the two franchise guys were butting heads at that point in time. One guy came up to me and told me to fast count it to get some heat and give him an out and the other guy said ‘Don’t fast count it. Keep it nice and slow.’ And so the person that was in charge evidently didn’t want to make a call, didn’t want to pick a side, and made themselves scarce all night long to where I couldn’t find them to ask them ‘Hey, what do you want me to do?’”
5. A Botched Pin/Win Gets Referee Wes Adams Fired
In August 2008 on WWECW, Mark Henry teamed up with Matt Hardy to take on John Morrison and The Miz. Matt hit the Side Effect and went to cover Morrison. It was reported Miz was supposed to break up the pin but missed his cue, so the referee in the bout Wes Adams covered 1-2-3, with the match ending far earlier than initially planned.
Hardy and Henry were declared the winners. Henry, who was supposed to get the hot tag from Hardy and dominantly run through Miz and Morrison, looked on in angry confusion.
Wes was following orders, officiating matches like they were shoot contents. But WWE were cutting costs at the time, with the belief that any small mistake by a Superstar or referee could wind up costing them their job with the company.
Wes cleared up the mistake in the back with the wrestlers after the match. But it was too late, his fate had already been decided, with John Laurinaitis claiming Wes’ call ruined the match. Wes was released from his contract soon after as a result.
4. AEW Dynamite Gets Off To A Bad Start With Messy Finish
AEW had let it be known in its inception that it wanted its pro wrestling to come across as authentic and real as possible, with strict rules and time limits dictating its matches. But when “The Bastard” PAC took on Trent’s in one of AEW’s first few editions of Dynamite, it’s authenticity was wounded, with critics labelling the finish to the match as amateurish afterwards.
The ending to PAC vs. Trent was sped up due to timing issues and an upcoming commercial break. So PAC quickly hit his Black Arrow on Trent and was supposed to score the clean pinfall. Referee Bryce Remsberg, confused with the timing issues, started making the count but stopped at 2, even though Trent was laid out and didn’t move whatsoever. The crowd obviously weren’t happy, with boos quickly hitting the ring. It didn’t help that PAC had a big match with “Hangman” Adam Page coming up a few days later at the Full Gear PPV and had to come across as dominant, so it didn’t look great when it appeared Trent might have kicked out of his Black Arrow finisher.
Thankfully PAC, frustrated, knew exactly what to do, having had years worth of experience working live TV in WWE. He turned Trent around and locked in the Brutalizer for the win, with Trent passing out.
3. Tim White Causes Accidental Title Change At WrestleMania 2000
There was an excess of midcarders and jobbers in the 15 Minute Hardcore Battle Royal at WrestleMania 2000 fighting over the WWF Hardcore title. It was the equivalent of what The André the Giant Memorial Battle Royal is now, giving lower Superstars on the roster a chance to do something and wrestle on WWE’s biggest event of the year.
The match was supposed to have Crash Holly retaining his title by the skin of his teeth but things didn’t go according to plan. Towards the end of the match Tazz hooked in the Tazzmission on Crash, only for Hardcore Holly to come and smash a jar of candy over Tazz’s head. Hardcore Holly pinned Crash, who had dropped to the mat with only a few seconds remaining on the clock. The timer was supposed to go off after the pinfall, thus resulting in Crash barely retaining. But referee Tim White started counting too early, resulting in Hardcore Holly winning the match and title.
There was a lot of confusion after the match, with even Howard Finkel announcing Hardcore Holly as the winner with a question mark to the live crowd.
To rectify the blunder the WWF had Crash regain the title from Hardcore Holly the next night on Raw is War.
2. Becky Lynch Walks Away With Gold At WrestleMania 35, The Ref Walks Away With A Fine
The first ever all-female main event at WrestleMania 35, that crowned Becky Lynch as the undisputed women’s champion and was the biggest moment in her career, was tarnished by its finish.
With Charlotte down, Becky rolled Ronda Rousey up in a crucifix pin to score the win, even though Ronda’s shoulder was off the mat. It was WWE referee Rod Zapata who officiated the match and made the cover, and as a consequence of the pin gaffe was fined afterwards off orders directly from Vince McMahon.
WWE has a modern policy of referees calling matches like a shoot. The belief amongst WWE higher-ups was Zapata should have stopped the pin when he saw Ronda’s shoulder wasn’t on the mat, with the wrestlers then having the responsibility to come up with another finish on the fly (even in WWE’s biggest match that calendar year).
The Chairman was clearly looking to set an example to others, with referee Dan Engler also getting fined around this time for a botched spot in the SmackDown Tag Team Title match on the card. Once again proving refereeing isn’t an easy job in WWE.
1. Earl Hebner Merchandise F**k Up Gets Him And His Brother Fired
In the biggest referee f**k up of them all, Earl Hebner, along with his brother Dave Hebner, were fired from WWE after years of service in 2005 for selling official and bootleg WWE merchandise without permission.
Earl was reportedly taking merch from live events and making bootleg merch like sweaters, sweatshirts and jackets, and selling them for a profit out the back of his car to wrestlers and fans. He gained a considerable amount of heat from other referees for his side hustle, with many wondering how WWE ever allowed him to do it. Fellow referee Mike Chioda remarked “I remember being disappointed because I thought how is the company letting Earl sell stuff and making money but not let us do anything on the side to make money as far as merchandise?” Turns out WWE never did allow it and Earl was doing it behind their backs.
Earl and Dave sold the merchandise in a store in St. Louis too. WWE, after being tipped off, sent a private eye out to the store to investigate, which resulted in the Hebners being fired.
Earl has continuously denied he ever did it, claiming “It was a big lie from day one. I know what they said, but it was a big lie. Why would you risk a t-shirt for a $200,000 job, for a $15 t-shirt?” It’s obviously still a sore subject for him, with him adding “I don’t want nothing to do with Vince McMahon, period.”