10 Undertaker WWE Dream Matches We'll Never See

A heart-breaking goodbye to The Undertaker, and his dream matches that never happened.

Andre Undertaker
WWE

At Survivor Series 2020, the final bell tolled for the legendary Undertaker, closing the curtain on his 30 year WWE career as an active wrestler. The sure-to-be Hall of Fame member has given fans around the world countless unforgettable matches, surprising classics and the occasional disappointment. With his long-coming retirement now in the books, one can't help but think about the matches we didn't get to see him compete in.

Quite often, dream matches are better left on paper as an idea that shouldn't be explored. There is no finer recent example of this than The Undertaker vs. Goldberg, from the Super ShowDown event on 7 June 2019. The ill-fated match was doomed right from the beginning, with the high-octane Goldberg receiving a head injury early on. A few botched moves later (including a scary looking Jackhammer attempt) and a pin, The Undertaker emerged victorious.

Regardless, fans of wrestling in general and The Undertaker as a performer have to ponder the matches we didn't get to see. At the right time, any of the following matches would have been worthy of marquee status for WrestleMania, or to headline some of the less prestigious pay-per-view events.

10. Braun Strowman

Braun Strowman the Undertaker Raw 2017
WWE

Back in 2016 during the build up to WrestleMania 32, it was heavily rumoured that The Undertaker was set to face off against Braun Strowman, then-heavy hitter of The Wyatt Family. At the time, no one wanted to see it happen. Braun had minimal time in the ring at this point, and whenever he competed he came across as limited and cumbersome.

Fast forward a couple of months, and Braun Strowman became 'The Monster Among Men.' The big man was given more opportunity to showcase his power, presence, and surprising agility while running roughshod over the Raw roster. This is the incarnation of Braun Strowman that would have made an encounter with The Undertaker special.

While 'The Deadman's' ability was certainly diminishing at the time, this would have turned out to be a hard-hitting, physical affair. The inclusion of a No Holds Barred stipulation or similar would have been wise, allowing the duo to compensate for 'Taker's shortcomings.

This could have been a wonderful throwback to The Undertaker's days as a giant slayer, much earlier in his legendary WWE run.


9. Seth Rollins

Seth Rollins Wwe Champion Newcastle
WWE.com

The Undertaker has a reputation for working extremely well against smaller wrestlers. His classic battles with Shawn Michaels, CM Punk, and Rey Mysterio are proof that 'The Phenom' arguably works best with opponents of a smaller stature. Seth Rollins would have been no exception.

The pair have faced off in tag team action, but a one on one match never took place. There were numerous opportunities for this to take place during The Undertaker's post-streak run, but it never came to fruition. It would have made for an incredible story to see Seth Rollins at the height of his heel run after the breakup of The Shield go toe to toe with 'The Deadman.'

While aligned with The Authority, a sneaky and resourceful Rollins stacking the odds against the legend with his fellow stablemates would have been a great composition for the match. The Undertaker, being an extremely experienced competitor, would have been forced to pull out all the stops against his opportunist opponent.


8. Drew McIntyre

WWE Extreme Rules 2019 The Undertaker Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

This match did happen before, though it took place on SmackDown in 2010 when Drew McIntyre was a much greener grappler. In the decade since, McIntyre has developed into a world-class athlete.

We got a teaser of this in 2019, in The Undertaker's last truly traditional matchup. Roman Reigns and 'Taker teamed up to take on Shane McMahon and the Scotsman in a match that was way better than it had any right to be. Within the confines of this tag team contest, we saw glimpses of what a 'Taker and McIntyre battle would look like. Not content with trading a few blows, the two big men teased the WWE Universe with an intense staredown, that fuelled rumours of an impending singles confrontation.

It's a shame we didn't get to see this take place. 'The Scottish Psychopath's' star was firmly on the rise in 2019, and a one on one bout with 'The Last Outlaw' would have expedited his progress to becoming a true main event player. In what would have been an intense, physical clash, there is no doubt McIntyre would have brought a serious fight and challenged the dwindling Undertaker to bring out his best performance possible.


7. André The Giant

Andre the Giant WWE champion
WWE

The fact that this match never happened was nothing more than tragic, unfortunate timing.

When The Undertaker began his career in WWE taking souls and digging holes, André the Giant was in unfortunate physical condition. When 'The Deadman' was on the rise, 'The Eighth Wonder of the World' was winding down his in-ring career. André reportedly had a great idea for a match with the young Undertaker, one that he never disclosed to anyone before his tragic passing in 1993. Even The Undertaker doesn't know the details of his plan to hatch a feud between the two behemoths.

If this took place, we would have surely seen The Undertaker in his role as the giant slayer. His matches when fulfilling the part of the smaller man were often of lesser quality, and laboured. There is no way to tell if a matchup between these two men would have yielded positive results, but with a man of André's stature involved on the creative side, there was every chance this could have succeeded in the storytelling department.


6. Daniel Bryan

Daniel Bryan Promo
WWE

In what would have been a throwback to The Undertaker's battles with Rey Mysterio, the dominant big man and the plucky underdog of Daniel Bryan would have torn the house down in a one on one capacity.

The timing never seemed quite right with this potential matchup, between Bryan's early retirement and The Undertaker's progressively reduced activity as a wrestler. During the late-streak period, the pair would have produced a classic, worthy of the big stage at WrestleMania. The Undertaker's superior size would surely have come into play, with Daniel Bryan going on the offensive to chop the big man down to size, chipping away at him with strikes and submissions. The resourcefulness of the plucky 'Yes! Man' against a monstrous 'Phenom' would have seen a great story, build, and top-class in-ring psychology.

The Undertaker's strength in working with smaller wrestlers would have shone through here, making Daniel Bryan look like a fierce and credible threat.


5. Aleister Black

Aleister Black NXT
WWE

The parallels between The Undertaker and Aleister Black would have made for a compelling story and strike-fest of a matchup.

The mind games both wrestlers are so proficient in would comprise the core of the build to the match. It's easy to imagine a battle of wits, played out week after week with each man attempting to gain the upper hand, before engaging in their strike-fest. The in-ring story the two competitors would have told writes itself as well. The Undertaker has met his match, a challenge for his reputation as the best pure striker in WWE.

The match itself would have been composed of stiff strikes and rough brawling. It would never have been a technical masterpiece, but it never would have needed to be. This style of match would have helped mask The Undertaker's late-career shortcomings. It wouldn't have been pretty, or grandiose, but it certainly would have been an effective slugfest.


4. The Rock

Rock, the undertaker
WWE.com

This entry is definitely cheating, but hear me out.

We have seen The Rock and The Undertaker clash on many occasions, in some excellent contests one on one and in multi-person matches. What we never got to see however, was a singles exhibition between the two men on 'The Grandest Stage of Them All,' WrestleMania. This is the definition of a big money match, and could have realistically taken place any time during The Rock's numerous returns, as The Undertaker was always there.

While in more recent years this match could have turned out to be dud, due to The Rock's inevitable ring rust and The Undertaker's in-ring decline, regardless of timing this match would have made WWE an awful lot of money. The Attitude Era icons have established chemistry, and would have been an apt match to stage during the latter years of The Undertaker defending his undefeated streak.

A marquee match if there ever was one, a tie of this magnitude would have been the main event of any WrestleMania in which it took place.


3. Eddie Guerrero

The Undertaker Eddie Guerrero Booker T Armageddon 2004
WWE.com

There was so much opportunity for a one on one rivalry between these two legends, but due to extremely unfortunate circumstances it never took place.

Having worked with each other in a Fatal 4-Way match at Armageddon in 2004, we were teased with what could have been in a showdown between the two very different wrestlers. While the composition of such a singles bout very much would rely on the classic Undertaker vs. small wrestler setup, Eddie Guerrero would have offered so much more.

Eddie, in his charismatic lying, cheating, and stealing ways, would have ripped up the rule book and tried everything in his power to overcome an unstoppable Undertaker. Unlike the rest of the matches on this list, with 'Latino Heat' involved, there would have been as much room for a technical showcase as there would have been for a humorous in-ring story.

The legendary Eddie Guerrero tragically passed away in November 2005, rendering this match impossible. There is every chance this tandem could have put on a match, or series of matches, for the ages.


2. 'The Fiend' Bray Wyatt

The Fiend Seth Rollins
WWE.com

The Undertaker has faced Bray Wyatt before, but never like this.

'The Fiend' Bray Wyatt is the obvious heir apparent to the mantle of WWE's residential supernatural character. The pair have faced off before, most notably at WrestleMania 31, long before the existence of 'The Fiend' persona. A match between these two distinct personalities would have presented a true passing of the torch moment, from one generation to the next.

While it would have been unlikely to be a five-star classic, the sheer drama and in-ring psychology would have been surely superb. In the ring, 'The Fiend' would have authentically been able to put down 'The Deadman' emphatically. Outside of the ring, during the build-up, Bray Wyatt and 'The Fiend' entity would have provided incredible chances to outwit The Undertaker, and beat him at his own tactic using mind games.

With 'The Fiend' having been unveiled to the WWE Universe in 2019, it was unlikely this match was ever going to happen. Perhaps it's better this hasn't taken place, but it cannot be denied this is a mouth-watering dream match for many wrestling fans out there. A clever way to circumvent 'The Phenom's' declined in-ring ability would have been to craft a cinematic match, just like the much-vaunted Boneyard and Firefly Funhouse matches from WrestleMania 36. Both men's supernatural-infused gimmicks would have suited this perfectly.


1. Sting

Sting WWE
WWE.com

Could it have been anyone else? The Undertaker vs. Sting is a dream match that tops the lists of many fans, not just for The Undertaker, but as one of the biggest matches that has never happened. A lot like some of my other inclusions in this list, this is also a cheat entry of sorts.

Back in 1990, this match did take place in WCW. The Undertaker, working as the villainous 'Mean Mark' Callous was on his way out of the company to the greener pastures of the then-WWF. Sting was still rocking his more colourful garb and surfer look.

These men battled each other for years, but for the prize of television ratings during the Monday Night Wars. Ever since, fans have been clamouring to see this fantasy matchup take place. 2011 was the closest we ever got to seeing this match come to fruition, with Sting openly admitting he was offered a match with 'The Deadman' at Wrestlemania XXVII, which he turned down.

Once again, timing was the enemy for this potential clash. Sting joined WWE in November 2014 and went on to feud with Triple H and The Authority. Less than a year later, Sting was forced to take a step back from active competition after enduring a legitimate and serious neck injury.

It's essentially guaranteed that this match will never take place, but one cannot help but wonder how these living legends would have fared against each other.


Watch Next


WWE: You Won't Get 100% On This True Or False The Undertaker Quiz!

The Undertaker Last Ride Gavel
WWE Network

1. The Undertaker's Real Name Is Mark Stephen Callaway.

Contributor
Contributor

Paul is an Irish writer who loves all things gaming, especially terribly long RPG games which consume his life. Co-founder, editor and a senior contributor at casualgamecritic.com. Paul also enjoys music from bands who are old, middle-aged and/or dead, watching people in spandex fight and endlessly re-watching his favourite TV shows. @psm2187