10 Worst "Big Reveals" In Wrestling History

Disclaimer: This List Contains Multiple Incidences of Hornswoggle.

Shockmaster Fall
WWE

Humans are naturally curious beings. Because our brains are so averse to ambiguity, we constantly seek out the answers to all of life's unknown questions. When we cannot find these answers, we can become dissatisfied or distressed. When we can, we get closure, which can be incredibly cathartic.

Apart from psychologists, perhaps nobody knows this better than an effective storyteller.

The problem is, when it comes to pro-wrestling, there is a massive margin of error associated with long-term storytelling. Even if a creative team comes up with an excellent, months-long angle with a bombshell reveal at the end, factors such as injuries, suspensions, or adverse reactions from fans can leave said team fumbling about for replacements.

Or, in some cases, the planned "surprise ending" was a stupid idea from the get-go.

Of course, nobody hits a home run every time, and I'm sure it's difficult to write consistently-satisfying angles in such a dynamic environment. But no matter the reason, pro-wrestling has seen plenty of anti-climactic, disappointing, and downright silly "big reveals" in storylines.

And these ten are the worst of the worst.

10. Kevin Nash Texts...Himself?

Kevin Nash Triple H
WWE

Kevin Nash had absolutely no business being a part of this storyline. CM Punk was the hottest act in wrestling in 2011, so the exact wrong thing to do was put him in rivalry with a 52-year-old semi-retired giant.

Nevertheless, Nash returned to the company that year by attacking Punk following his WWE Championship victory over John Cena at 2011's SummerSlam, allowing Alberto Del Rio to cash in his Money in the Bank contract on the downed Punk.

The next night on RAW, Nash claimed that he'd received a text from WWE COO and real-life best buddy Triple H, which instructed him to attack whoever won. Triple H denied Nash's allegations, but Punk was not buying it, so he verbally eviscerated both men in a way that only the "Best in the World" could. Over time, it was revealed that the person who had used Triple H's cell phone to text Nash was...Kevin Nash.

First of all, who takes someone else's phone to text themselves? Second of all, why would they put Nash in this storyline if he wasn't medically cleared to wrestle? Thirdly, why was Kevin Nash put into this storyline at all?! His inclusion did nothing but slow Punk's ascent to superstardom, and this painfully stupid reveal made it even more meaningless.


9. TIE: Two Aces & Eights Reveals

bully ray aces and eights
impactwrestling.com

The Aces & Eights story arc had a lot of potential when it first started. Their identities were mysterious, their social media presence was effective, and they seemed to cause indiscriminate chaos. It was, however, when they began revealing members' identities when the storyline started to jump the shark.

And no, the first of these reveals is not Tazz because, while his inclusion in the group was ultimately inconsequential, the actual reveal was not bad. No, the really bad ones were when Bully Ray revealed himself as President of Aces & Eights, and the #August1Warning.

Let's start with Bully Ray, a man who'd been fighting relentlessly against Aces & Eights for months, senselessly announcing that he'd been leading the renegade biker gang this entire time. While Bully Ray tried to explain in subsequent promos, it basically felt like TNA just wanted to do a swerve for no reason.

A few months later, TNA started cryptically tweeting and posting videos about a so-called #August1Warning, who eventually revealed himself to be MMA star Tito Ortiz. In theory, this isn't a terrible reveal, but it was one in execution, as the fans did not react in the slightest to Ortiz's arrival in TNA.

It's often said that the worst thing a professional wrestling audience can be is indifferent, and you're unlikely to hear a crowd with less "give a f**k" than the crowd in attendance for this reveal.


8. Hornswoggle McMahon

Hornswoggle Vince McMahon Triple H
WWE.com

Vince McMahon's booking of himself in the mid-to-late 2000s was mostly questionable.

In the course of two years, the man booked himself to wrestle "God," feuded with current US President Donald Trump, died and then immediately came back to life due to the real-life death of Chris Benoit, and even falsely promised to give away $1,000,000 on an episode of RAW. But no Vince McMahon storyline from this era can possibly be worse than the "illegitimate son" angle.

Returning to his normal character following the Benoit tragedy, McMahon spent the latter half of the summer of 2007 trying to find out the identity of his illegitimate son. To WWE's credit, this storyline was initially going to serve as a launching pad for Mr. Kennedy, who would use his family status to rise to main event status, much like Triple H did in the early 2000s.

Unfortunately for them, Kennedy was busted buying steroids online a week before he was set to be revealed as the son, so WWE had to scramble for a new illegitimate son. And their choice was...Hornswoggle.

So, instead of using this opportunity to spearhead someone else's main event push instead of Mr. Kennedy, WWE decided to point and laugh at us for being invested in this storyline in the first place.

Still, this isn't even the worst "big reveal" involving Hornswoggle...more on that later.


7. Who Ran Over Stone Cold?

rikishi mick foley
WWE.com

By the end of 1999, Stone Cold Steve Austin was in rough shape. Bothered by complications from his initial neck injury at 1997's SummerSlam, Austin required nine months of rehabilitation to recover.

To explain his absence, WWE booked Austin to get hit by a car in the parking lot at 1999's Survivor Series. So, for nearly a year, the burning question on everyone's mind was "who ran over Stone Cold?" Ten months later, we finally got our answer, as Commissioner Mick Foley revealed that the man behind the wheel was...Rikishi?

You know, Rikishi - the funny, portly man who dances around and rubs his near-naked ass in people's faces? That Rikishi? Yeah, nobody bought this guy as a heel.

While Rikishi was an imposing big man with admirable agility, he did not have the mic skills nor the charisma of a "top guy," and his push fell flat almost immediately. In an effort to correct their misdeeds, WWE decided to take the heat off of Rikishi by revealing that it was, in fact, Triple H who'd masterminded the scheme all along.

Rikishi would remain a heel for a couple more months after this, but was never considered a legitimate threat again.


6. The YET-TAY

The Yeti Wcw
WWE.com

WCW deserves a considerable amount of credit for how ardently they tried to get fans to continue to cheer for Hulk Hogan in the mid-90s. By this point, wrestling fans had largely soured on Hogan thanks to his stale "superhero" persona and his reputation as a backstage politician, but WCW worked steadfastly to preserve Hulkamania for as long as they could.

Enter the Dungeon of Doom, a stable of comic book-esque super-villains led by "The Taskmaster," Kevin Sullivan.

After conquering the Dungeon at 1995's Fall Brawl, Hogan was challenged by The Giant (aka Big Show), Andre the Giant's kayfabe son and the Dungeon's newest recruit. But The Taskmaster had yet another trick up his sleeve - an "insurance policy". Specifically, a Yeti that they had been keeping preserved in a block of ice.

At Halloween Havoc, Hogan dropped the title via disqualification to the debuting Giant. In the ensuing bedlam, out came the so-called "Yeti" to make the save for the Dungeon. I say "so-called" because he looked more like a mummy than an actual yeti. While the man under the bandages, Ron Reis, was legitimately 7'1", his awful aesthetic and his questionable bear hug on Hogan made him an instant laughing stock.

Immediately after the PPV, WCW changed his attire to that of a masked ninja, but inexplicably kept the "Yeti" moniker. He would spend his remaining years with the company shuffling through various names and gimmicks, all of whom were jobbers.


5. "Razor Ramon" And "Diesel"

Fake Razor Ramon Diesel
WWE.com

The hottest story in wrestling in 1996 was the defection of Scott Hall, WWF's Razor Ramon, and Kevin Nash, WWF's Diesel, to rival promotion WCW. The whole angle felt real, with Hall and Nash making frequent references to a "war" on WCW television and fans not really knowing if they were still under contract with the WWF.

Excitement reached a fever pitch when WWF's play-by-play announcer Jim Ross announced that he was bringing back Diesel and Razor Ramon, as WWF fans genuinely believed they were getting the two megastars back. Sadly, what followed was an ill-advised heel turn for Ross. Thankfully, he still did bring back Razor Ramon and Diesel...well, two guys masquerading as Razor Ramon and Diesel, anyway.

Not only did neither man look like the original men in the gimmicks, but they couldn't accurately portray them either. The phony Razor, Rick Bognar, was easily the worse of the two, possessing absolutely zero charisma nor discernable physique. The man playing Diesel, Glenn Jacobs, may have been more talented and imposing than his counterpart, but he simply did not fit the role of "Big Daddy Cool".

Mercifully, the placeholders were quickly buried by both the booking and commentary teams, so the act was not long for TV. While Jacobs would go on to become the legendary Kane, Bognar's remaining two years in wrestling were unremarkable, and he quietly retired in 1999.


4. The Anonymous RAW GM

Hornswoggle Raw Gm
WWE.com

The Anonymous RAW GM saga was stupid enough on its own, but this reveal catapulted it to an unprecedented level of idiocy.

From 2010-2011, we were given plenty of teases regarding the identity of the person behind this computer. Among the teased names were Shawn Michaels, Kevin Nash, Triple H, and even Stone Cold Steve Austin. It wasn't until the Summer of 2012 when we'd finally get our answer...during a "comedy" segment.

See where this is headed? You guessed it - it was Hornswoggle.

Yes, it was the absolute antithesis of comedy, the murderer of prestige, the living, breathing manifestation of fan apathy himself - f***ing Hornswoggle. And if you think those nicknames are harsh, just listen to the crowd upon the reveal - it begins with annoyed groans of "oh, come on," then leads into almost complete silence. And hey, while you're there, take a look at the dislike bar on the video. Given how overwhelmingly-liked most of WWE's YouTube content is, this should tell you a lot about how fans received this news.

They could have saved this already-dumb angle with a massive reveal, like literally any of the names they teased. Instead, they just f***ing shoehorned Hornswoggle in because...comedy, or something.

God, I hate Hornswoggle.


3. The Shockmaster

Shockmaster Fall Botch GIF
WWE Network

In 1993, Sting was set to captain the team of Davey Boy Smith, Road Warrior Hawk, and Dustin Rhodes for a WarGames match with Sid Vicious, Vader, and Harlem Heat. Unfortunately for Sting, Hawk got for-real injured shortly before the match was set to take place. Luckily for Sting, he found a replacement that would "shock the world".

Or so he claimed.

His new teammate was called "The Shockmaster," portrayed by Fred Ottman, who'd previously wrestled as Tugboat and Typhoon in the WWF. For no discernible reason, WCW decided that The Shockmaster should wear a Star Wars Stormtrooper helmet covered in paint and glitter. Obviously, they hadn't realized that this would obstruct Ottman's vision.

So, as he burst through the wall for his grand entrance, he tripped over a board, falling flat on his face and losing his helmet in the process. Ottman shuffled back to his feet, fumbling the helmet back onto his head and standing menacingly in an attempt to salvage the scene. But there was no turning back now, especially with an out-of-sync Ole Anderson providing his voiceover in the background.

Perhaps this reveal wouldn't have been quite as awful had Shockmaster not fallen "on his f***ing arse" (as British Bulldog quipped at the time)...no wait, yeah, it still would have. After all, you can't expect to be taken seriously while wearing a sparkly Stormtrooper helmet.


2. "It's Me, Austin!"

Vince McMahon Higher Power Reveal
WWE Network

The Undertaker went through a major character overhaul in the late 90s, as he transformed into the much more devious and far more sinister "Lord of Darkness" Taker.

In this incarnation, he regularly terrorized the likes of Stephanie McMahon, citing a "power that is greater than he" as the one instructing him to do so. Even after Shane McMahon usurped control of the Corporation from his father and merged it with Undertaker's Ministry of Darkness, there was still this "higher power" leading the way for Taker and his minions.

Rumors swirled about who the "higher power" could possibly be, with names like Jake Roberts and Don Callis among the most popular. But in June of 1999, the mysterious overlord finally revealed himself to be none other than...Vince McMahon.

First off, how in the world does this make any sense? Why would Vince be in cahoots with his son, who stole his throne, and a group of Satanic zealots hellbent on torturing his own daughter? The best possible answer to this is that he was trying to stick it to Stone Cold Steve Austin, who was squabbling with both the Corporation and the Ministry at the time.

So, just to get back at Austin, Vince fed Ryan Shamrock to the Ministry, had his own daughter kidnapped and nearly forced into marriage, and had The Big Boss Man f***ing HANGED. That's a bit overkill, don't'cha think?

Anyway, while this did produce one of McMahon's most famous lines ("it's me, Austin!"), it made absolutely no sense and nobody really ended up benefiting from it.


1. The Gobbledy Gooker

Gobbeldy Gooker Guerrero
WWE.com

Beginning in the spring of 1990, a giant egg began appearing on the stage at WWF events. In the months that followed, fans speculated about what possibly could be inside the egg; could it be a new superstar? A returning superstar? What could this big surprise be?! Well, fans got their answer at that year's Survivor Series when the egg finally hatched to reveal...the Gobbledy Gooker.

That's right - this egg, which fans had been curious about for months, ended up being used to debut a wrestling f***ing turkey.

This was so absolutely brain-dead that even fans of cartoony, 1990 WWF booed the ever-loving s**t out of it. As the Gooker gobbled and danced around the ring, the cacophony of boos and jeers only grew more vociferous. The audience at home clearly did not respond well to the feigned enthusiasm of commentators Gorilla Monsoon and "Rowdy" Roddy Piper, as Gooker only appeared of WWF television a handful of times after this.

Reception to the gimmick was so nuclear that the man beneath the feathers, Hector Guerrero, was fired from the company just a month later. But he wasn't just fired; they ghosted him. They stopped paying him, they stopped calling him, they literally wanted nothing to do with the Gooker any longer.

And rightfully so, because this was really, really, *really* dumb.


Watch Next


In this post: 
shockmaster
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

He/him/his. Born in 1992. Lifetime native of Massachusetts. Part-time columnist. Aspiring actor/singer. Black Belt. Twitch Affiliate. Drinks iced coffee all year round. Loves pro-wrestling and MMA.