10 Worst Times WWE Wrestlers Refused To Lose

When backstage politics got in the way of a victory for the other guy.

John Cena, Wade Barrett
WWE.com

Professional wrestling is all about earning the respect of your peers. The more respect you have from the boys, the power you ultimately have backstage. And the more power you have backstage, the more control you have on the outcome of your matches.

This facet of sports entertainment is littered with incidences of wrestlers refusing to lose a match for one reason or another. It could be down to personal animosity to their opponent, protecting their image or they just didn't like the plan that the boss had involved. The 80s wrestling boom was full to bursting with larger than life superstars refusing to lay down, with many a match ending with non-finishes so that neither man lost.

However, some cases of backstage politics, or the dreaded "creative control" card had massive detrimental effects on the people involved. A wrestler refusing to do right by the business has ground pushes to a halt, killed passion for the sport, or quite simply annoyed everyone in the back.

Being the biggest wrestling company in the world, incidents in WWE would have a wider effect on the wrestling landscape than something from AEW today or the waning years of WCW. These moments had lasting consequences for wrestlers, fans and WWE as a whole, and all that respect you earned throughout your career could be flushed away because of one selfish decision.

10. Shawn Michaels Refused To Lose To The British Bulldog - One Night Only 1997

Shawn Michaels European Title
WWE.com

At SummerSlam 1992, the British Bulldog defeated Bret Hart for the Intercontinental Championship in one of the greatest feel-good wins in all of wrestling, taking place in Davey Boy's home country of England. 5 years later, returning for the One Night Only PPV, WWF hoped to get a repeat with Bulldog once again winning in front of his biggest fans.

Only Shawn Michaels (and yes, this won't be the last time you're hearing that name) was standing in the way of that plan.

While a hometown win would generate the biggest pop, HBK, being in maximum-backstage-politic-mode, argued that the biggest story coming out of the event long term would be Michaels becoming the first ever WWF Grand Slam Champion; a wrestler who had held the WWF World, Intercontinental, Tag Team and European titles.

The higher ups agreed and Michaels was given the victory. The British Bulldog was the reigning European Champion, fighting in-front of the second hottest crowd he's ever had on his side, not to mention that his sister was in the front row, was battling cancer at the time and who Davey was dedicating the match to all contributed to another notch on Michaels resume which he didn't need.


9. Triple H Refused To Lose To Goldberg - SummerSlam 2003

Goldberg Triple H Elimination Chamber 2003
WWE.com

WWE has a certain amount of unspoken rules, one of which being if you're not physically able to defend your championship, it will be stripped from you. Triple H, at the height of his reign of terror in 2003, crotch-chopped that rule, which is impressive considering his crotch was indeed chopped.

Goldberg, who had arrived in WWE earlier in the year, was on a hot streak, mowing through all who was "next". By the time SummerSlam rolled around, The Game was indeed "next". But he would have to earn it inside the Elimination Chamber against 4 other superstars. Goldberg mercilessly disposed of most of the field, looking as dominant as ever and giving us an all-time great spot of him spearing Chris Jericho through one of the pods.

When it was Hunter's time to enter, Goldberg broke him out of the pod and dismantled him. All pointed towards Big Bill winning the match and the title at the second biggest show of the year, when a sneaky sledgehammer shot during a spear attempt abruptly ended Goldberg's streak.

Triple H did next to nothing in the match and walked away with the victory for good reason (in his mind, at least). Hunter was nursing a groin injury and wasn't able to compete to his full capacity. Unlike almost every other occasion, when this would necessitate a title switch, he argued that it would make Goldberg's victory greater if he were defeated at full health. It didn't work. Even though Goldberg would win a month later, the shine had worn off and backstage politics crushed another star's potential.


8. Hulk Hogan Refused To Lose To Randy Orton - SummerSlam 2006

Hogan Orton
WWE.com

Another name you'll hear a few times on this list is the Immortal Hulk Hogan, known by his colleagues as one of the most notorious backstage meddlers in every company he's worked for, though he was more known for refusing to feud with anyone more popular than him rather than simply lose a match.

This particular occasion saw Hulk stall an exciting new gimmick from a superstar who struggled to find his feet as a face, but won fans over as the Legend Killer heel, Randy Orton.

Orton was hot going into SummerSlam 2006, having come out of an amazing feud with the Undertaker and battling for the World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania 22. Following a short rivalry with Hulk Hogan, also involving his daughter Brooke, the two were scheduled to battle at the Biggest Party of the Summer. With an aging body and dodgy knees, surely Hogan was going to lay down for the RKO, right?

Clearly you underestimate the power of creative control. After all, this was Hulk Hogan, the biggest legend to ever come from pro-wrestling and Brooke had a terrible album to promote. With his pythons flexed and with Randy having nowhere near the power backstage that he would eventually gain, Orton took the fall and the Hulkster had another exciting young talent under his belt.


7. Hulk Hogan Refused To Lose To Shawn Michaels - SummerSlam 2005

SummerSlam 2005   Hulk Hogan Vs Shawn Michaels 11
WWE.com

A year before the Orton squash, Hogan had an even bigger star to extinguish. This time it was another man who was notorious for avoiding the job at all costs, Shawn Michaels.

When Hogan returned in 2005 for a storyline with HBK, the original plan was for a trilogy of matches between the two. Both would get one win apiece, followed by a rubber match to conclude. The storyline kickstarted in epic fashion with Michaels turning heel on Hogan and turned his bad guy act to 11, giving fans one of the most entertaining performances of his career.

After playing a major troll-job on the Calgary audience, fooling them into thinking Bret Hart was in the building, and a mock Hulk Hogan interview where HBK impersonated the Immortal One, Hogan himself took umbridge to the skits, claiming that Michaels was taking things too far and used this as leverage to reduce the feud to a single match.

Shawn Michaels claimed the contrary, saying that Hogan himself told him that he'd liked the work he was doing in preparation for that match, and claimed that Hogan only cut down the feud to avoid laying down for Michaels (where have we heard that before, Mr. Hickenbottom?).

So when SummerSlam came around, Michaels did the job, but not before selling for Hogan with video game ragdoll physics in one of the most bizarrly entertaining performance ever.


6. Neville Refused To Lose To Enzo Amore - Raw, October 2017

neville enzo amore
WWE.com

In 2016, following one of the best tournaments in WWE history in the Cruiserweight Classic, the new cruiserweight division was drafted to Monday Night Raw where things immediately fell apart. They were eventually given their own show in 205 Live, and were gifted a new top heel in the shape of Neville to help stabilize the show and bring legitimacy to the new Cruiserweight Championship.

Despite the number of exciting cruiserweights on the show and some amazing matches, 205 Live still failed to deliver in the ratings department. Vince McMahon would then decide to add new character into the brand by bringing in Enzo Amore and attempting to build the brand around him, with the bonafide G becoming champion shortly after.

Enzo's all mouth all the time style appeared to clash with the rest of the roster, something that storylines fed into with Neville and Amore trading roles, uniting the entire roster against the champion.

Just as the storyline was gaining momentum however, Neville walked out of the company just before Raw on October 9th 2017. Mainly citing long-term frustrations with the company, the final straw was that he was scheduled to lose to Enzo on that edition of the show. Seemingly as a middle finger to the man now known as PAC, Lucha Dragon Kalisto would win the title on that Raw instead.

Neville would remain inactive for almost a year before returning to the indies after his contact expired, never returning to a WWE ring and leaving the Cruiserweight division to die a very slow death.


5. Hulk Hogan Refused To Lose To Bret Hart - SummerSlam 1993

hogan yokozuna
wwe.com

A trilogy of Hulk Hogan antics concludes with his most egregious act of politicking.

By 1993, Hogan's star was waning and a new breed of superstar was needed to take his place. Everyone and their mother told Vince McMahon that Bret Hart was the Man but WrestleMania IX saw the Hitman lose his WWF title match to Yokozuna, and Hogan to take the title from the kayfabe sumo star in one of the worst moments from one of the worst WrestleManias ever.

The plan was now for the Hulkster to battle Hart at SummerSlam in what was to be a grand passing of the torch moment, with the Golden Era ending and the New Generation beginning. This match would never happen in a WWF ring as the Hulkster would drop the championship back to Yokozuna at King of the Ring via the first of two fireballs that would explode in his face, then Hogan would leave within the year.

The story behind this was that Hulk didn't view Bret as his equal and it would apparently not be realistic for Hart to dethrone him for the title. So while one of the best technical wrestlers in the world wasn't worthy of the championship in Hogan's eyes, he chose to hand the belt to a Samoan pretending to be a Japanese sumo wrestler who had to cut his WrestleMania main event in half because he was too exhausted to finish it properly. Bad call, Terry.


4. Goldberg Refused To Lose To Bray Wyatt - Super Showdown 2020

Fiend Goldberg
WWE

No matter how creative Bray Wyatt became in WWE, he will undoubtedly go down in history as the most mishandled superstar in company history. Decisions like the ones made in Saudi Arabia in 2020 only contributed to this.

Following the most baffling of booking decisions at Hell in a Call 2019, The Fiend won the Universal Championship from Seth Rollins at Crown Jewel (in Saudi Arabia again) the following month. Bray's newest creation would be built as the unstoppable force leading into the new year, battling Daniel Bryan in a good feud, and the Miz in a stinker. The long-term plan was for Wyatt to hold the belt until WrestleMania where Roman Reigns would wrestle and ultimately conquer The Fiend in the main event.

A good number of things prevented that main event from happening, but first and foremost was Goldberg refusing to lose. Goldberg allegedly argued that a loss to Wyatt would hurt his image as he saw himself as a "superhero" to the younger fans and, ultimately didn't want to disappoint them.

One the one hand, this would make sense if the event took place 20 years ago, but in 2020 Goldberg as world champion is something that no-one wanted to see... again. But on the other hand, considering the Saudi government is so out of touch that they thought Yokozuna was still alive, there might have been some merit to that argument. But a fleeting nostalgic pop is not worth the damage it did to another incredible creation.


3. John Cena Refused To Lose To The Nexus - SummerSlam 2010

John Cena Nexus
WWE.com

Today, on this edition of "Cena Wins LOL", it's the time John Cena refused to lose to not just one superstar, but an entire faction.

Big Match John has been known as the brick wall that has halted the momentum of a number of stars in the past, from Umaga to Rusev to Bray Wyatt (again), but perhaps no burial was as damaging as the one inflicted on what was the most dangerous group in recent memory.

The Nexus, made up of the competitors from the NXT gameshow, burst onto the scene by not just taking out Cena, but the entire Raw set and everyone around it. They continued to wreak havoc on the roster until Cena united the boys and challenged them to a match at SummerSlam 2010. At the event, everyone involved got the spotlight and all signs pointed to Nexus continuing their momentum for the rest of the year.

Then they hit the brick wall that they couldn't see.

The match came down to John Cena, and Nexus' Wade Barrett and Justin Gabriel. Cena was beaten and broken, finisher performed on the floor and multiple times. Then out of nowhere, he comes back to defeat both men in quick succession, becoming the sole survivor for his team.

According to Edge, Chris Jericho and Cena himself, it was the he who lobbied to go over the younger talent, thinking that the storyline had "run it's course". All men involved were baffled at the choice and the Nexus were never a viable threat again, with the majority of it's member drifting away in the following years. Eventually, John himself would regret the choice, admitting he made a mistake.


2. Stone Cold Steve Austin Refused To Lose To Brock Lesnar - Raw, June 2002

Stone Cold What
WWE

The day that Stone Cold "took his ball and went home".

The story throughout 2002 was that Steve Austin was getting frustrated with his role in the company, and felt that storylines for his character had become stagnant. Following underwhelming feuds in the first half of the year, Austin was pitched to work with the rapidly rising star of Brock Lesnar in the lead up to King of the Ring.

Austin was keen on the prospect of a brand new opponent, but was not at all happy with the company giving away a big money match that could have headlined any PPV on weekly TV, especially without proper buildup and, in his own words, potentially making the Texas Rattlesnake look weak. Austin no-showed Raw on June 10th and all his storylines from that point on were dropped, including a potentially great feud with Eddie Guerrero.

Stone Cold cited multiple reasons for his walkout of the company on top of the creative frustrations, including beef with some of the boys including Triple H, Scott Hall and The Rock, and a domestic incident with then-wife Debra. The job to The Next Big Thing was simply the straw that broken the camel's already fragile back.

Following his refusal to do the honours to Lesnar, the company verbally buried their star in the weeks following his walk out, severing all ties with him and Austin would not appear on WWE television for nearly a year. Things would eventually be smoothed over by the beginning of 2003, and he would return for one more round with The Rock at WrestleMania XIX.


1. Bret Hart Refused To Lose To Shawn Michaels - Survivor Series 1997

Montreal Screwjob
WWE.com

Of course it has to be the most infamous case of a wrestler refusing to lose. In this occasion though, he was given no choice. You all know the story by now, but just in case you don't:

In 1997, Vince McMahon told Bret Hart that he couldn't honor the big money contract he'd promised and was given the go-ahead to jump ship to WCW. Being the reigning WWF Champion, McMahon instructed him drop the belt to Shawn Michaels at Survivor Series. Hart, who had nuclear heat with Michaels for years at that point, was fine with dropping the championship. But he would under no circumstances drop it to Shawn Michaels, at Survivor Series, in front of fans from his home country.

The plan was allegedly set for Hart to retain at the show and drop it to Michaels when back in the States, at which point Hart's contract would be up. McMahon, panicking at the prospect that he might take the WWF title belt onto WCW TV, decided to take action.

So the plan was in place. Shawn Michaels had Bret Hart locked in the Hitman's signature Sharpshooter, but before Hart could reverse the move, Vince McMahon rushed to the ring and urged referee Earl Hebner to call for the bell. Hart knew immediately what had happened and needless to say, he was pissed. Almost everyone involved in the Screwjob left as fast as they could, with the exception of Vince, who took the brunt of Bret's fury.

This single act of forcing a loss caused a seismic shift in the landscape of, not just WWF, but professional wrestling as a whole. The business was about to experience it's hottest period in history, and all because "Bret screwed Bret".


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

A connoisseur of Star Wars, WWE, Sonic the Hedgehog, musical theatre and mature cave-aged cheddar cheese. Can't say that I have limited taste!