10 Wild Wrestling Plans That Were JUST NOW Discovered

Brawl For All? Kennel From Hell? Wait 'til you read what Vince Russo COULDN'T get on WWE TV...

Yokozuna WWE
WWE

By now, you'll have read about the most infamously awful wrestling plans that even WWE thought were too stupid to actually broadcast - which really is saying something, since this is a company that thought it was a good idea to exploit the death of Eddie Guerrero.

And push Kane for 20 years.

You'll know about the crazed pitch for WWE to thaw a cryogenically frozen nazi and debut him in the 2000s. You'll know about the plan to send Hardcore Holly into outer space complete with a chimpanzee mascot, which is fabulous. Just imagine the backstage interviews.

"Find anything on the moon there, Bob?"

"Your ass, sh*t-brain. F*ck off."

You'll know about the pitch for CM Punk to debut as WWE's first deaf wrestler, which, get to f*ck. That idea was so insensitive, so wasteful and so ultimately pointless. One can only imagine the awful skits the writers would come up with for it, like Punk failing to hear an imminent threat or misinterpreting a heel promo as something nice etc.

But what about those plans that have only just been revealed?

10. The Shotgun Saturday Night Tough Guy Champion

Evil Crush
WWE

On a recent edition of his 'Experience' podcast, Jim Cornette claimed to have retained in his possession, for 25 years, a list of wild and naturally awful Vince Russo ideas. He deduced that these alleged ideas were Russo's because they were so sh*tty. He offered up Shane McMahon as an alternative, but since none of the ideas involved Shane himself annihilating Dan Severn to a bloody pulp, they can't have been his.

This list actually represents the origin story behind the fabled, pathetic Russo Vs. Cornette saga: it was when reading this list of pitches that Cornette first determined he and Russo would not prove to be effective collaborators.

Pitched before the disastrous RAW of March 3, 1997, the taped Berlin show that looked indistinguishable to Heroes of Wrestling from a production standpoint - a show so stripped-back in its wrestling brilliance that Vince McMahon deduced, with Russo's urging, that wrestling itself was the problem - this was Russo's attempt to worm himself into the process.

Astonishingly, it worked, despite one such idea suggesting the creation of a new title: the Shotgun Tough Guy champion!

Per "Russo", the champ would defend the title exclusively on the experimental Shotgun Saturday Night show, and naturally, it would be contested exclusively in gimmick matches - "bar room stool in each man's corner, tables, whatever".

Now, here's something. The tables match was not invented until three years later, and was so successful that it remains a fixture to this day. Is this "list of ideas" on the level, or was Russo not that bad?

The word "whatever" here is very telling, mind. The subtext is hard not to read as "whatever, as long as it isn't a boring wrestling match".

Russo pitched Crush as the first Tough Guy Champion, and was going to have a precious badge instead of a belt. You know, the kind of thing a kid wears when they want to be a police officer.

This was not the only asinine idea that Russo scribbled down...


9. Two Minutes With Jake 'The Snake' Roberts

Jake Roberts WCW
WWE

The STARDOM Cinderella Tournament is a unique competition that, initially, promises brisk, urgent action as a primer for the later rounds.

A 10-minute time limit is set in the first round. The risk of elimination for both competitors in the event of a draw collides brilliantly with the risk of a strategic error to create a potent, unique strain of drama overflowing with urgency. Was this exhilarating, tense, high-speed action what Vince Russo had in mind when pitching the next idea on this list?

Hardly, since he was daft enough to select Jake 'The Snake' Roberts as the subject of this proto-Beat The Clock Challenge.

Yes, Russo pitched a Beat The Clock/Feast Or Fired hybrid as part of which, if a wrestler couldn't beat Jake within two minutes, they'd have to leave the WWF.

What the f*ck?

The WWF never wrote anybody out, so it was unnecessary for starters. Jake wasn't going to get over by failing to lose in two minutes. The most forgettable ham and eggers could do and did do that in a regulation TV squash. Also, Jake was a psychologically sound worker and everything, but watching him feel out an opponent for two minutes before the match simply ended would have made for dreadfully boring television.


8. Wildcard Extra Match

Freddie Joe Floyd
WWE Network

Vince Russo hated pro wrestling in its purest form and built a career - again, following a great wrestling show that failed dismally - on booking a show that had little to do with wrestling.

As part of this career-long quest, he "pioneered" several gimmick matches, which is the wrong would entirely, since no booker in their right mind followed the road he paved. Why would anybody book a second Reverse Battle Royal?

The first was a running race that Russo didn't realise was a race before booking it.

One idiotic bespoke special that didn't make TV, per Cornette, was the 'Wildcard Extra Match'. Basically, two actual stars would start the match, "but this twist" saw an "extra" enter the ring after five minutes.

The extra would be allowed to come in and do what he wants, as the two Rock and Austin types would then beat the extra (or an additional job guy) in order to win the match against...one another.

"Here is your winner (of the Rock Vs. Steve Austin)...

...the Rock (who just pinned Freddie Joe Floyd)!"

Not quite "And new!" as in iconic ring announcement, is it?

F*cking hell.


7. Not Quite The Worst Vince Russo Idea Ever

4 Royal Rumble
WWE

The time limit draw is a valuable booking tool, but WWE never fancied it.

The idea is to establish parity between two top-level performers in order to build interest in a rematch. It's an ambitious venture in and of itself, going 30 minutes or an hour, and the first match has to be so fantastic that the fans clamour for a sequel despite an exhausting runtime. It's only used rarely and entrusted with the very best as a result. The bold and the brilliant can pull it off and convince the audience that the finish is in sight, even when the slower opening phase telegraphs the result.

Vince Russo, him again, wanted to introduce the concept to the WWF on Shotgun Saturday Night.

There was something to this idea; he wanted the last minute of the main event to flash up on a screen via Royal Rumble-style graphic so that the fans in the club could count down. Fans like to count, and noise is good, but the issue is that every match would therefore have to go to the draw, and you end up with a match that ultimately means absolutely nothing. What was this: the last decade of Vince McMahon's run as booker?

Also, Russo wanted the main events to begin not with an opening bell but a shotgun blast sound effect, which was a stupendously dumb idea for a live show held in a public arena.


6. Flashlight Match

Vince Russo
WWE.com

Be honest.

Recall your first foray into inside wrestling circles, the first time you ever experienced a brand new lexicon which, intended for hardcore fans, you had no understanding of yet.

What does "carrying" mean? I didn't see anybody get lifted up, unless they mean for a move?

What about "gas"?

What's a "dark match"? That sounds so evil and cool, why aren't they on television?!

The truth of course is significantly less interesting, but for a while, it held a certain allure. Vince Russo wanted to make this a literal match type on Shotgun, with the idea being that fans would be handed torches to light up the action with no in-house source of light. This, funnily enough, was a terrible idea.

It's bad enough when fans audibly revolt with chants of "Bullsh*t" and "Boring" and the like. A negative crowd reaction can be spun, just about, as some aberration unique to a certain city - "They're booing competitors they usually cheer!" - but imagine an entire crowd entertaining themselves by pointing torches at one another or turning them off altogether in revolt.

"The fans are so scared of the violence in this Crush Vs. Bart Gunn match that they can't even bear to look!"


5. Double Yokozuna Bonus Slide

WWE Royal Rumble 1993 Yokozuna
WWE.com

Vince Russo had two ideas for Yokozuna's presence on Shotgun Saturday Night - again, according to Jim Cornette. One of them was actually half-decent, and the other, astonishingly, was as a racist as sh*t.

The first involved a fan competition to guess Yokozuna's weight. The correct answer was "Whatever Vince McMahon decided was most impressive on any given night without drawing the attention of state athletic commissions," but nonetheless, whomever was to come closest to the answer would be awarded a prize.

Go on.

Guess the prize.

Guess the most racist prize you can think of.

Wrong - not racist enough - it was actually a sushi dinner!

The other idea was significantly less problematic and actually, earnestly very good: several pasty, skinny jobbers would step on a scale, and when their total combined mass equalled Yoko's, they would collectively take him on. Honestly, that seems like tremendous value: it would have put over what an unreal physical specimen Yokozuna was while, at the same time, promising a unique squash match not unlike those that convinced the wrestling fandom that Ryback was awesome in 2012.


4. A "You Call The Spot" Match

Vince Russo Helmet
WWE Network

If Vince Russo is the master of anything - other than swerve turns, pole matches and taking credit for ratings generated by Steve Austin and the Rock - it's not quite getting it.

There's often a tiny kernel of logic to his most harebrained ideas. Cages are an impressive visual, so why not erect two? People will tune in for title switches, so why not book one every two friggin' weeks? Westling fans are as thick as pig sh*t, so why not just add electrocution sound effects and pass it off as a stunt?

In his formative years as a creative presence, he had the idea for a "You Call The Spot" match. Wrestling is all about giving the audience what they want - hence why suicide dives are so prevalent, because they are cool and people like them - but allowing a pissed-up throng of knowledgable New Yorkers to call a match from their seats was a preposterous idea. They would invariably ask Recon to do a space flying tiger drop or yell at 8-Ball to do a Japanese ocean cyclone suplex.

This would be very funny, but totally unworkable.


3. The Most Vince Russo Idea Imaginable

Sable WWE
WWE.com

Vince Russo had certain quirks as a booker.

He enjoyed a show-long angle. He tried not to let wrestling matches get in the way of his wrestling programming, and while there's an argument to be made that a Raw match with minimal build need not go 25 minutes Triple H, ideally, the combined total minutes of action per show should comfortably exceed that amount.

Russo was also fond of bra and panties matches, evening gown matches, basically any excuse to parade scantily-clad women on television under the most brazen pretext imaginable, which makes his next pitch as predictable as one of his unpredictable swerve turns: per Cornette, Russo simply scrawled "Beautiful Buxom Referee" on the alleged document.

F*ck the idea of an authoritative referee somehow credible enough to call a match despite missing every heel tactic, which, incidentally, is a vastly underrated skill: who wants to look at Mike Chioda?

And so Russo pitched the "beautiful buxom referee", who would call the action right down the middle, throughly impartial.

Swerve!

The women in Russo's WWF were all manipulative shrews, so obviously they'd cheat on behalf of the babyfaces after feigning to have decent values.


2. A Shelved Magazine Cover

Chyna Ic
WWE

As you might have surmised, Jim Cornette is the only person connected with wrestling who has recently taken to slaughtering Vince Russo's atrocious creative ideas.

Swerve!

Former WWF photographer Tom Buchanan has also exposed an absolutely foul, alleged idea of Russo's which, if true, is rather a lot worse than some mindless bullsh*t involving badges and torches and the like.

In 1998, the idea of establishing Raw as the edgy magazine and WWF as the family-friendly mainstay was firmly in place. It was easy to discern the difference between the two; WWF would have Steve Austin on the cover with copy along the lines of "The Rattlesnake spews venom!", whereas Raw would have a suggestive picture of Sable, the word "BITCH", and about a four hundred f*cking exclamation marks.

Not quite satisfied, Russo had an idea for a cover "celebrating" independence day in July '98 by having D-Generation X framed as posing nude with only the American flag covering their modesty, only, to insinuate that Chyna had an erect penis, a piece of wood was to poke out from behind. This never materialised, thankfully, but never forget how Chyna was perceived internally.

What a disgrace of an organisation.


1. The Original Forbidden Door Opener

Jon Moxley
AEW

Bonus positive entry!

Now, this is a subjective theory rather than a revelation, but it's quite robust - and bittersweet.

The Forbidden Door opener was incredible; a lengthy affair so fantastic that it hinted towards a stunning future for a company, NJPW, that isn't enjoying a time of great critical acclaim, it also functioned to get Wheeler YUTA over in defeat in addition to Shota Umino. The Jericho/YUTA exchanges were fabulous, and commanded a standing ovation within seconds as a result of Jericho's genius instincts. He sensed that fans were big into YUTA's multiple Germans spot, and a moment after calling a fifth on the fly, the entire United Center were on their feet.

As with so much else on the card, it was a compromise.

CM Punk was meant to work Hiroshi Tanahashi in the main event, not Jon Moxley. Mox only got the nod, and smashed the ever-living sh*t out of the nod, when Punk was stricken with a knee injury.

So where does that leave Mox in the original plan?

Having already smashed through the viable New Japan Dads, and with Tetsuya Naito too politically complex to deliver a satisfying finish, it leaves him standing alongside SHOOTER in the middle of the ring cocking the guns as Mox and Jake Hager made the opener an eight-man.

We were deprived the most wholesome "post"-pandemic sight in wrestling, so it's just as well YUTA had more than earned his spot in the Blackpool Combat Club.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Yokozuna
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!