10 Ups And 13 Downs From WWE WrestleMania 35

KofiMania and The Man can't save long, inconsistent show.

kofi kingston wwe champion
WWE.com

Well, that was a show.

WrestleMania 35 is in the books, and it was not for the faint of heart. The show started before dinnertime Sunday evening (Eastern Time) and finished early Monday morning (literally, as it was after midnight).

Along the way, we saw 16 matches, including seven title changes (eight, if you count the main event as being two title changes). It was a marathon viewing experience, one that you can only do once a year. The long show led to a burned-out crowd, despite WWE giving fans largely what they wanted: fan-favorites won major matches and there were only a few legit “WTF” booking moments.

But the quality of wrestling definitely took a hit Sunday night. WrestleMania 35 will not be remembered for it’s solid in-ring action. Only the WWE Championship, Cruiserweight Championship and women’s title matches qualified as really good bouts. Some of the matches felt extraneous and could have been moved to another PPV to get more attention, including Roman Reigns’ big comeback match.

When it’s all said and done, WM 35 will probably fall in the lower third of all Mania PPVs. You can’t do a seven-hour show and not deliver good wrestling throughout and/or iconic moments. And Colin Jost competing in a battle royal, the Outsiders posing as doctors or Hulk Hogan rambling for two minutes don’t count.

With that said, let’s get to it…


Downs...

13. Carmella Hides To Win

carmella battle royal
WWE.com

Leave it to WWE to go for the lamest finish possible for its Women’s WrestleMania Battle Royal.

Whoever books these battle royals definitely leave a lot to be desired when it comes to actually telling a story with the match itself. We saw Ember Moon return to action for the first time in months – with no mention of her absence or return – and run wild in the early stages, only to get tossed unceremoniously by Lana.

Then the Riott Squad took over and eliminated a few women before Dana Brooke tossed Ruby Riott and Liv Morgan, only get bounced herself. Finally, Asuka ran wild until Sarah Logan, who had a couple small moments throughout, appeared to win by tossing the Empress of Tomorrow.

Only, she didn’t. That’s because Carmella had been hiding on the outside, re-entered the match and won by tossing Logan. Because that’s what we needed here. The babyface woman who didn’t eliminate anyone and disappeared mid-match reappeared to win.

LAME.


12. Another Battle Royal, Another Cheap Ending

braun strowman
WWE.com

Remember when the first Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal was a big deal, part of the main card at WrestleMania 30 and highlighted by Cesaro slamming Big Show out of the ring? Many thought the battle royal could serve as a launching pad for wrestlers.

Now, it’s something to occupy the kickoff show and squeeze a bunch of guys onto the card. This year, it became a bad joke. Colin Jost and Michael Che from Saturday Night Live “participated” in the battle royal, immediately hiding under the ring for the entire bout as everyone got tossed rapid-fire.

Jost and Che re-entered the ring (didn’t we just see someone sneak back into the battle royal at the end an hour earlier?) and tried to eliminate Braun Strowman, to no avail. Braun would quickly get his revenge, but not before Jost tried to have his therapist calm him down.

Yes, this was a match that happened. At least Braun won convincingly.


11. A Waste Of Cena

John Cena Elias
WWE.com

Ever since Baron Corbin was announced as Kurt Angle’s final opponent, fans have been clamoring for John Cena to replace him. But it was not to be.

Fast-forward to WrestleMania, and lo and behold, Cena was indeed available Sunday night, and he did show up at MetLife Stadium, but it wasn’t to compete against Angle. No, Cena came out in his throwback persona, the Doctor of Thugonomics, to interrupt and beat up Elias.

Because when you think of what to do with John Cena at WrestleMania, that’s what you come up with. That’s not to say that his put-downs of Elias weren’t great and it was fun seeing him turn back the clock a bit, but knowing where he could have been used made this annoying.

And look, someone is probably saying that Cena likely has a movie he’s working on and couldn’t wrestle a match. But then don’t bring him out like this at all. Don’t tease him out there like this, only for him to be used for something pointless.


10. Evans Wastes Time

lacey evans
WWE.com

A lot of the sideshow stuff that happens on WWE PPVs can be construed as wastes of time, especially with shows running longer and longer.

But Lacey Evans strutting out at WrestleMania, getting introduced and then leaving the stage? Yeah, total waste of time. No nutritional value whatsoever. Why is she here? What is she trying to accomplish? Hell, EC3 has said more than Evans has.

One has to wonder if WWE doesn’t pull the trigger and have Evans do something – anything – on the Raw or SmackDown after WrestleMania, if they’ll ever have her do anything. Seriously, if she struts again Monday and/or Tuesday without doing something of consequence, then this “joke” will be beyond dead.


9. Styles Dragged Down To Second Gear

AJ styles Randy orton
WWE.com

God bless AJ Styles for trying, but at this stage in Randy Orton’s career, it takes a miracle to move any quicker.

Styles and Orton had a grudge match at WrestleMania that technically was fine, but it just dragged on at too slow of a clip. AJ tried to ramp it up a couple times, but to no avail. Thankfully, Styles avoided the Phenomenal Forearm into an RKO that some might have expected, even faking Orton out at one point and fending him off at another.

AJ would pick up the win here, but the match itself was largely forgettable, and hardly the “main event of any PPV” that the announcers were trying to bill it.


8. Ricochet, Black Come Up Empty

cesaro usos
WWE.com

Seriously, what the hell WWE?

The dynamic duo of Ricochet & Aleister Black have been on a rocket to the top of WWE’s tag team division during the past couple months, and they seemed slated to reach the top Sunday night at WrestleMania.

Only, they didn’t.

The duo didn’t lose per se, but the Usos retained their SmackDown Tag Team Championship by pinning Sheamus to finish a chaotic fatal four-way tag match. It just felt deflating, as the Usos are great, but probably would have benefited from a change of scenery, while Ricochet & Black were poised to cap the weekend with a win.

Instead, the duo has now lost three tag title matches in one week (Raw by countout, NXT by pinfall, and SmackDown via Sheamus being pinned). Just very bizarre booking that hopefully will make sense sometime in the near future.

Hmmm, maybe tomorrow on Raw?


7. Women’s Tag Match Plays To Silence

sasha banks iconics
WWE.com

Unless the crowd mics were turned off, it was eerily silent during the WWE Women’s Championship fatal four-way match.

The bout itself was a disjointed mess, without any real flow. Nia Jax and Tamina were knocked out of the bout for long periods. Beth Phoenix looked good in her return to regular action, even hitting a super-Glam Slam that proved to be the difference – only for the Iiconics to steal the pin.

Yes, Billie Kay and Peyton Royce won the tag titles. The afterthought tag team that annoys on the mic and underperforms in the ring won. Even Nia & Tamina would have been better.

And even that could have been overlooked a bit if the match had been any good, but it wasn’t.


6. Triple H, Batista Slowly Brawl

Triple H Batista
WWE.com

If you had low expectations for the No Holds Barred match between Triple H and Batista, you weren’t alone. Batista hadn’t competed in five years, while Hunter was recovering from a torn pec.

Both men tried to rise to the occasion, but the result was a slow bout that wasn’t bad, but just long. As expected, there were plenty of smoke and mirrors, as both men battered each other with stiff shots, using chairs, steps, sledgehammers, tables and even pliers. Triple H used the pliers to first “break” Batista’s fingers, and then ripped his nose ring out of his face.

They slammed each other on the announce tables, with Batista kicking out of a pedigree, and Triple H kicking out of a spear. In the end, it was Ric Flair coming to Hunter’s aid, handing him an extra sledgehammer to gain the upper hand and win.

The problem is that you can do this type of match if there’s an “epic” feel to it, but this wasn’t it. This match was decent, but not for the half-hour of PPV time it ate up fourth from the top on the card.


5. Reigns’ Return Lacking

Roman Reigns Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

This is not a knock on Roman Reigns winning his big return match. In fact, it’s a knock on how lackluster it was.

Drew McIntyre had done a nice job turning into the evil heel who dominated Reigns and his Shield brethren in recent weeks, making this mini-feud a little more interesting. But maybe this writer’s expectations were a little too high, as this match felt like a disappointment.

Reigns winning was by far the right call, but it never felt like he was truly in jeopardy. There was no big exchange of finishers or trading bombs, just Roman firing up and hitting a few moves and a spear to win clean.

It’s good to have Reigns back, but you just wish WWE had scripted a more epic return match for him. If this was the best they had, then maybe his comeback should have been delayed a bit rather than being fifth from the top on a seven-hour PPV.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.