10 Times WWE Booked Themselves Into A Corner

Turning the screw.

Baszler Fiend
WWE

The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia booked themselves into a corner with the murder of Jamal Khashoggi that allegedly took place in the Turkey consulate.

Khashoggi was outspoken against the regime, its harrowing human rights record, and the attempts to sports-wash it all away. This posed a problem; he was right, he had intimate knowledge of the backstage goings on, and his dirtsheet was influential. The Kingdom booked the angle without considering the long-term payoff. It was difficult for fans to suspend their disbelief - the "He just disappeared" plot hole was too gaping - and they found themselves in a worse position. The segment compromised the intended babyface turn and exacerbated their heel persona.

Oh, wait, sorry, that's not WWE. That is the brutal dictatorship WWE carries out propaganda for.

WWE, historically, has created similar problems for itself by first devising a masterstroke of conflict. The best pro wrestling programmes, and indeed all dramatic works, blindside you with a mystifying conundrum, in which the stakes are so vital to the characters that the repercussions are unthinkable. The Breaking Bad writer's room was phenomenal at this. Walter White was done for every week, from all directions, until he wasn't.

But this isn't science, bitch - it's WWE, pal!

10. Shayna Baszler Is A Vampire

Shayna Baszler
WWE.com

On this week's Monday Night RAW, Shayna Baszler debuted as vampire and attacked Becky Lynch via bite to the neck.

A very optimistic and out-of-character echo to Freddie Blassie - people were more likely to make Buffy The Vampire Slayer memes than pour acid over Baszler - this plot development drew widespread mockery and or mild disappointment. It looked phoney, Baszler needed no such theatrics to get over, and Becky's various ambulance trips undersold and exaggerated the drama.

And what's more, there's nowhere else to go beyond two directions: total farce or a backwards step into the mundane. Either Baszler is simply a vampire now, which is preposterous, or wherever they go next, barring the sort of exquisitely-crafted feud WWE simply isn't capable of, will feel a bit meh. This was such a shocking, controversial and divisive moment that a wrestling programme, even a good one, will underwhelm as a spectacle.

Moreover, Vince absolutely loves props, and this should absolutely f*cking terrify you, mate.

Does Becky, who has taken to wearing meme shades and daft jackets, rock up on RAW with some garlic around her neck?


9. Suplex City

brock lesnar john cena summerslam 2014
WWE.com

At SummerSlam 2014, Brock Lesnar annihilated John Cena in one of the most audacious, cathartic, gruesome - and fatal - spectacles in WWE history.

Powered by the confidence of conquering the Undertaker's legendary WrestleMania streak, the Brock Lesnar character honed his strategy to simply throw the hapless around like sacks of sh*t under a German suplex storm. He labelled this strategy "Suplex City" at WrestleMania 31, but erected the foundations at SummerSlam, and those foundations were unshakeable - because why, from a psychological perspective, would he deviate from a strategy that was both incredibly effective and required little physical exertion?

This was a trademark Paul Heyman booking decision consistent with his big picture shock mentality. It wasn't thought through; Heyman imbued the character with so much power that it indulged the selective motivation of the performer, resulting in too many shockingly one-sided and half-arsed outings.

The Lesnar character has proven a revelation since around this time last year, but the whole Suplex City bit has led us to a weird and stultifying point at which stars are meant to get over just by surviving the onslaught in a very good 14 minute match - and at which point the ripping, back-and-forth like of Lesnar Vs. CM Punk can no longer happen.


8. Charlotte Flair's Record Chase

Charlotte Flair Bayley
WWE.com

WWE is intent - very transparently - on promoting Charlotte Flair as a legend on par with her father, which has manifested as a career-long quest to equal Ric's (WWE canon) achievement of 16 World Title wins.

Surpass is more likely, given her relatively brief run in the WWE system. This has repelled many fans away from Charlotte, which is exceptionally counterproductive. The chase in 2019 resulted in unpopular, division-destroying wins (at the expense of Asuka) and forgettable developments met with complete apathy (a very tired programme with Bayley). The frequency and value inflation have collided to ruin the arc; the titles that Flair wins barely mean anything, they are so easily captured, and the arc is so obvious and imposed that the core of the premise - fans should want to see a worthy challenger ascend - was lost years ago. We're not even that deep into the plural.

This ongoing arc has now threatened the integrity of two of WWE's Women's divisions.

Charlotte won the Women's Royal Rumble match, but the idea of challenging Becky Lynch or Bayley was so over-familiar as to be completely untenable. She is now set to challenge Rhea Ripley, undermining NXT's sterling, multi-stranded division, and she didn't even entertain the idea of heading back to SmackDown, rendering it an ice-cold afterthought.

WWE had to give Charlotte Flair something to do, and that something revealed just how stale Women's wrestling has become after its Evolution peak.


7. Hell In A Cell 2019

Fiend Hell In A Cell
WWE.com

How transcendently brilliant is Daniel Bryan?

He recovered this piece of sh*t and worked several thousand people into thinking the Fiend could be good again. This piece of sh*t, of course, was the infamous main event of Hell In A Cell, which was shockingly awful on every conceivable level.

The Fiend brought out a big, oversized mallet. This was considered fair game in a barbaric match with no rules. The presiding official could not however condone a smaller hammer, and called the match off. This was the equivalent of a boxing referee calling off a bout for a body shot. A disaster of psychology and presentation, there was no need for this to happen. WWE booked a match between two acts they didn't want to beat, in a match where there must be a winner, and simply didn't deliver a winner. They strapped the f*cker later that very month, and if they wanted to wait until Halloween for full spooky effect, that should tell you all you need to know about how superficial this nonsense is.

The disaster of the finish was thrown into even sharper relief when one considers how the main event of TLC and the injury to Kairi Sane played out.

What this means, in storyline canon, is that WWE officials were concerned over the fate of an invincible supernatural monster in proximity of a sledgehammer than a concussed, diminutive human being in proximity of a ladder.


6. The Fiend, General

Bray Wyatt The Fiend
WWE

Daniel Bryan wrestled WWE out of said corner, because he is a genius, but this thing will retreat back into one and take a sh*t.

Bray Wyatt differs to spiritual antecedent the Undertaker, who also withstood and or no-sold punishment in his early guise as a stalking, impervious presence. 'Taker had the ability to adapt his gimmick into the context of traditional pro wrestling matches, and was an elite-level worker when he turned it on. We've seen very little of that from Wyatt in non-gimmicked attractions, and the standard elsewhere is incredible.

The Fiend's character is that of a relentless machine impervious to pain, or selectively impervious, given that he has to exchange momentum in the course of a match to make it halfway adjacent to pro wrestling. There's no consistent psychological basis to this, no perceptible weakness, no sense that a certain strategy might work if applied with enough perseverance, and consequently, fans get lost during his matches which more often than not generate the mildest of heat.

The Fiend is over, now, a bit, but he's either this dominant forever - a diminished return - or the supernatural monster becomes just another guy on the roster.

People will probably pay top dollar for his customised kickpads, so there's that.


5. Hell In A Cell 2012

CM Punk Ryback
WWE.com

Following Night of Champions 2012, the CM Punk Vs. John Cena main event of which went to a draw as pretext for the Hell In A Cell blowoff, Cena was forced to undergo surgery to remove bone chips from his elbow.

This necessitated a change of plans, but Hell In A Cell predated the Network era. WWE had to deliver an attraction worth purchasing, and since Cena was the preeminent or only draw, WWE made the only viable decision it could make by installing the white-hot Ryback as Punk's challenger. The problem, of course, is that Ryback was white-hot, and Punk was in no position to lose the WWE Championship ahead of his Royal Rumble match with the Rock.

To put it more succinctly, WWE were f*cked, and they responded by dislodging the appendage and jamming it directly into us by way of a f*ck finish.

At the end of a deeply underwhelming match, WWE scrolled through its rolodex of unfulfilling 'Let's deal with it later' bullsh*t by having guest referee Brad Maddox inexplicably turn on Ryback via low blow. Maddox explained on RAW that, embittered by his lack of success as an in-ring talent, he wished to make himself "famous".

Also Paul Heyman paid him off, but by this point nobody cared.


4. Hiring The New World Order

nWo WWE
WWE.com

The WWF hired the nWo because the nWo were draws and the WWF wasn't drawing.

Simple economics complicated to a preposterous degree, the WWF made exceptionally hard work of something that was never going to work. Hogan, Nash and Hall were no longer the cool disrupting force of professional wrestling. This could have worked - the act was reoriented with a knowing, meta acknowledgement of their toxic politicking - but this intriguing element was mostly dropped.

The "dose of poison" manifested as an attempt to end the careers of the Rock and Steve Austin, which if successful probably would have proven lethal to the WWF. It effectively did by 2003, as Triple H failed to draw as the tippy-top guy, but in any event, this was standard fare from the men who had revolutionised the industry eight years prior. The semi-truck and breeze-block attacks proved fatalistic, in the end; the attempts to get heat on the nWo were so overblown and farcical that nobody could take them seriously, and fans instead projected their own feelings onto the group.

Those feelings were nostalgia and euphoria, for the megastar they grew idolising had returned, ruining the core idea of the storyline.


3. The Undertaker Vs. Shane McMahon

Undertaker Shane Mcmahon
WWE

Shane McMahon returned to WWE storylines in 2016, in a bid to seize power back from the stifling tyranny of his sister, thus inciting a 'New Era' of opportunity and excellence.

Fast-forward two and a half years later, and Baron Corbin was removed from power to right the dismal wrongs of Monday Night RAW.

Comments section: WWE has buried itself for longer than I've been doing it.

WWE agrees with me.

But back to 2016. 2016 was a creative atrocity. Vince, defensive over his product, challenged the gumption of the prodigal son in the form of the Undertaker, who simply obeyed him, like he was the urn or some sh*t. WWE, in overloading the stakes to sell the attraction, wrote itself into a corner. 'Taker couldn't lose - it was a WrestleMania match inside Hell In A Cell in Texas against Shane McMahon - but the fans wanted Shane to win, to spare themselves Stephanie's counterproductive, shrill awfulness. So they simply had 'Taker win and reneged on the stipulation because Vince was impressed by Shane's big cushioned jump, which would have been more impressive had he sold it for longer than 24 hours. Also, while Shane lost, he didn't lose the "lockbox" of Vince's secrets. Shane covered up probable grave misdeeds, because he had power now, and we were expected to cheer for this spoilt, craven brat.

F*ck's sake.


2. John Cena Joins The Nexus

John Cena Nexus Feud
WWE.com

WWE, in order to delay or simply not do anything of meaning, scripted copout after copout during the sh*t-show that was the John Cena Vs. the Nexus saga of 2010.

After the catastrophic events of SummerSlam, at which Cena recovered from a significant head injury in a minute and a half to kill a stable to "send the fans home happy" - "WWE is incapable of creating new stars, yay!" - WWE booked a bunch of b*llocks bullsh*t they were never going to follow up on to waste everybody's bastard time.

At Hell In A Cell - WWE's own version of the Uncensored '96 Doomsday Cage match stripped of all perverse entertainment - Cena was forced to join the Nexus, per the stipulation, following wave after wave of interference in a cage match built as more of a cage match than a cage match. It was an effective and halfway entertaining spectacle, to credit the work of those involved in the wrestling side of things, but then creative knackered it.

Cena joined the Nexus with a boo-boo face, and was fired when he failed in his duty to screw Randy Orton out of the WWE Championship at Survivor Series.

Wow.

That was huge.

Except it wasn't, because he turned up in his gear all the time, and then got rehired by Barrett because six grown men were too scared at getting attacked by one man that they threatened a mutiny.


1. Survivor Series 1997

Montreal Screwjob Bret Hart Shawn Michaels
WWE.com

Survivor Series 1997 was the ultimate example of screwing oneself, ironically enough. Vince McMahon couldn't have found an easy way out even if he starred in a Survivor-soundtracked montage.

The machinations in play were far more complex to solve retrospectively with a modern lens that does not factor in the old paradigm. Bret Hart was a star; Vince couldn't just cycle him out the mix, and what's more, he was significantly less impulsive in 1997. His grasp of storytelling was stunningly intricate in its long-term vision, the moving parts of which had to be considered very carefully. He didn't want to strap Steve Austin yet; he knew WrestleMania XIV would better power his star. The Undertaker Vs. Shawn Michaels grudge programme didn't require the title, and that it was so deftly removed from the Dead Man at SummerSlam '97 shaped the next two major programmes. This wasn't the Network era, it was war time, and the slaughtered WWF needed as much narrative and star power as it could generate.

The problem, of course, was that the destination plotted in the summer was untenable. Vince wanted Bret out, but he would not be moved, particularly by Shawn, in Canada, after Shawn had declared he wouldn't put Bret over. Bret would put Austin over, but it wasn't the time. Even the gripping reactive elegance of WWF's '97 booking could not resolve this amicably.

Helpfully, Triple H removed the WWF from the corner by being the embryonic ruthless politician he would become. Let's just screw him, he said, changing the course of the industry forever.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!