10 Times WWE Got The Royal Rumble Winner Wrong
How do you ruin your company's year in its very first month? Here's how...
The Royal Rumble is always one of WWE's most hotly-anticipated events of the year, even when the outcome looks predictable. The promise of grand returns, comebacks, and monstrous Iron Man runs makes the Rumble an annual highlight.
WWE love pushing the idea that literally anybody can win the Rumble, and while the victor is usually someone who's already in the main event scene, the phrase is truer than ever with WWE's ever expanding roster.
It's absolutely vital that WWE pick the right winner, however. The Rumble sets the tone for the company's entire year, and particularly WrestleMania. Make the right call, and WWE will start 2022 with a bang, but get it wrong and WrestleMania 38 might be doomed before it even starts.
Unfortunately, WWE don't have the best track record when it comes to the Rumble, and history is littered with failed victors. Here are 10 times WWE got the Royal Rumble winner wrong.
10. Triple H (2016)
The 2016 Royal Rumble was actually one of WWE’s finer efforts in recent years, but the match’s quality often gets lost in the muck surrounding its chief narrative. It was blatantly obvious heading into the event that Triple H would enter the match and cost Roman Reigns the WWE Championship, and so it transpired.
This was the first time the gold had been on the line in a Rumble match since 1992, and while WWE continued to push the “anything can happen” narrative, there was only going to one winner. The previous weeks had made it clear that WWE were attempting to recreate their classic Austin vs. McMahon storyline with Triple H as the evil boss and Reigns as the anti-hero, and it flopped completely.
Triple H’s win was acceptable only from an “anyone but Roman” standpoint, and as a company executive and part-time wrestler held the belt aloft, it felt very much like WWE were rubbing their fans’ faces in the dirt. The outcome doomed audiences to several months of turgid television leading up to one of the most tedious main events in WrestleMania history. Reigns vs. Triple H was a slow, plodding 30-minute match that felt at least thrice as long, and Roman’s eventual coronation closed it on the sourest of notes.
9. Steve Austin (1997)
There’s no denying that Stone Cold Steve Austin is one of the greatest Royal Rumble performers of all-time, and 1997 was clearly his best performance. The match saw Austin eliminate an astonishing 10 wrestlers en route to cheating his way to victory, and while this was unquestionably the biggest match of his WWE career up to that point, the finish (and aftermath) was a convoluted mess.
WWE tried to inject some creativity into the finish by having Hart toss Austin from the ring, only for the officials to completely miss it. Realising this, Austin snuck back into the ring and eliminated the celebrating Hart, who thought he had the match won. Hart was rightly fuming, and things only got more confusing from thereon.
Austin had his WrestleMania title shot taken away from him amidst the controversy, and Hart became WWE Champion at In Your House 13: Final Four, only to drop the belt to Sycho Sid one day later. Thus resulted in the famous submission match between Hart and Austin at WrestleMania 13, while Sid lost his title to The Undertaker.
If this was the endgame all along, then what was the point in Austin cheating his way to victory in the first place? Not only did this completely nullify the Royal Rumble’s outcome, but it stands as one of the most stupefying examples of overbooking in WWE history.
8. Sheamus (2012)
It’s too easy to rag on Sheamus. His career has found a second wind thanks to his fantastic partnership with Cesaro, but for most of his career, the big Irishman has been one of the most maligned wrestlers in WWE. So over-pushed and overexposed was Sheamus that he’d started generating the dreaded “X-Pac heat” from fans who just flat-out didn’t want to watch him perform, and this was never worse than in 2012.
Heading into the Royal Rumble, Chris Jericho was the biggest heel on the planet. His flashy light-up jacket and trollish antics had put him back on the path to glory, and at the Rumble, Jericho promised to “end the world.” All signs pointed towards him walking out the victor, and even though he was playing villain at the time, nobody would have complained had we won. Jericho was still close to his peak as a wrestler, and he’s always been in a league of his own as far as character work goes. His victory was a logical decision, and the fans would have eaten it up.
It’s not like Vince McMahon to listen to his fanbase, however, and Jericho was unsuccessful. Entering at number 29, Jericho made it to the final two, but was eventually eliminated by Sheamus, who’d been in the ring for close to half an hour. This, of course, led to Sheamus’ infamous 18-minute squash of Daniel Bryan at WrestleMania, and a lengthy World Heavyweight Championship reign that nobody wanted.
7. Hulk Hogan (1990)
What’s that? “Hulk Hogan triumphing at the expense of younger, hungrier talent?” Surely not...
Hogan was still at the height of his powers in 1990. As the wrestling world’s undisputed biggest star, he made vince McMahon more money than anybody else, and without his peak run, WWE wouldn’t be the beast it is today. That being said, there was absolutely no need for him to win the 1990 Rumble, and WWE missed a great chance to elevate the fast-rising Mr. Perfect here.
The Hulkster was already a franchise player, and winning here did nothing for anybody. Perfect, meanwhile, had debuted with a significant winning streak. He was immensely over as a heel, and his technical skills were second to none. A big Royal Rumble victory would have sent him over the top and made him the main event player that he seemed destined to become, but his second-place finish saw him last just 3:32 in the match.
This was also the match in which Hogan and the Ultimate Warrior first ignited their legendary rivalry, and a Warrior victory would’ve added bags of heat from the get-go. Unfortunately, WWE took the easy option in 1990. Hogan’s dominance continued when he won the match again in 1991, and in 1992, Hogan was only eliminated through a lapse in concentration. Talk about over-protection...
6. John Cena (2013)
Both of John Cena’s Royal Rumble victories were bitter pills to swallow for his vast army of haters, but at least 2008 came under softer circumstances. Sidelined with a serious injury several months prior, it was touch and go as to whether Cena would make it back for WrestleMania, let alone the Rumble. His sudden appearance produced a massive pop in Madison Square Garden, and like him or not, it’ll go down as one of the best surprise returns in Rumble history.
Unfortunately, there’s almost nothing favourable about his win in 2013. His “One In A Lifetime” match against The Rock was a huge WrestleMania success the previous year, so of course WWE decided to run it into the ground. Vince McMahon decided there had to be a rematch, and thus, The Rock defeated CM Punk to become WWE Champion as a part-timer, and John Cena won the Royal Rumble.
Thus began the joyless slog to WrestleMania, and “Once In A Lifetime 2.” The next few months saw The Rock at his obnoxious worst in the lead-up to the big event, and their return match fell almost entirely flat. John Cena vs. The Rock 2 headlined WrestleMania 29, but the magic was gone, and by the time Cena’s hand was raised in victory, most fans were just glad it was over.
5. Lex Luger (1994)
If ever confirmation in Vince McMahon’s lack of faith in Bret Hart as WWE’s “top guy” was needed, here it is. The 1994 Royal Rumble was a mess, and if the rumours are to believed, WWE hadn’t even decided upon a winner until hours before the show. The result was Hart sharing the victory with Lex Luger at a time fans were crying-out for Hart to be recognised as the company’s rightful franchise player, but The Hitman had that moment taken away from him.
The match ended with Luger and Hart simultaneously hitting the floor, but the replays were inconclusive. Thus, WWE President Jack Tunney came to the ring and had Howard Finkel announce both men as the winner, with Hart eventually going-on to wrestle for the title at WrestleMania X.
1994 turned out to be Hart’s only Rumble victory, and in making him share the prize, WWE completely undermined the blood, sweat, and tears he’d poured into his run. He was, fortunately, able to become a genuine megastar by the end of the year, but it should have come a whole lot earlier, and a Rumble win would’ve been instrumental in helping Hart escape his late-1993 slump.
Instead, Bret’s second run as WWE Champion came off as a fluke, and this period is a big reason why never achieved the same levels of fame as guys like Hulk Hogan and Steve Austin.
4. Big John Studd (1989)
If ever there was a time for Hulk Hogan to win the Royal Rumble, this was it.
1989 was WWE’s second televised Royal Rumble, and for the second year in a row, the company crowned an utterly pointless winner. The match saw WWE increase the number of participants from 20 to the now-standard 30, but it remains blighted by an entirely forgettable winner in Big John Studd.
Studd entered the match at number 27, and made short work of Akeem the African Dream. It was down to him and Ted DiBiase in the end, and with Big John crowned the winner, it looked like a big push was on the horizon. It wasn’t: this match took place before Rumble winners were guaranteed a title shot, and Studd received no reward for his efforts. WWE did precisely nothing with him in the aftermath, and his WrestleMania V contribution was restricted to a guest referee spot in Jake Roberts vs. Andre the Giant.
At least Hogan’s victory would have popped the crowd. Similarly, WWE Champion Randy Savage would have made a logical winner, particularly given how his ongoing story with Hogan dominated the match’s narrative, but no. WWE plucked a winner completely out of leftfield, and while the company love to push the idea that “anyone can win” the Royal Rumble, 1989 proves that this isn’t always a good thing.
3. Roman Reigns (2015)
For Roman Reigns’ critics, Royal Rumble 2015 was the night he jumped the shark. The Rock’s most maligned cousin always looked like the Shield member most likely to be pushed to the stars following the group’s inevitable demise, and so it transpired. By the end of 2014, Reigns was well on his way to inheriting John Cena’s competition-crippling Superman push, and the 2015 Rumble was his coronation.
It didn’t help that the fans’ preferred winner, Daniel Bryan, was eliminated in depressingly swift fashion towards the middle of the match. In hindsight, Bryan winning wouldn’t have worked-out in the long-run thanks to his injury problems, but anyone would’ve been preferable to Reigns. He entered the match to a big chorus of jeers at number 19, and by the end, the audience were praying for literally anyone else to win.
Fan favourites Dolph Ziggler and Dean Ambrose were unceremoniously mopped-up by Kane and Big Show, and even Rusev, one of the company’s biggest heels at the time, was cheered over Roman. In the end, Reigns eliminated the Bulgarian Brute to crown himself the Rumble winner, and as The Rock held his hand up in victory, Reigns received the first monster anti-pop of his career.
WWE went some way to righting this wrong by having Seth Rollins cash-in his Money In The Bank briefcase during Reigns vs. Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania, but in the moment, Reigns’ 2015 Rumble triumph was disastrous for WWE’s early-year momentum.
2. Batista (2014)
As far as universally rejected Royal Rumble winners go, few can top Batista. Big Dave was booked incredibly poorly upon returning to the company, and while almost none of it was his fault, his comeback remains a low-point in WWE’s recent history.
The 2014 Royal Rumble should have belonged to Daniel Bryan. The Yes! Movement was at its most popular, and fans were screaming out for the plucky underdog to finally be elevated as WWE’s top guy. From his heinous firing following the Nexus’ debut angle to his 18-second loss to Sheamus, Bryan had been continually humiliated, embarrassed, and swept under the rug throughout his run, but the fans rallied around him like none other.
Bryan was the most popular wrestler in the company, and after being wasted in a match with Bray Wyatt earlier in the evening, he seemed a dead cert to enter the Rumble. The clock ticked down, countless wrestlers entered the match, and by the time Rumble hit number 30, anticipation was through the roof.
What happened? Rey Mysterio’s music hit, he suddenly became the most hated man in the city, and Bryan was nowhere to be found.
WWE fortunately realised their gargantuan error and eventually gave Bryan his career-defining moment at WrestleMania 30, but that doesn’t right the Rumble’s wrongs. This was one occasion where listening to the fans was absolutely the right thing for WWE to do, and their actions in the aftermath prove it. Unfortunately, this snub closed the 2014 Royal Rumble in depressing fashion, and set the year off to a terrible start.
1. Mr. McMahon (1999)
WWE’s insistence on pushing their authority figures to the forefront remains one of the fanbase’s biggest complaints. The McMahons and Triple H are comfortable the most consistently pushed performers in the company, and it continues in 2017, with Stephanie taking-up more airtime than most of Raw’s wrestlers.
It was at least semi-justifiable in the Attitude Era, however, when Vince McMahon vs. Steve Austin was wreslting’s hottest feud. The rivalry not only put Stone Cold over as a legendary anti-authority rebel, but its success helped steer WWE through the Monday Night Wars’ choppy waters, and without it, there’s a strong chance WWE wouldn’t be here today.
Regardless, nothing excuses Vince McMahon winning the Royal Rumble. Him entering the match was fine, and the training skits with him and his son Shane produced some genuinely hilarious television in the lead-up. Vince was entering at number two to prevent Austin from winning the match, and he was doing everything he could to ensure he was successful.
Most of the match saw Vince sit outside the ring and hide from the rampaging Austin. Just when Stone Cold thought he’d won the match, however, Vince returned to the match and tossed him out. It’s one of the most shockingly vain booking decisions that he has ever made, and it proved pointless in the long-run. Vince declined the opportunity to face his Corporate champion The Rock at WrestleMania, and Stone Cold headlined the show regardless.