10 Times WWE Tried (And Failed) To Be Edgy
Some controversial/shocking WWE ideas were good. These ones... weren't!
WWE (and pro wrestling in general) has been hellbent on looking cool, hip and happening since the dawn of time. Mainstream media outlets rarely report on anything to do with the biz if they can help it, but when they do it's very much a 'look at what these cretins have been up to' sort of deal.
The heralded heights of 'Attitude' did manage to make the then-WWF a hot topic in pop culture, granted. Unfortunately, successes there tricked the company into chasing that controversial reaction for good, and there are few things worse than wrestling trying then failing to be edgy.
It's actually rather embarrassing when this happens.
Throughout the 1990s, 2000s, 2010s and even into the 2020's (it's enough to make one gag that it's the 20s again), WWE has produced content it thinks will capture casual imaginations or make headlines. Sometimes, it does, albeit for the wrong reasons.
Meanwhile, poor hardcore rasslin' fans are left wondering who thought any of this was a good idea in the first place? After all, why watch great wrestling when you can see someone mimic the Jackass/Dirty Sanchez boom, eh?
10. Brawl For All Is Real Fighting, Man!
The only good thing to come out of 'Brawl For All' was that killer tune the WWF used for it. In 1998, Vince Russo convinced Vince McMahon that having his stars punch one another in the face for real was a great use of valuable TV time on Raw. Word to the wise: It was not.
In fact, it was horrible.
There were several things wrong with trying to latch onto the shoot-fighting train. Firstly, announcers looked like goons for selling matches/angles elsewhere whilst having to repeat that 'Brawl For All' was "real". How stupid is that? If it's the only real segment on shows, does...that mean everyone else is just playing?
Secondly, numerous workers got very-real injuries because they were legitimately getting smacked around in real boxing fights. These 'Toughman' contests were a blight on programming, got several guys hurt, bored fans to death and failed to draw in the shoot-fight crowd anyway.
What a waste of time.
9. Raw Underground = Fight Club
WWE tried another approach in 2020.
Imagine over-the-top commentator Shane McMahon of 1999 Sunday Night Heat fame had started narrating worked MMA fights. That's what Raw Underground was, but it was also a clear tribute to Fight Club; the first rule of Raw Underground is that nobody watches Raw Underground.
This was something different for the show back then, sure, but it was also a poor replacement for proper character development, compelling storylines or anything else fans wanted when they tuned into the flagship. Worse, Shane turned everything comedic by constantly yelling things like, "BAM!" when a punch landed.
It was like he'd watched some old John Madden footage and thought his soundbites would fit a gritty underground fighting ring, which is a weird thought. WWE cancelled Underground pretty quickly, and everybody moved on from the experiment like it had never happened at all.
Get used to reading sentences like that, by the way.
8. Val Gets His Venis Sliced
Google "John and Lorena Bobbitt" for grim tales about everything from cutting off penises whilst someone sleeps to assault and sexual assault allegations. It's not funny, obviously, so trust pro wrestling to try and make light of a situation just because it was making news across the globe in the 1990s.
John and Lorena's incident happened in 1993. Five years later, following John's detour into pornography, the WWF had their very own porn star collide with some genitalia detachment of his own. Or, at least, that's what was erm...implied when Kaientai boss Wally Yamaguchi yelled, "I choppy choppy your pee pee" on Raw in '98.
Then, the guy brandished a sword and apparently chopped said "pee pee" clean off.
It's actually a minor miracle that Vince Russo didn't elect to stick a fake penis on a pole and have Venis wrestle Taka Michinoku for possession of it. Praise the wrestling Gods for leaving that one on the cutting room floor.
7. Mark Henry Slept With His Sister
Speaking of grim.
The reality TV boom of the early-2000s is still keenly felt. Seeing and hearing what real people get up to has changed television forever, and arguably not for the better. Now, instead of producing tightly-scripted fantasy dramas, execs are green-lighting Kev from Essex being a "proper lad", and it's often nauseating.
In 1999, the WWF decided to start injecting some "reality" of their own by revealing that Mark Henry had a sex addiction. This wasn't a new thing either, apparently. No, Mark confessed during therapy sessions that he'd lost his virginity when he just eight years old. To his own sister.
Casually, the future 'Sexual Chocolate' then admitted that he'd bumped uglies with sis just days before turning up for that week's Raw. Some folks choose to look back on this gimmick with misty-eyed nostalgia goggles, but it was just another bid to look shocking, edgy and controversial for the sake of it.
6. Hawk’s Alcoholism Is Ruining LOD
Ask most wrestling fans young or old to name a face-painted tag-team and they'll probs say The Road Warriors/Legion Of Doom. OK, so somebody out there will mention The Ascension just to get a giggle, but stick with it. LOD were the prototypical monster tag-team of the 1980s/90s.
Sadly, they were never booked with any consistency in the WWF. Their first run got too cartoony, and the second? Oh boy, the second. In 1998, Hawk's real-life addiction issues were played out as a storyline on TV, and it made literally everyone watching feel very, very awkward.
Christ only knows what it was like for the guys doing it.
Generally, bringing real-life substance abuse problems into fantasy land is a bad idea and wrestling companies should stop it immediately. Seeing Hawk slur his speech, hold back vomit on the ring apron and even attempt suicide on Raw was way too far for most folks watching.
5. Tommy Dreamer Mimics Dirty Sanchez
The alt subheading for this was: "Tommy Dreamer Is F*cking Disgusting".
In 2002, WWE's creative team produced some of the worst telly of all the times. There's another example to come later on the list (not Katie Vick - let's skip that for once!), but Dreamer takes centre stage for the time-being. His homage to Jackass/Dirty Sanchez was dreadful stuff.
So, what was the ex-ECW lieutenant up to? Well, Dreamer downed a cup of The Undertaker's tobacco spit, brushed his teeth with the same toothbrush his dog had used and chowed down on his own hair after a visit to the barber shop.
Such shock tactics unsurprisingly failed to get Tommy over with fans. What were they supposed to do? Believe the dude who eats hair had a shot at battling the big boys in main events? It was incredibly forced, and nowhere near as gripping as the silly/foul antics of the MTV regulars.
4. Joe Gacy Is Woke
Today, Joe Gacy stands tall as the leader of NXT group Schism. Before that, WWE tried to capitalise on real world events by turning Gacy into the third brand's very own "woke superstar". No, they didn't actually utter those words on TV (not to this writer's knowledge anyway), but it was implied.
The idea was that Gacy viewed the wrestling ring as "a safe space", and encouraged others to join him in his fight against male privilege. His promos were crammed full of buzzwords with little care for context, and it wasn't long before some online were voicing their displeasure at what WWE were trying here.
FOX News bashed the promotion for "spouting some of the trademark rhetoric of the woke left" and trying to appear edgy by doing so. Over time, WWE de-emphasised those aspects of Joe's character and started turning him into a standard egotistical heel who thinks he knows better than everyone else instead.
That was for the best.
3. Billy & Chuck’s Publicity Stunt
Go back to watch the wedding between Billy Gunn and Chuck Palumbo now and you'll understand why so many folks were horrified by it at the time. The tag-team's entire gimmick revolved around question marks over their sexuality - were Billy & Chuck a gay couple, or were they just pretending?
Yeah...
WWE's next move was to heavily promote a ceremony that'd see both guys tie the knot on SmackDown. Come the wedding, Billy and Chuck got cold feet on the whole thing and revealed that they'd been working a publicity stunt for attention. Overnight, they went from slapping each other's butts to...not doing that.
In years since, several have claimed that WWE missed the chance to positively promote homosexual characters on TV, but Billy and Chuck were walking stereotypes more than an attempt to portray realistic gay men long before the angle's closure.
The whole thing was a colossal failure, and one that p*ssed many people right off.
2. HLA
Yes, it's 2002 again. No, you shouldn't be surprised.
Not content with necrophilia (sorry for another Katie Vick nod) and pretend gay weddings, Vince McMahon decided his flagship broadcast needed some actresses pretending to be lesbians too. So, then-GM Eric Bischoff smiled the creepiest of smiles as he asked fans if they were "ready for some hot lesbian action".
As if by magic, several models strutted down the aisle and locked lips in-ring. It was crass, and took the sex appeal of the Divas to the next level without any care or consideration for how unwanted these segments were on Raw. They were flat out embarrassing, and they didn't even really deliver what was advertised.
Nobody's suggesting that WWE should've gone further, by the way. However, Bischoff's character suggested that lesbian sex was on the menu for that evening's show. It wasn't, and nor should it have been.
What the actual hell were they thinking with this insulting, exploitative garbage?
1. Brian Pillman Has A Gun
In wrestling, workers make violent threats all the time. That's kinda the point; WWE wants you to be interested in Wrestler A kicking Wrestler B's arse on pay-per-view, or vice versa. It's staged violence, and often ridiculous, but the product is predominantly grounded with some sort of knowledge that everything will be OK in the end.
Characters always come back for more, basically.
That's why it was so out-there to see Brian Pillman brandish a gun during his feud with old tag partner Steve Austin in 1996. Austin invaded Bri's home, so Pillman pulled out a handgun and waved it around before everything went dark, gunshots were heard and people panicked.
The USA Network were not happy with the WWF for trying to introduce guns to Raw. Steel chairs and other weapons? Sure, they're fine. A crazed man whipping out a gun to shoot his enemy dead? Nah, that was too far for USA, and the feud didn't really go anywhere in the end anyway.
When else has WWE tried and failed to be edgy and/or controversial? For more like this, check out 10 Crazy Recent WWE Pitches You Won’t Believe and 10 Wrestlers That Don’t Deserve To Be Hated!