10 Times WWE Turned Trash Into Treasure

From game shows to game-changers.

Becky Lynch Ronda Rousey
WWE.com

No, we didn't get that title the wrong way 'round, though here's a sneak peak of this article's subverted sequel:

Asuka was treasure in NXT: an undefeated warlord absolutely drenched in a gleefully sadistic, wholly unique brand of charisma. On the main roster, and this was so sadly inevitable you dared not predict it, she became just another defeated performer used as an odd couple punchline in her abysmal partnership with Naomi, from whom she absolutely delighted at the prospect of learning English words ("Glow! Ah, glow!"). From wrestling arguably the best WWE singles match in 2017 to whacky "teriyaki" word play one year later, Asuka, somewhat fittingly, was a cooked stereotype. And then she became SmackDown Women's Champion! And then she didn't get booked for weeks on end! And now Lacey Evans is primed to go over her, because she is blonde. It is 2018 all over again, with one key, damning difference; this blonde's got legs from here to ya-ya! "We can't not push her!" is the mentality here. When, in reality, they could just push a performer who is actually able to perform on that stage.

In short, if Asuka is treasure now, she will be trash soon enough.

It's backwards, but on rare occasions, WWE was and is capable of forward-thinking...

10. Becky Lynch

Becky Lynch
WWE.com

It has become entirely pointless to critique WWE's sports entertainment through the lens of a pro wrestling ideologue. WWE doesn't write for its audience, nor does it write coherent stories. To gain any enjoyment from the 2019 product, it's best to simply focus on the performers and their ability to pull off thankless tasks.

Becky Lynch is a natural babyface, so of course WWE turned her heel in the summer of 2018. There's no doubting that anymore, revisionism be damned. She demanded Charlotte Flair raised her arm, she assaulted her without provocation, and, in true, telling WWE heel style, she took an intentional disqualification loss in order to delay the inevitable.

Only, something else inevitable happened. Becky Lynch was such a charismatic star that WWE recognised it, and repackaged her as an anti-hero, retconning the almost insulting inciting incident and shaping it to turn Flair. What we're seeing now is the opposite of what WWE had intended.

What we are seeing now is treasure where there was once trash.

Becky Lynch is so great in this role. Chin jutted, eyes narrowed, she is totally, coolly defiant. You can almost see the last lot of f*cks ooze casually out of her. She projects herself with an understated authority. This is a woman who knows she deserves to be where she's at, and could care less about how she got there. On the stick, she is similarly confident; she does a passable imitation of the inimitable Conor McGregor, and that is not the backhanded compliment it may read as.

This isn't entirely an accidental success; WWE has scripted and directed Lynch very well once it became apparent that initial turn was deeply misjudged, even if the principle behind that direction remains unsettling.


9. Floyd Mayweather

Mayweather GIF
WWE Network

Typically, casual crowds react favourably to celebrities in the pro wrestling arena, hence why they are almost invariably presented as babyfaces. Perhaps "traditionally" is the more appropriate word, because the Guest Host Era of RAW put wrestling fans off that idea.

But there's also Floyd Mayweather: a grotesquely unlikeable personality people endured for years as a mega box office attraction because they were so desperate to see somebody actually get a punch in. But, being little, WWE initially presented 'Money' as an underdog babyface character. This development was panned, and, with mainstream eyes on the company, WWE altered the trajectory and turned the heel heel.

The potential disaster materialised as a genuine triumph - arguably, the most entertaining use of a non-wrestler in WWE history. Mayweather was in prime pr*ck mode at WrestleMania XXIV, evading Big Show's lumbering offence with a mugging grin plastered over his face in a smoke and mirrors masterclass. He then sold for Show, delivering the catharsis even in victory.

Even boxing fans probably cite this as the most entertaining thing Floyd has ever been a part of.


8. Andrade 'Cien' Almas

Andrade Cien Almas
WWE.com

Andrade 'Cien' Almas was never "trash", but WWE didn't half botch his introduction.

It was uncharacteristically lazy of NXT. Even to NXT's in-the-know audience, lucha libre remains something of a fringe concern watched only by the most dedicated among the U.S. wrestling fandom. WWE then literally removed him from any vague recognition by unmasking the former La Sombra who, incidentally, was a tranquilo badass in CMLL. Reimagined by NXT, he arrived at TakeOver: The End decked out like Jeff Jarrett (!), slapping hands as he made his way to the ring.

His enhancement talent opponent, Tye Dillinger, was easily more over than the debuting international superstar. This felt like a backwards step, and so WWE took a step further backwards to rehabilitate the act by pairing him with one of those manager thingies that were so fundamental to pro wrestling at its most popular. Almas and Zelina Vega were an instant success; her rabid support compensated for his insouciance, and her verbal skills allowed him to enter the long-term, high-stakes storytelling domain. Almas was always capable of delivering ultra-precise masterclasses of hard-hitting, blood-pumping drama.

He was always in-ring royalty, but Vega handed him the keys to the kingdom.


7. The New Day

The New Day 2015
WWE

That first introductory vignette was chronic, maintaining Kofi Kingston's unimpressive form in this department. As a solo act, Kofi dealt out beach justice to Jamaican bullies (well, white American bullies in "Jamaica"); as part of the debuting New Day, Kofi et al., backed by gospel singers, promised to unleash the power of positivity, drawing, as everybody expected, a negative reaction in these ever-cynical times.

After leaning heavily (and not obliviously) into the obnoxiousness of the act, New Day turned face almost exactly as they had turned heel. The hyper-annoying bit turned back on itself to become oddly charming. It was clear, wonderfully so, that the stable were having the time of their lives out there. The New Day's act often comes across as juvenile, and repetitive, and far more concerned with banter over content. Little of it is funny ha-ha, but there's something so vibrant and energetic - infectious - about the act that compels audiences to it three years later, which, in this 3 Hour RAW Era, feels like a lifetime.

Consider the RAW landscape as the New Day entered relevance. Adam Rose, while on the way out, was still A Thing. Ryback was defeating Mark Henry. King Barrett was still in the midst of a push.

Fun, creativity, and palpable, all-too-rare agency, not positivity, has powered the act's staying power. They could wrestle The Usos tomorrow, still find meat on the bones, and then sell it as merch.


6. Batista

Batista 2005 Royal Rumble
WWE.com

WWE repaired Batista twice.

He arrived on SmackDown - his one marketable asset obscured in a suit John Laurinaitis told him to fork out on, before taking a knife to it - as second to the second best part of the Dudley Boyz tag team. This was sub-New Generation dross: 'Deacon' Batista's Ringmaster moment. Atoning for their sin, WWE quickly shoved Batista into the Evolution faction, and built him as a cool destroyer immune to power plays; the badass counter-terrorist to Triple H's WHC reign. This version of Batista, alongside John Cena, drew a record pay-per-view buy rate at WrestleMania 21.

He returned, following an excellent career as headliner, at the 2014 Royal Rumble, as the stark antithesis to the man WWE pegged him to replace: Daniel Bryan. The wheezing dinosaur to Bryan's incandescent, state-of-the-art performer, this version of Batista was transported forward to a time he did not belong to, and crowds nationwide let him know it. Boo-tista; Bluetista; both were synonyms of "public enemy number one".

To spare themselves the embarrassment of a rejected 'Mania main event, and any potential impact on the WWE Network launch, WWE repositioned Batista as a heel, and he revelled in his role as a spiteful, p*ssed off mercenary.

Batista was a killer in that Triple Threat Match, and put The Shield over big time as the final boss in two consecutive six-man stunners.


5. Mark Henry

Mark Henry 1999 European Champion
WWE.com

The WWF wanted Mark Henry off the books so desperately that Vince McMahon green-lit an onscreen humiliation campaign. This happens fairly regularly, of course, but the difference here was the sheer scope and duration of the thing.

Henry, throughout the Attitude Era, having failed to master the basics and proven himself as a danger to himself and others, was repackaged as Sexual Chocolate. We all have our vices. Kurt Angle's happened to be "gutter sl*ts". Batista favoured the wives and girlfriends of his contemporaries. Henry had vices, plural: transvestites, octogenarians, bodybuilders, family members. They all wanted a little taste of Henry's Sexual Chocolate.

Once Henry relearned his trade, and recovered from a spate of serious injuries, various attempts to rehabilitate the character, via unimaginative monster pushes, failed. Henry did recover, and became a respectable if limited worker a full 10 years after learning his trade in a decent WWECW stint. As the years passed by without major injury, the sensitive performer grew in confidence to such an extent that he pulled off a late-career fairytale run. Inducting all who dared face him into the Hall of Pain, this, at long last, was the Henry Vince McMahon signed in 1996.

A terrifying aural and physical nightmare, Henry was so credible and fearsome in the role that he even drew in the post-draft wasteland that was SmackDown. Incredibly, his work was so good that the Hall of Pain, and not the years of shame, have informed his legacy to the mat game.


4. The APA

apa acolytes protection agency
WWE.com

Reductive attempts at deadpan often fall into dreaded snark territory, but ultimately, the Acolytes were the two nearest big lads the Undertaker could daub naff "satanic" imagery on, and it didn't seem to matter that one was a cowboy, and the other was a black nationalist. That was the extent of the act. It was as one-dimensional as it gets. Even the most rose-tinted Attitude Era apologist couldn't name one memorable Acolytes match outside of the infamous Public Enemy encounter, and that wasn't so much a pro wrestling match as a massacre.

Those apologists remain in massive numbers, however, because between 1997 and 2001, the WWF utilised every last soldier in the trench to combat the WCW battalion.

Bradshaw and Farooq became the Acolytes Protection Agency, and the matches no longer mattered; they were a fun part of the shared universe fabric, utilised to advance storylines and deliver retribution. Two formidable bruisers, they were believable in the role, and as blunt with sharp one-liners as they were thudding the hapless to the canvas.

Misawa's lunatic neck-first bumps; Mick Foley's unprotected chair shots; Katsuyori Shibata's full-force kicks to the chest; the way in which the APA clobbered their opponents ranks among them as some of the most painful-looking sh*t to ever emanate from the squared circle.


3. Kane

Kane Debut Badd Blood 97
WWE

Glenn Jacobs has endured some abysmal incarnations in his time.

Corporate Kane. Embrace The Hate Kane. May 19 Kane. Cuck Kane. Finn Bálor-burying Kane. Teetering Around Tables In Australia Kane. Rapist Kane.

But before all that, he was also an absolute sh*t magnet, burdened throughout the 1990s as the Fake Diesel (still better than World Champion in 2010 Kane) and the evil personal dentist of Jerry Lawler, Isaac Yankem, in a name so consummately Vince McMahon you can actually hear the hahahahahah noise he made when somebody, probably Bruce Prichard, pitched it. Destined for the Where Are They Now? files (if only, those first nine months were good, but not that good), Jacobs was instead repackaged as Kane in late 1997.

Years and years and years of plodding, mediocre overfamiliarity followed, but before all that, Kane was a genuinely brilliant monster. It wasn't just an inspired gimmick, nor a well-crafted long-term narrative; Jacobs, behind a mask, conveyed an unreal sense of menace every bit as unsettling - and iconic - as the horror movie monsters after which he was modelled.

His head tilted eerily to mirror his skewed perception of the prey that is human life, his supernatural ability to launch hapless jobbers halfway up the RAW ramp, this version of Kane survives actual decades of diminished returns to inspire unease every time you return to 1997 on your Network watchlist.


2. The Women's Revolution

Paige Charlotte Becky Lynch team pcb
WWE.com

It seemed simple.

Debut the Four Horsewomen as a stable, after Bayley and Sasha Banks earned one another's respect, as October 2015 draws to a close. Together with Charlotte Flair and Becky Lynch, they invade RAW with a mission statement to eradicate the Divas era. Don't #GiveDivasAChance; #GiveWomenAChance. Four selected Divas, p*ssed beyond belief at the gall of these women, challenge them to a traditional Survivor Series Match. Poor Bayley is the only Horsewoman eliminated. This rankles with Charlotte Flair, who designates herself leader, which rankles with everybody, everything falls apart, and the stage is set for a Fatal Four-Way 'Mania match to determine the first-ever Women's Champion.

That's a good plan...but it needs more Stephanie McMahon!

Instead, the benevolent Billion Dollar Princess had the (style and) grace to allow these women to incongruously and without explanation form groups based on their ethnicity, resulting in anonymous and confusing multi-women matches. Mercifully, WWE put a swift end to this bizarre development, and to put over the notion that women were equal to men, booked them like their male counterparts.

Two awesome televised matches ushered in the sea change: the brutal Falls Count Anywhere clash between Banks and Charlotte on the November 28, 2016 RAW, and the babyface vs. heel masterclass Women's Title bout between Charlotte and Bayley on the February 13, 2017 RAW.

Previously, the women were shunted to the death slot on pay-per-view. But now, the Revolution was indeed televised.


1. NXT

NXT Roster
WWE

The original game show version of NXT wasn't a mere affront to pro wrestling; it was a caricature of sports entertainment.

Several rookies - some perceived as genuine prospects - were ritually embarrassed by WWE in what felt like the onscreen destruction of Vince McMahon's patience. If they can survive this bullsh*t, they can survive anything! was, maybe, who the f*ck knows, the rationale here. It took the most raucous RAW angle of the decade just to salvage those eight men from the scrapheap, and then SummerSlam 2010 happened.

The preposterousness continued unabated. Microphones were thrust into the faces of the damned; no bullet points, only bullet holes. The competitions became even goofier. Michael Cole suffered several misogynistic conniption fits before abandoning the show altogether at the season three mark. The show designed to highlight the future instead stigmatised the future as utterly hopeless. It was an insane proposition.

And then NXT became even more insane. It became the critically-acclaimed pro wrestling component of WWE's sports entertainment empire.

Triple H assumed the reins from John Laurinaitis, and reinvented developmental as a brand in which talent ideally developed, instead of wrestling in front of posters in gyms. Trips pushed the talent the fans wished to see (Neville), pushed talent we didn't know we wanted (Bayley), and reimagined NXT as an Independent-styled league with glamorous, corporate backing. It was the best of both worlds, only nowhere near lame enough to warrant that. F*cking. Network advert.

Moral of the story: unless Mitsuharu Misawa and Kenta Kobashi are involved, don't let Johnny Ace near anything.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!