10 Totally Wasted Wrestling Gimmicks

Even the most compelling gimmicks have the potential to be painfully fumbled.

adam rose leo kruger
WWE.com

You can be the greatest in-ring technician ever to lace up a pair of boots, turn into the second coming of Muhammad Ali when a microphone is placed in your hand, and possess a physique a Greek god would be somewhat jealous of, but without a decent gimmick complementing those qualities, your chances of making big bucks in the wrestling world are pretty damn low.

Now, when the word "gimmick" finds its way into the average conversation about those folks bumping around a squared-circle, most people's minds jump to the more larger-than-life offerings, with the likes of The Undertaker, Mankind, and The Hurricane being a few notable highlights. Yet, simply turning the real-life personality of a wrassler up to 11 can also produce a gimmick capable of captivating the world - just ask a certain Texas Rattlesnake.

But, for every 'Stone Cold', 'Great One', and 'Heartbreak Kid', there's unfortunately another seemingly mouthwatering character, brimming with potential, that finds itself being depressingly ran straight into the ground. From sinister puppetmasters to clinical mercenaries, these particularly absorbing gimmicks all frustratingly stumbled when they could've soared.

10. CJ Parker - Hippie

CJ Parker NXT
WWE

CJ Parker is an example of a star with all the potential in the world, but who just never really clicked whilst navigating his way through Triple H's developmental braindchild.

It wasn't through a lack of trying, though.

After being jobbed out during his early days in NXT, Parker returned with a new hippie gimmick, fluidly dancing his way to the ring and declaring that he just wanted to "change this world". The plan was originally for this new schtick to catapult Parker into being a fan favourite. However, as is often the case in the world of pro wrestling, the NXT faithful were having none of it and he soon transitioned into a deluded heel who turned on those in attendance. Think "The New Daniel Bryan" with added dreadlocks.

Despite this act clearly having some legs and Parker knowing his way around a ring, he ultimately found himself becoming fodder for whichever new face Trips and the gang wanted to get behind next. Thankfully, he'd land on his feet upon exiting WWE in 2015, reverting back to his Juice Robinson gimmick and forging a successful career in NJPW.


9. Leo Kruger - Mercenary/Hunter

adam rose leo kruger
WWE.com

Things may not have worked out for Adam Rose after finally answering the call and making his way on up to the "main roster" in 2014, but there was a time when the NXT talent possessed one of the most intriguing characters in the brand's history.

Before being rebranded as the party-loving, flamboyant leader of the Rosebuds, Rose went by the name of Leo Kruger during his early days on the black and gold brand. As a slightly unhinged hunter and mercenary of sorts, Kruger excelled when given time to deliver intensely creepy promos, referring to his opponents as "trophies" to be added to his collection.

Yet, someone clearly wasn't overly keen on this unsettling persona in the end as Kruger was quietly shuffled into the back after failing to get the better of NXT Champion Bo Dallas and Sami Zayn towards the backend of 2013.

Rose would eventually wrestle under the Krugar moniker after parting ways with WWE in 2016, but surely the sight of a deranged hunter picking off various members of the Raw and SmackDown rosters would've been more entertaining than the Russell Brand tribute act we were forced to endure in the end.


8. Doink The Clown - Dastardly Clown

DOINK Matt Bourne
WWE.com

On the surface, a guy dressing up as a clown and going head-to-head with the likes of 'Macho Man' Randy Savage and Bret 'The Hitman' Hart probably should've fallen flat on its face. However, in the case of Matt Borne's version of the dastardly Doink the Clown character, WWE were able to capture something rather unexpectedly special in a bottle.

On top of playing numerous tricks on unsuspecting members of the crowd, Doink would also utilise this disturbing penchant for fun at the expense of someone else against his colleagues, with the moment he sent Big Boss Man flying over a tripwire, and tricked Crush into thinking a prosthetic arm was real before smacking him over the head with it being just a few moments of hilarious madness.

Yet, once Borne was given the boot from the character due to his issues with drug use, the character began to slip into goofier territory as Ray Liachelli took up the reins. It was then only a matter of time before the Doink character became a go-to jobber and a once captivating menace was depressingly defanged.


7. Simon Dean - Fitness Guru

Simon Dean
wwe.com

The intentionally infuriating Simon Dean character was quite simply ahead of its time.

Making his way to the ring on his 'Dean Machine' (or Segway to the average Joe), Dean would make an example of an unfortunate jobber before forecfully introducing them to his 'Simon System'. For those not in the know, said way of life consisted of living off nutritional health bars and lifting the odd dumbell whilst decked in a snug sweatsuit.

In other words, his entire character was pretty much an early 2000s version of an annoying Instagram influencer.

Fans would clamour to see Dean get his comeuppance for force-feeding folks healthy snacks, however, which made the decision to pretty much kill off the entire gimmick after entertaining run-ins with Batista and Bobby Lashley on SmackDown that much more baffling.

His vignettes/informercials were dorky-yet-delightfully-d*ckish, and Mike Bucci was clearly having a whale of a time in the role, but WWE had other ideas and Dean was shuffled into obscurity before parting ways with the company in 2007.


6. The Berzerker - Crazy Viking

The Berzerker
WWE.com

Long before The Viking Raiders were pillaging and battling ninjas in a parking lot, John Nord paved the way for the modern day duo back in the early '90s under his guise of The Berzerker.

Understandably, the sight of a 6ft 8" monster of a man storming to the ring with a sword and shield would be enough to make most people sit up in their seats. And the way Nord would manhandle his foes with ease, even nailing them with picture-perfect dropkicks on occasion, was a sight to behold.

Sure, the fact that he couldn't go 10 seconds without licking his arms or shouting "Huss!" was a bit of an odd choice, but pairing him with Mr. Fuji and having Norse win most of his matches by count out after hurling his helpless opponent over the top rope was a surprisingly inspired decision and could've evolved into something genuinely entertaining down the line.

But, a feud with The Undertaker in 1992, which saw Bezerker attempting to stab him with a sword, was as good as it ever got for Nord's tribute to his former partner Bruiser Brody and he was gone from the company less than a year later.


5. The Ascension - Next-Gen Road Warriors

The Ascension
WWE.com

Taking something that has worked in the past before giving it a fresh lick of paint and a bit of retooling has often led to some of the most successful gimmicks in wrestling history.

During their time as part of the NXT brand, that seemed as though it was going to be the case for The Ascension, too, as Konnor and Viktor cleared out the entire tag division whilst channelling their inner Road Warriors. Full Sail absolutely lapped up the pair's destructive displays and with the pair fully embracing the more theatrical elements of their roles they looked sure to be a guaranteed "main roster" hit.

But, in one of the first examples of Vince McMahon just not "getting" one of Triple H's projects, the twosome were quickly buried on commentary and fed to the nWo, The New Age Outlaws, and the A.P.A. just a few weeks into life away from developmental.

Had the boss simply given the two a chance to bring the no-nonsense dominance that worked so well on the black and gold show to Raw and SmackDown for longer than two weeks, there's no telling where this unit could be today.


4. Alexa Bliss - Fiendish Puppetmaster

Alexa Bliss
WWE

Largely due to the unforeseen circumstance that was the entire planet shutting down in 2020, the Universal Championship found itself caught in-between one of the most excruciating feuds in recent memory when Braun Strowman and Bray Wyatt decided to take a walk down memory lane following WrestleMania 36.

However, just when it looked like the programme was beyond saving, Alexa Bliss was suddenly introduced and finally gave us something intriguing to latch onto. In the wake of being abruptly attacked by Wyatt's Fiend alter-ego, Bliss slowly morphed into a seemingly brainwashed ally of the supernatural clown, nailing adversaries with Wyatt's Sister Abigail and frequently finding herself locked in an unnerving trance.

Having Bliss steamroll through the women's division as this new threatening version of her former Goddess self, all while manipulating Wyatt's Fiend in the shadows, could've opened the door for an engrossing reign atop either Raw or SmackDown's women's divisions. But WWE eventually decided that the star's altered gimmick would be more effective if she acted like a spooky schoolgirl, threw up black goo, and launched fireballs at Randy Orton. And we won't even get started on her playdates with Lilly.


3. Sean O'Haire - Devil's Advocate

Sean O'Haire Devil's Advocate
WWE.com

After arriving alongside Chuck Palumbo during the ill-fated Invasion angle back in 2001, Sean O'Haire soon wound up being sent down to OVW to further hone his skills as a singles performer.

A spell working on Heat and various house shows would follow before the former WCW man was officially reintroduced in January 2003, donning a new Devil's advocate persona. In numerous vignettes leading up to his return appearance, O'Haire invited fans to indulge in their darkest fantasies and break the law, all whilst kitted out in a suave black trench coat.

Yet, despite the gimmick undoubtedly having potential and going down a treat with the younger demographic, it was hard to look past the fact that O'Haire simply couldn't deliver the goods in singles action and wasn't much cop with a live mic either.

So, despite even aligning with Roddy Piper for a time, the character was ultimately given the heave-ho and O'Haire was eventually let go in April 2004.


2. Matt Hardy - The WOKEN One

Matt Hardy
WWE

There's a few reasons why the fans inside of the Citrus Bowl absolutely lost their minds when The Hardy Boyz iconic theme tune suddenly rumbled through the stadium back at WrestleMania 33. Finally seeing Matt and Jeff Hardy back on WWE television was always going to go down a treat, coupled with the two being thrown into a ladder match on night one.

However, many of those deafening cheers were brought into existence at the thought of seeing Matt finally bring his white hot BROKEN schtick to life in the biggest wrestling promotion on the planet.

Yet, when the former ECW World Champion was eventually given the chance to embrace the "delete!" chants, the whole thing just felt... off. On top of being rebranded as WOKEN Matt Hardy, WWE's attempts to capitalise on the once-successful gimmick and creative masterstroke that was Hardy's Final Deletion didn't quite deliver the same level of all-out chaos and comedy.

All in all, Hardy ended up feeling like a diet version of his once career-revitalising character, and the WWE WOKEN universe was officially closed for business in the wake of Hardy's alliance with another other-worldly entity being abruptly ended...


1. Bray Wyatt - Eater Of Worlds/The Fiend

Bray Wyatt
WWE

There was a time when Matt Hardy's former Deleters of Worlds partner was one of the hottest commodities in the entire wrestling business. Bray Wyatt's cult leader character entranced audiences from the moment he set foot in NXT back in 2012.

The persona would transform as Wyatt and his Family inevitably made their presence known on the "main roster", with Wyatt himself leaning more and more into the fantastical elements that surrounded his 'Eater of Worlds' moniker. Yet, a seemingly never-ending cycle of the enthralling performer being built up to take on a big name, only to be convincingly bested in the end, damaged the act beyond repair.

Then, after going missing for nearly a year, Wyatt re-emerged with a character steeped in the sort of innovative and dazzling energy his last incarnation once possessed. The Fiend, alongside a mesmerising children's TV host alter ego, had arrived.

But, it didn't take long for WWE to run yet another one of Wyatt's ambitious creations right into the ground, with the demonic clown devolving into a parody of itself within a few months and never truly recovering from being bulldozed by Da Man in Saudi Arabia.

Oh, what could've been Muscle Man...


Watch Next


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!