10 Times WWE Got Their Own BAD Ideas WRONG

Terrible WWE creative ideas on paper, but somehow even WORSE in execution.

Ronda Rousey WWE Wrong
WWE

Bad ideas are bad ideas, but something that looks awful on paper can sometimes become even worse in execution. WWE has learned that the hard way numerous times over the years, and it's always a painful lesson (albeit one pro wrestling refuses to learn from!). In fairness, and as a mini-addendum to that bracketed point, the company probably figures most things are worth trying at least once.

One entry from this list is the exception here - it just shouldn't have happened, and there's no way WWE will ever try anything of the sort again. The fact it's still out there for people to revisit is a stain on industry history. Honestly, it was a shockingly rotten example of using real-life issues for publicity, tackling them poorly and wrecking a wrestler's momentum.

You won't be surprised to see it bag the number one spot.

Big names like Triple H, Ronda Rousey, Vince McMahon and more are all included. They were either responsible for, or suffered through, some of the dirt worst scheming from WWE writers ever. Incredibly, what looked crap in theory got even more miserable once it hit TV.

10. The Gobbledy Gooker Hatches

Gobbledy Gooker Hatches
WWE.com

Far from egg-cellent.

That'd sum up the curious case of The Gobbledy Gooker. Teasing what was inside a giant egg was an erm...curious way to hype Survivor Series 1990, but it might've been cool had some vicious heel torn out of the thing to destroy a babyface and kick off the fed's next hot feud. Of course, that didn't happen.

Instead, a dancing turkey jigged with Gene Okerlund as ringsiders looked on wondering why they'd fallen for the WWF's promotion before this awful pay-per-view reveal. Poor Hector Guerrero had to dress in the awkward outfit and do his best to entertain. The dude was fighting a losing battle from the get go.

Look, having someone else on the roster break free from the shell and ambush an opponent would've been silly, but at least it might've led to something else. The Gooker's debut is roundly regarded as one of the lowest WWF/WWE moments ever, and rightly so.


9. Chyna & Y2J Are “Co-Champions”

Chris Jericho Chyna
WWE.com

WWE has tried on the co-champions gimmick a bunch over the decades, but few examples remain more egregious than Chyna and Chris Jericho holding the Intercontinental Title together. Both worked a double pin on the 30 December 1999 edition of SmackDown, and feigned shock at being announced as co-champs on the following Raw.

This was a wonky way to gift Jericho his first title reign in the WWF, but things only got worse heading into the new millennium. Creative's co-champion idea lasted less than a month; the company ended their experiment at the Royal Rumble by booking Jericho to win a three-way that also involved Hardcore Holly.

So much for that.

The whole thing was an opportunity missed, and turned out to be a completely rudderless exercise that barely scratched the surface on these twin champs coexisting. It feels like the writers got every step of this story wrong. It didn't help 'Y2J', it didn't help Chyna, and Holly's involvement was too random to matter.


8. WWE’s “Greatest” Royal Rumble

Braun Strowman Greatest Royal Rumble
WWE.com

In 2018, WWE let money do the talking, and very nearly spoiled one of their most cherished traditions in the process. Saudi Arabian royalty footed the bill for a first ever pay-per-view in the country, and they demanded something massive. So, Vince McMahon decided to give them the "Greatest" Royal Rumble.

There's a reason for those inverted commas!

The main attraction was an interminable 50-man Rumble that promised to be the "Greatest" one in WWE history. Spoiler alert: It bloody wasn't. Braun Strowman won the thing, but the match is perhaps only slightly memorable for Daniel Bryan going a whopping 1 hour and 16 minutes in the match.

That was wasted effort, and the belt Braun got was wasted craftsmanship. It was never really seen again, and may even have been left over in Saudi as a token gesture. WWE risked insulting fans and the legacy of their actual Royal Rumble with this move.

Oops.


7. Brawl For All's Inconsistencies

Brawl For All
WWE.com

A shoot fighting tournament on WWF TV was a terrible concept to begin with, but the guys involved worked wrestling matches on the side whilst the tourney was in progress. So, it just sorta looked like they were play fighting in between Brawl For All fights, and that was maddening even for fans in 1998.

Here's an example: Bart Gunn lost to Vader in a standard match on Sunday Night Heat, then boxed The Godfather 24 hours later on Raw. Make it make sense. The least anyone could've reasonably expected was that the writers would stick to their guns. Or, should that be “Gunns”?

Sorry.

Brawl For All was sh*te, but booking the guys in it to wrestle standard matches in between fights was bogus and more than a little ridiculous. It was as weird as it sounds to see Gunn go from bumping around for Vader to punching lumps out of people for real overnight.


6. Gable Steveson Is Kurt Angle 2.0…Honest!

Gable Steveson WWE NXT
WWE.com

WWE immediately hyped Gable Steveson as some hybrid second coming of Kurt Angle and Brock Lesnar, and that was a real error of judgement. Steveson was running before he could walk - you’d think the dude was a surefire future Hall Of Famer with the way everyone was banging on about him.

In the end, Gable had 17 matches in total, and only one was on TV. That came at NXT's Great American Bash 2023 vs. Baron Corbin. The bout was lambasted from all comers for exposing how much of an in-ring rookie this Olympian gold winner truly was. Even WWE gave up from there.

Tough. They'd set expectation levels impossibly high with their bullsh*t overhype.

Gable was released in early-May 2024, and he'll go down in history as one of the worst examples of erroneous hyperbole in wrestling. It was a bad idea from the off to tell people Gable was special before he knew what he was doing out there. He had no chance of living up to the Angle and Lesnar comparisons.


5. Ronda Rousey’s “Babyface” Return

Ronda Rousey WWE Royal Rumble 2022
WWE.com

Some people just don't get pro wrestling, and Ronda Rousey is one of them. Her spectacular online meltdown when fans started booing that first run in WWE was spoiled brat 101. It showed that Ronda didn't have the mentality to succeed in the industry. She wanted to be loved and adored, not play the role of a villain.

Sadly for Rousey, the bloom came off the rose early. Fans saw through her smiles and glimpsed an elitist mindset they didn't like. So, the boos rained down. WWE tried again by bringing Ronda back at the 2022 Royal Rumble and putting her over. She was cast as a babyface badass again, and...it quickly flopped.

Surprise, surprise eh?

The exact same problems which had blighted her first run followed Ronda into the second. WWE should've known better than to hang Rousey out to dry here. Casting her as an elitist heel, or something like that, would've been less of a stretch.

Being honest, bringing Ronda back at all was ill-advised.


4. The Misery Of The Corre

The Corre
WWE.com

Look at the absolute state of those t-shirts.

CM Punk seized power of Nexus from one Wade Barrett in late-2010, and that forced Barrett to whip up something new. So, he and fellow Nexus member Heath Slater and Justin Gabriel joined forces with Ezekiel Jackson to form The Corre. It was a stunningly rubbish name, and they had some limp merch to go along with it.

The Corre was woeful, and perfectly sums up that 'bad idea on paper, even worse in execution' thought. The group lasted approx six months before being mercy-killed by creative. Admittedly, their implosion did lead to some Intercontinental Title fun between Wade and big Zeke, but nobody should be fooled by that.

Being fair, Barrett leading an offshoot rebel group of ex-Nexus members against Punk's new faction could've worked out differently, but it wasn't to be. The Corre instantly resembled a B-level squad who barely even believed their own nonsense about being superior.


3. NXT's Original Run

WWE NXT Rookie Diva Challenge
WWE

No, not the current developmental brand model. The original 'reality" show version.

What should've been Tough Enough but with matches turned into a goofy excuse to humiliate rookies weekly and giggle at the silliest side of Vince McMahon's "sports entertainment" style. NXT went from "pros" mentoring rookies to some hazing special that made a mockery of WWE's own product between 2010-2012.

Bizarrely, it's like those penning this stuff didn't even realise they were ripping the p*ss out of themselves. Aspiring WWE stars took part in some unwatchable challenges (both verbal and physical) in lieu of, y'know, actually honing likeable/detestable characters or their skills inside the ring. It made the show hard to stomach.

The reality TV direction was bad enough, but WWE couldn't even get that right by focusing on relationships or dynamics between the cast. In short, they missed an easy layup and got NXT badly wrong. It's a miracle the current show was born from this rotten egg at all.


2. The “Wild Card Rule”

Vince McMahon Wild Card Rule
WWE.com

On the 6 May 2019 edition of Raw, Vince McMahon struggled to convince everyone that his new "Wild Card Rule" was worth their time. According to McMahon, up to three wrestlers from Raw would be able to appear on SmackDown every week, and vice versa. This was part of an extended "Superstar Shake-Up" (Draft style).

It sucked and WWE didn't stick to it. Simple as that.

Things got confusing immediately when Vince suddenly extended the available loophole jumps from three to four (without explaining why). Then, as if that wasn't laughable enough, the commentators expanded the number to seven, back to three, back to four and then just forgot about the whole thing.

2019 was a thoroughly dire year for company creative, but the "Wild Card" mess stuck out. Fans didn't pop for McMahon's hype during the announcement, and WWE found out once again than people don't really care for all this brand warfare stuff anyway.


1. Booker T Doesn't Overcome Racism?!

Booker T Triple H Wm 19
WWE.com

Using racism to build towards a WrestleMania match was an abhorrent call, but it happened. In 2003, Triple H started talking about how "people like you" (aimed at 'Mania foe Booker T) didn't belong on top of the card or in possession of the World Title. The insinuation was clear: WWE wanted to rally support behind Booker.

There were ways to do that without trying to use his skin colour.

Booker T has always been an engaging character. WWE didn't need to have Hunter get racist, because fans would've been right there with Book heading into the biggest show of the year. It was obvious he deserved a run on top; that was enough of a dangling carrot. Nah, creative had to go down the racism route instead. Yuck.

Then, they had the cheek to let Booker come up short. He failed to overcome the unnecessary race-baiting, and Trips remained champ even though everyone was sick and tired of his heel persona being on top by the spring of '03. What an appalling and depressing commentary on wrestling booking this was.

What other bad WWE ideas somehow got worse? For more wrestling, check out 10 Secret Wrestling Retcons You DEFINITELY Don't Remember and 10 Things That’d RUIN WWE’s 2024! 


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.