10 Ups And 6 Downs From WWE SummerSlam 2019
Suplex City gets burned down; Trish takes final bow; The Man is Canada's new hero.
The biggest party of the summer has come and gone, and it’s time to clean things up a bit.
If you’re judging by its biggest matches, SummerSlam was a success, with the main event delivering everything it was supposed to, and the opening match setting the tone with a solid performance. Along the way, we got some pretty good action.
The PPV featured the farewell match for a WWE Hall-of-Famer, who proved that she can still “go” with the best out there today. It also saw another HOFer redeem himself from a poor performance earlier this summer by laying out an obnoxious loudmouth.
But SummerSlam wasn’t all sunshine and rainbows. The PPV suffered from a weird dynamic of having matches seemingly “toned-down” and ending just as they were starting to ramp up. Contrast that with NXT TakeOver the night before, where four of the five matches were epic showdowns that were all action from bell-to-bell. It’s not like fans would have rejected action-packed bouts.
Overall, SummerSlam was enjoyable, watchable, and notable for a couple key developments. It’s worth a look, but if you don’t have time, come on inside and check out what worked and what fell short.
Let’s get to it…
Downs...
6. Cruiserweights Rev Up, Stop Suddenly

WWE had been on a roll recently with Cruiserweight Championship matches at PPVs, but that streak was broken Sunday.
The bout between champ Drew Gulak and challenger Oney Lorcan wasn’t bad at all, but it was nothing different than you’d see on TV. The match was billed as possibly being the hardest-hitting cruiserweight title bout to date, which given the competitors seemed like safe billing. And the two men dug into each other pretty harshly.
But just as things looked like they were heating up, Gulak nailed a Cyclone Crash for the pinfall. It felt like they were halfway into the match and someone in the production truck realized they had to re-hype every match 10 more times, so they went home early.
It’s disappointing, because this could have been a pretty good match to really fire up the crowd, and instead it was just decent.
5. The Insufferable Corey Graves
It’s like when your Dad starts liking your favorite band. You go and get a new favorite band.
That’s how Corey Graves explained his sudden reversal on being an unapologetic, obsessed Alexa Bliss fan/stalker. Graves has spent countless hours gushing about Bliss like it’s a schoolyard crush, but Sunday, he switched gears to proclaim he was turning in his Alexa Bliss fan card.
The reason(s)? She wore Buzz Lightyear-inspired ring gear, which Graves said embarrassed herself, dressing like a Disney character. (Nevermind that one of Bliss’ iconic getups that inspired future ring gear was Harley Quinn.) The sudden switch was made worse by Graves prattling on throughout the match.
When Byron Saxton asking why he was so sour and whether Corey had gotten it all out of his system is the voice of reason, you’ve fallen off the wagon as a commentator.
Call. The. Damn. Match.
We don’t watch WWE to listen to crap like this. It isn’t character development, it isn’t moving a storyline forward. It’s stupid for the sake of being stupid.
4. Going Home Early And Slowly
Far be it to complain about a WWE PPV ending before 11pm (EST), but it certainly felt like several of the matches Sunday night ended somewhat abruptly, and the 10:30pm finish to the PPV seemed to bear that out.
What was the reasoning for this? A few matches ended just as they were ramping up, while others, while technically sound, were slow and methodical, which is not what you typically would want at a show like this. Ricochet/AJ Styles in particular was one that really seemed stuck in the mud.
Overall, SummerSlam was a good show, but had several matches put the hammer down and gotten a few more minutes, this could have been a blow-away show rather than just a pretty good one.
3. The Feud Must Continue

If you had to name one feud that you didn’t want to see continue beyond SummerSlam, Kofi Kingston versus Randy Orton has to top that list.
However, it looks like we’re getting that return bout between the two. Orton once again wrestled a competent – if bland – match, while Kofi was all fired up, but the two just didn’t connect. The match was starting to build a little in intensity and looking like it was going to work out OK, but then…
…Both men were outside when the referee’s count hit 10, forcing a double count-out that led to the crowd booing the hell out of that finish. Kingston snapped and grabbed a kendo stick, waffling Orton over and over before hitting Trouble in Paradise, but by then, it was too late.
As a fan who remembers Kingston’s first big push and how quickly it dissipated, this writer would have loved to see Kofi at least win this match, even if he’s meant to eventually lose the title to Orton later. This was just a disappointing result.
2. US Title Match Stuck In 2nd Gear

Let’s play booker for a second: You have two of the best in-ring talents in the world facing each other at one of the biggest PPVs of the year in a secondary title match. Both are capable high-fliers and technical grapplers. What do you do?
If you answered, “Book a knee injury so the match is 80% on the ground so the match plays out largely to silence,” then you could work for WWE.
AJ Styles and Ricochet had what should have been a show-stealing barn-burner of a United States Championship match, but instead, it was AJ targeting Ricochet’s knee for two-thirds of the match, limiting the challenger to only a handful of spectacular moves.
It’s really, really disappointing, because it looked like it was going to be a dazzling match, with Ricochet literally walking across Karl Anderson & Luke Gallows to deliver a hurricanrana to Styles outside the ring. But shortly after, Ricochet’s knee was injured, and the match was mostly fought on the mat.
It wasn’t a bad match per se, but it definitely fell short of what you’d expect from these two electrifying wrestlers.
1. Women’s Title Match Lacking

Until the Charlotte Flair/Trish Stratus match took place, it was tough to put a finger on what was wrong with the SmackDown Women’s Championship match.
That bout, between Bayley and Ember Moon, was similar to the United States Championship match, in that it was slow-going and never really got into gear. A decent portion of the match was fought on the mat, which is fine, but there didn’t feel like there was a lot of energy or oomph behind it, just two competent wrestlers going through the motions.
And just as the match was getting interesting, with Moon suddenly coming back with a series of high-impact moves, Bayley nailed a super-Bayley-to-Belly for the win. And thus the match was cut off at the knees and ended.
The contest never felt like anything more than an average TV match, not a title bout on the third-biggest PPV of the year.
Ups...
10. Women’s Tag Titles Defended

Call your friends! We had an unprecedented scene at SummerSlam during the kickoff show.
The WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship was defended Sunday!
It might seem silly, but Alexa Bliss & Nikki Cross successfully defended their newly won titles six nights after winning them, against the team who last held them, the IIconics. The match itself was garbage, with Billie Kay & Peyton Royce still looking lost in the ring, but the story here is that Bliss & Cross actually put the titles on the line on television.
By comparison, the IIconics went a solid 10 weeks before they defended the titles on TV. That’s just insane.
So we’ll take this one as a positive, regardless of match quality.
9. ‘Keep My Name Out Of Your Mouth’

The moment Buddy Murphy dimed out Rowan as Roman Reigns’ alleged attacker, you had to think he was on borrowed time.
Murphy was battling Apollo Crews in a nothing kickoff show match when Rowan attacked him outside the ring, drawing a DQ. Rowan continued to pound on Buddy, powerbombing him into the ringpost to lay him out. It was a short, simple bit, but it kept the issue top-of-mind and moved the story along – during the kickoff show, no less.
The match itself was decent up until that point, but this gave it more purpose. Let’s just hope Murphy doesn’t disappear from WWE TV for another four months.
8. Edge Makes An Impact

Sure, he might not be able to wrestle or take a bump, buy man it’s great to see Edge again.
The Rated-R Superstar made his way to the crowd while Elias was running down Edge’s hometown, noun, only for Edge to put him in his place.
There’s not much to say about this one, other than “Much obliged, WWE and Edge.”
Thankfully, Elias is almost always the perfect target for stuff like this.
7. 24/7 Title A Fun Sideshow
While the WWE 24/7 Championship has been an entertaining piece of Raw, the title doesn’t really conform to a PPV as easily, as most of the action is in-ring, and the 24/7 title tends to change hands everywhere else.
But WWE made it fun Sunday night, with champ R-Truth and Carmella fleeing Drake Maverick several times. First, they hid under the commentators’ desk during the kickoff show, while Maverick searched desperately for them. Later, Big E & Xavier Woods attempted to fire up Kofi Kingston by introducing local superstar Drake… Maverick. It was silly, but it worked just fine.
Even later, Truth & Carmella turned up as part of the international announcers, which is something only Truth could get away with. By the time Drake got up there, it was too late. Look for more of this to continue on Raw.
6. Right Amount Of Ga-Ga

No one was expecting Kevin Owens versus Shane McMahon to be a technical masterpiece… or even a good wrestling match. The question was whether they could do a bout that entertained without making KO look like a fool taking a bunch of offense from Shane.
They succeed in large part due to Elias being named outside enforcer for the match, with the troubadour gleefully interfering: tripping Owens, blocking KO from getting to McMahon, distracting the in-ring ref from making a count after a Pop-Up Powerbomb, and pulling the ref out after a frogsplash.
This allowed Owens to be in control for much of the match but unable to put it away. And that was what was needed here, because we were going to get KO demolishing Shane in 30 seconds, which is what we should have gotten if there was poetic justice.
But we should take what we got and be happy with it, so we will. Owens won, vanquishing Shane-O-Mac via Stunner. Good night, Boy Wonder.
5. Not Paid By The Hour

No one was expecting a 60-minute broadway between Dolph Ziggler and Goldberg, but Sunday night was nothing short of a massacre.
Ziggler hit a surprise superkick, and then another, before he was cut in half with a spear and put away with a Jackhammer, less than two minutes into the match. But that wasn’t it for the segment.
Dolph got his hands on a mic and said it felt like he was getting hit by a baby, calling Goldberg back to the ring to face him like a man, which the Hall-of-Famer obliged. Another spear followed, and then Ziggler grabbed the mic again, still writhing on the mat, and called him out again.
And once again, Goldberg obliged and demolished the Show-Off with a third spear. It was a somewhat baffling scene, with a delusional Dolph being ragdolled by Goldberg, but fans got what they paid for: pyro, a massive spear and a Jackhammer.
4. The Man = Canada’s New Hero

Whoever had the bright idea to make the Raw Women’s Championship match between Becky Lynch and Natalya a submission match, pat yourself on the back and ask for a raise.
The title contest opened SummerSlam, and it was a solid affair, with Becky going after Nattie’s arm, and Natalya attacking Lynch’s knee. What made the match interesting was that because it was a submission-only match, there were no pinfalls (so you couldn’t get pinned going for a triangle, for example), and no rope breaks or count-outs. That allowed things to move in a different manner than usual. Consider Nattie applying the Sharpshooter in-between the turnbuckles, for example.
Both women applied the other superstar’s submission holds, but in the end, it was Lynch’s Disarm-Her that won the day – and the tap-out.
It wasn’t a classic, but it was a pretty good match to open the show. Contrast this with the NXT Women’s Championship match Saturday night, which didn’t click at all.
3. Bray Nails ‘The Fiend’s’ Debut

You might not have been able to tell, but a lot was riding on Bray Wyatt debuting his Fiend character in his first match back at SummerSlam.
Wyatt has gotten the chance to reinvent himself, and this new character was doing quite well in vignettes for months, but if he couldn’t translate it in the ring, then he’d be dead in the water.
However, Bray nailed it, with an over-the-top, creepy entrance that featured Fiend holding a lantern that actually was a model of the former Wyatt’s head. *Shiver* The remix of his entrance music was well done as well. Everything about the presentation was spot-on.
The match itself was fine, as Wyatt smartly didn’t wrestle exactly like his former self, adding some different mannerisms to the repertoire. He caught Finn Balor’s attempted Coup de Grace with a Mandible Claw, which gave him the convincing victory.
Overall, this was a pretty effective debut for the new character. It’ll be interesting to see if they can keep it up over time.
2. ‘Thank You Trish!'

Whereas the Shane McMahon/Kevin Owens match had a bunch of extracurriculars to hide its deficiencies, Charlotte Flair and Trish Stratus didn’t need any of that to put together a highly entertaining, era-bridging battle.
Stratus – in what is rumored to be her farewell match (for real this time) – showed she still had enough in the tank to deliver a quality PPV match, going toe-to-toe with one of the best in today’s women’s division, Charlotte. Trish nailed her signature spots, even turning her countered handstand rana into a standard hurricanrana from the top rope. She put Flair in the Figure Four leglock, then bridged into the Figure Eight.
The high point came toward the end, when both women crawled toward each other and began teeing off on each other with chops. It was a high-drama moment, and Trish followed up with a couple near-falls to really rally the crowd behind her.
But this wasn’t to be Stratus’ night. Unlike her first farewell match in Toronto, Trish did not come out on top, as she tapped out to Charlotte’s Figure Eight. But it was still a nice send-off for the Hall-of Famer.
1. Rollins Burns It Down
Show of hands: Who saw Brock Lesnar taking the fall so soon after regaining the WWE Universal Championship?
Seth Rollins pulled off the impossible Sunday night, defeating Lesnar at SummerSlam to win back his title and silence the critics. It came in a brutal match that featured: six German suplexes, one F-5, two frogsplashes (one through a table) and three curbstomps.
What really made this match a marvel was seeing fans rally behind Rollins, because they weren’t all with him early on. It sounded like a split crowd initially, but that gave way as the contest wore on, with Rollins’ perseverance winning them over so much that they all were chanting, “Burn it down!” by the end.
Kudos for closing with a strong performance that elevated the PPV overall and let fans go home on a happy note.