10 Wild WWE Matches You Forgot Almost Happened

Crazy cancelled WWE matches for Steve Austin, Roman Reigns, Vince McMahon, Triple H and more.

Roman Reigns Adam Pearce
WWE

It's always fun when WWE teases a match on TV that doesn't end up happening. Typically, there are two reasons for doing this. One, it gauges opinion from the audience and lets the company know whether or not booking the bout would be a good idea. Two, it was never the plan anyway so they're just playing around before getting to the real story.

Swerve tactics, bro.

Not all of the matches here had a graphic to go with them, but they were pondered behind the scenes in creative meetings or amongst wrestlers. Some were cancelled because workers walked out on them, others 'cause they'd have cost too much money to put together, and one was even scrapped due to Vince McMahon feeling it'd be too much for his audience.

You won't believe some of the stories behind these pitches. WWE's writers abandoned one seriously barmy plot in 2017 and went with a more standard match instead, which was definitely for the best. Do you remember the original Sister Abigail? How about Steve Austin's pencilled-in challenge for SummerSlam 1999?

Everyone from Austin and McMahon to Roman Reigns and Triple H is involved. Enjoy!

10. Umaga vs. Jackass (SummerSlam 2007)

Umaga Jackass WWE
WWE.com

WWE laid the groundwork for this by having some of the Jackass crew take a beating from Umaga on Raw in October 2006. Unfortunately, Steve-O and Chris Pontius laughed throughout the segment, which didn't go down well backstage. As legend has it, everyone agreed to ditch the idea until USA Network suggested using celebs to bolster ratings the next year.

Jackass were back in the mix just like that.

Plans were put in place for cast members to show up at the Great American Bash and build towards a SummerSlam handicap bout vs. Umaga. Shane McMahon was heavily involved in this, because he was a fan of the MTV show, but it was never meant to be. Umaga didn't get to wreck shop on Steve-O, Johnny Knoxville, Wee Man and pals again.

Instead, the then-Intercontinental Champ worked a three-way vs. Carlito and Mr. Kennedy on the tentpole pay-per-view. He still got paid, but there's no denying the Jackass segment would've been higher profile than a routine Triple Threat. WWE couldn't make it happen.


9. Steve Austin vs. Coach (Taboo Tuesday 2005)

Steve Austin Jonathan Coachman
WWE.com

This is pretty incredible.

'Stone Cold' was set to face Jonathan Coachman in a match at the 'B' level Taboo Tuesday pay-per-view in 2005, but Austin reportedly no-showed the event. Coach told AdFreeShows in 2021 that he was disappointed by this, and believes Steve never really wanted to step in the ring with him at all - "He felt like it was below him".

This would've been Austin's first official match since working The Rock at WrestleMania XIX in 2003, but fans would have to wait until 2022 to see him lace up a pair of boots again. Let's just say that 'Mania 38 scrap vs. Kevin Owens was better than 'Stone Cold' vs. Coachman would've been in '05.

Nonetheless, Coach was gutted he didn't get to share the ring with one of the biggest stars ever. WWE pivoted by putting Batista on the card as his opponent instead. Fans voted for the stipulation to be a 'Street Fight'. Oh, and both Goldust and Vader were brought back to cameo alongside Coachman for...some reason.


8. Mick Foley vs. Mr. McMahon (WrestleMania X-Seven)

Mick Foley Vince Mcmahon
WWE

Hardcore great Mick Foley considers WrestleMania X-Seven one of the biggest regrets of his storied career. Why? Well, the Mickster was one of the early plans drafted up for Vince McMahon on the most lucrative show of the year. Almost unbelievably, Foley knocked the pitch back because he was "overthinking".

Mick once told Inside The Ropes that he was "a stickler for details" and didn't much like some of the "holes" in the plot. So, the WWF changed tact and went with Vince's son Shane in a McMahon vs. McMahon battle. It's fascinating to learn that Foley was initially in that slot opposite Vince, not Shane.

Bit of a clanger from Mrs. Foley's baby boy there!

Mick didn't want to beg for his on-screen job back after being fired. He didn't think that'd be a great look for his babyface character, meaning the match with McMahon was off the table. Looking back, the artist formerly known as Mankind, Dude Love and Cactus Jack wishes he'd swallowed his pride and rolled with it.


7. The Wyatt Family vs. Justin Bieber?! (SummerSlam 2014)

justin bieber bray wyatt
WWE.com

OK, so this wasn't going to be three-on-one. Bray Wyatt, Luke Harper and Erick Rowan weren't going to kick lumps out of Justin Bieber at SummerSlam. No, Bieber was going to team with John Cena and Big Show in a rather bizarre looking six-man tag. Rumour has it their tag name would've been, 'The Beliebers'.

No, that's a (terrible) joke. Sorry.

The match pitch sounds like a terrible joke too, but it wasn't. Former WWE writer Kevin Eck has spoken and written about this scenario countless times. According to him, the pop star was supposed to make a series of appearances on Raw leading into the biggest pay-per-view of the summer. Also, get this: Bieber was going to make the match-winning pin.

Worse, lil' Justin was going to beat Wyatt himself then celebrate with Cena and Show. That could've been disastrous for Bray, so it's just as well things fell through. Wyatt ended up working with Chris Jericho on the night, and Cena was unceremoniously squashed by Brock Lesnar in a memorable main event.


6. Hulk Hogan vs. Sheik Tugboat (WrestleMania VII)

Tugboat Hulk Hogan
WWE

The WWF was a colourful cartoon land of outrageous fantasies in the early-1990s, but this would've been a step too far. Bruce Prichard has revealed via his podcast that someone else nearly pipped Sgt. Slaughter to the WrestleMania VII main event berth vs. Hulk Hogan. That "someone" was Hulk's good pal Tugboat.

He was almost renamed Sheik Tugboat. Yes, seriously.

The WWF wanted to capitalise on real-life issues between the United States and Iraq by booking Tugboat as a turncoat who'd ditch Hogan and embrace The Iron Sheik (who was going by the name Col. Mustafa at the time). That would've led to Hulk vanquishing Tuggy at 'Mania before waving the US flag proudly.

Bosses chewed on that thought for a while before deciding to go with Slaughter instead. A few months later, Tugboat turned heel and aligned with Earthquake to form The Natural Disasters tag-team. That was the closest he'd come to headlining the biggest show of the year.


5. Roman Reigns vs. Adam Pearce (Royal Rumble 2021)

Roman Reigns Adam Pearce
WWE

There's a chance Adam Pearce will stick on a singlet and do some wrasslin' for WWE someday. The former NWA World Champion was an accomplished pro in his prime, but he's exclusively known as an on-air, non-wrestling authority figure today. Maybe a match vs. fellow GM Nick Aldis will change that.

Hell, things almost changed in 2021.

Back then, Roman Reigns was running hot as the tyrannical 'Tribal Chief'. Y'know, the heel version that successfully remodelled his entire WWE career. Heading into the Royal Rumble show, Reigns and Paul Heyman started dropping hints that Roman fancied putting Pearce in his place for meddling in Bloodline affairs.

WWE even created a graphic for Reigns vs, Pearce at the Rumble before changing that to Reigns vs. Kevin Owens on TV. The company went as far as insinuating that Adam's fate would be sealed in a dramatic 'Last Man Standing' bout against one of the best on the roster. At one point, people genuinely thought this was going to happen.

The real plan wasn't revealed until mid-January.


4. Chyna vs. Steve Austin (SummerSlam 1999)

Steve Austin Chyna
WWE.com

Vince Russo dearly wanted to see this go down at SummerSlam 1999.

He even scripted Chyna to win a three-way over Triple H and The Undertaker on the 9 August '99 Raw. Later, the '9th Wonder' beat Hunter in a singles to confirm that she'd be heading to the pay-per-view. That's when Mick Foley got involved, beat Chyna, then Shane McMahon booked a singles between Mick and Trips that led to the Triple Threat with Austin. Got that?

Yeah, WWF booking was car crash in the summer of 1999. 

Jim Ross told fans via his 'Grilling JR' show that there was never a chance Austin would go for the match with Chyna anyway. He didn't want to wrestle her, and nobody was going to force him to. Russo's scheming was shot to pieces overnight.

It would've been interesting to see what the buyrate would've been like for SummerSlam had Chyna vs. Austin gone ahead. That match certainly wasn't the wildest thing pitched during the 'Attitude Era', let's be honest! 


3. The Demon vs. Sister Abigail (TLC 2017)

Demon Finn Balor, Sister Abigail
WWE

See above for a match graphic WWE used to hype Finn Bálor's 'Demon' vs. Bray Wyatt as 'Sister Abigail' before TLC 2017. Skits showing Bray as 'Abigail' did air on Raw, but illness prevented him from appearing on the pay-per-view - AJ Styles wound up replacing Wyatt and doing the honours for Finn.

Who knows how 'Demon' vs. 'Abigail' would've worked anyway?

WWE were blatantly hoping fans would stump up cash to see what Wyatt as his then-mythical family spinoff would've looked like. Bray skipping TLC meant creative quietly shelved the feud completely and moved on to other things. That might've been for the best, being brutally honest.

Finn's 'Demon' continued along until running into a brick wall vs. Roman Reigns in 2021. That damaging situation and the dire rope break angle wrecked Bálor's offshoot gimmick, but there's a chance the match vs. 'Sister Abigail' might've done that first in 2017.

Be glad this didn't air.


2. Triple H vs. Mike Tyson (WrestleMania X-Seven)

Mike Tyson Shawn Michaels Triple H DX D-Generation X
WWE.com

Wrestler vs. boxer matches have a spotty history. Roddy Piper vs. Mr. T stands out as historic because it happened at WrestleMania, but then there were hopeless bores like Marc Mero vs. Butterbean and Arn Anderson vs. Johnny B. Badd (Mero again) over in WCW. It's a concept that just doesn't really work.

Triple H once told WWE's website that he was lined up to meet Mike Tyson in a boxing-come-wrestling bout at 'Mania X-Seven, and it would've happened had Tyson not asked for "a ludicrous amount of money". This, of course, would've come three years after 'Iron' Mike worked with Trips during the build towards 'Mania XIV in 1998.

Hunter wrestled The Undertaker at X-Seven in the end, and he's glad he did. That match became one of his firm favourites, and is a true overlooked gem. The same surely couldn't have been said about Triple H vs. Tyson with gloves. They were going to go six three-minute rounds. Six!

That's a torturous thought.


1. King Of The Deathmatch (WrestleMania XIV)

Mick Foley Terry Funk Raw
WWE.com

They'd have been mopping up blood for days had this wild pitch been given the green light.

Everyone remembers that violent exchange Cactus Jack and Chainsaw Charlie had during the 1998 Rumble, right? Both exchanged wicked chair shots to the head, and Terry Funk's alter ego even introduced the titular chainsaw for a bit. That was supposed to be the tip of the iceberg heading into WrestleMania XIV.

Mick Foley fancied repeating the pair's vicious 'King Of The Deathmatch' wars over in Japan. He pitched to Vince McMahon that the WWF book a 'Best Of 7' series that'd escalate before peaking at 'Mania, but the then-boss wasn't interested. He thought it'd be too gruesome and certainly wasn't into the idea of using barbed wire or explosions.

Mick revealed on his Foley Is Pod show that he actually wanted to "go off-site" and shoot a few of the matches at different locations. Then, they'd leave the best for last and showcase extreme violence in front of a live crowd at 'Mania. McMahon didn't think about this long before saying no.

What other wild WWE matches were advertised or in the works but got scrapped? For more like this, check out 10 DUMB WWE Face Turns (We Didn't Want To Admit Were GENIUS!) and 10 Times You Didn't Realise Wrestlers Were Saying 'Goodbye'!


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.