10 Times WWE Gave Us Something Awesome (...And Immediately RUINED It)
That wasn't the "Summer Of CM Punk". It was WWE's summer of poor decision-making!
Welcome to a world of wrestling moments akin to finding cash you didn't know you had in an old pair of jeans, then rounding the next corner and slipping on dog sh*t. Sure, you have that buzz of finding something awesome, but...you've also got to clean up one hell of a mess too.
That immediately ruins the rush.
WWE has done this to pro wrestling fans countless times. One minute, everyone's high-fiving one another at the thought of what's coming next. Then, they see what's actually next and instantly want to run away like that meme-baby who definitely wants to be anywhere else.
You might be surprised by some of the picks here too. There's everything from WWE's bid to reshape the women's division and "shake things up around here" with new match types, to ill-advised debuts and an entire TV show that needed more thought.
Often, and perhaps unsurprisingly, it was none other than Vince McMahon who wrecked early promise/momentum with one of his pesky, well-known whims. His decision-making totally ruined something potentially special overnight.
It also robbed fans of a few moments they'd waited years to see...
10. A “Women’s Revolution”
Stephanie McMahon was proud as punch when she introduced NXT workers like Charlotte Flair, Sasha Banks and Becky Lynch to the main roster on WWE's 13 July 2015 Raw. McMahon gushed with praise for all three, and promised they'd play a huge part in what was to become known as the "women's revolution".
Then, WWE spoiled it.
All three wrestlers were placed in going-nowhere factions for the sake of it. The terribly-titled "Team PCB" was comprised of Paige, Charlotte and Becky. Then, there was Sasha - she became part of "Team B.A.D" alongside Naomi and Tamina. This was a mistake, because it immediately diluted the spotlight.
Actual friendships between members were never explored properly. Instead, WWE's "revolution" was a group promotion and a bunch of lazy, uninspired stables that were never built to last. People could see right through that, and nobody involved really took off until ideas like "PCB" fell by the wayside.
9. Vader’s Debut
The WWF knew that incoming WCW monster Big Van Vader wasn't fit when they introduced him at the 1996 Royal Rumble. He debuted on that pay-per-view in the titular match, then got eliminated by eventual winner Shawn Michaels after approx 12 minutes. OK then?
Admittedly, the company booked a killer angle by having Vader attack onscreen authority figure Gorilla Monsoon the next night, but all of this was avoidable. His elimination by Michaels and the eventual gap between appearances softened excitement for Vader in the WWF.
Management should've waited until he was 100% so he could really make his mark.
They didn't though - federation chiefs elected to have Vader work at half speed on the Rumble show, then write him off TV. By the time he returned in February to launch into a proposed WrestleMania feud with Yokozuna, interested had cooled significantly. Missed opportunities would sum up Vader's two-year stint with the group.
8. The 2023 Draft
Pre-2023 Draft, WWE wheeled out everyone and their grandmother to brag about how huge brand exclusivity was/is. Imagine Roman Reigns being drafted to Raw?! That'd be hugely damaging to SmackDown. Or, what if SmackDown secured a major star like Brock Lesnar full-time, meaning he couldn't appear on Mondays?
Or, y'know, just sidestep the whole point of your gimmick by shoving Brock and countless others into a bogus free agency pool so they can work both brands. That'll do it. Worse, a string of champs (including Roman) can apparently circumvent WWE's "ironclad" rules, which takes one almighty dump on the whole idea.
The Draft should be awesome, but it's sullied almost overnight by this kind of booking. WWE has no less than 11 "free agents", and a whole bevy of workers who weren't even involved in the battle for talent between Raw and SmackDown at all.
This is why so many folks opt out of caring about the thing.
7. Bray Wyatt’s Return
Excitement on socials was at a fever pitch when Bray Wyatt returned at Extreme Rules 2022. People were very happy to see the guy, and hopes were high that a Triple H-led WWE would give Wyatt's creative genius the proper platform to flourish. Sadly, that wasn't actually the case.
His entire run was a bit of a stinker, being brutally honest.
After that hot start in October, Wyatt began cutting effectively the same promo time and time again. Folks were lured in by thoughts of inner turmoil at first, but then WWE hit the repeat button and people got bored. Things were already sagging by the time he matched up vs. LA Knight for a dire "Pitch Black" match at Royal Rumble.
That was ruined by Mountain Dew branding (seriously, promoting soft drinks was more important to the company than Wyatt or Knight), and by the fact Bray turned into some neon-drenched version of his old 'Fiend' character. The dude hasn't worked another match since, and is currently off TV.
6. Hell In A Cell
This probs won't be popular, but here goes.
Hell In A Cell was reportedly the brainchild of one Jim Cornette. He was the one who suggested sticking a roof on a mesh cage (like the Last Battle of Atlanta) and giving workers some room at ringside to operate. To Cornette, it made perfect sense that wrestlers could still tangle outside the ring but not be able to escape the cage.
The WWF debuted HIAC in October 1997 for a match between The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels. It was excellent, and it's not that Kane's own debut spoiled things but...he walked out and ripped the door clean off this seemingly impenetrable cage. Huh?
Obviously, that was a historic moment. It didn't really do much to present Hell In A Cell as some steel prison workers could never escape once locked in though. Keep in mind, this happened during the bout's very first appearance! That was certainly a brave call.
5. ECW Invading The WWF
Naturally, one can't talk about ECW invading the WWF without bringing up WCW too. That's coming in a future entry, don't worry. For now, try to comprehend why anyone thought ditching Paul Heyman (who was right there!) as leader of this extreme invasion was a solid plan.
Paul E was pretty much ignored in favour of slapping an ECW cap on Stephanie McMahon and pretending she was the new queen of extreme. This, rather annoyingly, was the WWF's latest way of ensuring that the McMahon family dominated everything. That wouldn't have been a problem had Steph been a neat fit, but she wasn't.
This remains one of 2001's worst ideas.
Fans of the original ECW were excited to see Heyman lead acts like Raven, Tommy Dreamer, The Dudley Boyz, Tazz etc against Vince McMahon's juggernaut. Instead, they got more family in-fighting and Paul E stepping aside so Steph could kid on she watched Hardcore TV in the 1990s.
4. WCW’s Invasion
ECW was only drafted in because WCW's own invasion was crap, to be fair.
News spread like wildfire that the WWF had purchased the competition in March 2001. Fans immediately started drafting up dream matches like Sting vs. The Undertaker, Goldberg vs. Steve Austin and Ric Flair vs. Triple H. Two of those bouts would never happen.
Top stars like Flair, Sting and Goldberg didn't roll onto WWF programming first. Nah, it was the likes of Lance Storm and Hugh Morrus who received that honour. How did they land body blows on the fed? Well, erm...Storm gatecrashed Steve Blackman and Trish Stratus vs. Perry Saturn and Terri Runnels for starters.
Yeah, this was nowhere near big enough to kickstart the invasion angle properly. It came across as second-rate; wouldn't it have made more sense for Lance to attack high-profile WWF stars rather than running in on a midcard inter-gender bout that lasted three minutes?
Awful.
3. WWE ECW’s Weekly TV
Paul Heyman deserves immense praise for hiding the weaknesses of his roster during the original ECW days. Acts like The Sandman, Tommy Dreamer and more played to their strengths, and the cult-like devotion of the group's (literally) hardcore following got people talking.
Following back-to-back One Night Stand specials, WWE decided to revive ECW full-time as a third brand behind Raw and SmackDown in 2006. Many had doubts about Vince McMahon's ability to book an extreme product people wanted to see, and rightly so - the debut edition laid bare McMahon's vision for a WWE-ified version.
Rotten gimmicks like "The Zombie" and other supernatural silliness (booked solely because the show was on the old Sci-Fi channel) disturbed high hopes for an ECW comeback. The weekly was ECW in name only, and eventually turned into a show similar to old 'C' level programming like Heat or Velocity.
Then, in 2010, Vince took it off the air for good.
2. The Summer Of CM Punk
Time for a little history lesson.
CM Punk's “Pipebomb Promo” was great. His WWE Title win over John Cena at Money In The Bank 2011? Wonderful. Then, the way Punk blew a kiss at an irate Vince McMahon before walking out on WWE was amazing. It really didn't take WWE long to ruin things from there.
Instead of talking about Punk's departure with the belt and the impact it'd have on company business, McMahon announced a mini-tournament to crown a new champ. Rey Mysterio won that, then the strap ended up on Cena in time for a rematch with Punk at SummerSlam. Again, things got worse despite their in-ring brilliance.
Alberto Del Rio cashed in his MITB briefcase to win the title from Punk in August, and Kevin Nash got involved to help CM spin off into a rivalry with Triple H. People remember the "Summer Of Punk" fondly, but it was a nightmare saga of poor decisions in retrospect.
1. Hulk Hogan’s WWF Comeback
Memories of the p*ss poor invasion angle were still fresh when the WWF started taking advantage of lapsed contracts with AOL/Time Warner to bring ex-WCW megastars to the promotion in 2002. The nWo arrived in February, and they were presented as a weapon Vince McMahon could use in his power struggle with Ric Flair.
Sorry, what?! WCW's rebellious anti-authority renegades were an instrument of destruction for McMahon? That was a shoddy enough idea, but it was made even worse by the fact WWF fans didn't want Hollywood Hogan. No, they wanted the good old red and yellow of 'Hulkamania'.
Hulk's first appearances for the company since 1993 were crushed by his nWo affiliations. Fans voiced their opinions loudly - they wanted nostalgia, and they wanted their Hulk Hogan back. Kevin Nash and Scott Hall were just getting in the way with all this "4 life" stuff.
At least they fixed it, but the nWo invasion between Feb-March was a wobble.
When else has WWE ruined something instantly? For more like this, check out WWE 2K23: 13 Best Female CAWs You Must Download and 10 WWE Stars Who Turned Into EVERYTHING They Hated!