10 Ups & 5 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (May 21)
Big E & Dolph Ziggler return, Kingston battles Zayn, and Shane crushes Reigns.
Once considered WWE's most consistent weekly brand, recent weeks have seen SmackDown struggle for quality, with the 14 May episode a particularly mundane offering from the new, Road Dogg-less writing team. Fortunately, this week's episode was something of a rebound. As the Ups-to-Downs ratio attests, it wasn't perfect, but the night's biggest problems stemmed from one specific performer on whom your mileage will likely vary anyway.
WWE.com's pre-show blurb promised Big E's big return, and we got it in a typically entertaining New Day opening segment that, predictably, didn't pass without incident. The 24/7 Title brought all kinds of chaos to Tuesday nights, too. R-Truth began the evening as champion and was forced to go to extreme lengths to keep hold of his dark green strap, resulting in some of the evening's silliest (read: most fun) moments.
Elsewhere, we got new SmackDown Women's Champion Bayley teaming with Raw counterpart Becky Lynch to face Charlotte Flair and Lacey Evans. Kofi Kingston faced Sami Zayn in a non-title bout, Carmella and Mandy Rose brought their Twitter beef to television, and Andrade and Ali kept the workrate fans satisfied.
Fingers crossed that this show signals a return to form. SmackDown must recover before the Fox deal starts in October...
Downs...
5. Wild Card W*nkery II: Return Of The W*nk
Please enjoy the above image of Drake Maverick trying to keep up with WWE's inability to adhere to the Wild Card Rule.
Last night once again saw five wrestlers cross over from Raw, with Maverick, Sami Zayn, Becky Lynch (who pledged herself to the red brand 24 hours prior), Drew McIntyre, and Lacey Evans all appearing. The limit is still four, by the way.
Join us next week when WWE will hopefully get this sh*t right.
4. A Nothing Match
While the "match" served its purpose of setting up R-Truth vs. The Midcard, Mandy Rose vs. Carmella was a wet fart.
Sonya Deville and the wig-clad Truth's ringside presence made it clear this was going to be a big pile of nonsense from the first ring entrance. The early focus was on the 24/7 Championship, not the action, communicating that Rose vs. 'Mella wasn't in the least bit important. From there, we got some rudimentary action between two mid-level wrestlers, before Sonya got involved, earning a beatdown from 'The Princess Of Staten Island' for her troubles. This all led to Rose scoring a two-count and Carmella fighting back before the procession of midcarders ran down to chase Truth off as Corey Graves bickered with his fellow announcers.
Tedious, contrived, and predictable, this was significantly less entertaining than Carmella's deleted tweet on the supposedly "unsafe" Rose.
3. Spoiling The Squash
While the match itself wasn't bad (far from it, in fact), that WWE decided to run Roman Reigns vs. Elias II so soon after Money In The Bank stunk.
Sunday's booking was perfect. 'The Big Dog' squashing 'The Drifter' in nine seconds was the right move, as, with Roman's post-return crowd reactions souring (unfortunately), a dull 12-minute chinlock fest would deal further damage to his support levels. Elias is ostensibly a jobber to the stars, too. He's never going to be 'The Guy,' and he's so adept at drawing heat that he can recover from such shellackings in an instant. There's no way a guy like that should look competitive against Roman bloody Reigns.
Re-running the bout 48 hours later undermined that effective piece of booking, and that Reigns would go close to nine minutes with Elias after thrashing him so soundly at MITB makes no sense. Yes, most of Elias' in-roads came from Shane McMahon's interference, and yes, Roman won, but the bout's existence remains problematic.
2. Oh, Great. This Guy.
Sigh.
Perhaps Dolph Ziggler's assault on Kofi Kingston would have come off stronger if he wasn't Dolph bloody Ziggler, but he is. The guy's still staler than week-old bread despite his four-month absence from television, and after years and years of being booked like a loser, your writer found it impossible to give a d*mn about 'The Show-Off's' reintroduction.
Dolph made his presence felt after Kofi had defeated Sami Zayn. He made the most of Paul Heyman's teased cash-in, ambushing the WWE Champion before battering him around the ring, then destroying his neck with a steel chair. Kingston was done. It was a stretcher job, but Kofi, the fighter that he is, rejected medical assistance, opting to head to the back of his own volition instead.
The former internet darling outlived his use as a pushable commodity years ago. His performance abilities haven't waned, but expecting a wide audience to invest in Ziggler is nuts. You can't spend the best part of a decade undermining a guy then bring him back as a hot-shotted main eventer.
1. Shut Up & Stop Crying
Where to start with this horrible Dolph Ziggler promo?
This thing stunk. It began with 'The Show-Off' rejecting a backstage interview and heading to the stage, claiming he'd boo himself if he was part of the crowd. Cue: the year's most cringe-worthy faux passionate delivery. Ziggler was trying to convey the idea that he was so upset by his own actions that it was bringing him close to tears, yet he sounded like an upset toddler who'd lost their favourite teddy. Couple this with that textbook '90s-style quiet/loud thing he likes to do on promos and his delivery was laughable.
Ziggler ran through Kofi Kingston's many triumphs, finishing each point with an "it should have been me." Nah, mate. You haven't won a big match since Pepsi Crystal was a hot product. This led to the reveal that he was facing Kingston for the WWE Championship at Super Showdown, because "he has to," before promising that every single audience member would come to admire and respect him.
Don't get worked into thinking that this is the start of a proper main event run for Ziggler. The man has come back for a sweet Saudi Arabian paycheque: nothing more, nothing less.
Ups...
10. Oh Hey There, Heyman...
We didn't catch a glimpse of Brock Lesnar on last night's SmackDown, but it was cool to see his Advocate, Paul Heyman, show up to tease Kofi Kingston.
Paul emerged after Kofi had thwarted Sami Zayn, then disappeared when Dolph Ziggler struck. A fleeting moment, but a strong one. The idea that Lesnar could conceivably show up on SmackDown and cash in on Kofi is as exciting as the prospect of him profiting at such a beloved champion's expense is terrifying. More than that, it raises SD's prestige ahead of the Fox move as, like him or not, Lesnar remains the biggest male name in the company. He's a different level of star to all these other guys, so let's hope he shows up sometime soon.
9. Shane Sets Elias Straight
Shane McMahon is coming off like a manipulative piece of sh*t in his alliance with Elias, and that's a good thing.
The night began with the duo backstage. Elias walked in on Shane while he was on a call, then profusely apologised for how his Money In The Bank match with Roman Reigns went. Claiming that he put his full energy into his performance and that the crowd calling him names put him off his game, 'The Drifter' was in full grovel mode, telling 'The Best In The World' that he and his family deserved better.
C*ntery ensued. When Elias offered to corner McMahon at Super Showdown, Shane said "nah," claiming he didn't need anyone's help to beat Roman Reigns. McMahon then insisted that he would accompany Elias for that night's bout, thus dealing the most definitive "sit down" moment of the whole evening.
This is emasculating, but it'll reap dividends for Elias. Imagine the pop when he finally turns on this bell-end.
8. Welcome Back
As dull, repetitive, and copy/paste as Raw and SmackDown's post-Wild Card opening segments have become, last night's was at least fun. Big E's "Welcome Back" ceremony had enough laughs and personality to transcend the basic writing, and it began with a case of mistaken identity.
Xavier Woods and Kofi Kingston's introduction yielded an imposter who, in Woods' words, "looked like Big E got left in the dryer." He peaced out as The New Day threw pancakes at him, before the real E showed up with heavy strapping around his recovering left knee, leading to the usual banter segment from WWE's premier trio.
The celebrations were cut short when Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn emerged, with the latter complaining about his lack of return party after re-emerging the night after WrestleMania. KO bailed, leaving Sami with the babyfaces, and with Zayn spitting hot bile at Booy Os, pancakes, and The New Day themselves, it was an enjoyable time.
7. Roman Beats The Odds
Roman Reigns vs. Elias II shouldn't have existed, but at least the execution was on-point.
This was a fun little shenanigan-fuelled battle between an outstanding TV wrestler and an effective stooge heel. Shane McMahon was heavily involved, taunting Roman at every opportunity, leading to the bulk of 'The Drifter's' offence. 'The Big Dog' controlled things for the most part. He succumbed to heel tactics on several occasions but survived each time, and he looked good throughout, hitting his trademark offence with the kind of impact we've come to expect from the former WWE Champion, who played his role in this pantomime perfectly.
Shane put Elias' foot on the ropes following a Superman Punch, leading to Reigns battering McMahon. Elias slammed his opponent into the steps soon after. His diving elbow got a two-count before Shane slid the guitar in, but a Spear and the 1, 2, 3 thwarted the villain.
Reigns going 2-0 over Elias was the correct move. 50/50 booking is the death of stars, so at least WWE got that part right.
6. Bayley & Becky Triumph
Bayley and Becky Lynch vs. Lacey Evans and Charlotte Flair was as close to an all-star women's tag match as WWE can deliver at the moment. It was the Raw and SmackDown Champions against the two most recent contenders, and this solid, well-crafted bout ticked the right boxes.
While nothing blowaway, the action delivered. It was three seasoned TV wrestlers and a promising up-and-comer keeping it simple without sacrificing the necessary story beats. Here, got Flair controlling traffic for her side, just as she'd done in her and Lacey's post-match beatdown of Lynch at Money In The Bank, while Bayley and Becky showed the kind of cohesion you'd expect from two performers who came through developmental together.
There were a couple of teases that we might soon see Bayley vs. 'The Man,' particularly after 'The Hugger' had scored the victory, with the duo looking a little cagey as they celebrated. That'll be one hell of a bout if it goes down on pay-per-view, so let's keep those fingers crossed.
5. 24/7 Chaos
The belt itself might be ugly as sin but the 24/7 Championship has already brought a sorely-missed chaos factor back to WWE programming, with its madcap segments delivering boatloads of fun throughout last night's SmackDown in particular.
R-Truth spent his evening on the run. He left Raw with the belt, and decided to disguise himself with a blonde wig and crop top to evade the company's midcard. This led to him being chased away from Carmella's bout with Mandy Rose and a bunch of different backstage interactions, with The B-Team bickering over who'd take his title, Drake Maverick huffing and puffing, Jinder Mahal almost stealing the strap, along with Brian Kendrick and Noam Dar showing up from 205 Live.
This gimmick is a hoot. It gets people on television, provides a few laughs, and breaks the show up. It isn't to be taken seriously and therefore shouldn't be. Just sit back, grab some popcorn, and enjoy the mayhem.
4. Rehabilitated
Bayley as SmackDown Women's Champion is a very good thing indeed, and what went down at Money In The Bank proves that when they want to, WWE can rehabilitate almost any broken character within a single show.
'The Hugger' cut a solid little promo with Kayla Braxton last night. She called Sunday "brutal," but said she'd do it all again, claiming to have created her own opportunity to make it impossible for anyone to ever doubt her again. Now, finally, she has moved past the hugs, and she wants each of her challengers to bring their best when they tangle.
Pre-Money In The Bank, there was a pressing need to elevate new women to Becky Lynch and Charlotte Flair's level, particularly with Ronda Rousey absent. Last night confirmed that they have successfully accomplished this with Bayley. She came off assured and confident in her promo, and felt like a big deal as she strode to the ring. On top of this, WWE let her score the decisive pinfall rather than 'The Man,' cementing a big night for one of the company's most valuable babyface commodities.
3. Making The Most Of It
While Kofi Kingston vs. Sami Zayn was hampered by a restrictive eight-minute runtime, it's impossible to fault the wrestlers themselves. They did everything in their power to make it work, and their efforts elevated what could have been a routine, run-of-the-mill TV bout to a different level.
A fired up WWE Champion started hard and fast. An adrenaline-fuelled blitz saw Sami poot on the back foot immediate, before Zayn, the dastardly bastard, bundled Kofi out of the ring. Kingston at the steps, then a flurry of punches, but fired back between the ropes, with his dropkick leading into the ad break. Afterwards, we got a Superplex for a two-count, a countered Helluva Kick, the former 'Underdog From The Underground' working his way out of Trouble In Paradise, then eventually eating it for the defeat.
It was good to see Kingston pick up yet another clean victory over solid opposition, as has been the theme throughout his reign so far. WWE are doing a fine job of presenting him as a fighting champion.
2. Of Course Ali Vs. Andrade Was Good
Andrade vs. Ali might be the most predictable Up in this week's column, but the match is here on merit. Two of the most athletic and exciting wrestlers on the brand collided in an all-action midcard affair that scratched the workrate itch, told a decent little story, and delivered a finish that kept things open for a possible rematch.
The former 'Cien' refused to take Ali seriously last night. He constantly mocked and taunted the ex-205 Live man throughout, with him and Zelina Vega hitting the tranquilo pose early on. This continued, and the braggadocio looked justified as Andrade ground his high-flying opponent down, controlling him for long periods as Ali struggled to fight back.
The heat escalated as Andrade tossed the smaller man into the technical area, and shock etched his face as the former Mustafa kicked out of his double knees in the corner. This fed directly into the finish, as Ali cradled Andrade, scored the pinfall, then made a hasty retreat.
This fortuitous victory means we're almost certainly getting round two before long. Who could complain about such a prospect after last night's showing?
1. Keeping Roman Busy
WWE have handled Roman Reigns' SmackDown run well so far.
Rather than throwing him straight into the WWE Title hunt (which would have absolutely killed his crowd reactions), the company have kept him on the fringes, with 'The Big Dog' battling Shane McMahon and his forces of evil instead. It's going over well, and last night's events leave plenty on the table for Roman.
He'll face Shane at Super Showdown, but will that really be the end of their rivalry? These events are overblown house shows. The beef between Reigns and his boss feels like it could be stretched through summer, so don't expect them to call it quits after Saudi Arabia.
Drew McIntyre awaits, too. Unveiled as Shane's latest charge on Raw, the Scot left Reigns lying last night, nailing him with a Claymore to close the show. Then there's Elias, who may yet be fed to 'The Big Dog' again before the Shane storyline concludes.
That's good booking, and having this many options on the table means Reigns won't run out of steam anytime soon.