10 Times WWE Got The Royal Rumble Main Event Wrong

The Jekyll and Hyde of wrestling shows.

Kurt Angle Mark Henry
WWE.com

While giving us some of the best WWE memories of the last 30 years, the Royal Rumble as a show is also notable for about a dozen pretty disappointing or anti-climactic finishes.

Generally, these come about when the company selects the "wrong" wrestler to headline WrestleMania - we're looking at you, Roman Reigns - although it's by no means confined to the Rumble match itself; sometimes, the World Title match in the spot of main event can be a dud, too.

In a way, we've only ourselves to blame. We often go into the Royal Rumble giddy with excitement, ready to usher in the beginning of WrestleMania season and get a glimpse of the match-ups that might await us on the Grandest Stage of Them All.

We're kids on Christmas morning, basically, and Vince McMahon is our dad. More often than not, he thinks his entire audience have been naughty boys and girls.

10. Royal Rumble 2012

Sheamus Royal Rumble 2012
WWE.com

Sheamus is a really good wrestler and, so far as we're aware, a stand-up guy to boot - but, when you look at the things he's achieved during his decade on the WWE payroll, does it not seem like he's punched slightly above his weight?

In addition to being a four-time World Champion, and a former King of the Ring winner, the Celtic Warrior has also managed to put his name in the elite list of wrestlers to have won the Royal Rumble, courtesy of his victory in 2012.

It didn't really make a huge amount of sense either. Sheamus, at the time, was neither an up-and-comer nor a truly established main eventer, making his win neither fresh nor particularly exciting (except for those who really love the fella).

Worse, it set up one of the most disappointing title matches in WrestleMania history, by which we of course refer to his 18-second triumph over Daniel Bryan, whose camera-time was cut short because Triple H and Undertaker needed 10 minutes each to make their entrances.


9. Royal Rumble 1989

Big John Studd
WWE.com

Two names from the list of Royal Rumble winners stand out like a sore thumb, those being the first two: Jim Duggan and Big John Studd. Put differently, the only two besides Shinsuke Nakamura who never held world title gold (and that includes Vince McMahon himself).

But at least the former, with his trusty 2x4 and endearing (if slightly annoying) catchphrase, was pretty popular. His triumph in the inaugural Rumble in '88 didn't catapult him to the main event, but he stuck around long enough to become an important member of the roster, that victory being his claim to fame.

Studd, on the other hand, actually departed the company in 1989, the same year that he won the Rumble, making all the effort they had put into pushing him as one of the WWF's next breakout stars count for precisely nothing.

Granted, they couldn't have predicted that he would up sticks at the turn of the year - but they generally don't allow wrestlers to leave for reasons as petty as wanting a bigger cut of the pie if they truly believe they have a future at the top of the show.

However you spin it, this was a failure, embryonic paradigm or no.


8. Royal Rumble 2017

Randy Orton Royal Rumble 2017
WWE

Randy Orton: Two-Time Royal Rumble Winner actually sounds about right. Whatever his foibles, the Viper is clearly a top tier star who deserves most of the opportunities that have come his way over his lengthy WWE tenure.

But 2017 was perhaps not the right time. Orton was only peripherally involved in the SmackDown main event scene after the return of the brand extension, his highlight of the previous year being the time he got his head cracked open by Brock Lesnar.

There was some intrigue growing around his storyline with Bray Wyatt, to be fair, but was that not more to do with the Eater of Worlds, who seemed finally to be on the cusp of the main event, than Orton himself?

Ultimately, he went on to accomplish very little during the rest of the year. After winning the title from his former leader at WrestleMania, he held it for all of a month before losing three matches on the spin to Jinder Mahal. It wasn't a great 12 months for him, and someone else could have used this spot instead.


7. Royal Rumble 2011

Alberto Del Rio Royal Rumble
WWE.com

Whether or not Alberto Del Rio ever really had the credentials to be WWE's leading man is perhaps still a bone of contention, but ultimately, he was the man the hierarchy earmarked as their next breakout star in 2011.

You can't really criticise that too much. Del Rio was clearly a huge talent, both in terms of his ability in the ring and his presence and charisma out of it. He was fast-tracked to the top, but it was fresh and new; on paper, exactly the kind of person you want to win the Rumble.

The problem is more the booking of the match itself. Specifically, Santino Marella being the runner-up, thinking for a second he could win the thing after catching his opponent unawares during his premature celebrations.

This looked less like the ending of a Royal Rumble than it did a TV battle royal to crown the next Intercontinental or United States Champion, and if they wanted us to take Del Rio seriously as a future star, he really should have won it by eliminating a big fish - not simply a comedy jobber.


6. Royal Rumble 2016

Triple H Wwe Champ
WWE.com

Because of his close association with the McMahon family, Triple H takes a lot of undeserved flak. He merited his spot as the winner of the 2002 Royal Rumble, for instance, and though his subsequent Monday Night Raw reign of terror wasn't to everyone's taste, he was undeniably one of the company's top guys.

When it comes to his triumph in the 2016 Rumble, however, it's hard to put up much of a defence. He was 46 at the time, as old a winner we had seen since his future father-in-law chucked out Stone Cold in '99, and his ability to put on great matches was by then greatly diminished.

While this decision was obviously taken in order to help reignite some of the fan support for Roman Reigns, there were surely other, younger heels who could have fulfilled the same purpose - among them Bray Wyatt and Kevin Owens.

The worst part is they clearly didn't have complete faith that any of that would work - hence why Dean Ambrose ended up finishing runner-up instead of Roman.

That ensured The Game would at least actually be booed a little when he became the last man in the ring.


5. Royal Rumble 1993

Yokozuna Randy Savage Royal Rumble 1993
WWE.com

You can probably say with a degree of confidence that Yokozuna was the least likely of all the Royal Rumble winners to put on a five-star classic (and yes, once again, that does include Vince McMahon himself).

And though it's probably true that judging him through the lens of today's wrestling is slightly unfair - the early '90s was a time when the WWE product in particular was altogether more cartoonish and kid-friendly - that fact doesn't change.

He was an attraction more than anything else. A mightily impressive one (not too many other 500-pounders can do a belly-flop from the turnbuckle), but a freak show attraction all the same, and one that should have been kept at an appropriate distance from the main event.

That's one school of thought anyway, but in 1993 WWE decided that he was the man to win a Royal Rumble featuring the likes of Ric Flair, Undertaker, Mr Perfect and Randy Savage, and then go on to beat Bret Hart at WrestleMania IX.

It was a dark time.


4. Royal Rumble 1999

vince mcmahon royal rumble 1999
WWE.com

No-one can have any complaints about the match-up which headlined WrestleMania XV. The Rock versus Steve Austin was the feud that defined the Attitude Era, and a fitting headline fight for the Grandest Stage of Them All.

How we got there, though, was perhaps a little questionable - at least as pertains to Vince McMahon, a 53-year-old businessman whose experience in the ring mainly consisted of him being stunnered once or twice, winning the Royal Rumble.

We get it: it's wrestling, and things aren't to be taken too seriously. Vince was an excellent character, and the yin to Stone Cold's yang; it made for an interesting twist on their relationship, and presumably had fans eager to tune into Raw the next night. But WCW got absolutely pelted for daring to put its biggest prize on the arm of civilians like David Arquette and Vince Russo, decisions that were said to have destroyed much of its credibility as a major wrestling promotion.

The WWE chairman may have bigger biceps than either of them, but this really isn't all that different.


3. Royal Rumble 2013

The Rock sharpshooter CM Punk Royal Rumble 2013
WWE.com

If you manage to convince The Rock to take time out of his now-primary career shooting Hollywood movies to appear on a WWE pay-per-view, you put him in the headline match. No complaints there.

But having him beat CM Punk? That was a bone of contention for a lot of die-hard wrestling fans, who viewed it as inherently damaging to the credibility of the WWE Championship for the man who had held the belt for 434 days to lose it to a part-timer.

It also confirmed to us, as if there was ever any real doubt, that WrestleMania 29's main event would be a straight-up rehash of the previous year's go-home encounter, meaning that the Straight Edge Superstar, off the back of a stellar 18 months, would be left out in the cold.

This seemed personally unfair to Punk himself, but more than that, it was a source of great disappointment for the audience. They would have been far more excited for 'Mania if its marquee match featured the man many saw as the best in the world instead of - or at least in addition to - a pair of aspiring movie stars who could drum up a little mainstream press coverage.


2. Royal Rumble 2006

Kurt Angle Royal Rumble 2006
WWE.com

Criticism of the 2006 Royal Rumble traditionally lingers on whether it was right that Rey Mysterio's push should have invoked the memory of Eddie Guerrero in the aid of some cheap cheers - but that match didn't close out the night.

Instead, it was a World Heavyweight Championship bout between Kurt Angle and Mark Henry, a match that was as thrown together as they come, the Olympic Gold Medallist having only been on the same brand as his challenger for a matter of days.

The reason this went on last, so we would eventually learn, was so that Undertaker could come out after the final bell and give Angle the fright of his life. They couldn't have done this in the penultimate match, partly because it meant breaking the ring, and partly because it would have been awkward if the Deadman had to sheepishly turn and walk (or ride) to the back after staring down his opponent so intensely.

The ramifications of not putting Rey Mysterio's Royal Rumble triumph on last were pretty serious, though. It signalled to the audience that the company viewed his WrestleMania coronation as a secondary story, a trend that would be observed right up to the day itself.


1. Royal Rumble 2014

Batista Royal Rumble 2014
WWE

In much the same way that Shawn Michaels dominated 1996 and Stone Cold Steve Austin 1998, 2014 was Daniel Bryan's year - to everyone, that is, except those in charge of booking the show.

Despite clearly being the most over member of the WWE roster, Bryan was overlooked for the position of Royal Rumble winner in favour of a returning Batista, who was supposed to fly back into our lives after a three-year absence as though nothing had changed in the intervening time.

Things had changed, though. Big Dave was still a veritable superstar, of course, but his popularity among the die-hards wasn't such that he could jump right into the spot of the 'Mania main event, particularly when there was such a capable understudy waiting in the wings.

By doing this, the company had passed up a very presentable opportunity to make right all of those booking wrongs that had befallen everyone's favourite everyman, going right back to his 18-second defeat by Sheamus at WrestleMania XXVIII.

Fans weren't just upset at his snub, but vocally angry - and the mistake was clear to all as soon as Batista emerged the following night on Raw.


Watch Next


Contributor