10 Totally Backwards Wrestling Match Stipulations

Loser Leaves Town? How about Loser STAYS In Town instead!

Thunder Rosa Kamille
NWA

The world of professional wrestling has long loved adding special conditions to matches. Generally, these are meant to be the pinnacle of a feud - a thrilling, extra-special way to blow off a longstanding beef between wrestlers.

These matches tend to live up to their goal and have produced some of the greatest spectacles in pro wrestling history. Hell In a Cell between Undertaker and Mankind. Jimmy Snuka's leap off the steel cage at Madison Square Garden. The first Tables, Ladders, and Chairs match. Hell, even Terry Funk vs Sabu in their barbed wire match for the ECW title.

The matches in this list are nothing like those.

No, this list is comprised of wrestling contests where the stipulation tagged on simply made no sense, either from a storyline standpoint or from a reality (well, wrestling reality) standpoint. They aren't limited to any one promotion; it seems that pretty much every wrestling organization operating in the last thirty or so years has managed to put on at least one or two stip matches that just didn't work.

These are stipulations that defy logic, that leave you with your jaw hanging agape at the fact that anyone wrote them, let alone approved them for airing.

10. Monster Truck Sumo Match - Halloween Havoc 1995

Hulk Hogan Giant
WWE.com

Leading up to Halloween Havoc, the mustacheless Hulkster was chilling on his motorcycle signing autographs when the Giant, then brand new, drove up in a monster truck, missing Hulk but crushing his beloved motorcycle.

This led to the Hulkster finding his own truck to engage Giant in a 'sumo match' on the roof of Cobo Hall. After several minutes of loud trucks pushing each other, Hogan won, because of course he did, and he climbed down from his truck to celebrate his victory.

Here's where it gets good.

The Giant attacked Hogan, who accidentally pushed the Giant off the roof and into the Detroit River. Despite this stunning development, no one seemed too alarmed. Hulk came to the ring for the regular match he was supposed to have with the Giant, and instead of being arrested for manslaughter, tried to justify himself.

Then the Giant, who not only survived but looked fine, made his way to the ring, fought Hogan, and ended up bearhugging him to death with the debuting Yeti after a Jimmy Hart heel turn.

What was the point of the monster truck bit - the winner didn't get any kind of advantage or benefit in their match. Why didn't they just finish the night with the Giant 'dead' and follow up on Nitro? How did the Giant survive his fall? Why wasn't anyone upset that Hogan killed someone?

What a fever dream.


9. King Of The Road Match - WCW Uncensored 1995

King of the Road Match
WWE Network

Dustin Rhodes was wasted during particular periods of his WCW run, being involved in ridiculous matches like the King of the Road against the Blacktop Bully.

For reasons that WCW never really explained, the only way for these two mortal enemies to end a feud was to fight in the back of a transport truck amongst a bunch of... umm ...hay. The goal was to make your way to the front of the truck and honk a horn, for more unexplained reasons.

The production needed for this short match was unbelievable - a helicopter, closed roads, a bunch of other camera trucks. If it had been sold as a cinematic match, we could bite, but the announcers kept implying that this was happening on the roads near the arena RIGHT THEN.

The match was sold as dangerous as hell, but when you couldn't see any other vehicles and when the two men only really moved when the truck went around a corner or curve, it was difficult to see the danger. At one point, Tony Schiavone was reduced to telling the audience that hay can be 'very abrasive to the skin.'

In addition, even though they only had hay to throw at each other, both men bladed, which was a no-no in WCW at the time and ended up getting both of them fired.

How this was supposed to equate to a violent blow-off between two hated enemies will remain a mystery.


8. Crybaby Match - In Your House Feb 1996

Crybaby Match razor 123 kid
wwe.com

When you look at the storied, Hall of Fame careers of Scott Hall and Sean Waltman, it's difficult to think that they count this among the highlights.

After a series of back and forth matches between the then 1-2-3 Kid and Razor Ramon, Waltman turned on Razor to join the Million Dollar Corporation. Razor, looking for a finale to their feud, proposed a Crybaby Match, wherein the loser would be diapered, powdered, and given a bottle, since Waltman had been acting like a crybaby.

Flawless logic.

The Million Dollar Man accepted on Waltman's behalf, and the match was set, with no stakes except embarrassment on the line.

Razor won the match with two Razor's Edge slams and the result was an unconscious 1-2-3 Kid being dusted with baby powder, put into an oversized diaper, and being given a baby bottle to suck on. When Waltman woke up, he pouted and cried. No one looked good coming out of this mess.

This was one of the last big matches for either man before they headed for WCW, possibly leaving partly because of the lingering shame of this match.

It's stunning to think that this New Generation garbage was just a few months before Steve Austin would deliver his iconic 'Austin 3:16' promo and the formation of the NWO, both of which would turn the professional wrestling world on its head.


7. Viagra On A Pole - July 31, 2000 Nitro

Viagra On A Pole Match
WWE.com

This is another debacle from the dying days of WCW, with Vince Russo's hand clearly on the wheel.

Shane Douglas and Billy Kidman were in the middle of a several-month feud over Torrie Wilson. Kidman had his shot with her first, including a sex tape that Nitro somehow had access to. Douglas thought he would do the same and also recorded a tryst with Torrie.

Problem being, Douglas had... urm... performance issues, therefore making him 'less of a man' and implying that millions of men who have medical issues of this sort are worthy of being mocked. Thus, the 'Viagra On a Pole Match' was born.

To what end? Did the winner keep the Viagra to use it? Kidman apparently didn't need it, and if Douglas won it would help him with his bedroom issues. Were you supposed to force your opponent to take the pills? The rules were never clearly laid out.

Crash TV, bro.

The planned ending of the match was for Douglas to hit Kidman in the face with the old-timey looking medicine bottle, forcing pills into his mouth. Before that could happen the bottle broke, which Douglas picked up. This prompted the ref to disqualify Douglas even though you were allowed to use the bottle on your opponent, and compelling Wilson to make Kidman 'eat' Viagra by gently bumping his head off the canvas.

Confused? So were the announcers, who spent most of the match making poor sexual innuendos.


6. Last Rites Match - Destination X 2007

Sting Last Rites II
TNA

The Last Rites match between Sting and Abyss may well go down as the worst in TNA's history. And that's saying a lot.

There was no explanation of what this match involved, only vignettes like Sting lying in a coffin ruminating on death. See, Sting felt Abyss had been corrupted, so he had to kill him so he could see the light.

We wish we were joking. Sting, babyface extraordinaire, was going to kill someone to save him.

On the night of the match, the rules were finally explained. Competitors had to call the coffin - sorry, DEATH BED - down from the ceiling on cables, whereupon you take your opponent, put them in the DEATH BED, and close the lid.

The match was a wreck. At one point, the crowd is chanting 'Fire Russo.' Sting blades his head from a shot to the gut. Despite Abyss 'struggling' to lift one of the tombstones, Sting easily shatters it with his bat a few minutes later. At one point, the arena goes dark and blue light and smoke appear, blocking the view.

Abyss chokeslams Sting onto the coffin, then wastes time setting up an elaborate spot with chairs instead of closing the lid and winning. Sting reverses, wins, and calls for the DEATH BED to rise, but the cables can't lift Abyss and Sting and the DEATH BED's weight, so it just kinda hangs out there in the ring.

All involved should be embarrassed.


5. TNA's Reverse Battle Royal - Fight For The Right Tournament

Reverse Battle Royal Bound for Glory 2007
TNA

In 2006 and 2007, TNA held their Fight for the Right Tournament, a multi-staged process to determine the number one contender to the TNA title.

The first stage was a reverse battle royal, where the objective was to beat your opponents by climbing over the top rope and INTO the ring. In theory, the concept works and was admittedly original.

In practice, though, it was awful. Wrestlers who regularly entered the ring by hurdling the ropes or were high-flyers suddenly lost all their dexterity and couldn't even get on the ring apron. Wrestlers spent time wailing on each other outside the ring instead of running for a clear space and taking a few seconds to climb into the ring.

Competitors who weren't scheduled to go any further in the tourney were just wandering around outside the ring, looking lost and apparently forgetting the ONE rule of the stipulation was to just get over the top rope.

Then, to further cap off the foolishness, the next stage of the match was a traditional over the top battle royal, meaning that all the time and effort to get into the ring was for the most part wasted. The last two men standing then had a one-on-one match to progress further.

The 2006 match was universally scorned and was tweaked a bit for 2007, but after that TNA quietly let the reverse battle royal concept die.


4. Judy Bagwell On A Forklift - New Blood Rising, 2000

Judy Bagwell
WWE.com

The closing days of WCW are like being able to sit at a distance and watch the Titanic sink. It's horrible, but such a spectacle that you can't take your eyes off it. At this point, Vince Russo had creative control, and with the few buffers that the WWE creative staff had played when he was there not around, he was free to completely lose his mind.

Thus was born Judy Bagwell On a Forklift.

Buff Bagwell and (Positively) Kanyon were in the midst of a program. To ramp things up, Kanyon began stalking Buff's mom Judy, before finally kidnapping her and challenging Buff to a match to retrieve his mom. His condition, however, was that Judy had to be on a pole, and if Kanyon won Buff's mom was his new valet.

Think about that for a sec. The resolution of illegal kidnapping and human trafficking was to be decided by a wrestling match.

When the match began, Kanyon drove out with Judy on a forklift, because, in his words, he couldn't find a pole that would 'hold that big fat battle axe.'

Yep. Somehow Kanyon got a forklift, tied a kidnap victim to it, and made it to the ring. Why was no one in WCW shocked by this, either kayfabe or for real?

Add in a David Arquette run-in and you have a historically bad match even WCW diehards have trouble defending.


3. Loser STAYS In Town - NWA Power 2021

Thunder Rosa Kamille
NWA

Back in May, NWA wrestler Kamille accused fellow wrestler Thunder Rosa, who has also been a regular on AEW programming, of using the NWA for her own ends. Kamille offered to put her number one contender's spot up for grabs against Thunder Rosa at a date to be determined with the stipulation that if Thunder Rosa lost, she could ONLY work for NWA in the future.

Oi.

Firstly, isn't every wrestler using their contracted promotions for their own ends? They all get paid and they all get exposure because of the promotion they work for. Kamille is not wrestling for altruistic purposes because she loves NWA.

Secondly, why would NWA agree to this? With this stipulation they are, in essence, telling the world that working for them sucks, is small peanuts, is bush league. Pick your fave. Being limited to one promotion shouldn't be a punishment, it should be a privilege. NWA is doing nothing here but defining themselves down.

Now, to be fair, during the TV spot where this match was made, Kamille did her best to explain that this would be hard on Thunder Rosa because it would limit her to always being in Kamille's shadow, instead of being able to dominate 'lesser' women in AEW. Unfortunately, Thunder Rosa interrupted the dialogue flow constantly, meaning that Kamille's point was for the most part lost.

It was a time-limit draw, by the way.


2. Child Custody Ladder Match - SummerSlam 2005

mysterio guerrero domink
WWE.com

That this one ever got written and approved is beyond belief.

In 2005, Rey Mysterio and Eddie Guerrero were embroiled in a feud that took a very odd turn when Latino Heat began involving Rey's family, alleging that he had a relationship with Rey's wife years before, which resulted in Rey's son Dominik being born. Eddie now wanted his son back.

So, Rey and Eddie decided that the way to determine the parentage and future raising of a child was through a ladder match. Hanging above the ladder was a briefcase with papers that 'guaranteed' custody of Dominik.

Much like with the infamous Judy Bagwell On a Forklift match, a family relationship and lifelong bonds, were to be determined by wrestling. Never mind court, lawyers, medical testing or what the child wanted, we're going to settle who the gets to be dad by beating the crap out of each other and climbing a ladder.

There were some really disturbing aspects to this angle. During the match, the camera kept cutting to the worried, confused face of young Dominik, who was sitting in the crowd with a 'social worker' ready to award him to the winner. Vicki Guerrero, Eddie's real wife, interfered in the match, adding more family drama. Michael Cole's creepy line 'Rey Mysterio wins custody of his son!'

At least we got a decent match from two of WWE's best high-flyers out of this mess.


1. Chamber Of Horrors - WCW Halloween Havoc 1991

Chamber of Horrors WCW
WWE Network

Halloween Havoc was generally just a theme for a WCW PPV; pumpkins and haystacks on the set, the announcers in costumes, you know, harmless fun. In 1991, however, WCW took this concept to a literal level and created the Chamber of Horrors.

The Steiners, El Gigante, and Sting squared off against Abdullah the Butcher, Cactus Jack, Vader, and Diamond Studd in a steel cage match with a smaller cage in the centre of the ring. In that smaller cage was an electric chair, into which someone had to be placed and electrocuted for the opposing team to win the match.

Let that sink in for a minute.

WCW asked us to believe that they were going to kill a man live on PPV by electrocution. What city or state would approve such a thing?

Aside from the unbelievable concept, there were other issues. The cage/ring setup made it very difficult to tell what was going on in person or on PPV. The oversized prop 'switch' that was supposed to activate the chair kept falling during the match of its own accord, meaning the chair should have been constantly activated.

Finally, a bloodied Abdullah the Butcher was put into the chair, Cactus pulled the switch on what he thought was Rick Steiner, sparks flew and lights flickered. The announcers moved between jokes about Abdullah being cooked and trying to sell the 'power of the chair.'

Awful.


Watch Next


In this post: 
TNA NWA
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Child of the Canadian '80s. Fan of Star Wars, Marvel (films), DC (animated films), WWE, classic cartoons. Enjoys debating with his two teenage sons about whether hand-drawn or computer animation is better but will watch it all anyways. Making ongoing efforts to catalogue and understand all WhatCulture football references.