10 Ways WWE Has Been An Absolute Mess In 2021
Repetition, releases, zombies, and murder. 2021 has been one helluva year for WWE.
Whenever the company is in the midst of negotiating a new television deal, WWE might try to convince studio executives that professional wrestling is a cyclical business, especially when things look a little grim.
There's quite a bit of truth to that rhetoric, but it's not all about the financial waxes and wanes. It also explains the way WWE has operated throughout the years.
In the early 1990s, WWE struggled to change with the times until it finally scored big with the Attitude Era. The initial transition back to a PG-friendly format was also a rocky period of time for the company. However, 2021 is certainly giving the past a run for its money.
Vince McMahon and his cronies may very well be sitting on stacks of cash at the moment, with the sports entertainment company reporting record profits, but that doesn't mean the overall product is winning over the fans. Worse, it doesn't seem to be attracting new viewers either.
From creative gaffes to the gross mismanagement of talent, 2021 has been one doozie of a year for WWE, to say the least. Sadly, it doesn't appear that things will change any time soon from the signs of things...
10. Bringing Back The Fiend Just To Kill Him Again
Things were off to a terrific start when Bray Wyatt resurfaced in 2019 and dismantled Finn Balor, but WWE couldn't go two matches before bungling everything up.
WWE simply hasn't been able to maintain 'The Fiend' canon. Despite winning audiences over with his original presentation, Vince & co. tampered with a winning formula and forced out enough paranormal banter to make even The Undertaker cringe. If 2019 Wyatt was a spoonful of sugar, the 2021 version was a shot of Ipecac.
If there was any hope left, it was the Randy Orton feud. It might have been riddled with Papa Shango levels of dark magic and an evil Alexa Bliss, but it was still long-term storytelling coming full circle. And when 'The Viper' burned Wyatt alive at TLC, it meant WWE could let the character chill for a moment before bringing him back even stronger.
That would have been too easy. Instead, 'The Fiend' returned in over-produced fashion only to job to Orton at WrestleMania. Not only was this another big loss for Wyatt, but the finish also made him look foolish, especially since his opponent tried to murder him a few months prior. And then he vanished.
Rumblings of Wyatt from WWE's side have certainly calmed down since April, especially with Bliss lifting the act on Raw. Only time will tell how Wyatt will return, but unless it's 'The Demon' vs 'The Fiend,' it's hard to see how fans could be won back over
9. Turning Alexa Bliss Into The Fiend
Once Alexa Bliss started chumming around with Bray Wyatt, fans quickly furrowed a brow. There was a slight chance that Bliss could've corrected the Sister Abigail angle of yesteryear, something even WWE alluded to when Abby the Witch tried to shoo her away. What ended up actually happening, however, was much different.
Leading up to the WrestleMania 37 betrayal, Bliss began to harness supernatural powers. This wasn't a great look for the former women's champion, as it focused on the less popular aspects of 'The Fiend' rather than the original mind games. In a sense, Bliss soon represented all of the worst qualities of WWE's resident murder clown. Once she turned on Wyatt during his match against Orton, the spooky shenanigans went into overdrive.
There's a way to use ghoulies in wrestling, but this certainly hasn't been it. Execution is everything, and such storylines need to be handled in a way that isn't detrimental to the suspension of disbelief. All of the hokey fire and brimstone stuff nearly insults the fans' intelligence, as it constantly reminds them what they are seeing is complete phooey.
The cooky schtick takes away from what a terrific performer Bliss can be under more traditional circumstances, and worse off, it affects the image of those who cross her path, such as Shayna Baszler. Hopefully, WWE will wisen up and find a way to drop the act before live crowds return in the summer. Otherwise, the fans are sure to voice their displeasure.
8. Throwaway Finishes
WWE is hardly a stranger to crummy finishes, but the company has really outdone itself in 2021. Whether it's Raw or SmackDown (sometimes NXT), fans are sure to see multiple throwaway finishes whenever they tune in.
When done correctly and sparingly, surprise roll-up victories, disqualifications, and distractions are decent tools to help further a feud. However, when they become abused, their effect is watered down, and they can ruin an otherwise terrific bout.
The main reason WWE relies on these old hat tricks is that it's constantly booking itself into a corner. Two big-name wrestlers are pitted together, but the brass doesn't want either performer to lose. At Hell in a Cell, Bobby Lashley employed a sneaky pinfall to retain against Drew McIntyre. It's undeniable the less decisive finish was meant to make it look like the champ barely squeaked by, and McIntyre "looked strong" in defeat.
But therein lies another issue. It was a small sin whenever WWE started to make it rain throwaway finishes on free TV. It's a damn-near travesty that the same lazy match endings have crept their way onto PPVs. HIAC had two near-identical surprise roll-ups within a three-hour span. One might have been acceptable, but two... that's just lazy booking.
Maybe one day WWE will learn something about satisfying finishes to great showdowns. Then again, that'll also be the day WWE stops booking the same few matches every week on Raw and SmackDown.
7. Booking The Same Matches
If you prefer recording Raw and SmackDown for later viewing, it might be rather difficult to tell if your DVR is working correctly as of late.
Although fans often favor SmackDown over Raw, neither brand is impervious to repetitious booking. Tune in to Raw any two weeks, and you're bound to notice that Asuka and Charlotte Flair are damn near sparring partners. Likewise, on SmackDown, Baron Corbin and Shinsuke Nakumara perpetually fight over the King of the Ring crown. The latter feud might have a little more meat to it, but it's hard not to notice the precise 50-50 booking.
The only way WWE seems to spice things up lately is by slightly tweaking the current recipe. For instance, the Beat the Clock challenges with Nikki Cross on Raw were essentially the same matches. Only one saw Flair losing in an amateur fashion, and the other featured an easily distracted Rhea Ripley. On SmackDown, rather than have Kevin Owens vs. Sami Zayn and Apollo Crews vs. Big E every week, the company really shook things up by shoving them together into one package.
At the very best, fans can hope WWE is simply coasting until live crowds return. Otherwise, it would appear the sports entertainment company is at a creative stalemate.
6. Not Creating Enough New Stars
For the better part of a decade, one of WWE's greatest strengths has been a loaded roster. Yet even with an unfair helping of the biggest names in the wrestling biz, few performers have found their way to the tip-top of McMahon Mountain.
Pick any WWE era, and surely you can name its marquee grapplers, from Bruno Sammartino to John Cena. That's not such an easy task these days, though. A franchise player is a wrestler who completely encapsulates their promotion. Roman Reigns currently fills those shoes, but beyond him, there aren't too many wrestlers who make you think "WWE" whenever you see them. Randy Orton could be considered the other top guy, but therein lies the major issue. He became a made man over a decade ago.
There's a glimmer of hope some weeks whenever an underutilized performer suddenly gets a push on TV. Sadly, these pushes often come to a screeching halt (largely on a whim), and instead of building a new star, WWE often leaves talent looking rather foolish. For instance, it'll become increasingly harder for fans to get behind Mustafa Ali if he continues jobbubg out while gimmick surfing.
With most of the main eventers in WWE floating around 40-50 years of age, many of them aren't going to be around much longer. Unless the company starts placing a stronger investment in its talent, it'll end up looking more like a ghost town than a bustling universe whenever their current stars hang up their boots.
5. Nostalgic Misfires
It doesn't really matter which one, but you're sure to catch a legend or two mingling with current talent whenever you tune into Raw and SmackDown around the time of WWE's big four events.
For WWE's older audience (which is the majority these days), a throwback to yesteryear after another stressful day might be well received. WWE knows this, which is why the company is more than willing to toss aside younger talent for the sake of a blast from the past.
Alas, WWE rarely makes good use of returning legends. Legend's Night, for example, largely consisted of performers who hung up their boots long ago and were booked as mere caricatures of their former characters.
A more glaring example came during both nights of WrestleMania 37 when Hulk Hogan returned to Tampa Bay and hosted the show alongside sparsely used jobber Titus O'Neil. Both performers called the area home but received varying responses. O'Neil was highly praised any time he spoke, whereas Hulk Hogan (who was there to boost interest) was booed out of Florida every time fans saw his face.
It's completely understandable if WWE brings back a legend, like Edge, to benefit the current roster and programming. Unfortunately, Vince & Co tend to bring back legends for the sake of garnering a ratings pop. Whenever we're lucky, they have little to no impact on the stars or shows as a whole.
4. Gimmicking Too Many Gimmicks
No promotion is safe from an over-the-top gimmick or two, but WWE surely takes the cake above all others. From the often cartoonish characters to asinine stipulations, a purist would be foolish to tune into Raw or SmackDown expecting to see traditional matchups.
On some level, WWE's obsession for everything hokey has been accepted as part of the company's image. Still, 2021 has pushed the envelope to the point that even the most loyal fans have cocked their heads in either dismay or confusion.
At WrestleMania 37, Apollo Crews couldn't simply have a match against Big E. Instead, he morphed into the descendant of Nigerian royalty with all of the customary regalia. Oh, and he acquired the accent, too. If that wasn't enough, his match against E was turned into a Nigerian Drum Match, which in reality, was just your regular no-DQ bout, but this time with timbales and cymbals.
The 'Mania 37 match was far from the only absurd standout. Fast-forward to Backlash, and The Miz encountered zombies in a lumberjack match against Damien Priest. Zombies.
Add all of this to the infinite number of ways WWE has jumped the shark with 'The Fiend,' and in 2021, it appears the company has grown far too comfortable with the studio environment afforded by the ThunderDome and continues to abuse its production facilities to the point some shows no longer resemble wrestling at all, which of course, is a perplexing move if "wrestling" is part of your company's namesake.
3. Releases
Bulk talent releases around WrestleMania season are nothing new to WWE, but it's definitely a topic that always receives the ire of both critics and fans alike. Although some performers choose to vamoose on their own, many more have been blindsided by their releases. Or at least they didn't want to see their WWE endeavours come to an end so soon.
Over the years, some of the names listed during a good old-fashioned post-Mania purge haven't been all too surprising, with many of them consisting of personnel or lower-card performers. Then there was 2021.
Aleister Black, Buddy Murphy, Braun Strowman, Andrade, Mickie James, Chelsea Green... this is just a small helping of all the talent released in the spring of 2021, and they aren't your typical curtain jerkers. Strowman was a regular main event figure on Monday Nights, and talents like Aleister Black seemed to be set for bigger and better things within the company.
There were some wildcards along the way, too. Bo Dallas was released, and some fans were actually surprised to know he had still been with WWE all along. Samoa Joe was also released shortly after being shoved into a poncho, only to return as an NXT enforcer.
With Joe in mind, perhaps there's a window for some talent to make their WWE returns. Then again, with all the other promotions that don't require as many "budget cuts," who's to say they should even bother going back up north?
2. Prematurely Killing Off Factions
When The Hurt Business first arrived, their booking was confusing. One week they declared they were taking over Raw Underground, but then they didn't. And then they did. And then there wasn't even a Raw Underground to take over. As time passed, though, they captured gold, dominated Monday nights, and developed from a creative standpoint.
Entering the spring of 2021, Bobby Lashley was set to defend the championship against Drew McIntyre at WrestleMania 37. WWE decided he would look stronger if he ditched The Hurt Business. Just like that, Shelton Benjamin and Cedric Alexander were exiled and soon disbanded. As soon as The Hurt Business started to pick up steam, they were completely dismantled.
Suffering a similar fate, RETRIBUTION unceremoniously broke up after... well, being a tremendous failure. Even though the concept behind the stable was ludicrous, perhaps the performers could have turned it around. Unfortunately, after their botched arrival, they were booked as glorified jobbers without rhyme or reason until they decided not to exist anymore at Fastlane.
WWE splitting up factions before they receive their due (or even have a chance to make sense) is a story all too common in 2021, and it's one that certainly needs to change. Prematurely killing off stables not only hurts the performers involved, but it also has the potential to chase off some fans. Why would anyone want to spend several hours each week investing in these groups when they might be abandoned on the whim of one old man?
1. The Raw Brand As A Whole
Wrestling fans criticizing Monday Night Raw isn't exactly a new trend by any means.
Ever since its creation, WWE's flagship show has gone through many peaks and valleys. In the mid-1990s, viewers cried out for WWE to freshen up its product after the cartoonish ways of the past staled. In response, WWE introduced the Attitude Era, which would go on to be one of the most revered periods in the company's history.
Today, fans still beg WWE to get back in touch with viewers and revamp Raw, but it's a bit different as of late.
WWE continues to push the goofy gimmicks and ludicrous (and largely pointless) vignettes, despite the demand for a more contemporary show. Whereas in the past, the company would have given Raw a major facelift in the name of competition, the best WWE can do today is surround Bobby Lashley with "ladies" and needlessly tag and break up random wrestlers.
Between the long slumps of low ratings and customer remorse, it's rather shocking Vince & Co haven't worked a little harder to produce more riveting material. They're able to do it after all - just look at SmackDown and NXT. There's some kind of disconnect or lack of interest that's driving Raw fans away in droves, and if WWE doesn't act in a major way soon, it risks tarnishing its image for good.