10 Worst Title Reigns In AEW So Far
AEW has introduced a lot of championships, but not every wrestler has been successful with them.
Championships in professional wrestling should be the most important thing to strive for, which is why it is important to preserve the aura of an accolade. Champions must be presented well; as the old adage goes "It is not titles that honor men, but men that honor titles." It is unlikely that Machiavelli was talking about wrestling when he said this, but it remains a good point all the same.
AEW has introduced seven titles for wrestlers to fight for, whilst also promoting the FTW title and the bulk of Ring of Honor's championships on its programming. Most of the titles have been booked tremendously thus far, but there have been some reigns that have failed to build the prestige of a belt.
It is crucial that AEW continues to preserve the luster of their championships, as one or two poorly booked title reigns can quickly diminish the power they have as prizes to fight for. They only need to take a look at their main competition in WWE, who have routinely dismissed the importance of championships, particularly with their mid-card titles.
10. Wardlow (TNT Championship, 136 Days)
Wardlow had a decent, if not great reign with the TNT Championship, but it also cooled off the big man who was red hot after defeating MJF at Double or Nothing earlier on in 2022.
'Mr. Mayhem' definitely should have won the title on his first attempt at St. Paddy's Day Slam, but his eventual coronation was delayed for some reason. Scorpio Sky and Sammy Guevara would instead continue to trade the belt on a number of occasions, whilst Wardlow sat around waiting for another opportunity at the gold.
When he eventually won it, there was no immediate plan for the Ohio native, who did have good matches with the likes of Orange Cassidy, Brian Cage, and Matt Taven whilst holding the title. Wardlow's stock had fallen so much over the course of 2022 that fans welcomed the title change when he dropped the belt to Samoa Joe in a three-way match also involving Powerhouse Hobbs.
Wardlow's TNT Championship reign would have been good for a star that was in the ascendancy, but he had already started to peak in popularity during the MJF feud. He is by no means done as a future World champion, but AEW has some work to get him back to the level he was pereviously.
9. Jon Moxley (AEW Championship, 59 Days)
Jon Moxley as the caretaker champion in AEW shouldn't be a bad thing, but having him do it twice in a matter of months sums up the year the promotion had at the top of the card. It was kind of an unwinnable situation for AEW, which had to deal with the impact of 'Brawl Out,' but there could have been an opportunity for someone else to have a short reign.
His record-setting third title win was an unnecessary one for the brawler who defeated his Blackpool Combat Club stablemate Bryan Danielson in the final of a tournament to win the belt. This in itself was a questionable decision, as Moxley could have lost and gone on holiday as he had planned, allowing the 'American Dragon' a chance to hold the World title at least once.
Moxley would only defend the title twice, against Penta El Zero Miedo and 'Hangman' Adam Page, with the match against the latter having a harrowing ending that thankfully led to a terrific storyline.
The title program with MJF helped the championship reign seem more worthwhile in hindsight, with Moxley losing after his mentor William Regal interfered on Maxwell's behalf.
8. Nyla Rose (AEW Women's Championship, 101 Days)
Nyla Rose was barely given a chance to establish the AEW Women's Championship that was floundering in early 2020, only defending the title twice in over three months. The total apathy that the company seemed to have for the division was summed up by how the women's title was never given a platform until Britt Baker captured it almost two years later.
Despite this, Nyla Rose and the inaugural AEW Women's Champion Riho managed to have a couple of great matches to try and establish the title. The 'Native Beast' would have little opportunity to do much more than that though, as she retained the title once against Kris Statlander in February 2020 before losing the title in only her second defense in May at Double or Nothing against Hikaru Shida.
Nyla was never really given the chance to be a champion, which is a huge shame as she is undoubtedly one of the most talented performers in her division. Hopefully, AEW gives her another title reign with the World or TBS Championship at some point as a make-good for a huge booking misstep they had with Rose's title reign.
7. Cody Rhodes (TNT Championship, 32 Days)
Cody Rhodes didn't need to beat Sammy Guevara for the TNT Championship, even if the latter was struggling as a babyface. The title change set in motion a difficult year for the belt that Rhodes himself worked hard to build up in 2020 as the inaugural champion.
Guevara had defeated 'The Redeemer' Miro for the TNT title after breaking out as a babyface in 2021, but his reign did not really take off, which allowed Cody to step in and claim back the accolade. Rhodes only defended the title once before dropping it back to the 'Spanish God' in an admittedly excellent ladder match, which would end up being his final outing in AEW.
The 'American Nightmare' may have seen this as trying to put Sammy over on the way out, but it ultimately failed as Guevara's second title reign was worse than his first. It is even more unfortunate that this may be some fans abiding memory of Cody in AEW, considering that his hard work established the TNT Championship in the first place.
It would only get worse for the title too...
6. The Elite (AEW Trios Championship, 3 Days)
The events of 'Brawl Out' made what should have been a triumphant return for The Elite a short-lived title reign that divided the AEW fan base between the trio and CM Punk. Kenny Omega and the Young Bucks were only champions for three days before Tony Khan made the decision to strip the trio of the title whilst an investigation into the backstage fight went on.
Death Triangle would then carry the titles after defeating the Best Friends for the vacant belts, which would help launch the trio's division despite all the turmoil. Of Course, The Elite would return to face PAC and the Lucha Brothers in a fantastic best-of-seven series, winning the Trios Championship for the second time.
It is hard to tell what kind of title reign The Elite would have had, or if they'd have even come up against Death Triangle had things all gone to plan. Nonetheless, the tumultuous start to the life of the Trios Championships could have ended the titles before they even got going, but thankfully AEW persevered with the idea which now looks to be a good one.
5. Thunder Rosa (AEW Women's Championship, 172 Days)
The legacy feud between Thunder Rosa and Britt Baker made the former beating the latter for the Women's title inevitable, but her ensuing title run was plagued by poor booking, backstage drama, and an unfortunate injury.
As previously mentioned, AEW really hasn't done the women's division any favors and champions often don't have much of a platform to perform at a high level. Rosa managed to defy these restraints in 2021, particularly when paired with Baker, but when she won the belt in 2022 she seemed devoid of confidence and power over the direction of her character.
After some good matches against the likes of Serena Deeb, Toni Storm, and Jamie Hayter, she would announce an injury that would take her out of action for an undetermined amount of time, eventually leading to her relinquishing the title.
AEW maybe should have just stripped the title from Thunder Rosa instead of determining an interim champion as she wasn't being helped by stories relating to her conduct backstage. Regardless, it it obvious she is a very talented asset to the women's division that would benefit from her being in it.
4. Scorpio Sky (TNT Championship, 38 Days)
Neither of Sky's two TNT title reigns stands out as being particularly good, but his first was ultimately worse for the health of the belt as he only retained it once against Wardlow before losing it to Guevara once again.
The aforementioned Sammy Guevara and Cody Rhodes hot potato of the championship had already diminished the accolade quite a lot, so doing it again with Scorpio Sky was very unwise. The feud between Guevara and Sky was pretty awful too, with American Top Team being a generally detrimental act to AEW in general.
The women involved in the feud, Tay Conti and Paige VanZant, were subjected to a load of gross humor that didn't reflect well on the company at all. It made everyone involved seem unlikeable, leading to Sammy Guevara turning heel and aligning with Chris Jericho once again, whilst Sky set off on an unremarkable run as TNT Champion.
Scorpio Sky hasn't appeared in AEW since losing the title for a second time to Wardlow in July of 2022 due to injury. He will be hoping to stake his claim as a potential champion again in the future, where he can have a more meaningful run.
3. Sammy Guevara (TNT Championship, 11 Days)
It didn't really make sense for Sammy Guevara to win back the title from Scorpio Sky, only to drop it again a couple of weeks later, but his whole face run was kind of a failure - which this reign signified.
His record-tying third TNT Championship win was the least remarkable of the bunch; after defeating Sky for the belt, he immediately cut the legs of his rival's chances of a meaningful reign. Having Guevera be involved in five title changes over the course of half a year wasn't good for his character or the TNT Championship in general, with his final reign being the least necessary of them all.
2022 was just a bad year for the title, with it only becoming more relevant again towards the end of the year under the stewardship of Samoa Joe. It is a shame that AEW decided to become so slapdash with their booking of the TNT Championship, as it is such an important belt when it is booked correctly.
Now that Darby Allin holds the accolade once again it is getting back on track, so let's hope 2023 is a better year for the title.
2. Jade Cargill (TBS Championship, Ongoing)
The question has to be asked whether giving Jade Cargill, a very gifted but green performer, such a huge title reign was a good idea when she is so new to the sport. In a way, it is admirable that AEW would trust her with such a responsibility, but the TBS Championship does not really feel like a big deal at all in the already under-serviced women's division.
Cargill has now held the title for over a year as the inaugural champion, but there hasn't even been a handful of memorable matches throughout that time. The problem now is that whenever she is dethroned as TBS Champion, AEW will have a tough decision to make in deciding how to book her.
In all likelihood Cargill will turn babyface at some point, hopefully providing a different dynamic to her work that will help take it to the next level. It is definitely time for AEW to try something else with the talented athlete, as she approaches 50 wins to begin her career it will be a big win when somebody eventually topples her.
1. CM Punk (AEW Championship, 3 Days)
CM Punk came back to wrestling after seven long years away, only to be done with the sport once again after just a year. Whatever way 'Brawl Out' is analyzed, it can't be overlooked that it may have been the last time the 'Straight Ege Superstar' appears in a wrestling company, which is a huge shame for the whole industry.
His final act as an in-ring performer saw him win the AEW World Championship, which would have presumably seen him carry the title to Full Gear 2022 where he would have faced MJF, dropping the title to his young nemesis. Instead, Punk was stripped of the title, like The Elite, except he has not returned to recapture his gold.
Even before the events that came after All Out, the build to the World title match between Jon Moxley and CM Punk was strange. Moxley squashed Punk in his return from injury, leading to a rematch at the pay-per-view where the 'Voice of the Voiceless' would theoretically be a hometown favorite.
The muddied waters of the heel/face dynamic and Punk's underwhelming hometown reaction were only the beginning of a tumultuous night that would be his last in AEW.