10 Worst TNA X Division Champions Ever

'It's not about weight limits, it's about no limits'. And no common sense, apparently...

Suicide TNA
impactwrestling.com

This past Sunday, the TNA X Division Championship celebrated its 14th birthday. The title has seen many ups and downs over those 14 years, but it is clear to all who have watched TNA during that time that it has long been the highlight of that particular company's programming.

Indeed, it was the X Division that provided TNA with its highest peak, as AJ Styles defeated then-champion Christopher Daniels and Samoa Joe at Unbreakable 2005 to win the title in what is regarded as TNA's greatest ever match. Some illustrious names have held the title, from those three men to Chris Sabin, Austin Aries, Jerry Lynn and Johnny Devine.

Wait a second, Johnny Devine? Yeah, the list of names to have held the title isn't exactly 35 for 35 when it comes to greatness. Even when certain Olympic heroes have held the title, it has been for terrible reasons and led to the strap being devalued as a result.

TNA has a history of putting their championships on some pretty questionable performers, whether it was Pacman Jones winning the tag titles or The Band winning those same straps in 2010. The X Division has not avoided this, unfortunately. Here are the 10 worst champions in X Division history.

10. Eric Young

Sheik Bashir Eric Young Final Resolution 2008
impactwrestling.com

This is less for the man holding the belt and more for the reign, but Eric Young's X Division Championship reign in 2008 lasted all of zero days.

The division was thinner than thin at the time, with Sheik Abdul Bashir the champion and not many challengers outside of crazy ol' Eric Young. This amounted to a number of X Division matches that didn't feature any real excitement, just two smaller guys working a heavyweight style.

EY won the title at Final Resolution in 2008 after some heavy-handed assistance from the referee, and subsequently had it ripped from his hands by Jim Cornette just moments later. Young didn't make it into the final of the tournament held to establish a new champion, and never really came close to winning the title again.

A great talent, but a poor X Division Champion.


9. Michael Shane & Frankie Kazarian

Kaz Shane
tnawrestling.com

One day, professional wrestling promotions will learn that having co-champions is almost always a bad decision. Whatever novelty there is in having two people fight over the rights to a championship dies away pretty quickly, and the belt becomes more of a comedy prop than a prestigious prize for the best of the best.

In July 2004, Michael Shane and Frankie Kazarian became co-champions of the X Division after they retrieved the belt at the same time at the climax of an Ultimate X match that also involved AJ Styles. Their title reign lasted all of two weeks.

Unless you are Chris Jericho and Chyna, a co-champions situation simply doesn't work. This is proof of that.


8. Suicide

Suicide TNA
impactwrestling.com

Professional wrestlers based on video game characters are very rarely (read: never) a good idea.

That is how the character known as Suicide got his start however, as a mysterious character in the much-maligned TNA Impact video game. He immediately became the centre of attention in the X Division, as a number of supremely talented performers had their talent wasted in their preoccupation with de-masking Suicide.

The list of performers who played Suicide is impressive enough. Christopher Daniels, Kazarian, TJ Perkins and Austin Aries all wrestled under the mask, and the character won two X Division Championships.

That didn't stop it being a colossal waste of time, however, not to mention one with an absolutely abhorrent name. The name was changed in 2013, presumably when TNA realised having a character called 'Suicide' was a terrible decision.


7. Sheik Abdul Bashir

Sheik Abdul Bashir
impactwrestling.com

Shawn Daivari never really got a fair run as an in-ring competitor. During his time in World Wrestling Entertainment he was used mostly as a manager for Muhammad Hassan and The Great Khali, and he lost the overwhelming majority of his matches. He did get a win over 'Hacksaw' Jim Duggan, but that was in 2007.

Daivari came to TNA in 2008, repackaged as Sheik Abdul Bashir. Exposing the lack of depth in the X Division, he won the title within two months, defeating champion Petey Williams and Consequences Creed (Xavier Woods) in a three-way match. He was champion for 84 days, before losing to Eric Young in something of a schmozz at Final Resolution.

One tell-tale sign of a company's opinion of an individual can be seen in how they perform in tournaments after their title has been vacated. In the X Division Championship tournament that came out of EY beating him, Bashir lost in the first round. Heck, even the long-forgotten Kiyoshi made it through that round!


6. Rob Van Dam

Rob Van Dam X Division Champion
impactwrestling.com

Rob Van Dam as X Division Champion. It doesn't sound so silly on paper, right? Quite the opposite, it sounds pretty damn (Dam?) cool. Why is it that everything about RVD is generally accompanied by the adjective 'cool' in a slightly wasted voice? Cool.

In reality, Rob Van Dam was X Division Champion only succeeded in exposing his deficiencies some 22 years into his career. RVD won the title from Zema Ion at Bound for Glory in 2012, cutting the legs out from one of the truly exciting young talents TNA had at the time.

RVD's reign lasted 137 days, but in 2012 it felt like another decision made by the company that only succeeded in pushing it back. Zema Ion, Sonjay Dutt, Kenny King, Joey Ryan and others could have gone a long way to recreating the glory of the X Division. As it was, RVD had a title run that didn't do anyone any favours.


5. Johnny Devine

Johnny Devine
TNA

'Hot Shot' Johnny Devine as X Division Champion back at the beginning of 2008 for all of 20 days. Until this point Devine had been in and out of TNA, performing in a variety of roles including spots in Team Canada, Paparazzi Productions and Serotonin. Despite being a perfectly cromulent performer, Devine pretty much peaked at 'decent faction guy'.

This didn't change in 2008, but he still managed to wring an X Division Championship reign out of it. Team 3D were the latest big men taking the X Division hostage, and Johnny Devine was their little stooge, their snitch. He defeated Jay Lethal for the title, but only thanks to the interference of Team 3D, Bubba hitting Lethal with a kendo stick.

Devine left the company not long after, and is pretty much semi-retired in 2016.


4. Sonny Siaki

Sonny Siaki
TNA

Sonny Siaki was one of those guys in the early days of TNA that you thought looked like a star, but you weren't entirely sure of why outside of 'big good looking dude'. He was a WWE guy in TNA in the middle of the 2000s, someone who everyone and their dog assumed would end up with a WWE developmental deal eventually.

He got that deal, spent two years in developmental and was then released. He was also the seventh X Division Champion and the first to hold the title for more than 50 days. His run as champion was the very definition of forgettable, and after 63 days he dropped the title to Kid Kash.

Looking back, Sonny Siaki was as generic as professional wrestlers got. His career came to an end when he donated one of his kidneys to his dying brother, however, which is an incredibly noble thing to do. Kudos to Siaki.


3. Syxx-Pac

X Pac Tna 2005
impactwrestling.com

Sean Waltman was a true pioneer of light heavyweight wrestling in the United States of America in the mid-1990s. He was one of the first truly small dudes to make a splash in the World Wrestling Federation, and despite the shade thrown at him he was a fairly integral member of both the New World Order and D-Generation X.

Whether you know him as Waltman, X-Pac or Syxx, he was relevant in the 90s.

As Syxx-Pac in 2002? Well, not so much. He wasn't so far past his prime in theory, but was clearly unable to keep up with the new generation of cruiserweight wrestlers in the United States. He became the 4th X Division Champion in 2002 and held the best for all of two weeks before dropping it to Jerry Lynn.

Yes, Jerry Lynn wasn't exactly a spring chicken in 2002, but he didn't look out of his depth as champion. Syxx-Pac was.


2. Kurt Angle

Kurt Angle TNA Champion Hard Justice 2007
Impact Wrestling

It is not unusual for an individual to find himself holding multiple titles at one time in a company. Seth Rollins is the most recent example, holding both the WWE World Heavyweight and United States Championships simultaneously towards the end of 2015. But every active male championship in a company? That is taking things a bit too far.

That is exactly what Kurt Angle did in August 2007, when he defeated Samoa Joe at Hard Justice to win not only the X Division Championship, but the TNA World Tag Team Championship to boot. Depressingly, Kurt Angle is one of three men to hold the tag titles all by themselves.

Angle's run as X Division could have been noteworthy, as whoever defeated him was in line for a major rub. Jay Lethal was that man, but there was no rub. It was Angle's second match of the night after all. Angle as champion devalued the belt, as it became an aesthetic prop minus that assumed pretence that a championship requires.


1. Abyss

Abyss Brian Kendrick Destination X 2011
impactwrestling.com

In any cruiserweight-style division, there's nothing wrong with booking a big man as champion. The idea of this larger than everyone else man bullying the division into submission whilst essentially holding the belt hostage is a story as old as time, and it often works well. Heck, it has worked with the X Division in the past, when Samoa Joe held the championship.

Abyss as champion however, well, that was a big no-no from the get-go. The Monster won the title from Kazarian in May 2011 on an episode of Impact Wrestling, as Immortal continued to rack up the titles in TNA. Eric Bischoff was waging war on the X Division for some reason, and Abyss was his main weapon.

Despite reading from 'The Art of War', Abyss was unable to kill the division, and the stage was set for someone to rise up from the abyss and defeat the man for the title. For some reason that man ended up being Brian Kendrick, a fantastic wrestler but not one who you felt would be the guy to take the X Division forward.

Abyss was an utterly ridiculous X Division Champion, undoubtedly the worst in company history.


In this post: 
TNA suicide
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.