10 Times WWE Introduced Something Cool (Then Panicked And Took It Away)

THIS IS AWESOME!..wait, where did it go?

Dean Ambrose Asylum
WWE.com

In a dark time (known as 2020) when WWE feel that it is a better to make Braun Strowman gyrate with The New Day rather than have the monster demolish half of the roster, it is worth remembering that not every idea they introduce is immediately terrible.

Some have actually been quite awesome - or at least could have been - and fans have fully got behind many a new concept in the hope that it'll be around for the long run.

Unfortunately, that often doesn't happen.

In fact, Vince McMahon has had a tendency over the years to pull the rug from underneath a promising project on a whim and bury a show/segment/format simply because it was either not quite delivering what the boss expected or due to the fact that he'd typically lost interest in his new toy.

Whatever the frustrating knee-jerk reason, many refreshingly original entities have been stolen away from fans before they ever had a chance to reach their apex.

Perhaps McMahon was right to pull the plug on these projects which he felt had nothing left to give to his organisation. Or, maybe WWE could have benefited from these ten cool commodities over time and the company should hang their heads in shame for panic-culling these brilliant ideas.

We'll let you decide...

10. Fan Voted Stipulations/Outcomes

Undertaker Big Show Cyber Sunday
WWE

You'd think that in the social media heavy environment we currently inhabit in 2020, Vince McMahon would be all too happy to lean into the interactive worlds of Twitter and Facebook on a more regular basis.

Well, long before every man, woman, child or pet had an account to hurl abuse at their spandex wearing heroes, WWE had the brainwave to allow their loyal following to have control over what would be taking place at 2004's inaugural Taboo Tuesday - via polls on their website.

The voting began the night before the event and various stars/match types were brought into the fray depending on which wrestler/stipulation garnered the highest support from fans at home.

It was genuinely quite exciting to think that the audience had full control over who would be given the opportunity to fight for a world title or what style of brutality their favourites would have to suffer through.

However, after another Taboo Tuesday and a few Cyber Sunday PPV's, WWE seemed to lose a fair bit of interest in the notion and - aside from the odd Raw poll - they veered away from handing the decision making over to the watching faithful.

There's been no real reason revealed as to why McMahon has still consistently produced online polls on WWE's Twitter and website, without re-opening the door for some crowd chosen outcomes on any of his current weekly wrestling shows. So, hopefully this rash decision to hold back on this intriguing concept will be overruled soon enough.


9. Mixed Match Challenge

WWE Mixed Match Challenge 2
WWE.com

Speaking of WWE's social media presence, in recent times they decided to seriously engage with their audience on Facebook by introducing them to the Mixed Match Challenge on Facebook Watch in January 2018.

At first, many recoiled at the idea of yet another throw away show - in the same vein of a Superstars or Main Event - but fans quickly realised that this programme was being treated as a free hit by all those taking part.

Sami Zayn and Becky Lynch were allowed to indulge in their charismatic personalities - which were hidden on Raw and SmackDown at the time - and stars such as Alexa Bliss and Braun Strowman managed to get themselves even more over with the WWE Universe throughout the inter-gender tag tournament.

The fact that the winning team - in the original season - were also gifted $100,000 to give to their chosen charity, was the icing on the cake of a thoroughly enjoyable tonic to the sometimes gruelling main roster television.

Yet, after the second season had reached its conclusion and the charitable gift was replaced with a number 30 spot in the Royal Rumble/all expenses paid trip for each competitor, the show was stolen away in the night. This was probably down to poor viewing figures. As the top stars got injured throughout the tournament, WWE lost interest in the show and sadly so did the fans.

Stick to its original prize, commit to the premise and let the stars cut loose, Vince. You were onto a winner and it was taken away too soon.


8. 'The Electric Chair'

Sami Zayn AEW
WWE

With a microphone in their hand the likes of Sami Zayn have the capacity to create magic on any given night... that is, when they are given the leeway to do so.

However, as you're probably more than aware of at this point, most WWE stars don't often tend to be given this relaxed platform to let rip on Monday Night Raw or Friday Night SmackDown. In fact, if you were a new viewer of the programme, you'd probably struggle to differentiate between the characters on each show because everyone sounds so bloody similar.

That's why it was actually quite liberating to see Zayn be introduced as the first guest on the new 'The Electric Chair' segment on Raw in May 2019. With the fans in attendance being given a free platform to ask whatever questions came to their minds, Zayn had no choice but to wing it and answer honestly in-character.

One particular outburst about 'AEW' set the internet on fire, but the concept itself definitely opened the door up for stars to flex their creative muscles and directly engage with the WWE Universe.

Vince McMahon clearly didn't approve of the reaction to this segment and quickly pulled the plug on it.

If the boss introduced a few guidelines - in terms of things he definitely doesn't want to hear being mentioned on his product - there's no reason this idea couldn't prove to be a refreshing hit down the line.


7. SmackDown Live's Ranking System

Smackdown Top 10
WWE

Ranking systems are always a toughie, simply because they tend to involve a lot of constantly moving parts which are frequently changing up the pecking order.

If WWE were to fully stick to a ranking concept, as they attempted to in early 2018 on SmackDown Live, they would also have to establish early on what the benefit would be of placing high on the 'Top 10 List'. If you stayed in the mix for a few weeks or got to the top of the rankings on either of the men/women tables by the end of the month, perhaps that would open the door up for a championship opportunity for that star?

The aforementioned SmackDown 'Top 10 List' allowed the roster to vote for who they believed deserved a spot in the rankings and in doing so it felt a little like a popularity contest.

However, there was definitely potential in the idea and if WWE had introduced a scoring system based on wins and losses, the list - split into two gender specific tables - could have proved to be a success over time. Instead, Vince McMahon scrapped the idea quickly after its inception and we were back to second guessing who was rightfully next in line for a title match.


6. No Automatic Rematches

McMahon Family
WWE.com

This one actually lasted a couple of months and tore up an established clause which had been written into imaginary contracts for decades.

The automatic rematch had become such a staple of western wrestling that WWE fans had genuinely come to accept that if a champion had lost their belt at an event, it would only be a matter of time before they were gifted their inevitable rematch.

However, Vince McMahon would proceed to absolutely murder the concept of rematches by insisting that 'the feud must continue!' and series after dull, repetitive match series eventually clogged up WWE programming.

So, when the McMahon family wandered down the ramp in December 2018 on an episode of Monday Night Raw and announced that automatic rematches would be no more, a brave new world was briefly unleashed on the WWE Universe.

For a time, new match-ups were brought into the mix and fans were given the chance to see fresh stars challenge for top belts.

That was until WWE did what they always do and panicked when they were forced into thinking outside the box to produce new programmes on a more regular basis.

Just as recent as this past week on Monday Night Raw, (in a match we have seen A LOT in recent times) Rey Mysterio was gifted a rematch for the United States Championship after losing it just a few weeks earlier to Andrade at Madison Square Gardens - for reasons.

Stick to making your challengers earn their title shots and fans will invest in their pursuit of the gold that little bit more.


5. Immediate Post-Match Interviews

Kevin Owens Interview
WWE.com

There's something undoubtedly special about seeing a wrestler take part in a backstage interview so soon after being involved in an extremely taxing match.

Often these backstage segments can lead to glorious moments of improvisation and entire programmes can be set into motion off the back of a brief interview.

Yet, WWE fleetingly went one step further.

After the 2016 Brand Split, the company allowed their stars to be interviewed inside of the ring literally straight after their contests had ended and this led to some quite memorable exchanges, particularly the one between Renee Young and The Miz. That angle actually even led to a programme between Young's partner Dean Ambrose and Miz.

So, the concept looked as though it could have some legs if used in the right way and not necessarily as a constant way of starting up feuds.

However - minus the odd re-emergence - fans haven't been treated to these spur of the moment debriefs on a regular basis for some time. It seems as though Vince McMahon has done what he has become infamous for once more and instead of sticking with a promising notion in order to allow it the time to succeed, he killed the fledgling idea before it ever had a chance to fully get over.

One day he may decide that he misses this alternate approach to prodding his stars, and we'll be right back where we were in 2016.


4. The 2016 Draft Format

WWE Draft
WWE.com

Speaking of the 2016 Brand Split, WWE were actually onto a winner with this version of the draft, weren't they?

Using SmackDown as the platform for the one night event, fans were champing at the bit to see which brand each of their favourite talents would end up on. The fact that Raw and SmackDown's Commissioners/General Managers were given the luxury of hand picking and announcing their roster selections on the show, only added to the authentic feel of the concept.

If you were drafted first, this meant that you were literally the top commodity in the whole of the company and the performers who were drafted later on in the night then all had a readymade storyline grievance to work into their characterisation for the foreseeable future.

Yet, despite this 2016 format being quite successful and leading to incredible crowd popping moments - Finn Bálor's inclusions being a standout - WWE opted to scrap the idea in favour of the clunky two day Superstar Shake-Up a year later.

This felt like a panicky, spur of the moment decision to revamp the draft as a sparkly new commodity in order to try and make it feel fresh and distinct. It definitely did the latter, but it was distinctly crap in comparison to the 2016 system which had worked so well.

2019's Draft brought back the hand selected anticipation to a certain degree, but the decision to have Stephanie McMahon announce each pick on her lonesome led to the excitement being mutilated early in the show. If it wasn't broke you shouldn't have tried to fix it, WWE. You had the perfect Draft model right there in 2016.


3. Commissioner/General Manager Dynamic

Dean Ambrose Daniel Bryan Shane McMahon
WWE.com

Now, WWE often get rightly lambasted for overloading their product with way too many authority figures which are hell bent on chastising their rosters, to the point where those talents start resembling naughty school kids rather than, you know, professional wrestlers.

Yet, that doesn't mean that WWE are incapable of creating figures who can effectively lead a brand without over-stepping their boundaries.

Case in point, Shane McMahon (pre-Best in the World) and Daniel Bryan struck up a legitimately fantastic partnership as the ship-steerers of SmackDown Live from 2016 to 2018. The Commissioner/General Manager positions meant that Bryan would be given a more hands on role in setting up matches and overseeing the day-to-day (or show-to-show) aspects that went into keeping the show from capitulating. Meanwhile, McMahon only popped up when an important situation needed dealing with and felt like a bit of a big deal when he reared his head on the show... those were the days.

Paige was given the GM mantle for an extended spell (after Bryan remarkably came out of retirement) before the concept was scrapped completely, with Paige and Kurt Angle acting as the last GM's on either brand...for now.

WWE obviously felt that fans were rebelling against the idea of having these figures in such positions of prominence on weekly television. However, instead of trying to rediscover what made the Commissioner/GM partnership work so well on SmackDown (let's not mention Raw) WWE opted to quickly scrap the entire format and head in a completely new direction after WrestleMania 35.


2. Talking Smack

The Miz Daniel Bryan Talking Smack
network.wwe.com

Talking Smack, by all accounts, was a show that was being pretty well received by most of the fans who committed to sticking around after SmackDown Live or one of the blue brands PPVs to watch it. That is, right up until the show was finally sentenced to permanent death in early 2018.

Yet, the ludicrous decision to get rid of one of SmackDown Live's weekly highlights didn't make sense.

WWE had a panel style show where stars - who perhaps weren't given the time to broadcast their points of view on the main programme - had a chance now to cut freestyle promos and garner genuine fan support.

The Miz even managed to turn himself into one of the hottest commodities in the company, simply by calling out co-host Daniel Bryan on probably the most famous episode of the short-lived riot.

If WWE had just kept Renee Young on the show and maybe drafted in someone like Paige or even CM Punk (in the FOX WWE landscape) to helm the creation alongside her - instead of murdering another concept just because they felt trigger happy - there probably wouldn't have been any need to invent WWE Backstage.

Instead, the quirky off-the-cuff little parcel of joy was mercilessly dragged away from our screens and another excuse to tune into SmackDown Live went along with it.


1. Ambrose Asylum Match

Dean Ambrose Asylum
WWE.com

So, you either loved this match or hated it with every fibre of your being.

Either way, we only ever got one iteration of it and let's be honest, it was a lot cooler - at least in theory - than any other match type that had been introduced over the last couple of years.

WWE's Ambrose Asylum involved a variation of weapons being hung from the top of a steel cage. This meant that escape was impossible and those weapons could be used to achieve either a pin-fall or submission victory.

The match between Dean Ambrose and Chris Jericho at Extreme Rules 2016 didn't lean into its extreme potential enough and despite Chris Jericho's gruesome thumbtack bump, the whole thing felt like a bit of a missed opportunity.

However, instead of trying to re-introduce the match further down the line in a different context and allowing an alternative mix of superstars to go at it inside of the unique structure, WWE did what they always do.

If it doesn't work once, panic and lock it away forever.

Just imagine for a second if you had this type of match going down on an NXT show, with Finn Bálor and Tommaso Ciampa trying to brutalise each other with this delightful selection of tools hanging from the sky - and all inside of a steel cage.

Get it done, Triple H.


In this post: 
dean ambrose
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!