10 Worst Gimmicks For The Best Wrestlers
It’s always puzzling when great wrestlers get terrible gimmicks.
Pro wrestlers and promoters have been using gimmicks since professional wrestling’s early days. The flamboyant Gorgeous George inspired generations of future stars such as Buddy Rogers, Ric Flair, and Shawn Michaels. Vince McMahon created gimmicks like ‘The Million Dollar Man’ that helped grow his wrestling empire. From Demolition, Doink the Clown, and Goldust to The Red Rooster, The Gobbledy Gooker, and The Yeti, wrestlers' gimmicks have taken fans and the wrestlers on an emotional rollercoaster ride for many years.
Some wrestlers and promoters catch lightning in a bottle with a gimmick. Del Wilkes putting on a red, white, and blue mask and tights to become The Patriot was genius. However, the same formula didn’t work out nearly as well for Hulk Hogan’s disastrous Mr. America gimmick. Other times, a wrestler must drop a gimmick by any means necessary. Ric Flair was being pressured by WCW to assume a “Spartacus” persona when he jumped to WWE in 1991.
Today's great wrestlers are also not immune to being saddled with a bad gimmick. How these superstars overcome such adversity are always interesting stories. The great ones find a way to survive and thrive.
10. Chad Gable
Chad Gable is an accomplished amateur wrestler and competed in the 2012 Summer Olympics. He signed with WWE in 2013 and soon became a tag-team specialist as a part of two successful tag-teams with Jason Jordan and Bobby Roode.
Gable has made the transition to WWE’s singles division with mixed results. He has yet to find that right combination of in-ring work and charisma needed to take his solo run up a notch. His new gimmick isn’t doing him any favors.
In late 2019, he was repackaged as ‘Shorty G’ and doesn’t appear to be any closer to breakout success or even getting more TV time than he did before the repackaging job. The underdog storytelling associated with him works but unfortunately, the name has been a huge hindrance. If the name isn’t dropped soon then we may see the old Chad Gable having success elsewhere.
9. Tanga Loa
Tanga Loa is the son of wrestling great King Tonga aka Haku. Loa is a member of a very successful tag team with his brother, Tama Tonga, called The Guerillas of Destiny. They are six-time IWGP Tag Team Champions and have also been Ring Of Honor Tag Team Champions.
Loa's wrestling career started in WWE’s developmental system and although he did make it to the main roster, his career never had a legitimate chance to flourish. It didn’t help that WWE gave him a shallow, stereotypical gimmick to work with in 2011.
Loa, then known as Camacho, was teamed with Hunico who was coming off a nice run working as Sin Cara. Despite the team’s potential, they wouldn’t be able to overcome a poor gimmick. Their presentation was very similar to the equally bad stereotypical Mexicools gimmick from the early 2000s. The team soon split and Loa was released.
8. Rob Van Dam
Rob Van Dam is known all over the world for his days in ECW and his long run with WWE. Whether working as a heel or a babyface, his persona, and unique ring style have been a hit with fans for many years.
Van Dam is also known for his work with Impact Wrestling and returned there recently. However, he was given a gimmick that just does not work for well known established stars and also failed miserably years ago in WWE. The gimmick stripped him of what makes him one of a kind.
Van Dam, along with girlfriend Katie Forbes, joined a Right To Censor like group called Cancel Culture. This group did to their personas what RTC did to both Val Venis and The Godfather. Both groups stripped away what fans loved about them, producing only cheap unstainable heat. They recently denounced the group and returned to their old fun-loving ways.
7. Cody Rhodes
Cody Rhodes is the son of ‘The American Dream’ Dusty Rhodes and brother of Dustin Rhodes aka Goldust. He has revitalized his career in and out of the ring since leaving WWE in 2016.
Rhodes embarked on a unique barnstorming tour that included stops in Ring Of Honor, Impact Wrestling, New Japan Pro Wrestling, and the NWA. He then helped form AEW instead of simply signing with another company. None of this might have been possible if it wasn’t for the gimmick that helped him walk away from WWE.
In the summer of 2014, Rhodes transformed into a Goldust-like character called Stardust to team with the aforementioned. Although he did his best to work with the unusual gimmick, it didn’t have the same complexity and attraction of the Goldust character. After numerous requests and creative pitches to shelve the strange character fell on deaf ears, Rhodes asked for and was granted his WWE release.
6. Natalya
Natalya is the daughter of Jim ‘the Anvil’ Neidhart and a member of the legendary Hart wrestling family which includes Bret ‘Hitman’ Hart, among others. The Hart family is known for their technical prowess inside the ring.
Over the years, Natalya has been a steady source of solid technical wrestling in a WWE women’s division that hasn’t always been known for it. Despite her credentials, WWE gave her arguably one of the most humiliating gimmicks ever given to a talent of her caliber.
In 2012, Natalya was part of a successful tag team with Beth Phoenix called The Divas of Doom. They had been a focal point in WWE storylines for about five months when all of a sudden she started to have an on-air flatulence problem. The gimmick was unpopular with fans, critics, and members of the Hart family alike. It was quickly dropped by WWE.
5. Drew McIntyre
Since re-signing with WWE in 2017, Drew McIntyre has taken the company by storm. He has collected the NXT Championship, WWE Raw Tag Team Championship with Dolph Ziggler, and most recently the WWE Championship by defeating Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 36.
Things haven’t looked better for the first British born WWE Champion. However, it wasn’t long ago that he was stuck in a mid-card comedy tag-team act.
When he signed with WWE back in 2007, there were high hopes for McIntyre which led to him eventually being dubbed ‘The Chosen One’. His high point during this run was winning the Intercontinental Championship. However, McIntyre soon fell out of favor and steadily slipped down the card to land in a tag team with Heath Slater and Jinder Mahal called 3MB - Three Man Band. They were glorified jobbers who were also used as ragdolls by the likes of Brock Lesnar and The Shield.
4. Bray Wyatt
Bray Wyatt is one of WWE's hottest superstars. He brilliantly reinvented himself after a long run as leader of The Wyatt Family. Fans can't wait to see the next 'Firefly Fun House' or what 'The Fiend' will do next. However, he had to overcome his early WWE gimmick to reach the level of success he enjoys today.
Wyatt, who is the son of Mike Rotunda, the nephew of Barry Windham, and the grandson of Blackjack Mulligan, was initially allowed to use the Rotunda name in WWE’s developmental territory Florida Championship Wrestling. However, he soon became Husky Harris and debuted on the main roster with The Nexus.
He often teamed with Curt Hennig’s son, Joe Henning, who was given the name Michael McGillicutty. The talented duo’s odd names and no push frustrated old school wrestling fans. Both were eventually repackaged. The Huskus character on ‘The Firefly Fun House’ is a rib on Wyatt's less-than-stellar past life.
3. Kazuchika Okada
Kazuchika Okada is not as well known outside of Japan but he is as decorated as any professional wrestler today. The New Japan Pro Wrestling star is a five-time IWGP Champion, was ranked number one in Pro Wrestling Illustrated’s 2017 PWI 500, and is a four-time Wrestling Observer Newsletter match of the year winner. And if it wasn’t for a terrible gimmick, he might be Impact Wrestling’s brightest star today.
New Japan sent Okada to the United States in 2010 to work with Impact Wrestling as a part of their working agreement. For about a year, he worked mostly Xplosion and dark matches before being repackaged.
Okada was then given a ridiculous Kato (of Green Hornet fame) ripoff gimmick that included being renamed ‘Okato’ and becoming Samoa Joe’s sidekick. The storyline was short lived and shortly after it ended, he left Impact Wrestling. New Japan also ended its working agreement with Impact and it was reportedly not a coincidence.
2. Samoa Joe
Samoa Joe is one of wrestling’s more unique talents. His throwback look, agility for a big man, and ring style have made him a popular and sought after professional wrestler. He has been a top attraction for Ring Of Honor, Impact Wrestling, NXT, and WWE. He was one of the staples who helped build Impact Wrestling.
However, Impact Wrestling is also where the talented Joe received his worst gimmick. The company went through a phase in which they felt they needed to re-invent the wheel. He was a victim of a bad repackage job in 2009.
Joe was already a multi-time former champion when he was unexplainably given the ‘Nation of Violence’ gimmick. The awkward gimmick included him wearing a leather outfit, having a facial tattoo, and using torture tactics and weapons. This new sadistic character also didn’t care much about winning or losing. The gimmick was a bad look and a poor fit for him.
1. AJ Styles
AJ Styles is one of the best wrestlers in the world today. He has been dominant in Ring Of Honor, Impact Wrestling which he helped build, New Japan Pro Wrestling where he led The Bullet Club, and WWE.
To WWE’s credit, they have largely left his persona and ring style alone. It speaks volumes when WWE does not tinker with someone who wasn’t built in house. This is why it was such a head-scratcher when Impact Wrestling did just that.
In 2010, he was already ‘the face running the place’ for Impact Wrestling. However, a change in philosophy saw the company bring in a lot of veteran talents such as Hulk Hogan, Eric Bischoff, and Ric Flair. World Champion Styles was paired with Flair and turned into ‘The New Nature Boy’. As talented as both are, the gimmick was not a good fit for either superstar.