10 Worst Babyfaces In WWE History

These babyfaces hopped aboard the Lex Express to Sucktown.

Triple H WWE Title
WWE.com

Pro-wrestling history dictates the best babyfaces are those heroic figures fans can relate to, invest emotionally in, and sympathize with when faced with adversity. From Hulk Hogan to John Cena, they typically overcome the odds and inspire waves of fans to never given up and work harder than the next guy in the room.

They are fairly humble, express gratitude for their success and always triumph in the end.

In effect, they are the living, breathing equivalents of superheros.

There have been a handful of occasions in WWE history, though, where those men dedicated to inspiring raucous ovations missed the mark. Their names do not preside alongside Hogan, Cena, The Rock, or Steve Austin. Instead, they go down in history as misfires, some sizable ones, who failed to catch on with audiences for a variety of reasons.

Some were arrogant pricks the likes of which were never going to generate the type of positive reaction Vince McMahon demands of good guys in WWE. Others were terribly miscast or lacked the supporting cast necessary to succeed in the role.

Whatever the case may be, they are notoriously recognized as some of the worst babyfaces in the annals of sports entertainment.

10. The Natural Disasters

The Natural Disasters Earthquake Typhoon
WWE.com

The early 1990s were an interesting time for WWE.

Not only were ratings down, interest in Vince McMahon's product was waning. Hulk Hogan was no longer the enormous draw he once was and his loyalty to the company was in question. The allure of stardom beyond the squared circle drew his attention and had many questioning whether he would remain an institution of WWE programming.

To offset the sudden fall from grace, McMahon made booking decisions that may not have been to the benefit of the performers involved.

Case in point: The Natural Disasters.

Earthquake and Typhoon were two bruisers, superheavyweights who pummeled the competition and overwhelmed them with their weight and size advantages en route to victory. They won tag team gold and were routinely foils for The Bushwhackers and The Legion of Doom as WWE rebuilt the division at the turn of the decade.

In 1992, the team was inexplicably turned babyface for reasons that still do not make sense. The victims of mismanagement by a tricky, underhanded Jimmy Hart, they had their guaranteed rematch with The Legion of Doom negotiated out from underneath them and given to Money, Inc. Furious with their pipsqueak second, they engaged Ted DiBiase and IRS in a feud that would last through the remainder of the year.

The face run never quite worked.

It was difficult to inspire sympathy when the babyface being isolated and beaten down should have conceivably been able to dispatch of the villain by himself, let alone with the assistance of a partner.


9. The Miz

The Miz Miz TV
WWE.com

There may be no more miserably executed babyface turn this decade than that of The Miz in 2012.

That would be because Miz's turn lacked that definitive moment that announced to even the densest of fans that he was now a hero. He worked against heels and in Vince McMahon's warped sense of storytelling, that made him a good guy. To the audience, though, he was essentially the same entitled reality TV star with a childish sense of humor and Titanic-sized ego.

He never evolved into anything more than he had been while one of the most hated superstars on the roster and as a result, failed to resonate with audiences.

No matter how many, many times he battled Wade Barrett for the Intercontinental Championship or found himself on the receiving end of a beatdown by the villainous stars of WWE, it proved nearly impossible to drum up sympathy for a character whose petulance was such a staple of his persona.

In the fall of 2013, Miz endured a brutal assault at the hands of The Authority's chosen champion Randy Orton, who beat the ever-living hell out of the Hollywood A-lister in front of his parents in his hometown of Cleveland.

When that still did not generate much in the way of crowd support, he was turned heel as if the nightmare of ill-fated heroism never happened.

All parties involved were much better off for it.


8. Alberto Del Rio

alberto del rio
WWE.com

In 2013, WWE management had the bright idea to repackage Jack Swagger, giving him manager Zeb Colter to help garner heat. Together, they would portray radical rightists who focused their attention on immigration and denounced the idea of Mexicans sneaking across the border.

To help the new character along, WWE Creative booked an Alberto Del Rio babyface turn and World Heavyweight Championship victory that did not inspire much in the way of fanfare.

It should not have been a surprise to anyone that Del Rio as an inspirational fan-favorite did not set the wrestling world on fire. Just weeks into the turn's infancy, he was abruptly turned heel for a Christmas edition of Raw, running over Santa Claus in one of his luxury vehicles.

And therein lies part of the problem with Del Rio's turn: he was still a pompous elitist whose claim to fame was an ever-changing vehicle of choice. Even as a proud Mexican babyface, he still felt the need to rub his financial wealth in the collective face of the WWE Universe.

That he never changed anything about his performance, outside of working from underneath as opposed to controlling each match he competed in, did not help matters. By the time the post-WrestleMania edition of Raw hit the USA Network airwaves, fans were infinitely more excited for Dolph Ziggler to cash in his Money in the Bank briefcase and capture the world title than they were at the prospect of one more month of a Del Rio title reign.

They popped as Ziggler, a heel, defeated a valiant Del Rio and captured the title. Within months, the arrogant second-generation star's flirtation with the light side evaporated.


7. Randy Orton

Randy Orton SummerSlam World Heavyweight Champion
WWE.com

Since 2004, Randy Orton has undergone several successful babyface turns but it was that initial one, on the heels of his first World Heavyweight Championship victory, that earned him a spot on this list.

At SummerSlam 2004, Orton capped off his rapid ascent up the WWE ranks, defeating Chris Benoit to win the top prize on the Raw brand. In doing so, he emerged from the summertime spectacular the most buzzing star on the roster. He also raised the ire of mentor Triple H, who was none-too-pleased that his protégé had captured the title he had worked all summer to regain.

A shocking betrayal led to an ill-fated babyface turn for Orton, who was not yet experienced or mature enough to get over with fans as a good guy beyond his spontaneous RKO finisher that popped audiences. He was arrogant, almost entitled even. He openly threw his heritage in the face of anyone who would listen, not just as a badge of honor but as a means of expressing his superiority.

Simply put, that incarnation of babyface Orton was a daddy's boy living off his family's reputation whose only claim to being a good guy was WWE Creative's unwavering stubbornness to get him over as such.

It failed, and by the time WrestleMania 21 in April 2005 rolled around, he was back in his comfort zone of douchey heeldom.


6. Diesel

Diesel WWE Champion
WWE.com

Diesel completed an improbable run to the top of professional wrestling on 26 November 1994 when he defeated Bob Backlund to win the WWE Championship in a near-record eight seconds. The fans in Madison Square Garden erupted, adding genuine excitement to a moment that very much felt like the coronation of the company's next big thing.

What started red-hot descended into mediocrity rather quickly before bottoming out nearly a year after it started.

First, it proved difficult to convince fans to throw their support behind a superstar the size of Diesel when he should have realistically had no trouble beating half of the roster's bad guys at that point. Second, it proved difficult to drum up consistent fan support when it was clear Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker were all far more beloved than Big Daddy Cool ever would be.

Perhaps most damning was the complete and utter lack of quality heels with whom Diesel could work.

King Mabel, Henry Godwinn, Sycho Sid, Jeff Jarrett and the aforementioned Backlund were not strong or credible enough heels to pose a legitimate threat to Diesel. As a result, he cruised through a year-long title reign. When he did face competent opposition, such as Hart or Michaels, it became abundantly clear that one of those two men should be champion.

Not the seven-foot-tall superstar whose height and demeanor were his claim to fame.

As the heel bodyguard of Michaels, he was imposing. As a cocky, unflinchingly anti-authority bad guy near the end of his WWE run, he introduced the wrestling world to the persona that would lead him to his greatest success in WCW.

In between, though, he was a massive failure through very little fault of his own.


5. Brock Lesnar

Brock Lesnar - WWE Champion
WWE.com

In 2002, Brock Lesnar obliterated Hulk Hogan, The Rock and The Undertaker en route to the WWE Championship and status as the top star on the SmackDown brand. So successful was he that "The Next Big Thing" moniker he had been handed no longer applied. He was wrestling's biggest frickin' deal already.

Then came the Survivor Series in November and a babyface turn ignited by Paul Heyman's betrayal and his first on-camera defeat at the hands of Big Show.

The run as a hero to the WWE faithful never really worked out the way WWE management had hoped. Though fans were receptive of him tossing the giant around the squared circle with impressive feats of strength, Lesnar never possessed the personality of a fan-favorite. He was a destroyer, an oppressive force. He worked best when he was pummeling an opponent into dust and selling for them during a babyface comeback.

He never thrived in the role of hero. It was difficult to get behind him during that initial run.

During his second run with WWE, Lesnar has garnered a fan following thanks to the similarities he shares with Marvel's The Hulk. Like the big green superhero, Lesnar smashes without hesitation. Fans tired of the talkative superstars and seeking a silent assassin of sorts gravitate toward him.

Something his lackluster, majorly disappointing babyface run of the early 2000s could never claim.


4. Vince McMahon

Vince McMahon WWE Title
WWE.com

Not even a brash, cocky Triple H at the height of his most evil could convince fans to fully support a babyface Vince McMahon.

The Game did everything from physically assaulting Vince's son Shane to marrying daughter Stephanie in the most convoluted, despicable manner possible but there was something about the egotistical billionaire that made it difficult for fans to feel bad for him.

Even when he was betrayed by his baby girl, his heart broken and ego shattered, McMahon was hardly the type of hero fans wanted to invest in. Who could blame them? He spent well over one full year telling fans what they wanted. He made life a living hell for rebellious antihero 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin, lovable underdog Mick Foley and charismatic "People's Champion" The Rock.

Why would the audience, which so passionately adored those characters, blindly throw their support behind the man who mistreated them and added to their allure?

By the time babyface McMahon won the WWE Championship from Triple H thanks to interference from Austin, any chance he had of garnering sympathy had evaporated. How could fans find it within themselves to throw their unwavering support behind a once-evil promoter who had just booked himself to win the company's top prize?

Wholly unlikable, even as his family is falling apart, McMahon ultimately returned from a television hiatus in 2000 and turned on The Rock, reassuming his role as wrestling's greatest antagonist.


3. Lex Luger

Lex Luger
WWE

In 1993, Lex Luger underwent a massive character overhaul, leaving behind his Narcissist persona in favor of an All-American, Made in the U.S.A. character that was tasked with dethroning the massive foreign fanatic Yokozuna. It was an honorable attempt by Vince McMahon to inject his programming with a new babyface hero for fans to flock to, embrace and hopefully, throw their hard-earned dollar behind.

They did not.

The fan base saw through the red, white and blue facade and recognized Luger for what he was: the self-absorbed guy whose intentions were not necessarily as pure as his character would suggest. He was still worried only about himself, his ripped body and winning gold to accentuate it. The pro-American sentiment was a charade, a misdirect.

That's why the WWE fans preferred Bret Hart over Luger. The Hitman was passionate about wrestling and had worked his entire life to win the WWE Championship. Luger, on the other hand, was a product of the machine whose claim to fame in McMahon's promotion was a body chiseled out of stone and a face the boss could plaster on magazines.

All of this does not change the fact that yes, fans did cheer for Luger. He was greeted by massive ovations in arenas across the country. Not because he was an admirable and inspirational wrestler but, rather, because WWE dictated it.

The sudden transformation from narcissist to hero fooled no one and for that reason, among others, Luger is one of the worst babyfaces in WWE history.


2. Mr. Perfect

Mr Perfect Summerslam 1990
WWE.com

There is nothing about the Mr. Perfect character that makes him a great babyface.

An egotistical daddy's boy who excelled at every sport and TOLD you as much, Perfect exploded onto WWE television through a series of pre-taped vignettes in which he demonstrated his athletic superiority. He could shoot basketball better than pros. He could throw a football 75 yards in the air, run down the field and catch it as it descended from the heavens. He was better at Olympic diving, running and pool. Most importantly, he was better at wrestling.

He carried himself as an elitist, better than absolutely everyone around him. The sheer mediocrity of the WWE roster disgusted him. The smug look on his face, the manner in which he spat his gum into the air and batted away... all of it made for a textbook villain.

That is why his 1992 babyface turn was as puzzling a booking decision as it was.

He was essentially the same character, over with fans only because of the respect they had for him as a performer. Between the ropes, his work suffered. He was nowhere near as effective a babyface worker under that persona as he had been a decade earlier in AWA. He was still cocky, full of himself and believed he was better than everyone. It did not click and by the time March 1994 rolled around, he was turned heel for the second time in his WWE career.


1. Triple H

triple h royal rumble
WWE.com

"I am The Game and I am that damn good!"

Sounds exactly like the type of rhetoric a babyface you actually want to support would spew.

Since his rise to the top of professional wrestling in 1999, Triple H has been the recipient of several babyface pushes but has never, ever been as convincing a good guy as he was a villain. And rightfully so. He is a wee bit self-centered, married to the boss' daughter, and the backstage orchestrator of many of his own championship reigns.

That his on-screen personas oftentimes come across as smarmy douchebags or forced badasses do not help. As iconic a WWE star as he is, and as many unforgettable matches and moments as he has been responsible for, those traits have prevented him from achieving greatness as a lead hero.

The 2002 babyface run that proceeded his incredible return from his first torn quadriceps flopped significantly and just seven months in, he was a heel again. A babyface turn in 2006 and the return of D-Generation X can be attributed to Shawn Michaels, a mass marketing strategy and domination of television time. His 2008 run as the face of SmackDown was overshadowed by the much more likable, entertaining hero Jeff Hardy.

No matter how many times Triple H has attempted a babyface run, he never achieves the level of overness that he does as a heel. His on-screen persona is entirely too unlikable for it and that is unlikely to ever change.


In this post: 
Triple H
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Erik Beaston is a freelance pro wrestling writer who likes long walks in the park, dandelions and has not quite figured out that this introduction is not for Match.com. He resides in Parts Unknown, where he hosts weekly cookouts with Kane, The Ultimate Warrior, Papa Shango and The Boogeyman. Be jealous.