10 Worst WrestleMania Moments Ever

A few things we'd like to forget about the grandaddy of them all.

Michael Cole Wrestlemania
WWE.com

WrestleMania is the night wrestling fans witnesses classic moments that stick with them for years. It's easy to conjure up an image of Hulk Hogan body slamming Andre the Giant in front of “93,000” fans at the Silverdome, or Bret Hart forcing Steve Austin to pass out to the Sharpshooter, or The Rock and John Cena going face-to-face at the 28th iteration of the show in a true battle of icons.

'Mania is the show the company revolves their year around, and Vince McMahon always wants to leave the audience with something incredibly memorable by the end of the night. Usually he does achieve this goal, but it isn’t always for the right reasons.

This is because his big ideas are often quite strange. Most of his fanbase finds his sense of humor either confusing or downright lame, and he loves bringing in celebrities who don't seem to mesh well with the product. He also has a tendency to book matches that have absolutely no chance of even reaching the level of mediocrity. Because of this, every WrestleMania can end up with its fair share of head-scratching, groan inducing moments. Plus, the show is six hours long these days, so that's bound to lead to at least some badness.

Now let's take a look back over the past three decades and countdown the 10 worst WrestleMania moments so far.


10. The Miller Lite Catfight Girls

Miller Lite Catfight Girls Pillow Fight WrestleMania XIX
WWE Network

Now, a little context here, the Miller Lite Catfight Girls were two women who gained their 15 minutes of fame by starring in a Miller Lite Super Bowl TV commercial where they stripped each other down to their underwear. Naturally, you would assume when WWE hired them for the night during the early 2000s it would be for the sole purpose of ripping each other's clothes off once again for the amusement of Vince McMahon. That's kind of what happened.

The two showed up to the arena and met up with Stacy Keibler and Torrie Wilson. Unfortunately they couldn't all get along, because the WWE women were in the midst of an argument over who created WrestleMania: Vince or Hulk Hogan. The Catfight Girls, who are apparently lifelong wrestling fans, chimed in and couldn't decide either, so on the spot they decided to settle it in a bed. Good thing there was one available in the arena.

The bed was placed on the stage, and the four women hit each other with pillows for a couple minutes while Coach provided play-by-play next to them. Four blouses were ripped off, but then for some reason they focused on Coach and pulled down his pants. And then, one of the Catfight girls rolled him up and Torrie counted the pinfall.

So let me get this straight...a man who wasn't even in the match, got pinned by a woman with no wrestling skills whatsoever, and another participant in the match somehow ended up as the official to count the pin and it actually stood as the official ruling?

What a WrestleMania moment!

Actually, to make this even more absurd, a tag title match with Kane and Rob Van Dam taking on Lance Storm and Sean Morley was moved to the pre-show, all so we could see a beer commercial come to life.


9. Santina Wins A Women's Battle Royal

Santina Marella
WWE.com

The 25-woman battle royal sounded like a pretty good idea at the time of WrestleMania XXV. The female competitors were being painfully overlooked in the company in that era, but featuring the best of the current roster and a few familiar faces from the past could have been a nice bonus to the show. But one man ruined it all.

As soon as the match was about to start at 'Mania, you could tell it wasn't going to be a very prestigious affair. The competitors didn’t even receive proper ring introductions, as Kid Rock stood in for every theme song. The match was rushed, and felt pretty disrespectful to everyone who was called up and asked to board a plane, get into their ring gear and compete in the match.

It was just bizarre to see Sunny come back to the company for the first time in years, only to be unceremoniously dumped out of the ring in 91 seconds. Former WWF Women's Champion Molly Holly also received pretty shabby treatment, as she made her first appearance after retiring, and didn't last four minutes. The entire match didn't even go eight!

The ending saw the embarrassingly unfunny Santina Marella (Santino pretending to be his own sister) toss Beth Phoenix out of the match. It was probably one of the company’s more ridiculous sexist moments. All of the talented, athletic women who were involved couldn’t stand up to the lowliest midcarder in drag.

It's amazing how far the women's division has gone in the span of eight years, and thankfully it will never again sink to the level it was at WrestleMania 25.


8. Snoop Dogg's Talent Show

Snoop Dogg Teddy Long
WWE Network

WWE loves to make their wrestlers look like goofs, especially if there's a celebrity willing to be involved on TV. Basically, people from movies and television shows are way cooler than a regular old wrestler; that seems to be the message the company has presented over the years.

At WrestleMania XXVII, Snoop Dogg showed up to put on a talent search. Why he would do this in a locker room full of wrestlers is anyone's guess. But first up was William Regal, who did his best attempt at rapping and finished by telling us he was "straight up Philly." Ah, get it? Because he's from England and not Philadelphia!

Well, if you hadn't used up all your laughs for the night at the opener, The Great Khali and Jillian Hall were up next to sing a song from Grease. Zack Ryder delivered his rendition of Rebecca Blacks "Friday", which while close enough in quality to the original, still didn't need to air on a pay-per-view you spent over $50 to watch. Then for absolutely no reason, Roddy Piper decked Ryder in the back of the head while singing, which made him a huge a**hole.

Yoshi Tatsu also sang, because one person singing in broken English wasn't funny enough for Vince. The topper to this never-ending gag was Hornswoggle as the last competitor, but since he couldn't talk, he couldn't perform. OR COULD HE? Yes, after Snoop left, Horny busted out an audible rap complete with dancing Bella Twins.

It was so corny you still can't fully comprehend how it exists.


7. The Deadliest Catch

Santino Foley WrestleMania 28
wwe network

Moments after Randy Orton surprisingly took a clean loss to Kane at WrestleMania XXVIII, we went backstage to see Santino sitting at a table wearing a raincoat in front of a plate of crab legs.

He wasn't alone, though, this was an opportunity for WWE to do a meaningless celebrity tie-in with a reality star from The Biggest Catch. The camera then panned over to reveal Mick Foley was seated next to them. Now keep in mind this was a time when Foley appearances were actually kind of special, so seeing him take part in such hokiness was a bit of a downer. Even worse was the pirate impression he was doing for no discernible reason.

If you also recall, Foley was at once a guy who returned to wrestling multiple times post-retirement just for WrestleMania so he could try and be a part of a true 'Mania moment. This wasn't exactly it for him. He was reduced to acting like an idiot as he put on Mr. Socko and bashed the crabs with his fist.

Of course, Ron Simmons ended the sketch by walking over while wearing a "DAMN" shirt and delivered his famous line "That was f***ing stupid!" Sorry, I mean "DAMN!"

To make the whole thing even more infuriating was that the segment ran longer than the opening match between Daniel Bryan and Sheamus!


6. Sheamus Vs. Bryan

Sheamus Bryan
WWE.com

We might as well continue on with WrestleMania VVXIII here!

For the second WrestleMania in a row, Daniel Bryan and Sheamus were booked for the show. For the second year in a row they were given the shaft; the second time around was much worse.

At the time, management saw big things in Sheamus, he was going to be the No. 2 babyface in the company, while Daniel Bryan was nothing but comedy fodder. Despite the crowd absolutely loving Bryan's actions, management thought they knew better.

To open up the show, Bryan did the job in 18 seconds, which was supposed to shock fans in a positive way, and get the night off to a hot start, but instead, they were angered. This was WWE's most passionate audience, and they were people who truly appreciated the talent of Bryan, and didn't want to see him squashed by the much lamer and corporate Sheamus.

This came to backfire on the company almost immediately, as the "yes!" chants really caught on the following night on Raw, basically kicking off the journey of Bryan eventually main-evening WrestleMania XXX. So while in the end things worked out for everyone (except for Sheamus), it was incredibly hard to stomach for much of the audience in the moment.


5. Booker T Does The Job

Booker T Triple H Wrestlemania
WWE.com

At WrestleMania 19, it took three Rock Bottoms for The Rock to beat Steve Austin. It took three F5s for Brock Lesnar to pick up the win against Kurt Angle, but one almighty Pedigree from Triple H was enough to seal the fate of Booker T in the biggest match of his life.

Wrestling doesn’t have a very good history of delving into race related storylines, and the Booker vs. Hunter angle certainly had racial overtones surrounding it. As you could have guessed, it didn’t go well. Hunter took a shot at the former WCW star saying “people like you” didn’t get to hold the Heavyweight Championship. People like you? What else but the color of his skin could he have been referring to?

Alright, so the set up was scummy, but having Booker T actually beat the hell out of Hunter and win the Title would have been a satisfying finish to the angle. Except it didn’t happen. Their match at WrestleMania XIX was fine, maybe a little underwhelming, but not terrible. At least it wasn’t until the finish. Hunter hit a Pedigree, but was so exhausted he couldn’t make the cover.

Now, in basically every other match in wrestling history, that spot has been used to set up the opponent dramatically kicking out and continuing the match. Not that night. After hitting his finisher, it took Hunter over 20 seconds to go for the pinfall, and yet it was enough to pick up the win.

It was a deflating ending to the feud, and a shockingly bad decision by management. It took years for Booker to recover, but even then he was never treated seriously as a top act again.


4. Big Show Vs. Akebono

Big Show Akebono Sumo Match WrestleMania 21
WWE.com

Did you ever want to see Big Show in a diaper? Well, you had to wait until 2013 to see that, but if you wanted to see him in a mawashi, you need look no further than WrestleMania XXI, where he inexplicably took on legendary Japanese Sumo wrestler Akebono.

It’s not exactly sure why this happened. WWE ran the occasional show in Japan, but they weren't really trying to really break into the market at the time in an effective way. If they had, they would have actually used Ultimo Dragon, and not tried to name Kenzo Suzuki after the Japanese Emperor during World War 2. It was likely due to the fact that Show is big, and so is Akebono, and Vince McMahon likes putting Show in spectacle matches at Mania.

However, this wasn’t even an actual traditional wrestling match, like the Show/Floyd Mayweather spectacle. This was contested under traditional sumo rules. Of course, Show was going to look foolish here, much like Bart Gunn trying to take down actual professional boxer in Butterbean at WrestleMania XV. When Show failed to move his opponent, he actually called for a Chokeslam. Unfortunately, he wasn’t able to hit it, because that would have been amazingly ridiculous, and probably broke at least a few sumo rules.

Show lost, as he was tossed out of the ring with relative ease. He got back in and showed a sign of respect for his opponent instead of going for that massive chokeslam. The two gigantic, nearly naked men gave us a WrestleMania moment that most fans wish they could forget.


3. Brodus Clay's Momma

Brodus Clay WrestleMania
WWE.com

Vince McMahon falls easily in love with corny, quirky gimmicks, but he also has a history of falling out of love just as fast and moving onto something else. Such was the case with Brodus Clay.

Clay debuted in his Funkasauras character shortly before WrestleMania XXVIII, and was given a pretty big push out of the game. It was a bit strange, as he had The Cat's old theme song and even his catchphrase of "Somebody call my momma!" Well, since the boss loves his dancing characters, he gave Clay an entire WrestleMania segment to do his thing. It's just that his thing wasn't very good. It was kind of a one-note joke that played itself out fast.

The Funkasauras emerged with Naomi and Cameron to inform us we were all going to call our mommas that night. As Clay spoke, you could almost hear in his voice that he realized what a lame pile of garbage he was about to unload on us. And it really, truly was.

"Momma Clay" came out, but she certainly wasn't related to him. She was a young woman in a wig, with an extreme amount of padding to make her look bigger than she actually was. Her friends in "The Bridge Club" then joined her and they all danced for a few uncomfortable, stereotypical minutes. Of course, the announcers acted as if it was one of the greatest things they'd ever seen, but for the fans it was basically the moment where Clay jumped the shark.


2. Piper’s Blackface

Roddy Piper
WWE.com

If a white wrestler put on blackface today, they wouldn't get out of the locker room before they were seen by someone in management and quickly fired. In 1990, though, Roddy Piper was given free reign to paint his body half black for some kind of idiotic race related statement for his match with Bad News Brown.

One might assume that this was a one-time poor judgement call on Piper’s part. But the thing is, he didn’t just do it one time! He also wore black face on an episode of Wrestling Challenge a few weeks before WrestleMania (in which he claimed he could be black...no, not really). At WrestleMania, the announcers seemed more amused and confused over Piper’s shenanigans, rather than calling him out for something that had been offensive for decades.

As the years have gone by, this stunt has become more awful to watch play out. You would think at some point Piper might have felt a tinge of embarrassment for doing it, or maybe even apologize! Not so, as he offered up a strange response when asked later if it was racist: “First of all, you know, I was born in Saskatoon. There are no Black people that I know of that are dumb enough to go to a place that cold. So, there's no racism in me at all." Wait. What?

Well, unsurprisingly the match itself wasn’t very good. Whatever statement Piper was going for was lost in translation, and it remains one of the most absurd and worst Mania moments ever.


1. Cole Vs. Lawler

WWE.com

There have been plenty of terrible matches in WrestleMania history, but most of them were at least mercifully short. Michael Cole vs. Jerry Lawler 'Mania 27 went an agonizing 13 minutes and 45 seconds. However, if you add in ring introductions and post-match nonsense, then the total time devoted to the slow moving trainwreck clocks in at closer to half-an-hour. Absolutely brutal.

Of course, Cole isn’t an athlete, which is why the length of the match was so confusing. It should have been a five minute affair (at most) with Lawler pounding his broadcast partner into the ground and shutting him up for good. Instead, Cole was on offense for a majority of the match, and nothing he did looked the least bit credible. Poor Jerry tried his best, but he was unable to make the contest watchable. It was also a poor use of Stone Cold, who made a rare appearance to serve as the referee. No one came out of it looking good.

In the end King did pick up the victory, but the good times didn’t last long. The Anonymous GM chimed in and reversed the decision of the match, which then led to many months of Cole bragging he beat Lawler. It was all a gigantic, embarrassing waste of time, and remains the worst moment seen so far in WrestleMania history.


Contributor

As Rust Cohle from True Detective said "Life's barely long enough to get good at one thing. So be careful what you're good at." Sadly, I can't solve a murder like Rust...or change a tire, or even tie a tie. But I do know all the lyrics to Hulk Hogan's "Real American" theme song and can easily name every Natural Born Thriller from the dying days of WCW. I was once ranked 21st in the United States in Tetris...on the Playstation 3 version...for about a week. Follow along @AndrewSoucek and check out my podcast at wrestlingwithfriends.com