10 Unofficial Rules That Exist In WWE Today
Looking at the top 10 unspoken guidelines that shape WWE.
All businesses have rules; some official, some unofficial, but to work for a company is to know what is expected of the employees and that includes specific guidelines that are to be followed. The world of professional wrestling and the WWE are no different as they, too, have their own set of rules that they expect the employees to abide by.
We don't mean wrestling rules like having ten seconds to get back inside the ring, breaking a hold when the opponent touches the ropes, or getting disqualified for using a steel chair, but rules that talents should abide by if they don't want to ruffle any feathers. A few rules may even apply to the company itself, but would be good for the talents to know.
In another era, half of these rules might be thrown out the window or not apply given the nature of both the talents and the environment of professional wrestling back in the day, but in 2015, these seem to be followed much more than they're forgotten. These laws being discussed won't be found in any sort of handout or collateral a talent receives when being promoted to the main roster. No: think of these rules as tips that might be shared from a veteran worker to a respectful rookie on a car ride from one town to the next.
Some of these unofficial rules may carry a larger impact than others, but all of them help shape the world that WWE is today.
10. All Babyfaces Must Smile
This rule might as well be posted at Gorilla next to INTENSITY and SELL and other WWE buzzwords that have been seen posted there before. If you're a babyface in WWE, you must show your smile!
The Rocky Maivia narrative explains how chants of "Die Rocky Die!" and "Rocky Sucks!" led to an eventual heel turn that created the biggest crossover star in WWE history, The Rock. In 1996, the happy-go-lucky Rocky Maivia was always grinning from ear-to-ear no matter the circumstance and it made fans want to vomit. Fast forward to 2015 and it's painfully obvious that every babyface on the roster is not only reminded to smile like Maivia did, but it's probably the last thing they hear before they walk through the curtain. Oh and the bogus "have fun" line.
Think about all the babyfaces in WWE today and name one that hasn't smiled. Even The Beast Brock Lesnar has been seen laughing and smiling whether it's at the fans' "Suplex City" chants or after giving Michael Cole a noogie. This is definitely a newer rule implemented over the past several years because superstars like Ultimate Warrior, Steve Austin, and Macho Man sure didn't smile often. Despite what some fans may believe, there is room for happy, smiling characters in WWE today so long as they are booked and positioned right. What isn't tolerable though is having every babyface that appears on television be commanded to smile just because they're the "good guy".
I'm not saying wrestlers should never smile, but the number of WWE babyfaces that look like they just found the "Smylex" ingredient from new and improved Joker Products is disturbing. If everyone busts through the curtain showing their pearly whites implying a "just happy to be here" attitude, the company is likely to continue churning out more Rocky Maivias than they will Rocks.
9. Everything Needs Approval
Thinking outside the box? Got a new move? A new design or logo for wrestling gear? For talents, the answer's always the same, "Is it approved?". It's understandable for WWE to have a proper chain of command and approval process, but what isn't sensible is for it to apply to everything under the sun. It comes down to creative freedom.
In WWE, everything needs to be approved before a talent can even consider using it on television, but is that really necessary? God knows today's performers get enough training and brainwashing education from WWE the moment they sign with the company that the talents should have a pretty good understanding of what it likes and dislikes by the time they make it to the main roster.
If the talent isn't capable or worthy of being given some freedom with their character and letting them run with it, then why are they even employed? It would be like if the Premier League or the NFL suddenly wanted the owners to approve every play before it gets run on the field - isn't that the point of hiring coaches? And don't you trust the players to execute properly? They know the rules, they know the goals, they know the purpose, now let them do it. It's the same thing for talented professional wrestlers that make it all the way to RAW; if they're good enough and smart enough to have made it that far, shouldn't they be given some faith? It's amazing how many people that want to do certain jobs are actually good at doing certain jobs without needing to run every minor detail up the chain of command.
8. Finishing Moves Don't Exist
There are no finishing moves in WWE anymore. There are signature moves, like the Attitude Adjustment and the F5, that have come to be associated with a certain character, but they aren't finishers. True finishers end matches most often and nobody's "finisher" in WWE today ends the match that regularly anymore. At their peak, the Tombstone, the Sharpshooter, the Leg Drop, and the Power Bomb were just a few finishing moves that nobody got out of. In the extremely rare case where these moves didn't result in the end of the match, those moments were protected and saved for the biggest of the biggest events: the main event of WrestleMania VI, the main event of SummerSlam '97, for example.
Unlike today where every month's PPV has someone kicking out of another star's "finisher", true finishing moves of the past would go years and years without being kicked out of. Bret's Sharpshooter lasted for over six years before someone ever powered out of it. Is it even possible to imagine something like that happening today? Today's WWE is a world where the "finisher" works sometimes and it doesn't work at other times, where sometimes it takes a second use and sometimes two's not enough, and sometimes it lays an opponent out, rendering them motionless for minutes on end and sometimes they're up after 2 seconds, ready for the next move. With inconsistency like that, the move is not a finisher, it's just a regular wrestling move.
7. Talent Sometimes Rises To The Top
"The cream always rises to the top," has been one of WWE's favorite sayings over the years, but in reality, it's been a long time since that's been true. Too many gifted, top-level talents have gone their entire careers without even sniffing a real main event. Superstars like Tyson Kidd, Cesaro, Natalya, and Dolph Ziggler are just a few examples of talents that were among the most talented performers in WWE but never positioned as such. Though their careers are not over, WWE's misuse of these talents have only helped dispel the myth that the cream always rises to the top.
Daniel Bryan and Finn Bálor are examples of times when the best talents have enjoyed success, but the new rule should read "The cream sometimes rises to the top." While there have been some superstars in years past that WWE has missed the boat on, the rate at which they are missing on blatantly obvious, immensely talented performers today is alarming. If WWE always operated this way then superstars like Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels, and Steve Austin might never have reached the heights they did. The company might be a totally different one than what it is today although they often seem to be hell-bent on reaching that destination anyway.
6. Commentary Isn't Important
During the various peaks of professional wrestling, the commentators played as important a role as any on WWE television shows. Whether it was Jesse Ventura explaining the heel's actions or Jim Ross encouraging fans to get behind the babyfaces, each commentator had a responsibility to help tell the story that was taking place in the ring.
Man oh man, have the times ever changed. Today, their responsibilities seem to have shifted away from assisting in the storytelling and into a function that includes advertising products and services that extend beyond the ring. Whether it's promoting a sponsor or product placement, the commentary team's job go way beyond what Gorilla Monsoon and Bobby Heenan dealt with. In addition, Vince McMahon is in the ear of everyone at the booth and is basically calling all the action but through the voices of whomever is seated at ringside.
Despite all the changes to the position though, it hasn't improved the show and the vast majority agree that the viewer gains nothing by listening to the commentary team's audio. The announcers often miss calls and important spots, instead focusing on verbally sparring with each other or discussing social media. To mute RAW while the commentary team is working is an improvement to the television show. That cannot be the desired result of WWE, but as it is, it can be done without and illustrates this rule
5. The WrestleMania Main Event Doesn't Matter Anymore
WrestleMania III broke the world indoor attendance record because the main event of Hulk Hogan vs. Andre the Giant was a match that everyone wanted to see. WrestleMania V generated nearly 800,000 PPV buys at a time when PPV was only just getting off the ground because the main event of Hulk Hogan vs. Macho Man was a match that everyone wanted to see. WrestleMania X-Seven is considered one of, if not THE, greatest WrestleManias of all time for many reasons but a large part involves the main event when Stone Cold Steve Austin battled The Rock in a match everyone wanted to see.
The past two WrestleManias have featured one of, if not THE, least over character in the history of the Show of Shows' main event in Roman Reigns. Unlike past WrestleManias, few wanted to see The Man in this position. Similarly in 2014, few people wanted to see Batista challenge for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship. All this is to say that the main event of WrestleMania no longer has the importance it once held and is no longer the selling point of the show.
The last match at WrestleMania used to be THE biggest match of the year and the success of the company's year was determined by it. Hogan and Andre helped make 1987 one of WWE's best years ever. Conversely, Lawrence Taylor vs. Bam Bam Bigelow personified 1995 perfectly. Nowadays, the WWE has done such a great job branding WrestleMania to emulate the Super Bowl that it no longer matters what the marquee match-up will be, the show itself is the draw.
4. All Talking Segments Must Be Scripted
For those that don't understand why WWE scripts every last bit of dialogue they can, allow me to explain: WWE does not want to take the risks associated with talents being allowed to "shoot from the hip" or use their own words. WWE wants every word spoken to be with their approved language as they don't trust their talents enough as they should.
It's understandable that a huge publicly traded company like WWE wants to limit their risks and mitigate any potential slip-ups by their talents, but when the company's entire existence is based upon creativity and a unique form of live-action storytelling, creative freedom is an absolute must. It's the nature of the beast. Maybe not every single talent should be given a live mic on RAW and told to "go for it", but there's far too many restrictions placed on the talents these days and their scripted promos top the list.
It's really ironic when you think about it. WWE scripts everything in order to keep their sponsors and business partners happy which is directly tied to WWE wanting to achieve the desired perception by the public and mainstream media. Vince McMahon has always wanted to be accepted and respected in the entertainment business, but what garners respect in show-business isn't safe, wooden scripting, but good, compelling storytelling that doesn't insult its audiences' intelligence. Are the zombies, the killings, and the gore that appear on The Walking Dead politically correct? How about the incest, womanizing, and violence seen on Game Of Thrones? Those two shows are far from PC, but they are damn sure respected in show-business. Everyone's laughing at you WWE, but by all means, continue to perpetuate the cycle.
3. It's OK To Steal Spots From The Main Event
A WWE PPV used to be a carefully conducted, thoroughly planned out show from the opening contest to the main event. Matches that occurred later in the card, usually the higher profile contests, were protected by not having similar spots performed earlier in the show. For example, if the last match was going to feature the use of a steel chair, or maybe a story where the heel worked the babyface's leg, none of those spots would be seen earlier in the night in order to protect the originality and success of the main event.
Well, that's clearly no longer a priority because, in terms of what's restricted from being used in order to keep the main event special, the current roster and agents' match plans are the Wild West. Too often, the same stories are told in multiple matches throughout a WWE show and even finishes are re-used and recycled for matches, including the main event. Take Hell in a Cell for example, where the same spots reoccurred in all three marquee cell contests. It's understandable that talents want to steal the show each night out, but there seems to be no professional courtesy and no protection for what is planned later in the show by the producers or talents. Unfortunately, the matches aren't the only thing that lack the necessary protection in WWE today...
2. Talents Don't Need To Be Protected
In addition to the match order and main event spots not being respected or protected, neither are the talents themselves. The difference here is that, with the various spots and matches, the responsibility can be placed on the talents. In this case, however, it's the bookers and writers that are to blame. It also doesn't help that commentary blatantly ignores key spots and character development, but their apparent responsibilities have already been discussed.
Enhancement talent and lower mid-card performers don't always need to be protected, but in WWE today, too many top level talents and performers with potential are being exposed and left unprotected by their booking on WWE television.
Stephanie McMahon is a prime perpetrator here. While men aren't able to do much physically in response to Stephanie, they also don't need to be put into a position making them look weak and humiliated without ever getting a comeback. When it comes to the women, Stephanie's wrestled one match in the past 10 years and, oh by the way, she won! How is that protecting anyone other than Stephanie? It's important to protect talents by ensuring heels keep their heat and babyfaces get comebacks, otherwise the audience loses interest, they don't believe in the characters, and nobody gets over. If that's WWE's end game, then job well done.
1. Getting Over Is No Longer The Goal

The most alarming rule that appears to exist in WWE today is that getting over with the crowd is no longer the ultimate goal. In fact, if talents want to be employed for any length of time and in a worthwhile position in the company, they shouldn't even attempt to get over unless they've been given specific instruction to. Instead of rewarding talents that connect organically with the crowds, today's WWE seems to foster an opposite environment. The company seems to have a pre-determined choice of whom they will "allow" to get over and even then, the chosen performer(s) must use the methods and strategies the company tells them and cannot take any liberties in their attempt to become a star.
It's a ridiculous, counterproductive approach to creating new stars. Zack Ryder is a great example of a talent who got over on his own, but because it wasn't approved by WWE and he wasn't one of their "chosen ones", he was soon buried and taken off full-time TV. Cesaro and Damien Sandow are more recent examples of talents that weren't expected to get over and as soon as the audience showed signs of supporting them, WWE positioned them to look weak and squashed their momentum (or took them off TV altogether).
As hard as it is to believe, actions speak louder than words and all of WWE's actions indicate that, unless the talent has been selected, getting over should not be the goal and maybe not even attempted. Despite the bogus brass ring myth, talents should do as their told, don't step out of line, and maybe one day, the company will anoint them as a lukewarm, mediocre sports-entertainer.