10 Ups And 8 Downs From WWE SummerSlam 2016

A Demon King is crowned, a Viper is bloodied and the Phenomenal One rules.

brock lesnar randy orton
WWE.com

On paper, it looked like there was a good chance that SummerSlam could top the always-enjoyable NXT TakeOver special that preceded it on Saturday night. However, “on paper” doesn’t always play out in practice.

Case in point, the 29th SummerSlam delivered several good matches, but after five hours of wrestling, it still couldn’t stack up to TakeOver: Brooklyn II. We did get two star-making matches, with AJ Styles and Finn Balor both emerging as major players in WWE. But we also saw the Tag Team Championships contested in a match that was played more for “laughs” (read: Vince McMahon-level humor laughs) than to highlight the appeal of tag team wrestling, which we saw at TakeOver.

The show’s length alone should be its own “down” if only because you’re mentally spent after watching four hours (five if you count the pre-show matches) of wrestling and “entertainment” angles backstage. By the time the main even rolls around, you’re just counting down the minutes until the PPV ends. WWE could have cut an hour without missing a beat, and things would’ve been a good bit better.

Still, SummerSlam was an entertaining event overall and provided some solid moments. What had its crowning achievement and what went to Suplex City? Let’s get to it…


Downs...

8. Chinlock City

ascension zack snyder
WWE.com

When you have a 12-man tag match, you should never resort to using a chinlock. If you’re confused about what to do next to wear down an opponent, just hand it off to one of your five tag partners.

But during the pre-show’s match between SmackDown’s six tag teams, Simon Gotch, Viktor and Tyler Breeze all in succession slapped a chinlock or headlock on Zack Ryder. (Breeze thankfully started mixing it up almost immediately.) The result was a crowd that was half-asleep before a frenzied breakdown brought the match to life.

Not all matches can be action-packed, five-star affairs. But when you’re talking about creating a new tag division and tag titles for your program, you probably should make sure the teams don’t actively bore the crowd during a showcase match.


7. SmackDown Women Schmozz

Nikki Bella SummerSlam 2016
WWE.com

Anyone else notice how the women’s and tag matches for SmackDown consisted of forced teams to cram the entire divisions into two matches? The women were forced into a six-woman tag match with no real purpose.

The big story here was that Eva Marie was in reality suspended for a wellness policy violation, and it was going to be interesting to see how she was written out. They went through her entire intro, then announced she was suffering from exhaustion, anxiety and stress due to hostile fans, and she’d be taking a vacation in the British Isles. Cute.

She was replaced by a returning Nikki Bella, giving the match some clout… and telegraphing the end of the bout as well. The match itself was kind of a jumbled mess, with only Becky Lynch getting a big reaction from fans. Nikki won by hitting her new finisher, the TKO, on Carmella.

Let’s be honest: Aside from Becky, Natalya and Bella, is there anyone who you’d trust with a new women’s title? Naomi has athleticism but just can’t seem to click. Alexa Bliss and Carmella are still raw and learning, though Bliss has potential. This match just highlighted those shortcomings, which hopefully will be ironed out in the coming weeks.


6. Establishing Physical Dominance

Cesaro Sheamus SummerSlam 2016
WWE.com

When Mick Foley announced a best of seven series between Cesaro and Sheamus, you’d be excused if you wondered what the stakes were for the series, because, a series of matches like this had to have some sort of prize for the winner, right? Right?

Well, according to the announcers, both men are fighting to establish “physical dominance” over the other and to protect their “reputation” in WWE as tough men. That’s it. They’re not fighting over a title or a title shot, or even the personal services of Byron Saxton. They’re fighting to see who’s the best.

And look, in some instances, a rivalry like that can be great. But fans aren’t stupid. They’ve seen Cesaro tread water forever. And they’ve seen Sheamus rocket down the card after being a world champion as recently as December. So it’s not like we’re talking about two top guys fighting for the top spot in WWE. You have a guy fans want to be pushed as a major star and another who only gets a reaction because he looks stupid.

The only saving grace to this would have been Cesaro running the table in four straight matches to really establish physical dominance, so naturally, Sheamus won Sunday. Ooof.


5. Just Can’t Care

apollo crews the miz
WWE.com

Maybe someone who reviews or watches SmackDown regularly can set the record straight, but it was hard to get into or even care about the Intercontinental Championship match.

Apollo Crews won a triple threat to earn an IC title shot against the Miz at SummerSlam, and beyond that, the feud consisted of an altercation (that took place during a commercial break) over Miz calling him Apollo Creed. That was about it, right?

Miz and Maryse together are a great mid-card heel act, and he’s doing a good job making the Intercontinental Title feel like something desirable he’s carrying around. Crews is an athletic specimen, but there just seems to be such an anemic reaction for him compared to many of the other NXT call-ups of the past year. It’s just not clicking, and his matches aren’t anything memorable, other than one or two spots.

In the end, Crews smacked the ringpost on a corner splash attempt and ate the Skull-Crushing Finale for the loss. Maybe WWE will pump the brakes a little on Apollo and have him develop his personality a little more before trying to push him again.


4. A Disappointing World Title Match

dean ambrose dolph ziggler
WWE.com

On the SmackDown before SummerSlam, Dolph Ziggler and Dean Ambrose put together a nice go-home segment for their WWE World Championship match, ending with Ziggler superkicking Ambrose’s head off his face (Dolph’s words).

But for whatever reason, their match Sunday did not really click with the crowd as many might have hoped. Maybe it was the match’s placement on the card, after the John Cena/AJ Styles classic and the tag title disaster. Or maybe fans just weren’t buying the ostensibly face-versus-face dynamic.

For whatever reason, the match was good (and Ambrose played an arrogantly dismissive champ well), but it wasn’t “World title match on the second-biggest PPV of the year” quality. Happy to hear from readers who agree or think otherwise in the comments on this one, because Ambrose and Ziggler are favorites, but yet this wasn’t doing it.


3. No-Go For U.S. Title

rusev roman reigns
WWE.com

Given how long SummerSlam was running, it was probably a smart move to bump the United States Championship match, but that doesn’t make it any less frustrating.

Rusev attacked Roman Reigns before he could enter the ring, beating him up around the ring, before Reigns returned the favor and brought a steel chair into the mix. Roman waffled Rusev and left him lying, leaving to a chorus of boos. He returned to spear the Bulgarian Brute, completely flattening him.

The only saving grace to all of this is if WWE is contemplating a double-turn here. Rusev is the one whose wedding celebration was interrupted and whose wife was knocked into a cake. Roman came off looking like a callous bada**, which might make him a hero in a different era (or if fans were more into him), but he left to thunderous boos.

If WWE thinks this was supposed to make him a bigger babyface, they’re not reading the crowds.


2. Tag Team Dud

summerslam jon stewart
WWE.com

Before anyone gets bent out of shape and proclaims that Jon Stewart and Big E gave us a great SummerSlam moment during the Tag Team Championship match, let’s remind everyone that just 24 hours prior, the Revival and Johnny Gargano and Tomasso Ciampa tore down the house in a classic NXT tag title bout that had fans on their feet.

With that in mind, the WWE tag title match Sunday was nothing short of a disappointment. New Day, flanked by Stewart, took on “Dr.” Luke Gallows and “Dr.” Karl Anderson (another lame joke) in a match that was plodding along just fine, when the challengers hit the Magic Killer for the apparent win.

However, Stewart would enter the ring, and that’s when things broke down. Gallows and Anderson inexplicably spent a solid three minutes dealing with a former TV show host, deciding rather than winning the titles that they’d prefer to post Stewart. That’s when Big E returned to cause a DQ, ending the suddenly abysmal match.

Fans loved Big E’s return, but it’s hard to reconcile the difference between the two tag title matches on back-to-back nights.


1. Short-Circuited Main Event

brock lesnar randy orton
WWE.com

What can you say about the first PPV match between Randy Orton and Brock Lesnar? Was it overhyped? Sure. Did it fail to meet expectations? Absolutely.

Orton/Lesnar had the makings of a big fight, without the big fight feel. Sadly, this match was basically 10 minutes of Brock throwing knees in the corner and a bunch of German suplexes. Orton turned the tables with an RKO on the announcer’s desk, a draping DDT and another RKO, but a punt attempt got turned into an F5 for a long 2.

At that point, Lesnar mounted Orton and started raining down hammerfists and elbows, with one of them apparently cutting Randy so deeply that he bled like a proverbial stuck pig. It was so bad that the referee called for a stoppage, awarding the abbreviated match to Lesnar via TKO.

It’s understandable that Orton couldn’t continue, but that doesn’t change how disappointing of a main event this was, especially after the PPV was looking so strong for the first two hours. Hopefully we’ll get some ex post facto explanation on Raw.


Ups...

10. Uso Heelish

uso ascension
WWE.com

Oh please let this actually lead somewhere… anywhere.

During the car crash that was a SmackDown 12-man (six team) tag match, we got a glimmer of hope that WWE finally has gotten the message regarding one of its acts, that it’s become stale beyond belief. Of course, we’re talking about the Usos. The brothers were one of the hottest acts in the company in 2014 into 2015, but ever since getting back into action late last year, they’ve increasingly heard boos from fans. That might be due in part to their relationship with cousin Roman Reigns, but mostly, they’re the same interchangeable, indistinguishable wrestlers they’ve been for years.

Sunday, the tag match broke down, leaving newcomers American Alpha with Simon Gotch. Jason Jordan hit the corner spear and tagged in Chad Gable to set up Grand Amplitude, but one of the Usos hit a blind tag on Gable and then hit a splash on Gotch to steal the pin.

It was a simple act, but stealing the pin like that sets the tone for the Usos to become increasingly jealous/resentful of the hot new act, American Alpha, and hopefully will lead to a full-on turn for the Samoan brothers.


9. Empire State Of Mind

enzo cass raw
WWE.com

If you’re a New Yorker or just are up on your NYC pop culture references, then Enzo Amore & Big Cass’ promo was a fun trip through time.

Enzo started by quoting Notorious BIG’s “Juicy,” followed by Cass singing Frank Sinatra’s “New York, New York,” and then the duo transitioned into a couple Jay-Z references to fire up the partisan crowd. It was obvious that the two were playing up that they were the hometown heroes, which they did perfectly.

And then, Corey Graves rained on their parade by dryly noting that after running down every NYC cliché, the fact remained that Enzo was born across the river in New Jersey.


8. Corbin Has Fun With A Promo

Baron Corbin
WWE.com

Sometimes, you have to take note of little things that show someone is trying to make improvements, even if it’s something that’s not seen by a lot of people. Case in point: Baron Corbin made an appearance during the SummerSlam preshow.

Corbin walked onto the set while the panel was discussing various matches, grabbed a mic and began complaining about how he was supposed to have a PPV match against Kalisto (whom he has been bullying for weeks since they both lost an Intercontinental Championship #1 contender match), but the luchador was hurt. Baron said that Kalisto feigned the injury and now was costing him money, which is what he was all about (getting paid).

He then looked at Booker T and commented, “Nice watch. Mine costs more,” before continuing to threaten Kalisto and walking off without answering questions.

It was a short promo that probably only a handful of WWE fans actually saw, but it was effective. Hopefully, it was a trial run to repeat it on SmackDown. And hopefully, it’s a sign that Corbin’s new bully persona will be more than that and will include a little of the arrogant jock who’s in it for the money.


7. Any Day Now

sami zayn dudley boyz
WWE.com

In each of the previous two episodes of Raw, we’ve seen D-Von Dudley inadvertently hit Bubba Ray Dudley, leading to the most decorated tag team in WWE (and professional wrestling) history lose to a lower-level tag team.

Sunday, it was Bubba Ray’s turn to accidentally clobber his teammate, leading to another Dudley Boyz defeat, this time to Sami Zayn and Neville. The high-flying duo are no slouches, but it certainly seems to have reached a point where the Dudleys are actively costing each other every match.

At this point, it’s an “up” because it has to be the last straw, right? There needs to be a conversation between partners about this, or a turning point. Losing and not being able to function as a team is more than enough of a reason to break up, so let’s see if WWE can pull the trigger at the right time: now.


6. Changing Horses

Sasha Banks SummerSlam 2016 Women's Championship
WWE.com

Let’s put aside the possibility that Sasha Banks is injured or suspended for a wellness policy violation (as the rumor flew around Twitter). Let’s assume everything is relatively fine with Sasha, OK?

So why take the title off her this quickly? Her injury looked bad enough, and if it’s part of a storyline that she got injured and couldn’t hold onto the title, then you have a ready-made angle for Sasha to recuperate and come back to try to take back the title from Charlotte. If anything, it shows how evenly matched the two top women are and that either can win on any given night.

So yeah, assuming no injury or suspension (the other rumor that popped up was that Banks was going on her honeymoon, so this would allow her to take time off), this isn’t necessarily a bad booking decision. But if she is legit injured or suspended… *groan*. The only saving grace would be an injury that keeps her out for a month and then she can come back to resume her pursuit, weaving the injury into a storyline.


5. Jeri-KO Successful In Silencing Enzo

Chris Jericho Kevin Owens
WWE.com

As great as JeriShow was, the pairing of Chris Jericho and Kevin Owens might be magical. That’s why it didn’t even phase when Jeri-KO defeated longtime tag partners Enzo Amore & Big Cass.

Typically, a makeshift tandem defeating a functional tag team is a negative in this column, but when you’ve got a fun, on-the-rise team like Jericho and Owens cheating their way to victory like this, you don’t even flinch. Enzo & Cass fired up the crowd, but fans also were into Jeri-KO’s antics during the match as well.

This is one of those feuds where now the heroes go back to the drawing board and figure out what they need to do differently to overcome. Just a fun match between talented and popular stars that worked well as an opening bout.


4. Universally Jeered

universal title
WWE.com

The moment Mick Foley announced the name of the new Raw “world” title, you had to believe it wasn’t going to go over well. Universal Championship? What’s next, Galaxy Tag Team Championships for SmackDown?

Thankfully, the wonderful fans in the Barclays Center let WWE know just how they feel about the title, especially the design, which is extremely similar to the WWE World Championship and the Women’s Championship, only with a red strap. Fans immediately booed the title, then broke into a series of chants: “That belt sucks!” to both “New Day rocks!” and John Cena’s theme song; “That belt’s stupid!” as if it were Sheamus; and “Hey, we want some new belt!” which they’d normally chant for Bayley.

Fans managed to get this out during lulls in the title match, and they remembered to boo tremendously whenever the belt was shown on screen. Fantastic.


3. Gutting It Out

sasha banks charlotte
WWE.com

Whether it was an angle to further the storyline between Charlotte and Sasha Banks or a legit injury, Sasha’s tumble from the top rope early in the WWE Women’s Championship match looked really bad, and the champ visibly struggled throughout the bout.

Still, both women managed to put on a really good match that featured moments that brought the Barclays Center to its collective feet, most notably Charlotte going for a top rope Razor’s Edge that Sasha countered into a hurricanrana. The two traded some innovative moves (a hiptoss into a Tree of Woe, a Boston Crab through the ropes, etc.), leading to Charlotte winning back the title.

Sure, it could have just been an early angle to run through the entire match, and let’s hope that’s the case, because losing Banks to an injury like this would be awful. Either way though, you have to take your hat off to the women for a heart-pounding match.


2. A Star-Making Victory

AJ Styles John Cena
WWE.com

During their phenomenal match that had fans on their feet, AJ Styles and John Cena continuous teed off on each other and made you wonder: Was this going to be another match where Cena takes his opponent’s best shots, kicks out and then wins with a simple Attitude Adjustment?

We’ve seen it multiple times in the past, with Cena absorbing punishment in a very good match, but ultimately kicking out of multiple finishers to win yet again. And that’s fine to some extent, but you’d be forgiven if you were left wondering when he’d really put an opponent over.

We got that Sunday night, when Cena made Styles. Yes, AJ already is an international star with a great reputation, but on Sunday, he beat a more-than-game Cena, trading move-for-move with the WWE legend.

There were a lot of great moments in the match, but probably the best counter sequence came when Cena sidestepped AJ’s Phenomenal Forearm attempt and slapped on an STF, which Styles reversed to a crossface, which Cena powered into an AA, which AJ rolled through into a Calf Crusher, which Cena turned back into an STF… which Styles then turned into a pin attempt.

At the end, Cena delivered a Super AA from the middle rope, only for AJ to kick out and Cena to stare in disbelief. A couple minutes later, Cena was looking at the lights for a three count in an incredible match. Kudos all-around.


1. A Universal Demon King

Finn Balor WWE Universal Title
WWE.com

After the John Cena/AJ Styles match mid-PPV, anything that followed it was going to have its work cut out for it. Thankfully, Finn Balor and Seth Rollins were more than up to the task.

Rollins and Balor hooked up in a high-energy, fast-paced match that showed that both men were evenly matched and willing to pull every move out of their arsenal. The storyline was pretty simple: Rollins never lost his first world title, then Ambrose cashed in his Money in the Bank briefcase to take Seth’s second title. He was looking to recapture that glory. Balor, on the other hand, was the longest-reigning NXT Champion and was a force of nature invading Raw.

Both men battled to become the first WWE Universal Champion, and it showed how badly both wanted to hold that distinction. In the end, WWE wisely went the route of vaulting Balor straight to the top, making him a legit star in just one month’s time (compare that to Apollo Crews and Baron Corbin, languishing on SmackDown).

While he might not have a long reign (you’ve got to imagine Rollins will end up with the title sometime soon), Balor winning here was both an awesome moment and the right call.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.