10 Times WWE Tried To Be Edgy (And Failed Miserably)

When Rated-R Superstars make us reach for our starts with an R-Remote Control.

Vampire Shayna
WWE.com

WWE and good taste don't exactly go hand in hand. This much we know.

Almost from WWE's inception, Vince McMahon's sports entertainment juggernaut has relied on varying degrees of raunchy humour and shock value to pop ratings. During the Attitude Era, these tactics worked like a charm, luring horny teenagers like moths to a flame - a flame lit with "puppies" and beer baths, but a flame nonetheless.

Ratings surged, and WWE regained control of the Monday Night Wars from upstart WCW. Edginess had helped win the day - or so we thought. Life can't be all Stone Cold Stunners and Steveweisers, though. For every D-Generation X invading WCW, there was Mae Young birthing a hand.

Despite shifting towards a more family-friendly product in the years since the Attitude Era, WWE still relies on raw storytelling to further the occasional angle. It's in the name of their flagship show, after all. Sometimes it works; sometimes it shoots all over your patience. More often than not, WWE's attempts at edginess feel contrived and devoid of any genuine heat.

Whether they shamelessly exploited real-life personal problems or simply nauseated the audience, these moments set a course for edgier waters and got lost faster than Shawn Michaels' smile.

10. Raw Underground

Raw Underground, we hardly knew ye.

Unleashed on unsuspecting audiences in August, Raw Underground took viewers from the plush corridors of the Performance Center to a dank basement warehouse where the fighting was more real, more visceral, more, er, um, raw. It had potential, we'll give it that.

With Shane McMahon at the helm, the whole affair felt more akin to your UFC-loving dad's midlife crisis than an injection of reality into a bloated sports entertainment spectacle. Part Fight Club knockoff, part bizarre cult gathering, Raw Underground never really clicked. Nobody could buy that its bouts were anything but predetermined, and without the fun of sports entertainment, it was honestly just boring. Besides, does anybody care that much about fighting? Oh, right, your dad. Keep on truckin', pal.

On the bright side, Raw Underground was a unique way of showcasing new talent, particularly those normally lost in the doldrums of WWE's Performance Center. The monstrous Dabba-Kato was easily Raw Underground's brightest star, riding roughshod over the show's basement dwellers until getting Braun Strowman's hands. Shame about that. Someone really should've warned him about those things.

With Raw Underground's recent cancellation, we can only assume its dilapidated digs will transform from secret pit fighting compound to Shane McMahon's new man cave. Rule number one: don't touch the remote!


9. Shayna Baszler's Vampire Diary

Shayna Baszler's a monster. A terrific athlete with a legitimate mixed martial arts pedigree, Baszler hardly needs to rely on a cheap gimmick to look intimidating. We're never not scared of her, and that's not going to change anytime soon.

When Baszler debuted on Raw in February, setting her sights firmly on Becky Lynch, fans expected her to dominate the longstanding champion. They never expected her to resort to cannibalism like a stranded climber on Mount Everest, yet that's precisely what happened. After attacking Lynch and knocking her out with the Kirifuda Clutch, Baszler removed her mouth guard and bit her unsuspecting victim on the neck. Ooh, is someone hangry?!

Yes, it turned out the cage fighter was now a rage biter. As Baszler stood up, her mouth dripping in Lynch's supposed blood, the audience groaned with disgust. Even the Twilight fans in the crowd had seen enough.

It was tacky, it was gross, and it did nothing for Baszler, who was subsequently defeated by Lynch in surprise fashion at WrestleMania. As usual, WWE should've known better. Baszler didn't need this kind of bloody spectacle to prove she's an absolute unit. Save the vampires for Hollywood. Team Jacob, for the record.


8. Phil Brooks Talking To Paul Levesque

At the height of WWE's Summer of Punk, Triple H arrived like a wet blanket to cool WWE's red hot antihero, CM Punk. They don't call him "The Game" for nothing.

With Punk riding a wave of popularity following his legendary pipebomb, fans expected a clear path for him up the WWE mountain. Calling himself "the voice of the voiceless," Punk's promos resonated because they blurred fact and fiction, channeling his own frustrations as well as those of the WWE Universe.

When Triple H wanted a piece of the action, he and Punk played off their real-life tension. Punk felt perennially held back by Triple H, who in turn mocked him through obscure fitness terminology. Sick burn, though, Trips. We're pretty sure somebody in the back knew what skinny fat meant.

It was a feud laden with more cheese than a fondue pot, yet the most cringe-worthy moment came when, to demonstrate his hostility towards Triple H, Punk invoked their real names, declaring, "this is Phil Brooks talking to Paul Levesque." Monday Night Raw, are we right?

In fact, it was so raw Punk's microphone was cut - twice. Even Triple H feigned outrage, demanding answers from a hapless WWE staffer. "What is going on, Frank, huh?!" Sadly, no amount of acting could make this moment seem sincere. It just felt so forced. Sometimes the fourth wall is there for a reason.


7. The Eye For An Eye Match

Where do we even start with this one?

Rey Mysterio's never-ending feud with Seth Rollins reached dizzying levels of disgust during The Horror Show at Extreme Rules, when the two squared off in the instantly notorious Eye for an Eye Match.

The stipulation was as ludicrous as it was ill-conceived, with extracting your opponent's eye the only way to secure victory. Yes, you read that right. To win, Rollins or Mysterio had to gouge the other's eyeball out like the villain in a horror movie. WWE wasn't kidding around with that Horror Show name.

This was no surgical strike, though. Rather than target the other's eyeball with precision, the match consisted of Rollins and Mysterio relying on WWE's standard assortment of weapons, from kendo sticks to steel chairs.

The wrestling itself wasn't too shabby, but hearing Rollins periodically cry out, "I'm gonna get that eye, Rey," was a tough sell. As gross as it was, nobody was ever going to take this match seriously.

When Rollins used the pointy corner of some ringside steps to pop Rey's eye out, audiences were treated to the hilarious sight of a red and white ping pong ball. Don't worry, folks. His optic nerve was intact! Our patience, on the other hand? Well, that was severed a long time ago.


6. Choppy Choppy

Choppy Choppy Pee Pee
WWE.com

Making his debut in May 1998 as a pornographic film star turned wrestler, there was nothing subtle about Val Venis. Boasting vignettes featuring adult entertainer Jenna Jameson and a finishing move called the Money Shot, Venis appeared ready-made for teenage boys wanting to live out their adolescent fantasies.

With all that testosterone and flagrant towel waving, it wasn't long before Venis's promiscuity got him into trouble. Sure enough, Venis was soon thrust into a feud with the Japanese stable Kaientai over his affair with manager Yamaguchi-san's storyline wife.

Promising revenge, Yamaguchi-San showed up with a sword and salami to Monday Night Raw. You can probably let your imagination do the rest.

Although initially successfully in fending off Kaientai, Venis was betrayed by his tag team partner, Taka Michinoku, who revealed that he was, in fact, Mrs. Yamaguchi-san's brother. What a twist! This led to the angle's most memorable moment, when Kaientai Kaientied up Venis backstage and appeared set to castrate him once and for all. Is this the end of our hero?

It was pure Attitude Era, but the ridiculous sight of Yamaguchi-san threatening to "choppy choppy" The Big Valbowski's salami neutered any underlying danger. Plus, Venis informing fans he'd been saved by his friend, John Wayne Bobbitt, a man accused of sexually assaulting and beating his wife, was beyond tasteless. No thanks.


5. Muhammad Hassan Terrorizes The Undertaker

Speaking of tasteless, we recommend bracing yourselves for this one.

Portraying himself as a wrestler of Jordanian-Palestinian heritage fighting the unfair treatment of Arab Americans post-9/11, Muhammad Hassan's arrival exploited the ongoing War on Terror. There was admittedly loads of potential in Hassan's character. In the right hands, he would've made an unlikely, compelling babyface in his battle against discrimination, but this is WWE we're talking about.

Rather than depict Hassan with any nuance, his character relied heavily on clichéd stereotypes. He was presented as a religious zealot, and his promos were often translated into Persian by his manager, Khosrow Daivari. With typical crudeness, WWE's broadcast team regularly claimed Daivari was speaking Arabic. What a complete farce.

Hassan even adopted the camel clutch, the preferred weapon of foreign heels everywhere. The WWE Universe couldn't silence him in "USA" chants fast enough.

Of course, these issues paled next to Hassan's most offensive moment. Following Daivari's defeat at the hands of The Undertaker, Hassan summoned five masked men, who proceeded to beat and choke The Deadman. With a smug Hassan looking on, Daivari was carried away like a martyr.

Although it was an already cheap segment, airing as it did on the same day as the 2005 London bombings was reprehensible. WWE quickly shuffled Hassan from all programing, ending plans to make him World Heavyweight Champion at that year's SummerSlam. Probably for the best, really.


4. Heidenreich Assaulting Michael Cole

With his jacked physique and snarling voice, it's no wonder Jon Heidenreich was so frightening.

Paired with manager Paul Heyman in 2004, Heidenreich was presented as a total psychopath. He attacked fans, he interfered in matches, he performed... poetry? What a sicko!

Yes, moonlighting as a would-be poet, Heidenreich dropped enough verses to give Shakespeare a run for his money. In the buildup to one of his matches with The Undertaker, Heidenreich rhymed his own name with "destruction of life." As far as truth bombs go, this one was a misfire. Maybe stick to your day job, pal.

However, it was Heidenreich's abduction of commentator Michael Cole on an episode of SmackDown that was far more unsettling than any bad poem.

Dragging Cole backstage, Heidenreich locked them in a room together. Heidenreich then thrust towards Cole from behind, all while growling suggestively into his ear. There was no doubt about it. Audiences were supposed to believe Heidenreich was sexually assaulting Cole. It was absolutely disgusting and to this day represents one of the company's true low points.


3. Triple H And Katie Vick

Katie Vick
WWE Network

Triple H is no stranger to controversy. The D-Generation X co-founder has landed himself in the middle of plenty of gross-out gimmicks over the years. None like this one, though.

As Triple H built to his match with the Devil's favourite burn victim, Kane, at 2002's No Mercy pay-per-view, their feud took a decidedly dark twist.

Claiming that years earlier Kane felt an unrequited love for a woman known as Katie Vick, Triple H accused "The Big Red Machine" of causing her demise. According to Hunter, not only had Kane intentionally crashed the vehicle carrying him and Vick, he had sexually assaulted her corpse after finding her dead. That's right, WWE had finally incorporated necrophilia into a story. Should we have really expected anything better?

The angle culminated in Triple H revealing footage supposedly showing Kane taking liberties with Vick's body. In reality, as you've probably guessed by now, it was Triple H doing a weak Kane impersonation in a funeral home. He was seen mounting a mannequin in a coffin as "romantic" music accompanied his every grunt and groan. How revolting.

Much to nobody's surprise, the angle tanked with fans and critics alike. Prior to No Mercy, the Katie Vick aspect of Triple H and Kane's feud was mercifully toned down. What a relief.


2. Hawk's Self-Destruction

Poking fun at someone's addiction and mental health challenges isn't cool. Given WWE's long list of casualties and track record of pushing superstars to the brink, both mentally and physically, you'd think creative might want to avoid directly tackling a sensitive subject like suicide. You'd be wrong, though.

In WWE's Attitude Era, no subject was off limits. Legion of Doom member Hawk learned that the hard way when he found himself in a storyline built around his own self-destruction. WWE blatantly leaned on Hawk's issues with drugs and alcohol, depicting him as an increasingly unreliable tag team partner fixated on taking his own life. Are you not entertained? No? Fair enough.

Hawk stumbled to the ring, he fell off the entrance ramp... you get the idea. It was troubling to watch, even by Attitude Era standards.

Hawk's behaviour prompted the addition of a third member, Droz, to The Legion of Doom, ostensibly to steady the team's focus.

The angle's dramatic finale arrived when a suicidal Hawk threatened to jump off the TitanTron in front of the live crowd. Droz climbed up, seemingly to rescue Hawk, but instead pushed him over the edge. Speaking of being pushed over the edge...

As if that wasn't bad enough, Droz then claimed he had been secretly enabling Hawk's addictions in order to get him out of the way - permanently. Hawk and Animal had seen enough. They left the WWE and hit the road soon after. Good for them.


1. The Brawl For All

And now the one we've all been waiting for.

Created by writer Vince Russo, WWE's 1998 Brawl for All was a shootfighting tournament designed to showcase some of the company's legitimate tough guys, partially in response to the rise of mixed martial arts promotions like UFC.

Although imagined as a way of launching favourite Steve Williams towards a big money showdown with Stone Cold Steve Austin, the resulting tournament was a catastrophe of regrettable injuries and upset victories. Fighting actually hurts people. Big shocker, we know.

Bart Gunn frustrated WWE's plans for Steve Williams by winning the entire tournament in shocking fashion. His reward? Losing in seconds to professional boxer Butterbean at WrestleMania XV, proving that no good deed goes unpunished in WWE.

Plus, fans hated the slow-paced Brawl for All, which stood in stark contrast to sports entertainment's usual bells and whistles. Maybe some pyro would've helped - then again, probably not.

As revealed in Vice's Dark Side of the Ring series, the entire tournament seemed more about Russo punishing a boastful John "Bradshaw" Layfield than elevating the eventual winner. Bradshaw did lose to Gunn in the finals, so at least Russo got something out of the Brawl for All. Here is your real winner...


Watch Next


Contributor

Investigator and writer based in Vancouver, Canada. Fond of history, professional wrestling, and rock hubris. Once co-directed a Star Trek fan film with a budget of less than $200.